High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/882/2004allowed

Sucha Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-19Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul,Mr. Justice H.S. Grewal12 pages

6% ,,--.,,.//0

00$$!

,0 "

'-)

7 , 6% ,,.-1,,.//2

00$$!

,0 "

!"!

#$%$ $"&'./.2 ( ) ) * ))

) + 8 ,!(%$8 (!+ "

!' (!00$$!')

) 8 7 $+ 7 +%9!:

( ! !00!$ " " !&! ( 9%"&1

! " " # "!" ;

< -= 0!" :2 ( $!"

"" !$ %"& ' "(

) !

* %+ %"!0% ! ,

"!" --%" ;->;= " !!$ "+ + .+ & " ! ! (! ?*?!&!+ ! & % # !

% "

"!"/ - ( !!00 0!$@0#":2!

%"?

!00$$!!

!1$2% (! &(+(!3! & &(!"4!""!5 %" !$ &(

- 7% & ( 0" # ( !

!00!$ ', ?7?-.?7?-B)+ + !00$$!

(!3! &((!D0 "

(! "!00!$ ( 1!" !:!"

;

(09%"&1+(# +

"( (!$$&!( ! ( 1! & @ !00$$! E % (! &( !" 4!""! 5 5

%" !$ & &(+@( @

"!" "!# $$ @:2($!"

!$ %?

$# 5 ) !

) #

!# !36 "

# !#

683 #

, ;+>? , # D1 ( $"

% (! &( ;-

10 1 $ # 5 ;->;=

10 1 $ # 4!""!

%" !$ &( , ;+>? , # D1 ( =

(0 !+!%# $"

"":2(!1 #!*!( ( &( 'A;

;)

"" - ! !:

% ; 0 + (! / - !

! !:

% ; 0 + !00$$! (!3! &( !" 4!""! 5 5

%" !$ & &(!$ &@ ((

%" % (! &( !1 # #( ( % #!

!*!( &('A;) ( *

* &+!*!( &(00"

%+ !

0! " :2 ( #!(+ 8%(! &( '( " !")+ !" ( : (8%*( ( ! &('A=) (!!&+!

%"% (! &(! "!

C !*!( &( 'A;) ( " (! # $$ @"+ 4!""! 5 5

%" !$ & &("$ "! :$ @ ( (!" #8%(! &(!:

($#2+ @(%0 (#$$ (& % "

(!3! &((!$$&"$2 "$ "!

( :$ @ ($#$&>!

!*$ #(" !"

!$!1 1 : &! "+ (!

%"#$"

( 9%" @! !* $ 0 !$+ !!$!+ @( 7 %*(" 0 0 &( 'A) 1"

?$&!

!$$2 D!1 " ( 1 ! !:

0 / -!"# %"@

"@ %"? ' )

"@ %"= 1D- 1 ($#0 !$& !$$2 0$!

($#2: @= 1# 1(1 "$ !"< 1# 1 ($#!0 0 !

#%:$" &@!0 A %"@!:

"0!"

@!*0%"

" :! %0 $@ 1 1!$ ! @!

@!->/8 88 #& %$@!01 %+&%$!H ' )

"@ %"= 1DI 1

(! 1"

!$!0 @>;"

#$#$&/ 1!:

($#! *$9 $" &@!0

(@ %"@ @!:

"0 G?!2@!!" "

(@:

"0+@ (0

#%:$" &+! :%!:$ !

! (!0?"&" @!0 @ ( . ( % "%!

( 8"

4&!$ ,0 '84,)'D )@!0 "

/ (

" #( 9%"

" !"+(@!#" - %% !* 7 0 !$+ 1 !+ @( ( %

%1:"

! %" 01 ( 0 @ # 1"H ( !1 # !*!( &( ( 'D )@!

""!;0 (# 1!$ $ ,'D >!" >-)@!

& "! B;0 H!"(0 !$,0

("(

8!& ! !.;B0

#(!

%"@!"

