← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2185/2004dismissed

Janak Raj v. State Of Hry

2020-02-26Mr. Justice Vivek Puri7 pages



      

 !"# $%!&&'

( $% )*$+

,-.!/0!&!&1 2 3 11111

( *-* (( $%. 11111

$5 

    

(+617 (8-- (054$)( 0

9 5)$-*

0%$(:



(1 61 - 5 8-00.1 1 

  1 ;< (

:*,

%  59*((:

3-59 ($% )$4)($5( 5!1&1!&&'45 =:):(:

(:*,

)$4)( 5,.

555($ **$*-59 0 ( :,50-5 )($#$%(:

)$()*-9*5 *.):$($ ) -,*() *)(0>"#?%$*:$(0@(:

)(@A5$5 $%* 5( 5!'1&1!&&'45 =:)::

=** ($-5 9$9$$-* *$ (%$

$5$%(=$.

*5($ . %  $%  *1&&&&B    5 %- (  =:

$%0  ($  %-(:

  -5 9$  9$$-*  *$ (%$

$5$%(:

$(:*1 ;!<  % .0(:

* -(%$(:,.(:

)-($*($(:

(:($!#1!1!&&&0  5:-  $9=(:%

$= $%%) *:5 * 52,5 

,(:

 %

9, (=

2): (:$% 4

9 6:($4

9  21:

(=** $(( 5=:

:

=* )$9%$(:

*5 $%4

9 6:).9

*(),9$:**:$- 1

(=*

:

5$*-* )$1$() -5  )($#&$%

 )(=** 4 $:,-(:

$* 5)$%5 - $  5:-

1:

):$%(:

,9, 9)

(=*)$5-)( =:):

5($(:

.$%

.:-*21=$*

*$%&&9* ):$%

.:-*2= 5=5(:

9

.:-*2$= 9:9=* %$-5($, '29*1>&&9*1$(:(:

*

)

*5,- 2 )

=

5=(:(:

, 9 **$@ @1:

)(9()

= (2 ($ $** **$45

( . $1 )$

($$% 4 *(9($0 %) -5 )($#$%(:

)(=*5

$-(9*((:

(,-((:

(

5 5$(9- (.5)  ( ;< $*-,*((( (*)* )-($:* C 5*.

**C=( *0

.0 D*

)($  9:0 D!   :

D  5:- 0 D'  *:=0 D#::( 0 D/ 1*: 9:1:

.=* 5,. D  5:-  D'  *:=1:

$

(.=* $5-) %$   D*

)($  9:0=:$=* $*( 5* (($$-*

%%) $%  (($ (0=:$4 % 5(:

%)(*$%(:

5 -((:

)$-( * , 9(:

 **$@ @1 D  5:- :*



$(-5 )($1 11 D#::( =* $*( 5* 65:5 ( 5(:

$

(.*% )-*($5.(:

 2:1 5$)- (. 45 :* *$,

)-($1 ;'< :**(( (-5 )($1 110(:

(:*  5(:

)$ )( **$%)(9 45

99*(:5

5 5  %  

)($  $  ))$-(  $%  (.  %)($    (:

 4

9 $= 0$5 % 45 :*,

5,.:1

 ;#< E5 3-59 ($%)$4)($5$5 $%*

(:*,

)$4)( 55* 5* ($ 5 $1$% 3-59 (1 ;/< 99 %$ *53-59 ($%)$4)($5$5 $%

(:* %  5(:

*((

;< :4 :

5

5)$-*

%$(:

( *5

-* 5(:

)$51 ;"< D:

** 9(:

3-59 ($%(:

5( )$-(0(:*

95$, : %$%(:

((:((:

$%(:

)-($* ,* $(:

5

$*($$%(:

$%%) =( *$ .5$5

=( **:*,

3$ 5((:

( $% .1 -(:

$ 5($.

$4*$*$% )($#&$%(:

)(:4 $(,

)$

5=(:5(:

 5*)

) *(:

*(( (*$%(:

$%%) =( *=:): * $%(:

)-($($, 5$-,(%- ;>< (:

)$(.0(:*,

9-

5 (( )$-*

(:((:

)$(, .,($,* )$4)($$(:

5

$*($$%(:

$%%) =( *1:

$4*$*$% )($#&$%(:

)( $((()( 55*)

) * 99(:

*(( (*$%(:

=( *(:

*(( )*  )$* F- ( ;&< (*$5$-,((- (:($5

(=( **=*3$ 5((:

( $% .,-(()$(, (  5($, ))-*() ($5*,

)-($1:

5

$*($$%(:

$%%) =( )$(, 5*)5 5

., )-* $%(:

$%%) *((-*$ .0-( 5 -

**)$9 (9$-5*(:

%$1  -(:

$ 0(* )* $%):)

.1:

$%%) *:5$ $%$($(:((:

( =*:49)$(,5=(::1 :

(=** $(( 55-9(:

 )$-* $%2,55=*

:

5$*-* )$1$* F- .0(:

$3$9$%5

(=( **, )$ **9%)(55$ *$( . )((:

9 - )-($1 ;< *9%)(F- *($($, $$2 5($*=(: 95($(:

$)$

) )($#&$%(:

)(1(:*,

$( 5$-(,.(:

5)$-*

%$(:

((:((:

(=*$(

* 5(:(:

=*:49

9 9:(($9 ((:

):)$5-)( 5(:

$% 9G (( 5$%%) $69*(( ;!< (:

)$(.0(:*,

)$(

5 ((

)$-*

(:( .:*,

5%$(:

,9, 9)

($:**:$- 1:

5( )($#&$%(:

)(*)$% $ .($:*

*$ ):55$ *$( (:

.%$(:

,9 9) 5$:**:$- ,.(:

(($, 4 51 ;< (**9%)(($$( :

(:($ .$%)$(,5:*

55-9(:

)$-*

*$ ):$%(:

(1:

)$(,5=*, 9)

(

*(),9$:* *:$- 1  :

$4*$*  $% )($  #&  $%  (:

 )(     F- 5  ($  ,

)$

5=(:(:

((:

.:*,

5%$(:

*$

):5(*$)$

) =

$(4(( .=:)::*$(

5%$(:

*$ ):$%(:

(1 (:* 950

) *

) $(:

5 )*$

$( 5*  !"#! $%&'# ()!# *&*+, %-&. / / &'-%0 %12&%0&%+*2

=:

( :*,

55$=*%$

$=*+ H/1* 95*

), (.$%(:

F- (*-5

)($#&$%(:

)( )$)  50(*=

((

5(:(  5(  $%  )($  #&  $%  (:

 )(  *  )$% 5  ($

*$ ):I5$(($* ):$%4 :)

$

  )$( $ * *1 1 )$) -*$?A* )$5 $*((-($  ): #$%(*3-59 ( 4 9:)

 .

*(( *(:((:

)$4)($.$(, ,* 5H$ .I$(:

,**$% $** **$$%

)(()

5%$

*$ ): 4$ ($$%(:

F- (* -5

)($#&$%(:

)(,-(%(:

, $(:

45 $ )$50*-):(  )) ( ., $$2 5($1 (:

*(()*

*$ ):$%(:

))-* 555 $( *- ( .$%.)$(,514 %(:

=* .*-): .0(:

* )$- 5$(,

$%$ =($%)$

) $%(:

F- (*$% )($#&$% )(1-((:

):$%(:

:)

5 .$% )$(,5 -*-((:

($:49*($$5 $4 50

.

)-* =*$)$

) )($#&$%(:

)(*%*H

*$ ):I=*)$)  50$,  %( ), C( 5*$*($4 5( )($% .

%$(:

):$%(:

:)

1.*-):5 =$- 5,

5 .(:

(

(:$%)$) -*$?A*%$ *51I ;'< (:

($%))-*() *0(:

. 5%$(:

*(),9, 9) 5$(:

*:$- $%(:

(*$(4(( 5 . 5(:

$%(:

)-($)$(, 5*)5 5$(:

*)$

(:((:

$4*$*$% )($#&$%(:

)(:4 $(,

)$

5=(: ))$5) =(: =1 ;#< 5  )$-*

 %$  (:

 

(  :*  $( 5  $-(  ) ( 5*)

) *  99    (:

 *(( (*  $%  =( *  =(:   95  ($ 5%% $%(

49(:

*(($0(:

5*() %$=:):(:

(=** $(( (.0 C*( $%=

((:

$(5 *(- (-* 5 ($).$-((:

= 9: (1:

5*)

) *0*

$( 5$-(05$$(.  (:

)-($($  5$-,(%- 1    % =  $  5*)

) *    ,$-5  ($  

    (:

 *(( (*$%(:

=( *5- ($ $%( 5(:

.5$$(.

 ( 5($% *%.(:

)-($1 ;/< .:*,

5,. D  5:- (:

D'  *:=1$(:(:

=( *:4 5

$* 5 % .*(*%)($. $

*

)(*$%(:

1:

.:4 94  *(*%)($.5)$**( ()$-(=(: 95($* F- $%(:

(*

59($(:

.$%)(9()

*%$(:

$** **$$%(:

(1$

=

0$*(.$,**5 $-(9*((:

))-* 5,.

$%%) *5$ *$*5 $-(%$% 

)($1:

$*($$%(:

=( **-%%) . $4 *5 *(, *:

*(:

( 

%)($% .$%)(9()

*%$(:

)$*)$-* $** **$$%

(1 ) (  %)($% .$%)(9()

%$(:

)$*)$-* $** **$$%(:

(* $4 55 *(, *:

5,.

*(*%)($.5

,

45 )$* F- ( %( *5-  $((% =*(:

)-($( 5($

($*9%)) ;<  (  $-(  :*  )$ .   )$5 5  (:

 %59*  $% )$4)($$(:

,**$%*(*%)($.5

,

45 *(, *:9(:

9- ($%(:

(, .$5(:

*:5$=$%. *$,

5$-,(1**-):

%59* $%)$4)($0*  )$5 5 ,. (:

5 ( $-(0

- :

51 ;"< D(: 95($(:

F-(-$%* 0(.,  ($ :

 (:(  (:

 5 F-(  *  )$ *-(   =(:  (:

 9- (  $%  (:

(:*,

 $*

5( $-(5(5$ *$()

%$ .( % ,.(:*$-(1 ;><

$(:

%$ *5 *$*0(:

, 95 4$5$% (* 5*** 51

 ;!&<

(*$, 5 ) **.*(

*, (( 5%$

)(9:*  *(*$(:(:

.-5 9$(:

 $* $ :1 3.

& 45    ! #  67