Munish Chaudhary And Others v. Ut Of Chandigarh And Another

  
       
  



   

  
 !"  !

# ! $! % &!! !"'
(! 

) 
* 

  


 



#! !

*+ ,- '-!

*. /  0 # -(,'*.  ! ) ! 1 - & !'*## !% 
(!

#/2+!- !+'*.  !!) 3

 ! "

#$% & 

'() *+ &       )   !  -   
!

#
 5( 6 (   78  3 9    

'  !(!  (    ) !!  4'4

'

8#
 # ,  -   - !  9' 
(! ' 
  
       (!  

 +)! + 8))!' !78/!(!  :  +),+:" :,+,"'+2!'/ ,,(  ) !!  !! + #!!-( '1,(! 
,'
(!  

!!5 & " !;!   +), 8 )! 

, 5),  ,

!  !+ -<'# ,- - !9'
(! /

 !

=!   !   ,  !     ) !         !!     !  /    )!.  )  >(  :/  +),  + 2!      2!!  -(  & 5!        <!!-( * !(  +'.)!, 78/ , /  :   ,!  

')! /  / 78 

783  

/!!(!# ,- +;!'% '

(! !.!    !!(  !!*>!#9 #4

' :+ :  78/!6 :"   !)!  +)! +!!.:/ )! < ! !

:+ )! ! :"  !'+



)! .:! !  #!, ! / ,  / )!  / )! +!" ! ! . !  +)! +  <)   ) !/!, ++ :". ?   
!./ ! !+ :"
.,1(1!

. '
(!  

 3 /'

/.!'   !(      ,  ) , ("  /  !  :"    ) ! 8)) !  )!"! !6 ( 78'  !, )  !!

'):" . ?    !
@#3



,A
!  /+  $ % '

(!   !B

& !',! ,))!( !% 
(!   !  ! +- <!;-( '/ )! !:+   (  ,, : ,  !' !( . : !+ ,, / <  )   +  +),+

, 2!,,  .:! !:" 1,(! 
, < ! !    !  :+  )! .+:,", '% &!! !"/ ,   /" 6 (  78  #/  2+!  - !+'  ,!   ,  !     +),:+    /  )! ,,(  ,.,, 78 8 . !,! , ! )!(.! ,  (      

8. . !" 5),  ! )!+ 

& :5(!   ))! : )!.):/ .",2!!-(  /  / !)!(*.  !
!'
(!

*!, /   5),  !.(( 

     "'

'783 

/, (:"

2!!-( & 5!(.",':!  !,/ +2! !  4' '  

98#
 8))!'

! 

98#
/,,!  *  !783



/, (:"  ))   +"( 2!!-( & 5!' / /  !  4' '



8#
# ,- '+;!'% '
(!

!()" )! ()!  !/ 78')! !       +)! +    )! !!  /  )!  )   !

6 ( !

 ?   ) /!,, /./ )! !!7:!!"

*>!#9#4 -  

) !       )!    /  ,"    )! .  '    / *. +,"'<!!-( -!!-( & 5!+   ! 

/ !;!  !)!  & "!   !! + 1,(!
, ++2!'/  , !,. .",/) 3:
! ! 8    + +' 

, /   ! ,

8 . ! !.,     )!  8  .   !,  5 (C  +!:"/"

 +))   

#

&  !!(!!

$(,   !  6!":+!) !

D6!"!) !/:+:"

! 

8./

+'     /      ,,     ) !     /    / " )! (!
+) 
!*: ( +

*,, ) !)))! & "!  !.,,"

 ! (  ,  ! "/ ,++ ), / ,   (/  / ,:(,/ !/ ,, /!  ("   !  *!,' / !(  *,!"

 : .'.,):/ )!/,/ 78)!( 

/!6 '. !! *>!#9#4 8 ' !:     !/ ,(  +  '! !, ! ! !  + 

)!/ !(! .,"  +)! +

& ! !' +),<
:,+2!))!: !   !+  ,, /(+

A :  !,     ( !

,  
(!  # ,'  8    !     +)! +  

'     )"   /     D> *        : 

 +)! +D> *'8 .  :; 783 9

'%E 4'4

'

8#
#- - !9'
(! ',,:6)! (!(  ! ! +!,, / : +) E6  *!) ! , :!. ! +  ! 1, (!
,'
(! ' !( /  )! !!.  +)! +. ,!,"/ " !  !)!! !(   !  !('!

- ',! ! ,!

3 3'

D>#!  !?!!  !' 

:!! ++:! !?!*  / ,+5.!"

! + ("  ;,"+) , !+  + ) !

& " .,  , !

.'/  !5 ! !!5 F*F!5F?F!).,"

8+" !./'!

 78   4  8#
 !+,," :6   :  +)! +  < /.!' '  +),    )!  +),   * !(  +'   !  +)! +/  ) !  :  !, 

 ( !

,  
(! ) ,  ?') ! . ,  ),!, ;(+'):". ?     ! 



 ' 

 * !(  +'  !!  /  )      )      +/     +,! !+ 2)(./! !+'))!

-     ! !  )! (  )!    78'  /   / !(!/":5 "!

'+":>! ,"

&   !' ' ,  78,,)! (!( ! ! +'

!. :6  !! !(,"

&  !' /.!' )! ) !  !++:!  ?! ,,  ::" !5( (.   !:"/"

.  !!)!. # ,, / !+

'

+



 F;),F @  ! :! !! !) !!G0E3