"+ &! @! ! " $!" & ( (0! (!$$!!&! (1 ( !@!(!#

11 "

( % + @( ( !

%" @ (!&" #

## %" ;-!"@ ( ;= + @( ((20$!""

&% $2 !

" $! 1" !$ ( 0 D!1 " ! 1!2 ! @

$%" & A 7 %*(" 0 & &( '@(

" ( 1"

$&!$D!1 ! # ( " !")+ A- ! ( (!" J7!#1! @(

00!"( 0$!'D )L+A;!*!( ( &('

10$! !)!"A= = 8%*( ! &('2@ )+!"AB7

% K:!$ &('@(

(0 1 1 #(" !") AB7

% K:!$ &( 0 "(! 9%2

( (!"@!%## ( "

% #!% !% "!( !""

" + ! # 1!$@ @ @D!1 "!"(

# @! !" (!:## "!( ( ! #(!

( D!1 ! %" ;; + ( !

" " ( 1 ! & %1! + 0$ !"" #!$ 10$ ! "%

$$!& !$ 2+ !"(!( " !" @ @! ( "" !& '( !$$&" K%! $ : & @ ( !*!( &() + !" %&" (! ( @!

!%"!(H !2 !(( &(+( !@ %$"

#!$$%"

;='

)

( !

%" " " $!" !2 " ( "# ( $!" !$ %+# " &(

%$!!

% %

@ ((1"

!$ $ " !"

"$2 &%0 (

2+% "# " & #&% $ 4!"

1!" ( # $$ @ & %:1 :(!$# #( !00$$!? '

)

(

% @! !" ( (! !* 0$!

! !:

% ; / -H ( " !" @! ( #" ( ( 0 !$+ @( ( 1"

?$&!$ D!1 ! @!

"! 0 (!1 &(H( " " -!!:

%0 M+( !1 #A;!*!( &( ( @!

" $2 ! !:

% ; 0 - ( # 1!$ , , 'D > !"

" >-) @! & " ! B; 0 + !" ( 0 !$ ,0 "

!&%"(!( !

("(8 8!& !!.;B0 4!"

%D0$! " "$!2!## "" % 2# "

"$ :! +1:$$ (1!"

% & '

)

@!!$ #%(!&%"(! A7 %*(" 0 &("% & & ( "0

!& !$$2 !"1 " (! ( ( 0! ( !"!"

"!2#!

#!!%$:2! 2 +1% ($(!00$$!

":2($!"

(! ! ! #1%" %

@!! !!

* :2 * @ 0 + % ( $ @!

!: 1!$ !" %!%!$+ !"

$!$2@ (

#( ! #(0

4!"

+ @( $ '

) "!@ & ( ! # ( % (

?D!1 ! #A7 %*(" 0 &(+!&%"(!(

@ !

0" (! ( !*$ 9%2 ' 9% %2

-) ( " !" @ ( ( # "$2(!"

" ! :%$" ( $!

!$2%"1 "(! (0

(!:

( 9% @ ! $2# 1(!0?"&"@!0 :$ @ '

@!#%(!&%"(!:

( ((!$$&"2@ A;

; !*!( & &(!"A=8%*( ! &(@ ((!( (" !"

+!"@( @+!0( !

#(0 +0@( ( #!(

(" !"@!!!

4!"

!&%"

(!!&$2 2+ #(@ 2@ 1!"!2!10 0 ( #!(!

!"! (%!" 2%## !!

&(:

%H( %&(( ! $!2 ( % #(( 0 !$!"(( 0 !$@!!:

%= = *1!@!2+( (2$ "&" 0 (! &(! "1! " $ $2!#( "!(+@( ( (@!!&! 1!$(%1!

+ %$2 ! &"

%: ( 0

!( 1 @!!$ $ %:1 "(!!0( 0$! 'D )+ (

* 0$!

% " ( ( % # (

10$! ! 0!2 (0 0 " "0"!:$ % #$ &(! (

1 % ( %1!

