Ram Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana




   
 





!"#$%$%

&'(&)!* +)  $$,$$  -) (  .

)/! ,$$  0 !*! 




  
 


) !" 1)$!23*4

3

1)$.$'$!3*4

3

)+0 1)$)5(!.!6+*433)/!$ 1)$*/.!6+3*4

3

)+

&02!!$ 
 


 + 0 !)  2 !6 7+ +)



( * 28) .!6+3 7) )*

&&!6 +

  (!*) . !  93 ::3 :; )* 7+ . ! :9
$ -* 5(*6&! !*

)*) ** :$#$% 0 * 8/ + (* 2 16 )3
 2 3 8723 + 0 !)  !* * 28) .!6+3 7)

(!* 6(2/

)+

 (!*). ! 9#3:: !*:; )* 7+ . ! 9%
$ + 0 !)  7) !!

*   (!*)"

!*)

(  &0) !&!

)  0)

9#<9%
 7  & !+  !*   0/ 

$< + !*3 * (2

0/&!

!3  ()+) (!*)6


)!*/ $

!*)

(  &0) !&!

)  0)

::<9%
 7  & !+  !*   0/ 

$< + * (2

0/&!

!3  ()+) (!*)6

=> )6 ( &0) !&!

)*/ $

!*)

(  &0) !&!

)  0)

:;<9%


!/)!* 0/

$;< +!*!* (2

0/&!

!3

()+) (!*)6 )6 (  &0) !&!

!& !+$ 22 + !!

  7) )*)*   )(!

())!2/$   74)3 28) .!6+ 7  )*)*   8 )2 *  ! 0) 8

 6

!*( 

)  0)

! /)  ! +  ()! +!6 0) 8 !*  ! + (&

$3< 7+ + ()/ ! + 2? & (!   ?0 0  !* 8

 6

* 8+4 ) *()!6 +

) *0) *$ 66)4*

 + 5(*6&! !* )*) 0 * 8/ + 2)!* )2  ()3 + 0 2* ! 002 8

) + 2)!* . !  (*63 .) $  74)3 4* 5(*6&! ** 9$$ 0 * 8/ + 2)!* . !  (*63 .) 3 + 002 2*8/+0 !) 7 * & *3+)8/

)&!6 + 5(*6&! !* )*) 0 * 8/ + )2 16 )$ + )4 2* 8/ '2( & 6!  + 6)!

 0) 8 !3 7  2 * & *8!6!

&!!82$ .2266)4*3+0 !) +4 2*+0) ! )4 !$   0) + 0) (  3 @2( & &* 

&02!  + ! $;$%%%  <$: $&$3 +2 !6 7+ + 

! '2( & 7  (24!6 +) 2*  7+! + 0 2 !6 7+ +) 0) !  )&* 7+ 70 !   ?* +& !* !

* !5()  (0 ! +&$ A+! 8) +)

 +

&02!! ) +* + 02

())!

3 22

 +& +*

=:>

2*7/7++)) 0 470 ! $ ))6 )

3 !4 6 !7 

!*( *!*+0 !) 7) +)6*

4) ( 

 !*

(!*6(2/8/+2)!*)2 ()!*

*

)*!62/3 &! !*8 4$ A+2

!6 + 0 !) 3 + )2  () )

)**+

7!6 !*!6" B$  7

&!6  

+0) !  $   0) + 226 ! 

 + 0) ( $;$%%%8 ($<$:$&$3 & A '2( & 7) 0) !  +) !*  !* + 

( * 0) !  & +) +4!6 70 ! !+)+!* !*648!6  +& ( * !5()   A @2( & !* A '2( &$ A @2( &   !* A '2( & 2  *0 * + ! $;$%%% 7+! +/ 7) 0) !!+) 2* 3

( *0) !  &+) !*648!6  +&!*!5() 7) ( *  +&$ A @2( & 2  ) 4* ) ()$ +) &* 24*!

!+ 2!+ +0

1@

&C$ A<!*1@

A  '2( & C$ A< !* D)/ )0 )

A @2( &C$ A9<$ 0) 4+&* 2)0 ) 3 )$.$@$66)7200)*  A937+ 0) 4*D )/)0 )

A@2( &!* *++) 

) ()

 2  (2! !   2 7) 0)$ + 0) ( ! 2  C&!* )$ $ $ 12?   0) 4 +1@

A'2( &$ ! !6+) (6++4*!

A!* A3
&

+47++/+*64!&)24)

=9> *!7+ +

?02 !$;$%%%$ + A A 

)*2!+) C&! & ((!

+*$+) !

+!6!+)

C&! ! 7+ + *!  +) 4) /   )(+ (2 7!  $   * (83  7 02   A @2( A'2( &7)

!*7+ +) 0)4 (  &!  8( +  !2/ )2   &!

) * )0!

  !* ** !

 &? + !) 4*!

A !* A (!)282$  @)!* *

(! 2 (8&* + !) 4*!

A'2( &   !

!  ! 7+ + &! )

)** (!*) . ! 

 )$ $$ *()!6 !4 6 !$   * (83 4*!

A  & C!   !

!  ! 7+ + &! )

)** (!*) . ! 

 )$ $$ 8/ + !4 6!6

)3 8( 0)( 2

 &!

 '2( & )

)** (!*) . ! 

 )$ $$ &?   4*!+ &7 )

)**8/+
!4 6!6

)!  (2&!!)!* 722 2*+

&02!! !!

822 7*  (

) !+ 8  

 * 4 !4 6 !$  A '2( & 7+! 00)* ! + 7!  8 C +* 64! + &)24)

+!

*!7+ +

?02 $;$%%% !* +  4*!

   (22/

!  ! 7+ +4*!

&$E + 

) * !*!6 7  (0+2* 8/ + 2)!* 0022  ()3 7+2 * & !6 + 002 2* 8/ + !) $

=;>
 +4 +)* + 2)!*

(! 2

) + 0 !* + 2)!* .

(! 2 !* 7+ +) 82   !

+46 !+) (6++)

)*

 $ +4)/ ( 3+2)!*

(! 200)!6

+0 !) + 37+2

!!6+ 0)/) +F(!(&

!!

3 (8&*++ !+   7 )6 )* 9$;$%%%$ + 0 !)  +4 8!3 +( 3 !6 + 6 !/

)2

) + 2   /) $   * 3 (

 +) (8 !4 !!

  /)3 + 0 !)  +4 2)*/ (!*)6 !  0)

7 & !+  +$0) &++0 !) !*

&02!!) &+ &4226$+( 30)/)+  8! &*

) )*( !6 + !!

 &0 * (0 ! + !)  !2)*/(!*)6 !8/+&$
! (00 )

+  ) ! 3+2)!*

(! 2

)+0 !) + )2* (0 !+5(*6&!



)*!!

+

+  ())0 ) 

)*0'(&)- $.

(!583=> =)&!2>:$ ! + +) +!*3 + 2)!* .

(! 2 + 3 7+2

!) 4)!6+

) * (8& ! 3)6(*+8 + +  ()  82 7 +4 )

)**  !*!6 + +  

( * !) +* ( *!5()  A'2(

&$ .( + !*!6 8 *

6! !*

!4!

!6 4*!

3 *  !

 (

) &!/0)!2262/!*+!

30)/)  &*

)* & 2

+)4 !$  + +  ()  82 7  ) +4!6 )(!G* + 4*!

!)

)*3+4)6+2/

*+0

)+

 (!*). ! 9#3::!*:;)*7+. !9% $
!&/ 0!

!3!

  &* (

)!) )!

!+

=> 5(*6&! !* )*)0 *8/+ () 82 7 ) +

! 0)  

)!*$ !

3 +

 + !)  (0+2*$ A+2

&!6   + !!

 0)3 8/ !

73 + !)  +4 2)*/ (!*)6 !  & !+  (

 +  2 (8 !4 !!

!/)$?!6!

! *) !+

())!

 ! +    0)!    + /) %%% !* +

++0 !) +48! !6+6 !/

)2

+ 2   /) 3 ! &/ 0!

!3 !

 (  (2 0()0  7 (2* 8 )4*8/ !*!6+0 !) 8+!*+8)  6!3 (!*)6 +)&!!6 !!

$
! *3!* 

5(  7 (2* 8 (82/ &3  + (8 !4 !!

 &0 * (0 ! + !)  )*( * !2)*/(!*)6 !8/+&$
!47

+8 437+2(0+ 2*!6+

 + 0 !)  (!*) . !  9#3 :: !* :; )* 7+ ! 9%
3 + (8 !4 !!

 &0 * (0 ! + !)  )*( * +0) *2)*/(!*)6 !8/+&3 8( (85  0/&!

$< +$+ !& (! +228*0 *8/+

( *0 !) 8

)+2)!* + (* 216 )3.) 37+!0)

7 & !+ 

&  */$  2!6 

&02/ 7+ + *) !  )6)*!6 *0 

!3 +22 & (!   ( &  * & 2

 + )4 !$

4  ! * 0 *

!+8 4)& $ #$%$%

  
 


*

!
 A++).0?!6< !*"  < A++) 0 )82"  <