Lovepreet Singh v. State Of Punjab
9
!"
"#$% 7777
,(, ! & '(#) &* & ' & ' & ' & ' +"
+"
+"
+"
& ' . & ' . & ' . & ' . - - - - # - 7777 #/ ","#- ,"#- ","#- ,"#- ". ". ". ".1 1 1 19 &/"#$- &/"#$- &/"#$- &/"#$- ". ". ". ".2 2 2 219 19 19 19 57!
! 57!
! 57!
! 57!
! 7!&(& =&#)"&1/ +& '
' %
7 7/%"&)!"#$% %"#/1 (#)&*7 ,7#)&."!"#$%1/ +& ' .&"#&# 7 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> 173&.6 173&.6 173&.6 173&.6 ! ! ! ! #
" "#%&,*
#'".
(#/ !
+ "#8:'%&& "<& &
&$&"0!(& &0,%&!&#%" &123%
"#&'
* '
/&,4 % !!56 6 '$&# '
& , ?&# "+"
& <*&". %
1"#+&, &"#$
728 /&
/ :7 7@1 $",
/ ' ''
, (#",%&*.
(#/
!
+ "#,89 9&#/8' % 1 :91& ."+ ! & "#!%&#&1", "+ !! &$&3 %&."67 7
$& &;
#' % $& "#, ,&$&"#, %
", %& %
.&"#&# 1 1#&;
.<1&,A&# !"#$%1&..
/ %& # 72781%
"# &# &$
.. ' % (+%&, ' . 7891 .+0 1 1 # ' ₹ 1
11?7 &"/ +" <1 %&."1 ' & &. +#,"/ & "
₹@11?&, <1( 'A%"+%₹11?A&, &"/ %($% *� &#,'
&#/₹@11?"#+&,%"# %
'A" # ,, ,7 &. A&, '&+"." & / *< ;
/"& ( "#/ =&( &##1 A% &.,
/ &# &//" "#&.&;(# '₹1@1?'; % .&"#&# "# %
' !%&&#)" !"#$%,#');
!"#$%7 ",&..
/ %& %
&'
1( "#/ =&(&##/",%# , .<* $&#/ ;&#/"#$&#&//" "#&.₹ 1@1?1A%"+% .&"#&# '(, / &<7 !% (#.&A'(..< &"# / % "$"#&. &$
.. # %
B %& " A(./ * %&#/ /
#.< ( #
&<;
# '₹811?7 ",'( % , & / %& % "$"#&.*"&#& ;&"# "#% ,, ,,"# % 0#A.
/$ '!%&&#)" !"#$%7
<"#C( , "#",A# /*<&++(, /&.A"#/ !"#$% &#/ (*"#/ !"#$%1 * % ,1 &+% %./"#$ & @D ,%& 1 A% %&/
+( / & &. A ' # < "# '& ( '
!"#$%
%
"#6&#/="&#/
=&("..1&( %"E"#$ % ; * &"# %
C(","
&#/+;
,&.
&#,&+ "#7A
1" ",&..
/ %& %./
!"#$% 3
"#61 "# +##"
&#+ A" % ( "#/ =&( &##1 &+ "
.< & "+"
/ "# % &#,&+ "# &#/ ,(*, C( # .< /
.
/ /",%# , "# # "#,1 ;&0"#$ "..
$&. / ;&#/, ' &//" "#&.;# <(#/ $(", '+;;",,"#7 "#$*(#/ , +( # ,,&< ' +( "# ' % ,&.
/
/1 % &++(,
,#, '&".
/
# &
.< ' % ,&;
7
#, &/1 &+ "#$ "# +..(,"#1 % < ",,( / & .
$&. # "+ % .&"#&# *&, / # & '&., &#/ '&*"+& / , <1 &..
$"#$ %& % .&"#&# %&/ %";, .'+&#+ ..
/&#// , < / % &$
# /& / 7278&#/ %& %
, ;# < ' ₹@11? %&/ *
'(#/ / "# +&,%F&# &,, "# +& $"+&..</ #"
/*< % .&"#&# 7 .&"#&# /(.<
."
/ %
2 ,&"/ # "+ &#/ ;&"# &"#, %& % "$"#&. &$
.. +# "#( ,
;&"#(#.&A'(..<"# % ,, ,,"#'( "#/ =&(&##7 27 / +(#, . ' %
%&, "
/ %& & *&
(,&.' % " , .',%A, %& &..
