High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/574/2015allowed

Jasbir Singh v. State Of Punjab

2015-04-27Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

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

71!"#1 7/'1#*+#$"%'&

7=>7 @7*#,%&"#*#1!"9%$#+"!"%'-!)-!97 %&"*%$"

!*'!*!' 4#!*'#1$/'&#9 *"-#2!*"%#&-!8#)##'-#!*1 629!%'!'"%'"-#2*#&#'"$!&#%&+-!*!'0%":!/*%#A% # "-#!$$/&#1B2*#&#'"2#"%"%'#*99#,!"%'&!,!%'&""-#2#"%"%'#*!*# A%"-*#,!*1"6!%'"!%'%',%99%$%"*#9!"%'&A%"-!9!1;);"-#'!6#

!'0%":!/*!'1-!8%',"-#*#!

"#*#8#'2#* *6#1!&#$'16!**%!,# A%"-/",#""%',1%8*$# *6"-#$629!%'!'"/*"-#*!99#,!"%'&!*# A%"-*#,!*1""-#2#"%"%'#*-!8%',&"9#'!2!%* ,91#!**%',&7'# ,91*%',!'1C7B$!&- *6!'96%*!-7A-%$-)#9',#1""-# $629!%'!'"

D-%9# %&&/%', '"%$# 6"%'7 "-# 99A%', *1#* A!& 2!&&#1);"-%&/*"' ( E4#!*'#1$/'&#9 *"-#2#"%"%'#*-!&&-A'"-# $2; "-# $629!%'" %9#1 /'1#* +#$"%' "-# *"#$"%' D6#' *6 6#&"%$ .%9#'$# $"7 A-%$- &-A& "-!" "-# A% # "-# $629!%'!'" !'1 -%& $-%91*#'!*#&"!;%',%'"-#-/&#!9',A%"-"-#2!*#'"&

"-#2#"%"%'#*'!""#62"!""-%&&"!,#$!')#6!1# *!'

!6%$!)9#&#""9#6#'")#"A##'"-#2!*"%#&'*!9*#F/#&" "-#2#"%"%'#*7+-!*!'0%":!/* A% # "-# 2#"%"%'#* 7 :%*!'0%":!/*!'1+-!6&-#*+%',- 6%'*1!/,-"#*!'1&'

2#"%"%'#* *B8%99!,#-!"-,!*-7#-&%9!'1 %&"*%$"!*'

!*!'7!*#%629#!1#1!&2!*"; "%$# 6"%' )# %&&/#1 " "-# *#&2'1#'"&7 *#"/*'!)9# * 7&/)0#$""1#2&%" &=7B !& 9%"%,!"%' #G2#'&#& %' "-# #,%&"*; "-%& /*"7 );

9#!*'#1$/'&#9 *"-#2#"%"%'#* *$#&& !&"%!&A#99 %99"-#'#G"1!"# -#!*%',72#"%"%'#*%&1%*#$"#1" 0%' "-# %'8#&"%,!"%' !& !'1 A-#' $!99#1 ); "-# '8#&"%,!"%',

%$#* ' "-# #8#'" -%&B"-#%* !**#&"7 -#B"-#; &-!99 )# *#9#!&#1 ' )!%9 ); "-# '8#&"%,!"%',

%$#* ' -%&B"-#%* /*'%&-%', )!%9 )'1&B&/*#"%#& " -%& &!"%& !$"%'7&/)0#$"""-#$'1%"%'&6#'"%'#1)#9A7!& #'8%&!,#1%'+#$"%' =>

*( % ! $'1%"%' "-!" "-# 2#*&' &-!99 6!5# -%6&#9 B"-#6&#98#& !8!%9!)9# * %'"#**,!"%' ); 9%$#

%$#*!&!'1A-#'*#F/%*#1H %% ! $'1%"%' "-!" "-# 2#*&' &-!99 '"7 1%*#$"9; * %'1%*#$"9;6!5#!';%'1/$#6#'"7"-*#!"*2*6%&#"!'; 2#*&' !$F/!%'"#1 A%"- "-# !$"& "-# $!&# & !& " 1%&&/!1#-%6 *61%&$9&%',&/$- !$"&""-#/*"*" !';29%$#

%$#*H %%%!$'1%"%'"-!""-#2#*&'&-!99'"9#!8#'1%!A%"-/" "-#2*#8%/&2#*6%&&%' "-#/*"

%8 &/$- "-#* $'1%"%' !& 6!; )# %62&#1 /'1#* &/) &#$"%' = +#$"%' = 7!&% "-#)!%9A#*#,*!'"#1/'1#* "-!"&#$"%'

" -!& ,'# /'1%&2/"#1 "-!" "-# 2#"%"%'#* -!1 1/9; 1#2&%"#1!&/6 C=7B"A!*1&9%"%,!"%'#G2#'&#&!'1"-#&!6#

-!&&%'$#)##'*#9#!&#1""-#$629!%'!'"-#*#! "#*2!*"%#&A#*# 1%*#$"#1"!22#!*)# *#"-##1%!"%'!'1'$%9%!"%'#'"*# "-%& /*" " #G29*# "-# 2&&%)%9%"; !' !6%$!)9# &#""9#6#'" '

== "-%&/*"-!1!9&%&&/#11%*#$"%'&""-#2#"%"%'#*" 6!5#!1#2&%" C 7BA%"-"-#*#,%&"*; "-%&/*"!'1 *&/$- !6/'"")#2/"%'! %G#11#2&%"%'"-#0%'"'!6#& *#&2'1#'"& =!'1 %#"-#$-%91*#')*'/" "-#A#19$5 & 2#*

%$# *#2*"7 "-# &/6 C 7B -!& )##'

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

&"!'1&1#2&%"#1);"-#2#"%"%'#*A%"-"-#$!&-)*!'$- "-%&/*"

)#*#9#!&#1%' !8/* "-#$629!%'!'"/2'!*#F/%&%"#!229%$!"%' )#%', %9#1%'&/$-*#,!*1

%&2&#1 2*%9 7 2*%9 7 2*%9 7 2*%9 7

+ +

+ + 5!'$-!'