Balwinder Singh & ANR v. State Of Punjab




   
   

 !

"#$ $%&'&() 

 "*+&(,$-.&(/0"(,"(#0$-  $#&#&($-'

1$-'2'

.#"#$ 2(3"4  $'5(,$(#
 


     

-$'$(#) -..260&3"7,8%"#$ -#0$5$#&#&($-' -1"-2(.0"-9"77 2(3"4 '(32--"7,8%"#$ -#0$%95*"&("(# :::

      0$&('#"(#5$#&#&(0"'4$$(  &*$,2(,$-.$%#&(;<-  '$$6&(/#0$4$($ &# "(#&%&5"#-=4"&*##0$5$#&#&($-'&(%"'$ 
  ,"#$,  <

2(,$-'$%#&(;


 7-$/&'#$-$,"# *&%$ .#"#&(7&#=.2#07/"

*$",&(/'  (  -$%-,  +2*,  &(,&%"#$  #0"# 
 %"9$  #  4$ -$/&'#$-$,"##0$&('#"(%$ >"9*$'0 "(&**$/"#&('"/"&('##0$5-$'$(# 5$#&#&($-'"-$#0"##0$=0"8$"4$##$,02'4"(, #0$%95*"&("(#("9$*= .2-$(,$->29"-#0"8$%99&##$,'2&%&,$"(,+0,&$,(  <

 "8&(/0$"-,%2('$* -#0$5"-#&$'"#*$(/#07
"9 #0$ %('&,$-$,8&$+#0"##0$&('#"(#5$#&#&(,$'$-8$',&'9&''"* 0$2(%(#-8$-#$,5'&#&( "%#&'#0"#,$%$"'$,.2-$(,$- >29"-+"'"#$("(#&(#0$-$'&,$(#&"*5-$9&'$'2(,$-#0$+($-'0&5 #0$ 5-$'$(#5$#&#&($-' -$%&'$"%%2'"#&('"/"&('##0$5-$'$(#5$#&#&($-'"-$ #0"#+&#0"8&$+#$('2-$#0"##0$5-$9&'$'&(?2$'#&("-$8"%"#$,7#0$ 5$#&#&($-'",5#$,"5"#0 0"-"''&(/.2-$(,$->29"-"'"*'0&'+& $"(, $8$($(#$-$,&(#"("*#$-%"#&(@'%2

*$(  

&$#0$,"#$+0$(#0$



    $(/"/$9$(# ,"2/0#$- ,$%$"'$,.2-$(,$->29"-+"' &A$,

*$",&(/'  (  -$%-,  "-$  "*'  &(,&%"#&8$    "  ,$8$*59$(#7  +0$-$4=  "

%95-9&'$0","*'4$$("55"-$(#*=$(#$-$,&(#"(,&(#$-9' +0&%0 .2-$(,$->29"-0","/-$$,#8"%"#$#0$5-$9&'$'+&#0&("5$-&, B ,"=' 8$(#02/07$(#$-&(/&(# '2%0%95-9&'$7& 7#"6$(#4$

"%#2"**=%--$%#+2*,(#32'#& =-42##-$''"(="**$/"#&('"'-$/"-,'#0$ 5-$'$(#  5$#&#&($-'  0"8&(/  -$'-#$,  #  "(=  2-#0$-  0"-"''9$(#    #0$ ,$%$"'$,-0&'+& $42#+0"#0"'0$"8&*=+$&/0$,+&#0#0&'2-#&'" '2&%&,$  (#$  ,"#$,  < <

7  +0&%0  &'  &(  #0$  5''$''&(    #0$
(8$'#&/"#&(//$(%=2(,$-#0$0"(,"(,'&/("#2-$' #0$,$%$"'$, ("5&(#$,?2$-=0"8&(/4$$(52#*$"-($,.#"#$%2('$*7+0 &'(&('#-2%#&(' -9.
>2*+"(#.

&(/0+2*,'249&##0"##0$$A5$-# 5&(&("'-$/"-,''&/("#2-$' #0$,$%$"'$,(#0$'2&%&,$(#$0"'4$$( '2/0#"(,&#&' 2(,#0"##0$'&/("#2-$'"-$&(,$$,#0"# #0$,$%$"'$, #-"('*"#$,%5= #0$'2&%&,$(#$+"'9",$"8"&*"4*$ - 5$-2'"* #0&'2-#"(,"%5=#0$-$ +"'$8$( 2-(&'0$,#%2('$* - #0$  5$#&#&($-' 
(  #0$  '2&%&,$  (#$  #0$-$  "-$  '5$%& &%  "(,  %"#$/-&% "**$/"#&('"/"&('##0$5-$'$(#5$#&#&($-'$-/"#-=*"(/2"/$&'"**$/$, #0"8$4$$(2'$,$8$(4=5$#&#&($- "/"&('##0$+& $ #0$,$%$"'$, "(,+0&(#2-(&'#0$%95*"&("(# 2-#0$-#0$'2&%&,$(#$-$8$"*'#0"##0$ 5$#&#&($-'0"8$4$$(#0-$"#$(&(/#0$,$%$"'$,+&#0,&-$%('$?

2$(%$'( #0$5-$#$A# *"2(#&(/#0$&-5-A&9&#=+&#0#0$5*&%$"2#0-&#&$'0-$$ '#-"(/$-'+$-$"*''#"#$,#0"8$4$$(02'$,&(#0$/2$'#-9 #0$ 5-$9&'$'&(?

 

 !

; "4,2%#$,"(,92-,$-$,"*' &(,"9$(#&(&(#0$'2&%&,$(#$
(#0$*&/0# '2%0'2&%&,$(#$0"8&(/4$$(-$%8$-$,"(, +0&%00"'4$$(5&($,#4$2(,$-#0$'&/("#2-$' #0$,$%$"'$,"(, %25*$,+&#0#0$/-"8&#= #0$

$(%$7#0&'2-#&'(#&(%*&($,#$A#$(, &( "82- #0$5$#&#&($-'#0$%(%$''&( "(#&%&5"#-=4"&* #0&(/ 9-$&'4$&(/4'$-8$,*$'#&#'02*,5-$32,&%$#0$-&/0#' #0$5"-#&$'

$#&#&(&',&'9&''$,         

*2%6= C0$#0$-'5$"6&(/@-$"'($,) $'

C0$#0$- $5-#"4*$) $'