$& "#,.
/&$&"#, %
+#++ /1 ";
*&*.
&#/ /
"/ ' &#< ;
" 7 / +(#, . %&, '( % "
/ %& %
#'&., .<";
."+& /"# % "# C( , "#7 /+(#, .%&,"
/ %& #,
+"'"+1/"
+
&+ %&, *
#& "*( / %
&#/ % $& "#,&$&"#, %
&
&$( 1;#"*(,&#/$ &."##& ( 7 /+(#, .%&,&$( / %& %
",#;& "&. / ;#, & "# .
# +(.
&*"." <' %
"# %
# +&, 7 /+(#, .' %
%&,+# #/ / %& # &..
$& "# %&, *
# ;&/ &$&"#, %
$&/"#$ ' &#<
<1#", %
&#< +
< * ''
/';%";7 +(#, .%&,,(*;"
/ %& % /", ( "#C( , "#", ( .<+"
"."##& ( &#/*<./$"#$ % "#C( , "#1 % .&"#&# %&, "
/ $"
,&;
& +";"#&. +.(7 / +(#, . %&, ,(*;"
/ %&
# %
",# " % ,"$#& <# & < % /&$
# , ..7 / +(#, . %&, ,(*;"
/ %& /( '&".( & % #/ ' % .&"#&# "/ + &"# /+(;
# , &#/ +
& "#1 ,, ' * &"#"#$ C(","
+(./ # *
/ &#/ ,(+% / .&< ", # & "*( &*.
%
A% A&, ;
.< &+ "#$ &, &# &( %"E
# & "
' % &.A# ,' %
1* "#$&%./ G %
%&,#"#/
#/ #
,#&."#
, "# % &#,&+ "#,7 27 7 /+(#, .&,, , %& % +(, /"&."# $& "#,%(./ # * (, / &, & (#" "
;
&,( &#/ ", )(, "'"
/ #.< A% # &*,.( .< ,,&<' % +
<';& "&.
"/ 7 /+(#, .%&,&$(
8 %& # %"#$ ", * +
/ '; %
7 ( % ; 1 %
", &/< )"# % "#
, "$& "# &#/1 % 1 # (, '(. ( , A(./ * ,
/ *< , #/"#$ %"; * %"#/ % *&,7 # % &' ,&"/ ,(*;",,"#,1 % $&# '&# "+"
& <*&".", /'7 87 +# &1.
/! & +(#, .1A%".
&","#$,(*;",,"#,"# &#/ ;A" % % , & (,
*<A&<'&#&''"/& " /& /978791A%"+% ", &.
&/< # +/1 %&,
, / % $&# ' &# "+"
& < *&". %
*<&$("#$ %& % ''
+;;"
/*< %
",, "(, "##& ( 7
&# ' % ,&"/, & (,
&/, %(,- H87
%& &,'&&,.
' %
",+#+ /1" ",
+ '(..< ,(*;"
/ %
",&+., .& "
' % A# ' %
< #&;
.< &.A"#/ !"#$%1 A% %&, +( / "# '& ( ' %
7 ( % 1 " ", ,(*;"
/ %& %
", & .
$&. # "+ /& 7 78 A%"+% %&/ *
# ",,( / +;
.&"#&# *< / +& 0&,% !%&;& # * %&.' ' &++(, /?
!"#$%7 # % ,&"/ # "+ 1 " %&/ *
# ;
# "# / %& ,"#+ % .&"#&# A&, (#&*.
&&#$ % &;(# "# C( , "#1 % &$
.. "# C( , "# A&, +&#+ ..
/ &#/ %& % .&"#&# %&/
# / , < / % "$"#&. &$
# , ..#27 78&#/%&/
/*&+0 % # "
, &;(# "#+&,%# % ,&;
/& "# %
' % A" # ,, ,7("#$ #C("<
/"#$,1 # 27:7@1 &++(, /?
%&/ ,(''
, & # * ' ! %& % .&"#&# %&/# $ % ,&.
+( /,"#+ *&.&#+ &;(# +(./# * &&#$ /*<%";&#/ %(,%",
# A&, "#/"+& "
' ''
" ( ' % , &;(# 7 %(,1 % ,(*, C( # +.&"; ;&/ *< % &++(, /?
# 27:7@ A&, "# , &0+#'."+ A" % % &*
'
/# "+ "#A%"+%" %&/*
#+.&";
%& % , &;(# %&/*
#&.
