Labh Chand And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others
!" # $%&'( )* +,( #-( $-*# )#, $%&'( )* +,(# $--*# ( #
!"
#-( $-*# )#, ) # $ %& '
( )* *) "**+ ,- .!/0
!/ *1 "**+ ,- .! 0 '
2 3 2
!
*!
"*"* ,- .!40 5 '
2 $ !),0 26&
7 ,8& 0 !94! , 2
0 , : ;0 2 2 ''
2 $ % 2 2 <2 6&(# $3( #% $
Page 2 of 14 6&( 2
2 6& '
7 ,8& 0 !9 ) # 7
3$'$
)"+=!9+) 6 !"#$% $ &!* / $$ "4 * !9+)2 2>&5'( # . &""' (" (()" ""( #"* (+"(($, " )- < .. 7= . -& $
- # -.),'
0& 2 &
?& &6 $$ !9 * !9+)2 '
2>&5'($ $& 2 . &." ' ( " ( ("" " ""( #$"*( +"(($ , ( +"(( # " )- # '
"9+ !9+) ""6 !"#$/*% $$ !9 * !9+)'
"91 !9+) "
Page 3 of 14
"*6 !"#$/*% !9 * !9+)'
)!! !9+) "*6 !"#$/*% "4 * !9+)'
)!1 !9+) " 6 !"#$ /* % "4 * !9+) '
))) !9+)0"* 6 !"#$/*% *!
*4 !9+) ' $ $ ' 2 & $ 2 2 & 2 $ $ < 2 ' $ 2 2 &
)/ !9+/ $ $ !4 *1 !9+/''
!4 *1 !9+)$ # $&'
'@
" !9+ " " 6 !"#$/*% #$$ $ '
*4 *"
!9+ $$ !4 *1 !9+/ 2
& # 7 ='
!4 !9+1 & &'
$ 2
A2 '
!!
*+ !91+ . < !),30$ !!
*"
!91! $2 2 ''
$ # !!
*"
!91! $
Page 4 of 14 &'
'@
4 !91!
#$$ !) *!
!91)$7& 2 ''
''
&&& !) *!
!91) 7 $ 2 2 $ !
*+ !91+ < 6&( ' ,-.40 & ' &
&'
"" !9+/2 $ 2 $
*"
* !9+9 $ # ' 2 , & 0& 8 & $ $ "!
!!
!9+9 2 & $ 2 & B !+ 8 ) '
' !9*1, :'';0$ 2 < $ 6& ( ?8
8 8
8 &''
!9+) !9+/ $ . $
! $
"2 $ !!
* !99) <
Page 5 of 14 2 $
&$ & < & ' & &''
2 $ & . $ !9+)!9+/$ & $ & 2 22 !9+)!9+/2& $ 2 .. 2 & & 22 $ $ . #' B+8!* '' & ' '
$
!) $'
#$ '
( < 1/ $ $))$ $'
"/+.3'."**" "1" "* 6 ,+ "* "
! $ $ '
" .3'."**" "1" "*6 2*" "*" #$ !9 *1 !9+/$ $
$ & - 2
23 2$ "1 *"
"**4
Page 6 of 14 "1 * "** 2 '
( 2$ '
$ $ 2$ 2 ' '
!9+) !9+/ & )* *) "**+,-.!/0 $
!9+)!9+/$2 2& 2 $ 2 2 & $ 2 $ $ && & & . '
1/ $ 2 '
2 3 2 !),0 #$ !/ *1 "**+ #
. &.',"(+"' *",*' "() "" " $ %,, ' ( , 34)3)3556 +( ") $%,, "* ( " ( " ,
+"* " ' " , # ,) "*.,")7*"*"(,$ ,"" *+'""(1,*""" ' ++ ) 896:(3555 + +* 8;6" 3553<3=!2$(",(
Page 7 of 14 ++" ( !"#""> " ", ,' + # ' , " # ! ,# ," !,"1 /* " " < *,"= $ 7;67
# $ %,, ,"
" 7?> " " ++ " , #+ ( ,' " (,," ) *"* " "1 "'",$ # " # $ %,, , " , ( " +,+ " ( "+,' ( "3<*=<8=() *'" (""* " ( '", )) 1 " ( # 7;86>8: " 7;6:>64) . " *" (""* ( , " *," '" # ) ," ( +' +"""*((<!"#=) +"+ (1,"++ "+") " ( "@ ,+ , " " ))!) ( # !
