Chief General Manager v. Bala And ORS

 





      
 



 
   

  !"# $%&'(  (  )  %*  + %  ,-"(  ,.&"  )+  +%  (%$+(  " + %/0,0/%
*%/1 2 *( 33 ** 4 %"$"

10 *( %" , "3 "

   





5% " # %*6$0%) (*./7! 

%( 33 ** %8*6$0%/7!  % %"(.2*.%/7! 

%!%""9- !%"% "3 " ' ::::::::






2("% %"(**"3"  ( 033 * 


 ". **"!%""9- !"



  * 9 (*

% "3 " '

  

  ! ""

 2(""33 * * 9&( ( )  %*+ %,-"( ,.&"+".%  ;  3"" 9&( %!!  *0"2%9$*/,(< * %% %% "=( 2%9$*= % ( ,- 1+( * %% %% "=(  ! " =0%7 (!* !!    >

  9% /(  !" ( !" "" % (/  > (% .( * %?,@;' 9 +%7 9&17%1+(A533$"% 

%0 7**+  **  @ 0 .( 3"" + %"  *9% 1+(/1(7 5%<"(/,9%/1$*/,+($(/ ("(01$*9$@'

0,-1+(/  &*/,0 (-/,- %/ + % *9%*" 9% ( "(% .( * % %07**+ 6( %1(2(  03."

9 +%7 9&17%1+(/%7 %( * "  ( %.(  % !( <**"(  ?$0%.%"7**+ 6(%.%/ 9$"    ,-"(  ,.&"  ,1,2  9 %+  , 5 >  9 + %7 %"(*& +*+ *&9&,01%$3/% "3 @( % /!0

%0 *("   %033" % !2( 9$""( (  03 9$> 02("( !**$"!!$%% $ %"( +*+  %7+ ( 9$"9&"%7 %/% "$*+-$% "!!$3" (  0317%/1$*/,-1+(/  &*6"(( " % "$* ( !! ( %!!$3" (  03*""$

% -$% " 2( % "3 " '( %  * " 3% !*03 ;

>/.(!(."**. 9&( 2%9$*  2( 2%9$*"" ""  !03 " 
 // ( !*0"/.(!(."!03$ " **."#  

 

 0   ! "  ,-1+(



  !!    >

 +   ! "  

7 (*&!0  (  ! "  ' 

7

%  7  97   $!   .%"

3 %"* B3 " "

' ' C 
 3 %0(

  

 

7 03 "  !*!$*     %  33*&+ 0$*3* % @

@C

//  ' 8 % !$" * %( 33 **("""* ( .%( +%$( ! " ,-1+( ( %3"" + %". % %7 **+ (  03?,@;' .( ( 33 **=" $", 5 >!0

%0 *("  33" % !( !**$"<3*! ( 0%/""$!(/!* %(( !! <3*! $ %"(  +*+ %7+ 9(( 7 (!* "!03 "."9 33% "' #' "*"!  ( + ( 2%9$* ""$  ""$"9* /"( 2%9$*!" %(  "0& ,D ,01+(/%7 % ( 33 **="9$" @ ( ( %(/* % !$" * %% "3 " '

%+$ "( + ( 2%9$*""$  % . **% " ( "0 !** %& % % !  > (7 ( %* % !$" * %9(( " "/3% %0 3 %$"+( % !% ; 2( 2%9$*/.(*  !+""$  +"( 33 ** ( % /% * $3( " 0  5D *9%1+(/.(." &  . ""*"*+ ( 
,EB5 1 *9%1+(."0+"

( !*0"/""$!(/( ." 3  . ""? "$33% ( 7 %" ( !*0"(( 9$"F$ "."9 +%7 %"(*&  +*+ *&/.( % "(  03."9 +%7 0 % "3 ." 3%*&
9 %0* " ? " (( 9$""( (

  03/% "$*+ ( (  ! " 3 %""-$% "( ( % 3"" + %" % 7 %/-$% 1(75%<"(5D@/ + %5D  ,- %1+(5D (7 *"0 ( "0*%" 0 "(( 9$" ."9 +%7 %"(*& +*+ *&"( ( 9$"2( !! !!$%% $  $* 9$"%7 %,01%$3/% "3  2( 2%9$**"<  (  !(,D ,01%$3 %7 % (

+  9$"  0   (  !%0*  !"  % +%+  (  !!    F$ "."3 ++"(02( 2%9$*!0 (*("*%& " 0  ,D ,01%$3""$

! % 9$( !+  7 !

