High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/815/2011dismissed

Madhu Sharma v. Yashpal And ORS

2024-12-11Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel12 pages

! "#$%$ &' (()

*+% ' ,- ( . . -

!"" #"!" $ ! %& ! '

($") "* + ($, ----- . - / ( %

! "."/ "" , "/ ,0

.!/"1!""2 "3" !/"

"")(4 566 57 %6 %888 )" ( "&892 &67

:5:

%&9 %&8 ;

" """ %

< ""

< ($,

"/" ,2." * ( " ;( =( "/ )" ;/ < ""//0

//" *"/ )"

/ ; 1! :2 "3 " >(.

* /

$" >(. .(, 0 */(..

""/

( ":%8 ; ;"."/ ( "/;(. )( "&67 &892 :5:

*" ":& " / ; )"//

"/ ;( "

$( ). %: 69 566?

@(" //

). )" .( "&892 :5:

*" ":& ; * "/;( "

; 1! :2 "3( "&67 ;

* "///

* @(" )( "&67 ;*//

; 1! :2 "3* ( ) ")(".!".50 !0" 5666A2B"

(/ !0. " * ( ) ( ")( ".!".:. .." ( " &67 ;

& 4/")))" ,0 $( ). %: 69 566?

* !!/ * "/ )" "

$( ). ,

""/"=( +( !( !!/ &566?* "/ ,0

; 1! :2 "3

)" " "

",0 "/;(( "&67 ;

!!/ %:566?

*"/ ,0 //)") @("/

!,0 "/;(

""/ " =( +( !( "

.. $( ). %5 %% 56%6 , !!/ ) C "/ !!/"/ ,0 )" @("/

!* "." ".2,

!!/"/ ,0 ; 1! :2 "3)" " "

",0 "/;(*

""/"=( ) @("

; 1! :2 "3 ) .

)" ".( "&67 ;

() //) $( ).

%5 %% 56%6! ,0

""/"=( ) *

.!/" ,0 "/") ! "."/ "" !""

//) @("///

" ! ?

/ (/ !"

(//0) () "

")( , / !"" $( ). ! ,0, / ;(,/*( ,

(!."!! """

")(

.!/"." ! ; 1! :2 "35: 6% %888 0 %. ."."/ ( .") *./ ,")") @(

*0 (/ 4 * / *" !/"

.!/" ")(

""/"=( ) //"/*,0 "."") !!/"/ ,0 )( ,")"/ 0D!"0! ",

!" "(,." !!/*"/ 5: %6 566?

* %5 %% 56%6 ")( ""* " "

""/"=( ) (/ " !!/

!!/*"

" "."/:2E0 )( /"."""(/2!!/"

"$( "( ."

"( )( , / !"" $( ).! ,0

""/"=( ""

! !!/ "/ ,0

; 1! :2 "3 @(" ". )( "&67 ;

"/(",/"" 0 "

! "(,." ! ""

//)" )" ! ) ") . *0 " (,." "

/ ,0 ! ("! !""*./

( . *0 " )(

" ".( ":%: ; ;

." ")"".,() ,0 !"" *

! ,0 ." .") "( )( *())" !""" 2D.""

*0*)" ! ")( ""* !"0 " ")( ,0, / ;(,/* ,0 !! "") "

" !! " $( ).! ,0, ;(,/*/",/,"

""!""""/ ,//*

0 , / ! " "

$( ).! ,0, / ;( ,/*, ( ") (!! "" "

/",/,."" " (,." ""//)/"0!"0" " ") ( ,0, / ;(,/* (

"" !"""/",/, "."

(/ $( ).! ,0 / "/;( * "/;( /,/0 " (") "

/( " //) ,0 .!/" < !/ %9 %6 %888 * 4 * / 5' %6 %888 ! !! "") "

"/ ;(

/( .!/" "),. //0D." %8 %6 %888 <". 0)" !

//)

( * .!/"* )""$(",0 ! " (,(/ "/;(( / ,"

"/"0" .!/""/ !"

0 " !/ * *(,$

(/0" "*" . *0 "/;( / . .!/" ."

.!/". 0 .!/" ,(,")

*" (/0,0

"/;( / " "

/" (!",/0 !,/*" "(

.(,

! * /

"/ ," (," "

/ ,0 ! ("

*/ / "

*! ,0 ! (" * *0"

/*( 0 ."/0 .., (,

; 1! :2 "3

(

0 .." 0 ( "&67 ; ,"// /" *0"

/." (! %5

""/"=( * "/ /")*" !!/"/ , / / !!/"/ ,0 )" @("/ * , ,0 %6 0 /"."" !" " "/ 0 !!/"

" <")

" /0

( ""/") !!/ %:

)(. , / !"" "" $( ).! ,0

""/" =( !!/* "."

(.%62 0

/0 !" !!/."")! "),(:2E0 " *" ((, .(,/(, ", )( !( ,0 !"" !"" /*/".""., , ") ./0, ( "!/ !!/"/ ,0 ! ("<". ".<"

"!/ !!/"(/( . ;(" )/,( *" ! ") "( ."( "

" !!/"/ ,0 ! (" , ( " (. ")

/0" "/") !!/ !!/"/ ,0

*, ,0". "* ,( (0 !!// !/ ( /0 *" !! D!/"")" " ")( ,0

""/"=( ") /") //(! ""/") !!/

. !!/"

"<") "

/0*"/ *" !!/0". !(/ $( ).! ,0

""/"=( ) * /(,.""* , / D!/"") /0 <") " ""/* . ) ") " /0 (/ , ( ,0 ;( /",//0 *" ! "

!! * ""@(//0 / !!""/* "" !" /0,( D!/"(" " / "

/0 ! " , "/0 *"!!/"

"<") " /0""/") !!/ ,

""/"=( *0("

//0<") " /0 /*/"."" ,".!/0") )( !!/""/ ,0 /0!" "(,"/ /0")/ 0 .(,D!/" *" !/(",/") " (.

// < ""

/ " "!! ! "! (") !!/"/ ,0" " 0)" ) ") "."/"!!/"/

""/ " =( ) (

"//)/"0

""."0 ,( " "."/ !!/"// ,0 )" @("/,0

""/"=( "* ".2,

" "(!$( ,( ,0 ( "."/"!!/,0

""/ " =( ) )( /".""

!!/"/ , / "

; 1! :2 "3 )" " "

"( "&67 ;

""/"=( ) / 0 /*" ." " "/ /,/0 " (") " "

""/"=( ) /( "

! ,0 ! (""/ ! ) )"

! !!//; 1! :2 "3 * * "

,0 "/;(( "&67 ;

* @(" ,0

""/"=( ) "

)

""/"=( ) / // "

/ )" "..")* *0"

/ "

/*)"/("/0 ( " ! (" "/ ! *0"

/*)"!"

*."!!!"" . " ( . .!/" . ) ") )"") *0"

/*)( 4( . ,"// !( //) *0"

/*!

*0" ! *"D." ! .

)(. , / !""

" ".( ":%: ; ;

." " )" ". ,() ,0 !"" *

! ,0 ." .") " /! ! ("

""/* ."/)")"".")/"

, ( *0"

/ F,/(!.;(

/ //* G

H %7

)(. , / !"" *())"" 2D."" !"" *0*)" ! ")" /! ! (" " / /* " "."/ "/ ! (".( "*/) " !","/"0 ! ("!" )"

,0 ,/

(, !""# $ %

& ##" '

(##)*+

F,/(!. ;(, G

$ % # & #

(

# )'

# $ '

H %?

! "."/""!"" !0. ,0 !"""//0")"

$( ).! ,0 / ;(,/*

! ""!"" ! ""

/",0 "

!0 ,() ,0 !"" !"" "&6%1:3 ; ; ! "," ") ;(. ")" ") @("/"" ") "

" "/ /* ""/!* ") /"." !" )" @("/ ",D " !")/0 /0"D !"/ "/"))"//)/"0!"0 " " ")$( ). @("/ ( ") ;(.0. , < !!//"/;( $( " I,/ (!. ;( " )"- ) $% $)#"& ##"'

-.))#"+

* "/ /")*" ""/!* ") ;(" )" @("/ / //* G*+

, $

- ./0

1 ,

' #

# 2

, 2

3 $ 2

$ ', $

% 3

3 $

3 $ ,

- 2

H %9

""* ,2." /"." ! ""/$(" "" ! "/") ." ! (" " ( , " 0 "//)/"0!"0" " ")( ,0, /

;(,/* !"" ,,/ .0

" (. ." ")2 ")"

! ;(,/** "/!") $( ). @("/ ,0

(").""$("

!"" "

/ ,0 ! (" // !@("

! B "/ , " ! %8 (//0 ! "."/ "" !"" "

"." ,") "

")!!/"

"13 "0 /// "!

")/0

. - .,%% 565& $

C !<")A A C !,/ A