"# " (,) '$ "A ,+ , " !"#$ , ', B11* "* + 3555 <3= !2$ 8;6 " # (, * !"# " " *" # ,# ",,"""+,C, ,$+ #' , ') ($.
"# "(" C, " +,*" 1,*" " ) . ' "," $ %,, *# + +,*" 1,*"""++'( ""*#) ""!" +"( !"#$% "* " " " (
Page 8 of 14 !"# " # " ,# , , " + , 76 <?= ( !,"1 /* " " < *,"= ,$ 7;69$ ($"#+++"" *"+")-
&& 1/ $ 2 5 '
& 2 $ $ !
*!
"*"* # 2 5 '
$ & . &75) . ' *" ,* *," '" # " ," ( + "+, () ""(("" C," "'", "'"));)7)7;89"+" "++('*""+" ( " " C," > " $ # "+"("," +'"( !,"1 B "("$ 7;94) + # D+ " # 7;:3)."
+",$"" ((""C,""( " ( ( ," "# ( D+" , ( " 3 <*= ( $ +"A # " *," # "(" #',(1,*"" 7;)7)7;:9).","+,(( +" " # " +" !"# , ,"#,"( !"# (( C, ," , 76 <?= ( !
Page 9 of 14
,+ ,$ " !"# ( '* , ', B1* "*A > 3559 <9= <'=:9;$++#(+, "," "" 1+ #+" " +"(*'+"" D+ (('# (" +, " " ,"#++#)!"+""*+, D+ * (,"" ((,# "
+"* , + " ) ." +" $',"7;)7)7;:9""(
+" "* ( ' , , , *"* ,+,,"* ,"*"#'" ,(,
"+#"*( !"#) 77)
"""')?9(7;:9
"*1,"(',"+1, ((" #1,*"" 7;)7)7;:9'" "*"""( )?9(7;:9),'"
""'""("7? " " 77)3)7;47$ 1,*" " 7;)7)7;:9 ' " C, *" , ,'"(,,"", *" + 1,*" ' # "A
,+ , " !"# ', B1* "*A) (+,*"+"E ,( #+'+"","*" >("" ""$ +' ," " 7?("#" "('*#( ,(" "#" " " ' " ' " !"#)"""(#"1,"* (""++"(+""")7)
Page 10 of 14 "A ,+ , # " !"# , A ,' " # (, " *" " , C," +"*"""#(""+"" ,(",'",("* "" +") " , ( ," "7?("" *
#"),+""" *'"
"(('+" ,+" " (,'*""( +, "," " " ' +" " *"+, ",") 73) ."' ("#( '($.("" " +" '" +" " " '" +" # ) +# ( +"'"+")- &2 $ $ < 2 ''
2
& &
)/ !9+/ !4 *1 !9+/ $ *4 *"
!9+ & '@
/1+ !9+ <2 $
!" $ 4 7 !94) 2
$2 $ B 2 & 2
Page 11 of 14 '
&$ & 2 2 <2
$ 2 $ % $ 2 $ & 2 & < 2 ' 2 $ 2 $ 2 $ . $ 2 2 # 8 $ $ $ 2 $ & $ '
$&$ 2 $ $ #2 & & 2 $ $ $ .
<2 $ &
A2 '
& '@
" !9+ $ . <2 & & & 4 )! !! 1!4, -
Page 12 of 14
A2 '
!"#(/*$, 6 B1* "*C 355<9= <'= :9; &2 2& @ $2 <
5'
&9/!)!) 2 !!+4 $& !9 " D 2EF 7!9/1 # - F $ & # ''
2
& 4 )! !! 2 1!4 2
8 & ? & !9+) !9+/ $ 2 $ $ # $ $ $& $&
''
& $ 2 $2 $ . # .2$ $ 2
$$ &
Page 13 of 14 # $2
2 2 $ & -& $ 2 2 $
&& # 2 2 '
$ & '@
" !9+ 2 2 !"#$ /* , < ,+=$
A2 '
&
22 2& 2%= &% & &5? !"#$/*%"6 2* " C !99!,!0 888 )41 < 2 2 2
A2
'
6& , 0 :,++#(+, ",""" 1+
#+" $"+"($*'+"" D+ (('# (" +, " " ,"# ++#)!"+""*+, D+* (,""((,#"" +"* ,+")- # $ 2 2 $
$ & $ % $
$ 2
# $ $
Page 14 of 14 & $ 2 &$
!"!" # D( Whether speaking / reasoned :
Yes / No Whether Reportable :
Yes / No