Surjit Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another


 

     

     



 

 

      

 
   

    

  



 



    



  



 

   !

!"#"#$%!&  '&(#"  #%)*  *+,  -*+..!%)!/  "*!  $&/!&  /+"!/ 0 1 0  2*!&!34  "*!  "&#+.  $'&"  *+,  5&$-!!/!/  "$  ,'66$%  *#6  +, +//#"#$%+.+--',!/'%/!&!-"#$%71

*!5!"#"#$%#,8#.!/'%/!&!-"#$%9 

:!+&%!/-$'%,!.

+55!+&#%)$%3!*+.8$8"*!-$65.+#%+%"
&!,5$%/!%"$ &+#,!/+%$3(!-"#$% "$"*!6+#%"+#%+3#.#"4$8"*!5!"#"#$%+,+--$&/#%)"$*#6"*!$&/!&5+,,!/ '%/!&!-"#$%71

#,&!;#,+3.!

""*#,,"+)!.!+&%!/-$'%,!.8$&"*!5!"#"#$%!&6+<!,+5&+4!&"$ "&!+""*#,5!"#"#$%+, &#6#%+. !;#,#$% *!5&+4!&#,+--!5"!/ *!5!"#"#$% #,"&!+"!/+, &#6#%+. !;#,#$%

%"*!3+,#,$8"*!,"+"!6!%"6+/!34-$65.+#%+%"6&#<#%)* = > $ 77/+"!/1 ?'%/!&!-"#$%7@90@9 @91 +%/ !-"#$%?@0@?9@?1$8&6,-"$.#-!"+"#$%!*.$%#,"&#-":'/*#+%+ 2+, &!)#,"!&!/  8"!&#%;!,"#)+"#$%+ 8#%+. &!5$&" '%/!&!-"#$% 07=>



2+,8#.!/#% $'&"2*!&!34-*+..+%2+,,'36#""!/+)+#%,"+.(#"#%)* A:+<*+@$#<+%/!&#%)*"*+""$$8$&"*!$88!%-!5'%#,*+3.!'%/!& !-"#$%79

!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)*A#"++%/+%$"*!&+--',!/+";!!& #%)*@$'&(#"#%)*2!&!8$'%/#%%$-!%"+%/2!&!5.+-!/#% $.'6%$

8"!&-$66!%-!6!%"$8"*!"&#+."*!-$65.+#%+%""!,"#8#!/+, 3!8$&!"*!

$'&"+%/#%*#,,"+"!6!%"%+&&+"!/"*!5+&"#-#5+"#$%$8"*!5&!,!%"5!"#"#$%!& '&(#"#%)*+,'%/!&
B



 

  

!  "#$# %
#
  

! &'

(%  %%'

!  $   $
  %$ $& 

 

# % ! !$%

' %% % !  )      !  ! 
# 
    

% 

&'

(% 

&% 

  $

%*        

' %+  )     
  $
 ,-

% #  

 ' %  %  ./

 /

0-    ! 1 &
 








 %1  2 




 $2  
  % %  !

3 $

% $
 ,-

$%#  

 $$ 

 !

 '  4   $
  

 5%#
  


       $ '



7

$&    

 %% ' %% 

 '    -

 1    2       


    %5%#
 * $ &

 

 

 %%

!   " #$# $  %%' 

&%

   $$6 ''$ #$$   '$



  $$    ! '

$   '   

%$  # $ 'C 8"!&"*!+8$&!,+#/!;#/!%-!+%+55.#-+"#$%2+,6$;!/'%/!& !-"#$%71

"$,'66$%5!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)*+%/+";!!&#%)*+, +//#"#$%+.+--',!/ *!"&#+. $'&"+..$2!/"*!+55.#-+"#$%34,'66$%#%)"*! 5!"#"#$%!&+,+%+//#"#$%+.+--',!/+,"*!!;#/!%-!*+/!6!&)!//'&#%)"&#+. "$5&$,!-'"!*#6

:!+&%!/-$'%,!.8$&"*!5!"#"#$%!&*+,-$%"!%/!/"*+"+8"!&"*! ,'36#,,#$% $88#%+. &!5$&" '%/!&!-"#$%  07=>

"*!6+""!&2+, -$66#""!/"$"*!-$65!"!%" $'&"8$&"&#+.+%/+""*+","+)!$8!-"#$%17

%$-$)%#D+%-!2+,"+<!%+)+#%,""*!5!"#"#$%!&+%/+))&#!;!/+)+#%," "*+""*!-$65.+#%+%"+55&$+-*!/"*#, $'&"5&!,,#%)8$&-$)%#D+%-!+)+#%,"

'&(#"#%)* :!+&%!/-$'%,!.*+,#%;#"!/"*!+""!%"#$%$8"*#, $'&""$"*!

