Pal Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others



   

       

 



 !"#$"%&'&#()
   









































 



 



 

 )  *+   , ,  ,-   *+   , - +  

!"#"$%
&'
"(")
 *+"
,
'
 
-"
"$")

)
%"( 
 '" '"$)
 *+" ,
 

. 
!$# 
&')
 *+"
" 
 '")
 *+" ,
'
"

$+"/ 

0
,  ,- .

/ 0


112 

2

'
"

$+"
,
3 $"

3
,
'
"

$+"
"  

0

'
"
#


"$$# )
" )
'
"3

33
,
")
"
"4
#'
'
"

$+")

"-

+



 

5

'


'
"
#

(,
' 6
#'
"
"7
'"
"
3" "3
(
3"


 
+8 

5) 
3"-
"
 "-&
+
 
$&"$
+
"
9:905955)
+ #',
(+3
+$

4
8.

'
"
$&"$
+)
' #$7
3 $"

"

$+")
" )
'
"';
++ "
#

 

"$$&

3"-
+"+'3
 
-'""

0<5)
<9=)
" )
,'  

.8"3
"+'"7"
"$$& $7
+"+'
'
3

$
, -'""

2952)
29.:)
295:)
295>)
,
* &
"
'+
""&
 '
"7
3
'
"
-'""
3(
"
"*

'


( #
" 
(7
'
"3
"+'"7"
++ = ?'
'
"

+"3

,
'"&
(,
' 6)

959:5955)
'
'",
4"+
 
#"
3"


(7
' 6 





 
  
  


  
 


  
 


  
 

 

  




    

 

 







 
 
!"

#!

!$!#
%&'


()*
 

     
"


+
,


-  

%.

 * & 
#/0#
 

    

 

  


  
#!

$"

!$!!

1
 








 


 
 


  


 
 

2 

 

  



+
,


-  


%.

 *
& 
#/0# . *)
*

259@5955)
'
6
'"
3"


' '",
4"+
  





 

-


  

  




 


  
 
  
  
!!

$0 !$!!
 

$"

$"

!$!!

4
+

  
 


 


  
 
  
 


 
 



 








 



 
  
   





5



1 

 


$!

$0 !$!!



 
-



2 
 




 







   


5  
.

 5 

 
5




 

-



#6 $"

!$!!









 

 
 

-7

/60"(!$!!

&+



#6 $"

!$!!

0 *)
"
"$
,
'
 
+
(7
'
6
 2>9@5955)
 
#',
(+3
4"+
'",
+$)
'" '
 
++ )
'"

3"


"
3"

'
6
'" +"+'3

$"
+3 

-'""

0<5
"
<9=
# 3*

2:9@5955)
" )
'"

3*"$
,
'
"
+"+'3)

$+
""+
#"
"$
"-
,
"
#"
* 
'
*"+"


,
+'
$" 
'"
(
+$"

'
",, "*

'"*
( '"
*

'
"3
"+'"7"
++ 1


 








-


#!

$"

!$!!
9 
:
5  
.


5  
 
5 +

 

-


& 


;


5 

 
<  4
5
;


5  
&
8

#6 $"

!$!!



 

-


 



 

1







   


 

: 
8

=/!


=/)

 

#0 $"

!$!!

 


 


 
 
  




 

4  








( 

 
 

 




 
 


 

&'


.(!

&'

 .(#





 
-




  


=







  


 

 

  
!$

+
 
.+
& 
#//>









  

 
  




 


  






- 





 


( 





 

 

  




  


  



2  
 
 




 


( 


 
?




    





:

'
$"
+$
,
'
#$7
3 $"

"

$+"/ 

0
(3
'"
'
 
*+)
"
3"


, '
"

$+"
,3
'
"(*
"
-'""
3(

"
$$&"$
*+)
" '
"3


+
(7
"7
*"$ )
( &
"
++$*
 )
") 3"


(7
'
6$$+
++ )
#'$
'
7&
"

 
+ @
,
'
%"(
$$"&
633
" 
A&$"B
+)
2<:2
A,
' '",
+"$$
C'
2<:2
+CB
,
)


 

'
#$7
3 $"

"

$+"/ 

0


"
$

 
'
$*" "7
*
(,
'
6$$+
++ )
-&
"
 '3)
,
  $7
$$&"$$7
"3 )
,
"7)
,
+'
$" 
(7 '
"3
"+'"7"
++ @ +)
'
 
*+)
,
"7)
"
3"


,3
'
# -'""
3(
0<5
"
<9=)

",
'
$+-&
,
'
&"
"$$
 ,
,
'
 

 
  
"
'
"+
,
' "

$+"
'

++ )
')
#
3
'
#$7
3 $"

"

$+"/ 

0

"
"$$
+'
$"
(,
'
$"

6$$+
++ )
(7
,$&
"
$

 
+
22
,
C'
2<:2 +C
 
&
)
'
$"
'"$$
+ 
'
$

#'
4
3' (
",
'"&
"$$
",,+ 
++ )
" )
'"$$
"$
+  '
$"
,
'
"

$+"/ 

0)
&" &
$$&"$$7
$+-&
, '

"$$
"
'
"+
,
'
"

$+"/ 
++ 29

+D+)
#'
'
"(*
*
$(7)

'
#$7 3 $"

"

$+")
'
#


+$  
,
#'
' "(*
(*"
"$&#'
"$$
 &
"

$+")
,
"7
    ,  ,-  







- + 

    

-"*
&'




?''
 "-&/"

E/ ?''
 "($ E/