!$ + " # ! # ( !! $!@!

!D1$2"

%:#%$ '6) %(1 + $!"

!&%" (! (

! :%" % (! &(@! !

(!$ !*!( &('A;)H( " !" "

(%+!0(0 +(" !"

@! ( ""!&+

!%( "!(

%$":

(( &(+ #!2 ## @! 1!" % !

0"#!

+ @ %$" : % " ;='

) H ( @ + ( !00$$! ""

K% !$ '6 )

@! $!$2 !&%" (! :

( A; !*!( &( !" A= = 8%*( ! &(+ : & $! ( " !"+ @ %"

@ H ( ( 1 2

!" :

:2 "0" @ !"

1!":2 1 !"

+@!%!

!# $2%0 (!: !2 9%

((@ +"0 : &!!1N$&(# 1( #!(+#%( ""( " : $ 2 - +$!"!

% $9% # "("$!2 $ "& & &

#( ,:2 2!&% &(!( 11" !0

2 #(#!1 $2@! % !1 ! " ! $ # # ( " !"H # 1!$ ! " ( %& 1"

!$ ! ( 1$ "

" " + :2 $#+ " ( 0 +(# +"

%:#%$ ;

@! #%( !&%" (! A A; !*!( &(N 1 2

$!$2 !1 !

! : &

!" !%!$ !" @! #%(

:2 A= 8%*( ! &(

8 " 0! ( 1 @ @ !:$!"@ %$"

1! !!2" (

! #(0 = A( $# & (1"

!$ " +$!"!

%$ $ %:1 " ( (! (

%$! 1 2 # % " "%

! @ ( ( 1"

!$ "

" (#!!$*%$$ 9%2@!

!%":2!(!0?"&"

@!0 !" @!%## ( " !2

% !% "!( !$

!" (! ?!! # ( ( 2

# !!%$ A 7 %*(" 0 0 &( :2 (

10$! ! !" ( : ( A= 8%* ! &( @ %$" !"$2!## # ( ! #(0 !( 0 2!(!0 1@! 11 1" !!1 #( 9% "#!( %(1 +

#( !

!( ! #(!

%"0

""!"" !$

0!2@! +(# +1!"# " 1 !$

#( !!00!$ B A(!(!"$!"

%$ # (0! !"0%"( "

(# $$ @ & %! # " 1 ! ? '!) A(( ( "$!2 !" K% $ "& & ( , !" ! #!

$2 2D0$! "H ':) A(((

#A; !*!( &(!"A=8%*( ! &(!"( ( ?" % ("

>0 10! ( " : $ 2 (

%$! H '

) A(( " # ! ! ( # # 1 "

%: ( 0! $ &

" H '") A(( ( 0 0

%" ;=

0! %$!$2 % (! &(+ @( $ $ 1 " !

H ') A(( ( @( $+ ( 0 @! %%

#%$ !:$ ( & (&% $ #(!

%":2 " ! !:$"

%:H

'#) A((:# #"

%:1% % (!00$$! /

(

% @! ! ; 0

/ -H ( 1 84, #( " !"@!

""! 0 # $$ @":2"!(! %"

0 - (!1 #A A;!*!( &('D )@!

""! ;0 -+$!" & (& ! ## 1!$ $ , 'D > > !" >-) ! B; 0 ( ( 0 !$ ,0 !

(" ( 8!& ! !

! .;B 0 A( $ "$!2 #!!$+ "1!" !

! 0$!% :$ !"

& D0$!! : !% ( , D0 " : ( !$

+ "0 ( 9%" : & !* !

1 ( 0 !$+ (

10 ! % 1 1! ( 0 H !# "!( ! ! #!$ ( 0 !$+ ( # 1!$ 1!

( 2 @! 1 $2 ( %$!

(D0$!! (!(#!1 $2 0 3"!1+ ! + (#!

+#%$ $$2!

%# ( $ "% &( &(!"!&! !#( "!(E0!

%$!$2@(( % ((

0 !$0!"(0 !