$&/!&/+"!/1

=%%!E'&!
9>2*!&!34"*!5&+4!&$8"*!-$65.+#%+%" 8$&"+<#%)-$)%#D+%-!+)+#%,"5!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)*2+,%$"+--!5"!/ "#,+&)'!/34.!+&%!/-$'%,!.8$&"*!5!"#"#$%!&"*+",#%-!"*! 5!"#"#$%!&34;#&"'!$8 "*!+3$;!$&/!&,"+%/, /#,-*+&)!/"*!&!8$&!"*!

9
5&$;#,#$%,$8!-"#$%71

-+%%$"3!+""&+-"!/"$+//#"#$%+..4+&&+4*#6 +,+%+--',!/+%/"*!$&/!&/+"!/1

<!!5,*#,#%%$-!%-!#%"+-"

%"*!-$%,#/!&!/;#!2$8"*#, $'&""*!+&)'6!%"#,+3,$.'"!.4 6#,5.+-!/+,#"#,%$"+-+,!2*!&!"*!5!"#"#$%!&2+,,!%"+,+%+--',!/"$ 8+-!"&#+.

+"*!&*!2+,8$'%/#%%$-!%"+%/2+,5.+-!/#% $.'6%$

*!&!8$&!#"-+%%$"3!-$%,"&'!/"*+""*!$&/!&/+"!/1

5+,,!/34"*#,

$'&"*+//#,-*+&)!/*#6 "#,$"*!&2#,!-.!+&"*+""*!-$65.+#%+%"2*$ 2+%"!/-$)%#D+%-!"$3!"+<!%+)+#%,"5!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)*+%/"*!,+#/ 5&+4!&2+,/!-.#%!/ *!  ,!-$%/  +&)'6!%"  +/;+%-!/  34  .!+&%!/  -$'%,!.  8$&  "*! 5!"#"#$%!&#,"*+""*!,"+"!6!%"$86&#<#%)*#,%$"*#%)3'"!-*$!,"*! +;!&6!%",$8"*!

 #%-!#%"*!8#&,";!&,#$%"*!5!"#"#$%!&2+,8$'%/ #%%$-!%""*!&!8$&!$%"*!,+6!+..!)+"#$%,"*!!E!&-#,!$85$2!&'%/!& !-"#$%71

#,%$"(',"#8#!/ -&$,,
;!&,#$%#,+.,$,!"'534+.(#"

#%)*A:+<*+2*!&!#%5!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)*#,,"+"!/"$3!+%!4!2#"%!,, +%/#"#,+-+,!2*!&!3$"*,#/!,*+/',!/8#&!+&6,+%/*+/,'88!&!/#%('&#!,

#"*"*!+,,#,"+%-!$8"*!.!+&%!/-$'%,!.8$&"*!5!"#"#$%!& *+;!5!&',!/"*!$&/!&#65')%!/#%"*#,&!;#,#$%5!"#"#$%+%/8#%/"*+""*! "&#+. $'&"*+,)#;!%;+.#/&!+,$%,8$&,'66$%#%)'%/!&!-"#$%71

+,"*!&!#,!;#/!%-!2*#-**+,!6!&)!//'&#%)"&#+.#%/#-+"#%)5+&"#-#5+"#$%$8 5!"#"#$%!&'&(#"#%)* *!&!.!;+%"5$&"#$%#,!E"&+-"!/3!.$2
B)  '$'

 

%  %''  '

 '

 %$'$ !%

!

%

 )

 

$$!%'%

?
!6+ &






%  


  

 

!  "

#$# 1 %'%



  %  

 %%  "#$# '$%  /# % 



 $
 %

  % &$$ $' %$ % %

#     

    

       


%  %      

$ 



  $$  # $

 '!

%  #% '!

'$   %  #     

  7  
 


 

%  %% $

%

  % '

 '



 

 

 ! '$    !C ""*!,"+)!$8,'66$%#%)+%+//#"#$%+.+--',!/"*! $'&"#,%$""$ "!,""*!!;#/!%-!"$&!-$&/+,+"#,8+-"#$%"*+"#"2$'./.!+/"$"*!-$%;#-"#$% $8  "*!  +--',!/  ,$')*"  "$  3!  ,'66$%!/  "&$%)  ,',5#-#$%  &!)+&/#%) #%;$.;!6!%"$85!&,$%#%"*!-&#6!#,!%$')*"$!E!&-#,!"*!('&#,/#-"#$% '%/!&  !-"#$%  71 

 %  "*!  -$%,#/!&!/  $5#%#$%  $8  "*#,  $'&"  "*!

#65')%!/$&/!&5+,,!/34"*!"&#+. $'&"#,3+,!/$%-$&&!-"+55&!-#+"#$%$8 .+2+%/"*!!;#/!%-!$%&!-$&/+%//$!,%$",'88!&8&$6+%4#..!)+.#"4$& #65&$5&#!"42+&&+%"#%)+%4#%"!&8!&!%-!

--$&/#%).4"*!5!"#"#$%,"+%/,/#,6#,,!/

 !-!63!&

 !

'.+"# "#