High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2269/2004dismissed

Sheikh Badroo Doza v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-05Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

!"! #$ %%&& '#( )( *+ % )#

,- %.(#/0 1-&( &/ #!%%&& 2#*% -!/,/)( *+ %%&& !"! #$5#+6&# 7(-/ %& (#/ ! 89 :4 4;

( # 4 :##(- )6!#%(+ /4 !# ####< /)& - #=*(-= 4

/!5 0 !# ! #5!!!5+" #=##% ! 0#6/!5 ( #- #-#(=%# = #

6# %6 4/

> (&!#( #- (#!##-#(=%# = #%#= !

#&6/!!%#%#( 0#

#! 4;

/%&%#6&+69,(#0 -!#=)& -/#/ ! 5 -%#&& - !#5!

#0 (&=0&&-)!#&?5! !%&%#6#! #+( !0&&-/ % 5 =&62"= -!* ? != 5!&/#(#+# -#-# : ,

5 +#0 - !#-!!#5!# %#

!0 -!.9.#?!%&%#6 %!# ( ! 5-(

6+-!0 - 5#&6 - !"6!#5!

5-(

6+- (&& + - !# !## !#? ! = 5!&/7 >:+(+#!) #= #= #+6=&#6 =%= %#(!( !"! #$+#! 0- - #?!) #= &!(5#0 - !#/5!!!=5! !(!#0 *(##!# !!+ " ##= !=&#6 =% #%#0 -!#/!!+ %#(+#! 0- - #? ! %& %#6 (% ! = #+ 5 + - ## !+- %& ! # ! 0- - #5 #!!# !+-/! #= !(!#-!-!##! %# -# #-$#?!

(0 ==@A)%- !#! ( %# -$#?!==5 - +6 ! ( +6 ! 5 ? !##/ ! 0- - # 5#&=-)& -# -=-$#!%? #%!

!7-=! -!/) (#&##0!%?!5%%# !! #(5!!( % 5 ?!##!)!=& #=!(!#-! -!#! ( %# 6!#-$## -#+(!(#% )7-=! -!

0 == @A) - +6 ! ( +6 5 /(!/!+- !#(#5##! !65# ( %%%6!("=%&

-=!5#5 #= !(#+- 0# %#&?!65#-0 #&:4

+ -5-!/!#(%%%6!(" !!+-=( +;"-

-=?!(#+- -#(%%%6!("5# 0# (## %#&?!+(&"%#&5#&5!! &9 !0 - #% ,?#(!&5! 0# 2"= -!/ % 5 ?+(&"%#& =%&%#&5# " %&% 0#0#6==?=%&&=%# 5#&" B!#!=#(##0&!#0 -& (5!#/5!!5&" % B!%# & #!(5 ( ==5%#%# !#-#?

-#( ##5##0(% !(0==?#=(#!# #!!#/ 0A( 5# +6.#! )&

0(##(+5!(5#0#B!0 & -5!=#(#5#" %&% (C5 !%& !#(-! +&B#= -!/ !+5!!

#=&895##!%& B!%& !%& #0#65%#%#

;

#(# !%& /!(& -5!! %#%#6 !5 5#%#(+#!90 # .(=#/2 !)& -/5!!0#! !#=!( 5 B!(5%((% ! &"(% !%#%#65%5!!2!%& B!%#%#65%#(+#9&&C-#

#6 %# - 5# ## ( (# - ! (# 0- / =%& %#& 5# ! !=& @A= #/)( *+

!#(-! +&("!0 -! %##%#@A):#0!##=/!5#( +!!(# )%%62#=%& 0- !##=&/ !&& - !(5%#%# & !(#

#%! !(#/+#0 -!%#= !#-# ( # 4 !5& - !(/ !5!#-!# -&6/5!!/! %& -(&6 &=#& (# -!(#0 /!%#( A= !&&5 -5

)D49,(#0 -!/5!5!9 0- - # !%#-# -!#0#6! #+ #=!# !( (#!#+(! 0- !0 -+ ( +6!=%#0 -0#((= @A)@A)1 +(&"%#& @A)@A)

)D ) (#& 7-=! -! & (%%# ! %#( =#&%% -! #C(!