0 (

! # ( 0 + :

( A; !*!( &( !" A= = 8%*( ! &(+ #(" !"+@ "(

% K% + + ( @+!

!&$2 #(@ :

(" 0 ( 1

(0 !#(" !"(!": #" (#!$( 0 !$! 1 ! ( (( !% #% (K%!$ 2!"$ &(! 01 !"$ :! !"1:$$ ( (1 A+(# +# "1 (

#($!"

# (!00$$! (

$2+!0A7 %* *(" 0 &(+ ((0! ( ! "! A; !*!( &( !" A= 8%*( ! &( ( " " ! 2( & !:

% ( !!%$ ( ( "

! ! # !$$&"

!&"!!

*!"(!

:2* @ $$!& &+ ?" % #( #!

%1 # ! !%$ '$ !$ !1) ! ( !$ 1"

!$ #!

! %!%!$ 1 %0$" @ ( ( !"1 1 " #! $% !$ ( 0 "% & ( &( "0 0 ! ( (

0 !$ !" ( !: # !2 !10:2 A;!*!( &(!"A=8 8%*( ! &(

! !(%!

!" 2!!

& &(:

%+( (

!00!

@ ( 1!$ $ (%1! :(!

% ( #! % %1%$! $2

" ( @ ( # (

%$! !

% !"

" " ( 0 # A;

; !*!( & &(!"A=8%*( ! &(!( ( 1"

%:#%$ < 0( 0$!'D )+( "

*0$!

% "( ( % #(

10$! !0!2 (0

@!%!:$ 0 !2 "#

% #$ &( &!;0 (1 ( # %&% %!$ $ &+ 0! %$!$2 ( !: # 0

# #% !$ $ &( % + + " # ! ("!* (!"

%:+ (!$ " $! ( 0 0 !" #!1 $ ! 2

" (! " # ! @! ($ 0 :$+ + ( @+@( ((20 #(2@ @ !$!"2%""

%: !"( , , $# "$!2"+!:

# #$ &( &:

& # ! # 1 2 ( 0 : $ 2 # 1 !* " 2 ! : !#$2 D $%""

- AB7 % K:!$ &(! :% %""!( #(" !" ( (!" 9%2+ %## ( " !2

% !%"!( (!1"

!$ $

$% +( ( @+"

+:2 $#+0 (!%( ( 0 #( 9%2

(0 !+@(@ &("@ ( (%!%!$ 1 !"( "

%:#%$0 > " # ! + # ! !:$"

%:!:

%(D!

1! #! !%$!"( $! :%"

( !$$&"

2 # + ! :+

! - " (:!

*" 0 #%$ !:$

% %$! " +"

%:#%$0 !" " #

! +!"( # 1 "+ % (

2 ! %! !

$ &(+ " #

2 !

! %: %# 0! 0! :2 "!

!:$"

%: -- 1 !$ 9% 0%" K% ( 0 !:$ ( ( &% $ :2 "

" ! !:$ "

%: ( 0 !+ (

!! # ' ) & # ! !" !"K%!$2 D0$! "

" "$!2 $ "& & ( ,H H ' )#! $%

" !( 2 #!!%$:

:2!1"!! $!!(#

% 2 E E ( 1 # !"1 # ( " !" ( ( 0 !$H ' ) )

# A;!*!( &(!"A=8 8%*( ! &(+

@ ( (

" !2 (% %1! :(!

%H ' ) ?0 0

# $ &( & " & & " # ! ! &(%!#+$!%@ ( (! "%!$"

%:+@( ( :

( ( ! !:$! "%:! !$

( $!" !$ % $

*" ( %1%$! ## ( # 1 (0 "

# " ( "&(! ($!@"1!"# %! & !

%" ;- -

K%$ (!:

+( !

!!00!$!!$$ @"!"(

#(!00$$! ! " -B 02 #( ":0$!

" (# $ #(

" ! $%$"&'.

./.2 9) +: