High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2172/2025dismissed

Jai Kishor v. Mukesh Kumar And Others

2025-07-24Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"()* * * *++ ++ ++ ++ &,&'-". +++//!00( 1!.'2'

23!'-,24.($" -!.' +++ !'/"($!( '

)

) 56 + ,

7 56 + ,

7 .!'!( )

.+"-(,24.8$9"% !#". -!//!00( + ,

78+ .0

78+ .0 + //!00( $!#!($( "+8 & ,&'-".8 -' /.!#!..!$ -&' .!:20. '!%"($ //!0 :&(' -! ;2$:4!( ($ $!%.!! $ !$ <++ /''!$ => 0!.(!$ &' .&% 2$:!8 0?0 -!.!&(# !. .!#!..!$ "' -!@&.' //!00 ! "2. 5 8?-!.!=>8 -!//!0#&0!$=> -! //!00( %-00!(:&(: -! ;2$:4!( ($ $!%.!! $ !$ ++ /''!$ => 0!.(!$ &9&0 2$:! 2(&". &9&'&"( 8 0?0 -!.!&(# !. .!#!..!$ " ' -! @ .&0 "2. 5 8 -!.!=> $!%.!!&(: -! '2& #&0!$ => /0&( &##.!'/"($!( "+8 23!'-,24.8?'2/-!0$+ +

!'/"($!( "+ 23!'- ,24. #&0!$ %&9&0 '2& #". /!.4(!( &(;2(% &"( :&(' //!00( $!#!($( "+8 '!!3&(: &(;2(% &"( - -!//!00( =!.!' .&(!$#."4%.! &(:-&($.(%!&( /2=0&%/'':!+-!//!00( '?!00'.!'/"($!( $!#!($( "+8

2(&%&/0 "2(%&08"$08%"( !' !$ -!%&9&0'2& +''2!'?!.!#.4!$+ " - -! /. &!' 0!$ !9&$!(%! ($ -! .&0 "2. $!%.!!$ -! '2& 8 .!' .&(&(: -!$!#!($( '#."4!(%."%-&(:2/"( -!/'':!4.3!$

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

<+ -! %'! "# -! /0&( &## .!'/"($!( "+ 23!'- ,24.

&' - -! &' -! "?(!.&(/"''!''&"( "# .!'&$!( &0 -"2'! '& 2 !$&(.&!($' "0"(>8"$0E-&' A''!''4!( (24=!.&' ($& &''& 2 !$?& -&( -!.!"# 2(&%&/0 "2(%&08"$0+!-' 3!( /0! - -! //!00( ($ " -!. /.&9 ! .!'/"($!( ' &( %"002'&"(?& - -!.!'/"($!( 2(&%&/0 "2(%&0.! .>&(: "!(%."%- 2/"(/2=0&%/'':!($ -!>?( "4!.:! -!'4!&( -!&."?( /0" F-"2'!+ ' /!. -! '& !/0( ((!A2.! A+ =!#".! -! .&0 "2.

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

.!.!/."$2%!$'2($!.) I( -! %'! "# /2=0&% (2&'(%! ". " -!. ?."(:#20 % ##!% &(:8".0&3!0> "##!% 8 -!/2=0&%8'2& #".$!%0. &"( ($&(;2(% &"(".#".'2%-" -!..!0&!#'4>=!//."/.& !&( -!%&.%24' (%!'"# -!%'!84>=!&(' & 2 !$8

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

-!//!00( -'("4!.& '+ + -!#&($&(:'.! 2.(!$=>0!.(!$ .&0 "2. '?!00'=> -!&.' //!00 ! "2. $"(" .!D2&.!(>&( !.#!.!(%!+-!'2& -' =!!(.&:- 0>$!%.!!$+ + -! /.!'( //!0 -' (" 4!.& ' ($ %%".$&(:0>8 -! '4!' ($'$&'4&''!$+ + !%.!!=!$.?(%%".$&(:0>+ *+ !($&(:4&'%!00(!"

'-00' ($$&'/"'!$ "#+ *++ *++ *++ *++ K ,

7L K ,

7L 20'! -& 7-! -!.'/!3&(:F.!'"(!$) !'

7-! -!. !/". =0!) !'