0- - #/!!- !% !5 ! #! %# - 2 % ! (# +- ! - ; "-

-= %%%6 !(" 5# #0# #= ! ( % !( )D; +&("!0 -!/#=&5 # 0 !0@A)6 -!!!%! =%&%#& !!=&@A= #/)&

#!5#! 0#!=+62!%& ! =%&%#&#=

)D 90 #.(=#/5!5%2 )& -!#&0 =! 4;

/! # %#%#6/=%&%#& (5#%#(+#!=+6 ,(#0 -!92( !%#%#6 %( !5 &!0 - #% . &&!(#%#& +- + %( - ! & =%& & &% 2 (#!# % #-# -" - % !%#%#6/=#(# - #%#@A)7!-!##/ -! 4

/!!%#( !%#%#6+#!9&&C-#+6=0 -%%&

@A)1 !9&&C-#!%##@A)1>4#"% -! %#%#6 *(&1.2:?!50#/ #%#@A)1>+6 !9 !#-/7(&&"! 5!#-#!#-%!#/ !-#+6% -##@A)1>;#!!%#%#6+ % !%& ( ##(&B! 0 #6! %#%#6@A)5%#%# ! ! #%#%#6!+

%#(+#!9&&C-#2(#!#!!(

5-0 ##- - =%&+ &6$#=! !=&&+##6+(! % D!!!%#( 0 - &( = !(5##( # ;4;

#)/ 5!!&&! #= -#(= %%# - ! %#( 0 - !=5#%((!(+(! !&&- -!!5

!+ &&6 0&0 !2!" (%%&!&&5 -

" #$ %& '% ( )*#

)% #*&$)# " +, (+(&

+,"-) $%& .) (/# &$ 0

% 1&

(2),

#* % $ $ & #, 3& ($$* )%$ 4 & ( ))*% ) 5 ! 0 /!(A= 2*)& D4/5!%#(:4 444

:4 4

6A= -!5 /!(5 %#0!9,(#0 -!/!9 0- - #!+ %(

%#&& -(6 # # = D99#* -!%#(!###= 44

!5!2 0 #.(=#5%&6 &( # D;2"= -!/ % 5 /5!!*

!%&%#6 5 !#0#6 !#%# -! + -0 (%+6!%#( #!# !0 -+ 5 0# +6!(B!5 5A= +6!( ! !! 4;

/!!- )&)0&&- )!#&

5!%(+5 *-#!0&&-# !%(#%#&0 -!%( !=9,(#0 -!

" ! !(=+ =%# 0 +& " %%# ! %#A %#%# - =%#= B! 5 ! %%%6!(" 5 #0##=!( !%# 9=6+= !#!!(!&! 0 ;4E

250#/ ! &))! =0 %%& ( # ;44#)&&:+(+# ) #= / 5!! %%& 5 &&5 44

/ !) #= 5 A= +6 ! %#( )D ! #= &0 )D ) #= ! 4;

/( !"! #$5%#(+#!=+61 :"' (FB !=(&!=!!!=5! ! #+# -: ,

/5!!(5#0 -# - )D /!! %!# %# !( ( ! %%%6!("#=!#!=%# &#!!(5 ##( %# !5 !!- !%# & #!==@A)

#A= )D +656 &0 (%%&= #6= (5## ;

9 ! = /(=!#0 -& +& -!= !

5#0 -!# (#!#!0#"#-# -%(#! #5 ! =!5=(+B!(!! #: ,

/5!!!5#0 -!=5!

#)!#& !6/!#=6(!#6! =-!G 4E8/> ) !6 ! - #= -#=!#5( ##0# ### -(%%&= #6= (/! ! A= D (+# ("!0 -!/ 5! %#( - & =-@AH @AI@AH=-4;

#=2C(##B #-#-# - !"! # $ @AI- &=-4

%&&6 - ! !"! #$!" %& 44

/4;

"-%%%6!("5#0##=!# 89 5#-#)& )!#& 4 #!# -#-(= /&# #&(# 0 !(= +0/5!!&!=--#0 !!&!%# %%&/5!!5" (% 44

5! 5=##-(&#!# - !0#66/ %%&

( # ; #)!0 -+ &+6!%%&& >(# (% ! =%# = (# - ! % 6 %%&/!=5&&5 4;

:5!!=(%##-(&#!# -

9!0!#&# ( &#!%%&& F( 0/&# ,#!)( *++- -!#(-!! ##

B! #& (# #&6 - (% ! #& (= #6 0 +#(-! & +6 ! %#( ! #! &# &( !(5#0 -!=#(# - ! = !5(+/5!!=5! +6! -.9.#

"-%%%6!("+ -## !#=

+-5#0#!##=/ !56/!(5(

(% ! #+ !#B! " (% +6!(!=#!#!=5!

/ 5!# #0#6 5 4;

/ (! !

+!&#% +&#!=/5 # #*+6 -0 -- 0 -# ### -!0 +#(-!

&+6!%#( 5&& " +6!( 0 +#(-! &+6!=B!#0#6 0&0 ! 0#6!-! ( -==#&C( 6B!# ! -

##!5!!9 0- - ##!#%&%#

5! ! 0- ! 6 %#0( =6 5! ! (%#=%+65!!/!6=-!!0 0&0!( ! &&6#%- !=(#! 0 :0&

6= #6%#0 !=(+!# 4 #-#!*(-= ###+6&# ( &# !%%&&

!"# !"$" %&!' ( !)*+6!%A(#/!*(-= !&% !(>%%&& =(! !#0#6!+ #=! =- =#( #/ 5!! 5 - ! # ! #0#6 ! + %(#( #% 6 #

#= @0 !#5/! #(= !5# # 5! A/ 5!!!+#0 !+ = 4E #-#!!#*(-= #&(% +6( &#! %%&& +!,

!"# !"$" %-$ ./%+6 -& !!(# ;

;/!*(-= & %%& !!%# 1# ( &!###0#(*(-=

(%%#! ! 0& 6= #6%#0

5!#B!%A(# &!0

# !"$" %-$ ./(

!+ )5!&& -5!#& -#0#6 E"-%(=5! =%&5# !=&A= ##

6#0#6/!50#/!#5 0 !=%&5# =%#5!# 6%#*(5(!(/!&65

!&+&! 4 1# ( &!(#!####*(-= +6 -& !!(# 1"

+!2)# !"$" %-$ ./ % 4 4 ;4E

/5!# ### - *(-= +68(&& !!(# -!

# !"$"3

%-$ ./(2

5! !& !=%&&& &C(##0##=!(/5 #( % %# #!5! ! % %# !(-! #(5!! &+6!9 0- - #5 %#(5 / ! #(= /5!&!!& 5# ( !=#! !%#( (& +!#5

( !#& 9 !*(-= 5!&!5

(=+ (% !%&#! 0#!&!#%#

#!5! 0 / /5!#!! /5 +&-#6 #!=/%#((!%# /5 (# -!#& !# 5 (#6#C(#= ## -!&5 !(+*

! 0#6 *(-= / 5 +#0 !

! %%&+&%# &#! ( #& ! %#=/0!&#!##&

!#*(-= ###+6&# ( &5 #! ! 1$+! # !"$" % &+4 ) -! "

( !+ )

5!# 5+#0!5! #0#65 #=!(+(-(

6+-## #/!#5 0&

!95+#0! !###6 (# 4 1# ( & ! (#!# %& #& (%

*(-= $4

# !"$" % -$ ./

!+ )955! % 5 !+ * (# -!#! #0#6 #+ 2!%%# 5 #! -!!- (#5#%#(# +& "

%%#5! !!0!%& #( " (!/ 5 %!& -!

++&0!

