← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4613/2018dismissed

Dinesh Kumar Khatri v. M/S Shri Balaji Stone Crushing Company

2018-05-16Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages





       

%&'!'() #*"#$ ('+,-.%,+%& /'&&(' 0'- 1 +%%2 &('-+(3.4%(5 / '4(6'(&  

     ''(&)

%7,%&+-%867%&'8!&+'4'&&(' ,%2%4%&867%&'8!&+''4(6'(& 

 !

5&+4'&&(8&+'4'&&(''':&+';-%+(3!&+'6' 6%&'6  "<#"#<8  4%'6  =5 &+'  '%('6  -6%  %3&%&'  &  %8

%6%=%68>(('?-' @8=5A++&+'%44%&(!'6=5&+'4'&&(' -(6' '&( 8!'

'?%.(%&(!&+'.4%(%(&(&+'

.4%(&(;-'&(8+%=''(6.'6 B'%('6-('!&+'4'&&('-=.&&+%&&+'4'&&(' +-6(&='4'(%C'6!&+'!%-&!+-('((&+%7(3

'?%.('6&+'.4%(%(&(%7&%-'3(3&&+'&!&+'.%&&'8 A++%&-%5%.'-4%&&+'&.'A+'(&+'&%&'.'(&!&+'%-'6-(6'

'&("

>3@A%'6'68=5A+++'+%66'('6+%=&5 &A%6&+'.4%(%(&8%(6+%6!-&+'&%&'6&+%&('&+'&+'+';-'=' +3(%&-'8(A%&!'6-4%(6-'6=5+.(!%7-!&+' .4%(%(&8%(6%%.%&&'!!%&&+%6=''(&'(!.++-' +-8  %  4'  &+'  '%('6  -('8  &+'  %6  &%(6  !  &+' 4'&&(' %-'6A%';-'6&='4-&&&+'.4%(%(&=5A%5! '?%.(%&(8A+++-('+%6(&6('8(!%&'%6(3&

"

+%(3'!-(' B'%('6-('!&+''4(6'(& .4%(%(&8(&+'&+' +%(68!&-=.&&+%&%&%&'6(&+'.4-3('66'8&+'.4%(%(&A% '?%.('6=5&+'-('!&+'4'&&(' %-'6(&+''6%&'8' # # "#<8   #<"#<  %(6  -5 "#8  "#<8  %(6  %  -+  +'  +%6  =''( '?%.('6%&'(3&+%(&'6(&+'.4-3('66'8%(6&+''!'&+' -=';-'(&!(3!&+'%44%&(-(6' '&( 8!'%(3 &+'.4%(%(&!'

'?%.(%&(8A%(5%6'%5(3&%& +-3+&+-&+%6=''(!&+'4((&+%&3%(&(3(' 44&-(&5&&+'4'&&('&'%&+'.4%(%(&&'?%.('+.(5 (&+%&4%&-%4(&%+%=''('!''6&+''(%=7'8A-6(& 4'2-6'&+''4(6'(& .4%(%(&8+A'7'8 '%('6-('!&+' '4(6'(&!-&+'''-4(%2-63.'(&!&+' -4'.'-&(&+'%'

! " #$$%" & $'("" & $8 "# >*@ *D#84'!%54(&(3&4%% !&+'2-63.'(&8A++ '%6%-(6')

 F'+%7'(6%&'6&+%&-(6' '&( *!&+'&8 &+'.4%(%(&%(37'+'76'('=5A%5!%(%!!6%7&%(6-+ %!!6%7&+%=''%6('76'('(%(5(;-58&%&+'4''6(3 (&+'-&8A++.%:'&'%&+%&%.4%(%(&(&';-'6& '?%.('+.'!&A''('%!&'!(3&+'.4%(&%(6('%!&' -..((3!&+'%-'6 !!6%7&%(6&+'6-.'(&!'6=5&+' .4%(%(&%(3A&+.4%(&!&%:(33(C%('!&+'!!'('%' 36'(-3+&=''%6('76'('%&=&+&+'&%3''4' -..((3 &%3'%(6&+'4&-..((3&%3'(&+'A68&+''((''&5

&'%%(6'

'?%.('&+'.4%(&%!&'-..((3!%-'68-(' &+'%3&%&'4%'%4'!6'%&A+5&+'.4%(%(&&=' '%'6  -+%(6'&='4%'6(%(%44%&(.%6'=5&+' %-'6-(6' '&( *>"@!&+'&-.&=5&+'-&( -..%5&%8%!&'&+'%-'6-..('68+4'%&=''6'6 -(6' '&("

>3@%(6+'?%.(%&(8!%(58%(='6('=5% %3&%&'%(6%!(6(3%(='37'(=5&+'-&-(6' '&("

>+@ %(6&+'%.'4'6-'%(='!A'6=5%%3&%&'! !!'('!6+(-!+';-'('!!'('-(6' '&( $!&+'& %6-.'(&=%'6!!'('F'.%:'&'%&+%&!&+'47>%@8>=@ G>@& '&( $!&+'&%'+A(&+%7'=''(.4'6A&+8 &'+(%5&+'..(!&+'!!'('&%(6.4'&'6%(6&! &+'%-'6&+A&+%&(!!'('-6+%7'=''(..&&'6=5+.! 4'!'%(%(66'!'('H (7'A!A+%&+%=''(+'6=5&+' -4'.'-&+''( %=7'8&&+''!!'&&+%&(!%&&+''((''6&'%%(6''?%.('% .4%(%(&%!&'-..((3&+'%-'68=-&&+%&%'%65+%7(3=''( 6('(&+'4''(&%'8A&+&+'.4%(%(&+%7(3%'%65=''( '?%.('6%&'(3&+8''('%(&(&'!''A&+&+'.

4-3('6 6' (';-'(&58&+4'&&(6.'6 A'7'8(%&-%58A+'%62-6%&(3-4(&+'.%&&'8&+' '%('6&%-&A-6:%&&+'-'(&&&%&58(-6(3A+'&+' &+'%-'6+%6%&&+'(&%&%3'%'!-&'63((3&+'+';-''&8%(6 A+'&+'(-+-.&%('&+'(-A-6+!&(&&+'.

47'&+'%=&5!&+'%-'68(6+%3'!A+++'+%6-'6&+' +';-'8>(&'.! '&($!&+''3&%='(&-.'(&&8$$@    !

 ) 

#*"#$ 73%3