7*9* % !%+"(02( 2%9$* $%( %9" %7 (,D

,01%$3 7 " ((  03."9 +%7 %"(*&  +*+ *&2( 2%9$* (" *" !" %  ( %+$0 " %"  9& * % !$" * %( 33 **% +%+ ++&0%+7 %*+ (  03/(. 7 %/ & %! 9 (( "0   7 . ( 97 /(  +"% !% 9&( 2%9$* ""$  / "!** %& % % ! 9&("!$% #  



 ""

("!" /!%""9- !"(7 9  * 9&( !*0"

 (! ( !03 "

2( % "33*! * *+.(( !%""9- !" 03* ( * +*% 3% " 7 " % "3 1(% 7/.(."

( %  ! " ,-1+(
%( % ""0  ( 33*!/ ( "0 "**. ?. 7 %/"(%  % "3 1(% 7/  *% &"9$%" /( "0 "(**9 33%  F$**&0+"( % "$%77+!*0"

'

 8 %   !$" *  %  !%""9- !%"% "3 "      '

"$90"(( 2%9$*(" %% "" ""+(  %+ (  ! "  
 ' 3 %0(.( % "/( ." 03*& "1. 3 %$!3* %3% *(*&.+ "+ +
 3 %0("*" %+$ ((  ! " ."*"% %+3+"("*!0 ."
' 3 %0(/$ .(!(( ."+7+
 (". 8 %  !$" **"!  (0$*3* %  "($*(7 9 33* "

*"%+$ (($+(( !*0"% !(*% /. 3% " (  ! " /9$( 2%9$*(" * +%&!03 "!!$ *"" *7 

!/*"" !"%$0/*""  "  $ %* B3 " " "*"!  (( 2%9$*(".% &  % "( 0$ !03 "

   (  ( %  (/  * %   !$" *  %  ( % "3 "$%!  03&  %+$ "  (    +%$  "  0  $   (! ( !03 "

 D(*  "" ""+  (  !0    (   ! " /  (  2%9$* 9" %7 ("*%&! % !  %0( $!3*%3% *( (9 3%$! % +%+ 03*&0 .+ " (  ! " 2( .  (  ! " (33* ( $!3*%3%/ *(/ .(!(% 3%."0 ( ! " ,-1+(!$*9 +7  03*&0  %. 7!!&""$!(/( 2%9$*!0 (*( ,-1+(."!$**& 03*& ( $!3*%3% *(/ 3% %0(*+(( % " 7 ! % +%+% %+ 3+"9&(  ! " 2( 2%9$*"" "" ( !0  (  ! " "
 ' 3 % 0(/ F$*( *9$% %G %( " !%!$0"! "/("!$%"

@ ( !" % 7 .(( 9" !  &!+ !7!+ 7 ! ( !%%&/( !0  (  ! " /""" "" 9&( 2%9$* "!** %& % % ! 

' !"        
   

 !"# #  "

$?H9* 3 B$%("( *( !"  " *  03*& 3 %""9 *.( +   & %"/  I "9 0 ("!0 .%" $$% 3%"3 !"2(  ! " ." & %" + "9 0 ("!0 "3 %!$0

?H9* 3 B$%97 % %% !" 03 " 
> /  !7 *( ""*"9 **. !*0""3 %9" %7"

?H9* 3 B$%!"  
 "

@   7 .    0&  97  "!$""/  !03 "    .(!( !*0"%  * "% "" "" " **.#  

 

 0  (  ! "  ,-1+(



  !!    >

 +  (  ! "  & %"

7 (*&!0  (  ! "  ' 

7  I   7  "    9     .%"

$$% 3%"3 !"

' J
@ C
 3 %0(

7

( 797  $! .%"

3 %"* B3 " "

 
''C '>'3 %0(

7 03 "!*!$*   %33*&+ ( 0$*3* % ;

'>'

;C
/ / 

7
$ %* B3 " "

'

B 03 " %*"" !"%$0


B 03 " %*""  " '

%
 $" ""%

>

> "" F$ * 0&"!$""97 /( 033 *   ""0"" ?. 7 %/( !%""9- !"(7 0 % ( "0 % 3%*&!! 3 .% ( 2%9$*"0  ( !03 "**. !*0" % ( ,-1+("!% "  %0 //  
 / / 2( !% " 0$ !03 ".** !%%& % "A>'I3 %$0 %0(   *+ ( !%"" 9- !"  **  !$*  % *K 33 **"$%!  03&  9 + "$% % ( 

+7 (!* .** 3"( "(%  !*0"( % 9<!!$"%3&( "0 (%$+( 0% "*0".**"(% ( 0$ !03 ""3 %( .% ( 2%9$*2( 3% "

"(**9 %( %.!"" &


'

()*(+, - "$   

  D( ( %"3 <+% "  L " D( ( %% 3%9* L "