(=#(- (# 0#(%%#!0 -# 5# =#& (&+- +65 +& "%%#B!= 6! 5 5 !& + ( #&+& 5 # 9 ! 0#6 *(-= /#+&6&>%&5 5 # 5+#0!5! !# &&- 6 =6- !

%&&&&6=%&!%%&& !#5 #

#!=%- !%%&& /!#&(#!#-!&6 &(! A= % 5 #! #0#6+ -5 0#+6!( # 6(+ ! %#( B!%&6 -!=%&! !=&@A= #5&(!& -!5! !=%& 5# !!=&@A= #5! E!(#/! %#( 0

+0 !-#( !# 5 % %#0 ! ! #-# ! #( > -## !#%5# &6!-(& #-(& #&!# # &5#" -:# #& (#( 5

!"*# !"$" %&!' (

!+ ) /5+#0!5! ==&6 #% !# #= /!9 'B=-!) !# 5 (#)##0!+( /!#0#65 %# -$#/5!!!%#0 !/!#5 # ##5!!5&& # *(-= !2-!(# ;

!#=%# *(-= %# #0+6&# ( &5 1!"

1$+!# !"$" %-$ ./( !+ ) +6 -& !!(#/5!# !0#( %!5#(/5!!#( #

* 67 4 4( 4 !+ ) !) 6 !(( $ 67

) ( (( $

)

*$& (* 67

)

)%$* & (

(( $

* 5!44 8!$ " -"'4 !04 $/" 4 " 4( 4 !/ 6 $*

)%$ 6 #$ % %

* ) & &

)% *% (

)68 $* (

)%$% $ 1) $49) ( $$ :& * 5!44 8!$ " -"'4 !04 $/" 4 " 4( 4 47 !'%4 !/ 6+$ % $ (( $ ( % 6 $$ * % &

8* 5!44 8!$ " -"'4 !04 $/" 4 " 4( 4 !/ 9 "4$"0"" "" 6 #$

%%$$ % (

# 6 (

) &% (6 +

( / $$(

% &) % % ( $$

$" ))

(( ( $ & ( % 6* 5!44 8!$ " -"'4 !04 $/" 4 " 4( 4 !/ 68 $ % &) &

&$%#$) $ ))

(( :* 5!44 8!$ " -"'4 !04 $/" 4 " 4( 4 !/ 6;$ )%$

6. * ( # , $ ) % %%* &, # ( ) % ( % %%$$ & 6+&

&:&

* (

# #%$ #* % $ ( ) & " "'& ( ($ )%$

6 1

&%$

!#*(-= #&(% +6!( &

# !"$";

%< +6!(%#=(# %%&

#&;4

/5+#0!&5 !% 0#6&#! 0 !# 6#%#(#&&&-&6 ( -!#!

$(#/!0 &&!#+65&& += =+& !(#5(& #&&!#(= (5!!# 6#(%#*(!+ (!(9!#! $(#5 =%& !&5 %#(# !#5 6%+&6!0 &&&"&6!0+ =%# 5!# #%&(# -!(#(!#!#$(#/! / (&+!!0 &+&+=+& 0

B!(/!=( #0#6 #+ 0&0#(& (!%+&6 6&%& /#!#=(!! (5 (% !#0# #+ ! !&# ## +&#%&(+&A%& #!%# +- - #+ !#!0 -+ #0 +6!= - ! =!525#-!&6 0 +6!#&(# # -! #+ #0##=!=/! #&(#!+ =5!& 5!! 05# -!= (+ 0 =%# = 4 6# &6/ 5!! ! = =(= %##+#! B!=%(- *(-= 0 ##

%+6!#&(##5&& # /+(% %#%# %%#& %%# 0 ## #%# &5 B!# &&-&6# #=6!# B!*(-= 0

## #(%!&5!#!%%&( + 5!( 6=# !==# -&6 E %%&& !"! #$+ +&-# !=+6!(#2+& &&!7(&-#/ ! #(##5## -!=## ="!=( #-!#= -

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %