← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12460/2022dismissed

Subhita v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-07-10Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj15 pages

   

        

  ! ""# SUBHITA  

 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 

$  %&$  '( '  )      *****      



!"

 $

 

  

&

!' !(

)

  '*

!"

   

*

!"



   +

!"

 $



,  (*

 ----- ( '  )+ , -./ 1.

.

 /       

    

   010203 4

5  006   +)  # 

). 5# " 7$$ # !

%.

!  !'  #

   

   $   02320 +) 

, 8



! (

)

   / #

 

% / *

  $ 

) +

$

 # /  

  $9  %  #



/   : 0;! + /  / + $

 

!     

   

         

 

-2-  <

.

 

+ $ $ 

#

  

 

 

$ 7  

+

$   

#  +) ##

 

  / $ 102203

2023203!



   $ 

 # 

#



 #

) 

 + 

!$$ 

# # #

     $ 

 

  $ %    

 (   ! .

%  '

     /  #

#

     

 #

#  

 (   ! .

%  '

 "    

!   # 

$  !    # !

  +

## $#

#

=#     +) #

## $#

#

=



   #"  , 03 2023203   #  

!   # 

  

! '  # > &&

 ?

@ 

# /  #

 0A .

 .   #

#   # ) #

   $



##

  

$ 

 #

#

    

+ 

+ 

 

#

 $ # 

  #

  $  /+)   

$

% /#

 

 



           

 $

 5/

 $

$  9  %! " !  

 #  +)  5# "7$$ #  1 // " $

! 

$



 +$

 8

 

  +  $$  "  $  

) #

# +)  $$ #  $  



%

-3- *

 =        +)  8

 

! (

)

 5 #  /  $  . $ 

 " 

   02320// " $!   

+ $   =.

$

 

" )

/  # @ 

 # + .

#

' .  $ # 

 @

# /7 # @

+ $$ ! 

'

# 

"#

#

@ $ 

# #

+ $   +    #  ( $   " )

/    

 

) #

# +)  $$ #  $  .



)  & 

 

$ 

  /! >   / 

$ 

 

"

 )/ "

$$  "   #

  

5 01 

/     

  ) " 

)  



 

  

/#

 ( #!+  

$ @

#

#+) $$ #  

 " "

 #

$   

/  " +  #

  

 /

  ( $  #



)# !#  $#

#

 

 

 @

# /#

#+)  # "

+  /

  ## $ # ) #

  

## #

#

   

/  #

  $ ! 

## $ )  $



/ +

   $ "

 9  

!.

$

 

(

)

  / # 

% /*

/ #

$ 

-4-

@  +) $$ #  $ 





#  $ @ )#

#+) ! $ &



 /

>  

$

  #

=

"  +  #

#

 # $ # !  $

 #  

 

 

$ 7  

   /  # #  

 $ /+ 

 

    //   " # # #

 (    $ #

#

## $ $7 +   $ $

  !  # )  /  +)  

!  $$ #  $  



% / *

 # 

#

) 

#



/   $    

 # 

 # "     # $201=#

##

/)# = #



 #+) 

)   /



5  0"

5

# $

 5

#   !"# $#  %   

"   %   &  '

 "(  ''  '        "

 )") *   "     

(#"

 ( "

% "(      

% %

"(  (' 

   (' 

% &(( 

 " " "



("

""

  "  ! ++, -*  .  

. 

.  ( % %     ' ) 

  

. 

.  ( " "

   "( ## "   '

 " #      ("

"

 &

 

 

#"

  &      "  % #   ("

" " %

"(  (# (   #  "(  

(# 

( #   #

  &

      "

 

-5- "'( ( 

  ( "(

%  "(  #  ''((  ( ( % '       #   ((%    '( % 

 '(

"   &

   ' 

  " "

 ++,% %   /  # & '

   '%   #   0

 &     ( #   &$  

 "(  * 

     "

 )") *    0

      ''((    

(  %  & #

    "   "      1#

 &

  

%  2



# 

 "  (' 

%"(       %% %

"(  (' 

   # "(  # ''(( 

% ( "

  /  " #(( $    "  '

  &#  ("    #"

 "

"  " # " / 2

  #   %  &  ''((   "     ("

" "  ! "

     0

  (       #"

   "

 )") *  &

    2

 '

      #  

  

%   "    ("

"

  (' 

%"(   ! # 

"   "

&  "( # ''(( 3

 0( 4%5#  '

   6) 4%5 +     &(  #   #     (&  ( ''( %   "

"

 '

"

  "

 ("

" " #

 8  

%  %

"(  ( ' 

 9' 



   #1   7 2(# # % % "     #  #"

   "

"  "  '%     #  "

 )

-6- ") *   0

 ( '(  "( #

''((  "

 /  "" %(  B (#

  +&#+ #   /

$

 

#    // " $

)

#  $



)  

) 

/ #  #

  

$

 

#

#  

)$



 ?  +  +)      # @ 

# + # " + #

5 $#

"

# +&#

 

#

#

+ $ 

)+# ' .  $ # 

?

@

"+ $

 = 

'

" /   $) $  #  "

  ) $  #

 ( $     $ 

/ #  $   #  "  '01'12 ! "  '

 '"

(   "    "

 # ""

  ""

 

% %

"(  ( ' 

  # ( ((%     ( % %   " % #  " '(" 

     # 1   / ((&''( "&( #  %

"(  ( (&         (&  "

%    %

"(  ( ' 

 9' 

 "( % "

(   '(

#  % 

#  %   



   

   45+   &( # #   (& 

   ""

  ""

  (  %    :%

"(  (" /'( !(2 ' 

-7- :''(  " 

 %   #  &   '( 

  #1  ; <$$ $$$$ $$$$ $$$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ 45+ # &( # #   (&   ("

""

 ("

%  "%

"(  ( ' 

 ; $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $$$ $    45!'

#  2

#  % ''( "

     : $  " ! '

#  & ((' &(## ''( "   & %   & '

   & 9 / "# 

# (# &  &  "  ##   

% &

'

  " &' / "#  #

% & & " ##   (# & '

  &' " &       "'' ##      #  '

 #  '

 (&'  

/# &   & " )##   # % '

#  $ 

%   & '  ! ''( "

  ( ( &

 %   #    9

# ''( " 4&5 /     #   #   "

  ''( "

    &  %  &  $  #    &   (%(

'

 

# " !"( '

  & 

  &   ' "   &  #  = "  /  " #  "

'( 0

9 "

'( 0 ' 

   

"

  (( & &    %

  "

'( 0     /   & " # >  = "  -&   #   ((% " "   

 & " #

  "

'( 0





-8- :



   #   "

'(

  

  "( '

 ! # 



 

 ((&&  # 

 &)+    ( % 

  " "   " #  "(

    & (

 '

(   "'(  

"'"



 #&9( & 

 

 "

" #  (,%  ?( +"

 ((&""'

  4"5:"'# (   '

 ' )

 '

 " #      & (

 "

"  " # & (

((&   # &

% "(   45!"( '

 (&''

& :## 

( 

  & *  0        0( % 

   45 /  " #     "

"     " # ' "((#( &' % '# (#  ( & &(

 9

" &(## "(  4#5 ! 0

 9:



   # " "    0

 (( & "'   ' #  ''( "

 9"(  "    "&"

  (("

( '    # 1:@  %5!0 #:



  # @  '     "

   '

"  (    #  %''( "

 9"(  

 '(# 

 

"   ''

'

 #  '( 

  #  "   4' ''( 5 A ? + +)  @

 @ 

# /

  # +

) 

#   @ 5  #

)$    ##

  # 

-9- #

#

#

    

"  # 

##  =

#

+#

 #

# "

$



  # #  @

 %  #

#

 .

 #

#

  $ #      $ #

 = 

 

 +

  $$ #  $  

 $

 #

)   $ # $ / @ 

"

  $) "  #   # +  ) $  #

      + $   + #

 +  

= +&# @

# .

. 

)  @ # 

# #

#+ #

) $  

     $) 

) # + #

$$ # 

 

  * !   $ @

  

/    

 

) 

7 





+ #

+) ! " !  

 % +)  @ )7$$ # " #

 $

  =  #



+ #

#

) #



  / "  # #

#!

 $

 +)   @ 7$$ # D( .

+ %

 2023203#

+ %

 $

 "  #

  # 

 # #

#   #  #  %  #=#  $

  +  #

$ 

 3 ? " 

 

 .

 

 + $ $ 

# "

 

"/



/ #   

/     



-1002 " /!  +   # )

/+).

  

    #

 # $201



) # @  +$

  .  $ #   #

 

!'

)'

)

!



$$

#  $ 

 @

! " !?$  $ )$   .

$

 

 00 .   $    #   # + 

#   #

 +$

 

/ 

 #

$

%

 $

  $ $

 + $      

  

      

 * #

+   

  

    #  #

 + 

%  $



/     $ 

   #

 #

     #  = 

'

   +   

 #  @

#

   #

 + # "     #

   #

  # 

#

# +     = .   4$

 /6 $  #

"     .

D

$  #

#

 

% .

 #

     $  #

D#

# " # +&# " #

 " 

$(

)

  / #



% /*

. $

$*

 

    

%

 $ #

  

#    

 $

 #

D#

$

   ( #!#  $

$   

)   #

 #   #   #

  



?$ $#   $

-11- + $  )

+ 

$  # !

##

$

"

)   

 #

#

 % # 

 #

  #  " # $ # ) 

"  

+ 

$     #

$ 

$!  # D#

+#

     $#

 0  #

& #

 

#  +  

"  $

# 

  @  + % +)#

#

 

)!  $ #

$#

 

)

"

  )

 +  ) $ #

#+) #

 +

 #

#

+ ++)

     $  ! " ) #  #

   +   

5

  #

$  $#

# ? 

+   / $ $

+ $  #



) +  )

  $+ "

 #=*

  #     $  #

 ) %   #

#  @ ) $

   $) $ +  /   $  #

 = @

#  ++  

/   #

#

+ $



 

) #  #

+ %$

 01  +

   #

# $    @ ) #

 +  

@  # + 0  $  !   $ @

  

@

  



) $ /  #    # 

#

#   # #  @

%  #=

 #

 + ##  #

# " 

$  # 

#

#+   $



? $  "   

-12- $ $   $"  /   #

+)

$$ #  $ 

% / *

) # $ # ) $

 +    "

/ %  #

 +)# 



 $# #   

"

/

$

 " /= #  @

% #   # # $   # 

  #  $ 

#

? 

  +





$#

 % #

 +)

" "   #

 ?

 

+ #

" /

 + / #

#   # #

#   #   #  @

%  #! $



+)( .

+

/#  @

# /!

+ # " #



# $ @  # 201 09 ?  @  +%

@  % $



/  # 

 # #

# $ #

 ) $   =

+&#+ 

+

)$

/ !

 "!



$+ # $) 

/  

/& #+  $

  # 

$  #  $  

 

/  # #

#  /  7

) " /



) #

  $ /

#  $ + 

# #

# /



/ ( " !   $ @

 #  $      " )  

  $ #

@  + % +)( /.





#

$ 

 

 $    / #)

#

-13-

$

)

= $ " /

+)

 / "

# $$

)

%

$

  $) #$  ),  

 +

+) "

#

  

#

#

+)" /

/  #

## 

@ )$

# # )'

+ 

$ 

 

)# ##

# )

# #   #

##

#

)#

$

# 

# #

# $  $  $ #  +  )

+ #$  

)+

# $#

+&# " )!



 $  0B "   /!  # $ 201   + "

  #

/   $

 

#    $

D +



) 

/  #  #

! " !  + $     #  #

 + / "

 +)  ) ) 

  #

/ + $    #   @    $$    / +  ) #

 

       ##  

/  # 

#

=!  

"   ) $ +    # #

# $  #

   @  $  #

 %+ $  # !201 0A =   #

 

 $

 #

 + $  #

 + $ # 

$) )?



/ ! .

$

) +   + # 5#@    

  +  ) +   

   + #  $ 

) #

$

+ $  = 

+ +  ) $ #



  

/  

# $ $

 )

+

 $   #

  

+  = @ $   +

-14- +

)   $  +$

"

/ @ )  .

$   

#

$ + # $  +  #

)  /

  $   

#  $

!$ "

 

+ 



 0 =  

  " )  

  $$  "  $    ) "

$

 +      #

  =) 

 7$$ #   @ + #  $  )

$ +) +@ $$  " #

'#"

+$$ #    



   / #

+) 



" !  



"    "

   $$ #  $





 "    "  /

   

 #

"/   #

=" )$ # 

   #



   $   "  /

+@ $$  "  "+ $ +) 



/  

 



5 0

01#

)

 @

 +) $$ #  $ 



% /*

$ "    "  /

 +)     $$ #   

" +  +$

 

 

 

%#

%

+    $  # $ # "  / =)

 "

   

  ) #

 

) # #

#!  

/ "   @

$$ #?#

+ +   #$ @

)  

 $#    /  

#

+ $   +  =

+)  

 #

+ + 

+

 " 

+ 

"  #

-1503 ?$   

 /  )

 "  ) 

 +)  

  = 

##

/)  =   

 

##

/)         ,( '  )/  & +""#        (  E  /D



 FD, E 

+  FD,