&/< (# /7
' 1
/.< ,%"' "#$ &#/ /",+
&# , &#+ , ' % &++(, /?
+( / A" % +& $"+&. ";
( & "#, &$&"#, %"; "#/"+& A&/, % B", ' " '(. "# # "#, & %
< "#+
"# ' % &#,&+ "# +% & % .&"#&# 7( % 1" A&, % &++(, /?
A%%&/"# /(+ / % .&"#&# % A# ,&#/%&/ .&< /& &+ "
.
"# % # "
&#,&+ "#7
# .<&#/
"/ # .<&#&
#;&/ (,( <"#C( , "#7I 87 7 /! & +(#, .%&,'( % &,,
/ %& +#,"/ "#$ % "(,# ,, ' % &..
$& "#,1 +(, /"&. "# $& "# ' %
", ,,&< (# & % % *&/ +#, "&+< &#/ +
% "..$ ;# <7 "
# % ,
" < ' % ''
1 %
B", , & ,(*, &# "&. ."0 ."%/ %& %
;&<&*,+#/ &;
A" % %
"/ 1"'%
@ ", #.&$ /#*&".7# % , #$ %' % ,(*;",,"#,1/",;",,&.' %
" "#"#%&#/", /'7 877 /+(#, .' % .&"#&# 1A%".
&","#$,(*;",,"#, "# &#/ ; A" % % ,(*;",,"#, ' .
/ ! & +(#, .1 %&, &.,
# .<
, / % $&# ' &# "+"
& < *&". %
*< &$("#$ %& % &..
$& "#, .
/ &$&"#, %
& , "(, "# #& ( 7 /+(#, .%&,,(*;"
/ %&
1"#+##"
&#+ A" %%", +&++(, /1%&,&
/ (,( <' % .&"#&# 7 / +(#, . %&, ,(*;"
/ %& 1 "# +&, 1 %
", $&# / % +#+ ,,"#'&# "+"
& <*&".1 %
",&..."0 ."%/ %& %
;&< &*,+#/ '; % ,, ' )(, "+ &, &., "# '
? "# ";"/& %
, +( "# A" # ,, ,?
"/ 7 # % , #$ % ' % ,(*;",,"#,1 /",;",,&.' %
" "#"#%&#/", /'7 @7
%&
% &/ % .
/+(#, .' % "
&. & "
,&#/%&
$# %($% % & &".&*.
+/' % +&, 7 97 ,
+&, ( ' %"# % "#C( , "#1 % $& "#, &$&"#, %
& $&
&#/ ,
+"'"+7
(,&. ' % ;& "&. #
+/,%A, %& %
%&/"# /(+ / % .&"#&# % &. A# ,' %
<"#C( , "#&#/1 %(,1%&/+.
&&#/ &+ "
.
"# # "
&#,&+ "#7 ",'( % *# ( %& &#&
#;&/ (,( <' % .&"#&# 7 +#/(+ ' %
";& '&+"
'.
+ , /",%# , &#/ / " '(. "# # "#, '; %
< "#+
"#' % &#,&+ "#7
"#$+., .< .& / % A# &#/%./"#$&A ' # < .&< /&#&+ "
&#//;"#&# .
"# %
# "
&.&#/"# /(+ / % .&"#&# % &.A# ,7.
$&.# "+ /& / 7 78",,( /#%",* %&.'+& $"+&..<, & / %& % &$
#
9 , .. %&/ *
# +&#+ ..
/ &#/ %& % # "
&;(# %&/ &.
&/< *
(# /"#+&,%#27 78 % .&"#&# 7A
1/("#$ #C("<
/"#$,#27:7@1 %
0 & +;
.< +# &/"+ < , &#/ * ' % !1 , & "#$ %& % .&"#&# '&".
/ &&#$ % *&.&#+ &;(# &#/1 %(,1 % <, /''
/7 ;( (&..< "#+#,", # &#/ ,%"' "#$ , &#/, +.
&.< "#/"+& &# & ;",.
&/ % &( %" "
,&#/A#$'(..<(,( <7 +# &/"+ "#,$ ' % ;& &#/ , &*.",%& ";&'&+"
+&, '+% & "#$&#/'&(/7 97 7 ( % ; 1 % "#
, "$& "#$&$ #+<%&,,($% % +(, /"&. "# $& "# ' %
' ''
+ "
+
<1
"'"+& "# ' '&+ ,1 &#/ , &*.",% % *&/ +#, "&+<1"'&#<1* %"#/ % ++( 7 +&(, #&< .&(,"*.
+&(,
#,%A#1& %",, &$ 1';A%"+%" +&#* +"
/ %& %
%&, *
# '&., .< ";
."+& / "# %
# 7
7
",* '" "#$ ;
# "#%
%& A%".
+#,"/ "#$& &' $&# '&# "+"
& <*&".1 % ( %&, C("."*&
#,&'
$(&/"#$ "#/"
"/(&."$% ,&#/ + "#$,+"
&."#
, ,7 ( ($% +0# A" % % ;&$#" (/ &#/ #& ( ' % ''
J % .
& "*( / % &++(, /J % #
/''&"&#/'
"#
, "$& "#&,&., %
&#/A"/ ";
&+ ',(+%&..
/"#"C(" "
,# % ,+"
<7 ",";
& "
%&
<
,#"# % !+"
<+&#
+ &#& ;,
'
';' */"#$K'
& '&#< &#,$ ,,"#7 %",, &$ 1 %
",#;& "&.# +/ %./ %&
";&'&+"
+&, ",# ;&/ ( &$&"#, %
7 ;& "&.A%"+% %&,+;
# +/&#/
.";"#&<"#
, "$& "#1&
& * , &*.",% /&
&,#&*.
*&,", ' % &++(,& "#,7 %(,1 " ", # &
"& $&# &# "+"
& <*&". %
1&," A(./# ,,&".<+&(, ";
/";
#
"# ''
+ "
"#
, "$& "#7 #! &
! &
! &
! & 7#".!%&;&13 6 ! :
-
7#".!%&;&13 6 ! :
-
7#".!%&;&13 6 ! :
-
7#".!%&;&13 6 ! :
- !3"6 2L !3"6 2L !3"6 2L !3"6 2L1 % !(
( % ./&,(#/ -3! 7 :1 &&96 H97M '"#/'+ "# % ,(*;",,"#' %& +(, /"&."# $& "#", C(&." & "
.<; ."+" & "#"
/ %&#C( , "#"#$&,(,
+ A%",A ..
#,+#+ /A" %&'& (&*.
/ (#/ !
+ "#82:' % / 7 #&+&, ."0 %",1 ''
+ "
"# $& "# ' & ,(,
,# ", ' #/(, &/ &# &$ "#/","# "#$;&#<(, '(."#';& "#,&#/&.,;& "&.,A%"+% A(./%&
#+#+ &.
/7!(++ ,,"#,(+%"# $& "#A(./ .(/ "' % ,(,
,#0#A, %& % ",A .. /&#/"#,(.& /*<&
& , *&"./ /("#$ % ";
% ","# $& /7N <'
#"# $& "#"#,(+% &+#/" "#A(./ /(+ &;
" (&.7 &$(;
# %& % +(, /"&. "# $& "#",'&($% A" % % /&#$ ' %
,#* "#$,(*) / %"/
;
%/, #
/ # * +(# #&#+ /1 '1 ,(+% &# &$(;
# +&# * &/ &#+ /*<&..&++(, /"#&..+";"#&.+&, ,7 ( %&,
,(;
%&
#,"*.
."+ ''"+ ,A(./+#/(+ % ;,
,"#& #,"*.
;&## &#/ %& %, # (, / A" % % &,0 ' /","# "#$ ''
, A(./ # +#/(+ % ;,
,&,''
#/ ,7I :7
A' % , "(,# ,,' % $& "#,1 %",( '"#/,#
.."#$ $(#/ #/ % * '" ' /",+ "#&< ."
' %
7
1 +(, /"&. "# $& "# ' %
", # ,,&< '&# ''
+ "
"#
, "$& "#K (#&
. % ( %7
" "#",1 %(,1
"/';
" ,&#/",%
*</",;",, /",;",, /",;",, /",;",, /7 7
%"#$,&"/%
"#&*
,%&..*
/ * &#
,,"# ' "#"#( #;
" ,' % +&, ?"#
, "$& "#7 7 #/"#$&
."+& "#3,61"'&#<1,%&..&.,, &#//", , /''7 3! 6 3! 6 3! 6 3! 6 ". ". ". ".19 19 19 19 ;&%& " M% ,
&0"#$?
&,# /- ,?
M%
&*.
- ,?