Vishal Kumar v. State Of Punjab
"#$ $%&'&() *
+&',"-./0"1 $#&#&($1 +$1'/'
2#"#$ /(3"4 $'5(6$(#
1$'$(#) 12/(&-,"6,"72168%"#$9&#, 1.&15"-2&(:,768%"#$ 1#,$5$#&#&($1 '(0-1$9"-77 /(3"4 ;;;
,&'16$1',"--6&'5'$ #,$51$'$(#5$#&#&( &-$6/(6$1 2$%#&(*1 '$$<&(:#,$4$($ &# 1$:/-"14"&-##,$5$#&#&($1&( %"'$ 6"#$6 /(6$1'$%#&(' 7
1$:&'#$1$6 "# -&%$2#"#&(7&#=.,"1"17&'#1&%#22":"1 >$"1($6%/('$- 1#,$5"1#&$',"8$4$$(,$"16 1&$ -=(#&%$67 %"0$#4$1$:&'#$1$6(#,$%05-"&(#
($ "0,"(6$1,/3"%%/'"#&('":"&('##,$51$'$(#5$#&#&($1"(6% "%%/'$6"/#"0./0"1"1$9&#,1$:"16##1"(' $1 ',"1$'4=9"=
1:$6 6%/0$(#' 05-"&("(# "--$:$6 #,"# ,$ ,"6 :# 1$:&'#$1$6 " %05"(=&(#,$("0$ ?'(#$051"1=>"(6"1<'>#6&(#,$=$"1
"(6&(9,&%,,$"-(:9&#,,&'9& $("0$-="(3$$#,/3"9$1$#,$ &(&#&"-&1$%#1'#&'"--$:$6#,"#/(6$1"5-"(($6%('5&1"%=#,$51$'$(# 5$#&#&($1"'"-'%"%%/'$6"/#"0./0"1%"0$#4$&(6/%#$6"'',"1$ ,-6$1'&(#,$%05"(="(6#,$1$"
#$15$#&#&($19"'"-'0"6$"&1$%#1 05-"&("(#"--$:$6#,"#,$,"6 @',"1$'&(#,$%05"(="(6 ',"1$'9$1$&(#,$("0$ ,&'9& $"(3$$#,/3"--$:"#&(&("(/#',$-- &'#,"#(#,$'#1$(:#, " $16$$651$'$(#5$#&#&($1"(6
"/#"0./0"1,"8$:##1"('
$11$6#,$"
1$(#&%$6',"1$,-6&(: #,$ %05-"&("(#"'"-',&'9& $&(#,$&1("0$' "8&(: ,$"16 %/('$- 1 #,$ 5"1#&$' "# -$(:#, "(6 ,"8&(:
5$1/'$6#,$5-$"6&(:'(1$%167#,&'/1#&' #,$%('&6$1$68&$9#,"# #,$5$#&#&($1&'$(#&#-$6##,$4$($ &# 4"&- ##,$8$1=/#'$#7�"=4$(#&%$6#,"#"-#,/:,#,$#1"(' $1 ',"1$,-6&(:(#,$4"'&' "("--$:$6 $16$$61$-"#$'
4"%<# ?
A 7=$#7#,$%05-"&(#-$"6&(:##,$1$:&'#1"#&(
9"''/40&##$6(A@
-"%$6(1$%16"#(($B/1$ &'"%5= #,$5$#&#&( &-$6 /(6$1'$%#&(A1 &-$64=#,$%05-"&("(# "0,"(6$1,/3""'
"-' ,&' 9& $"(3$$#,/3"&$
'$$<&(:
%(%$''&( 51$"11$'#4"&-&( 6"#$6 @ /(6$1'$%#&('
7
1$:&'#$1$6"# -&%$2#"#&(7$1""''&7&'#1&%#,"-& (%$6$6-=7%05-"&("(#&('/%, 9"'"/#"0./0"1&$%"%%/'$6 &(#,$51$'$(# 8$(#,/:,7#,&'/1#,"'4$$(&( 10$6#,"#"
%"(%$--"#&(1$51#9"'/-#&0"#$-= &-$65$1#"&(&(:#'/%, 7=$#7#,$ "8$10$(#'0"6$&(#,$5$#&#&(6/-='/551#$64="("
&6"8&# "0 ,"(6$1,/3"9/-64$1$-$8"(#(5"1":1"5,'"(6 '/%,5$#&#&( #,$%05-"&("(#,&0'$- ,"6%"#$:1&%"--="8$11$6#,"#,$"-(:9&#,,&' 9& $ ,"6 1$'&:($6 10 #,$ %05"(= ( "(6 '/%, -$##$1
1$'&:("#&( ,"6 4$$( "%%$5#$6 4= "/#"0 ./0"1 05-"&("(# &( #,$ 51$'$(#%"'$ "0,"(6$1,/3" /1#,$1,"6'#"#$6#,"#$8$("5/4-&%(#&%$ ,"64$$(&''/$6&( 10&(:#,$5/4-&%"#-"1:$#,"#,$"-(:9&#,,&'9& $,"6 1$'&:($6 10#,$%05"(="'&1$%#1' #,$%05"(=('/%,5$#&#&(
&$
51$ $11$6&(#,$=$"1 &#'$- #,$1$&'(# $8$( " 9,&'5$1?"--$:"#&( 5$1#"&(&(: # " 1"/6/-$(# #1"('
$1 ',"1$ ,-6&(: ,$%05-"&("(# "0,"(6$1,/3"&(#,$51$'$(#%"'$"'
"-',&'9& $"1$"-''#"#$6#,"8$ &-$6"5$#&#&(/(6$1'$%#&('*7*A7 7"(6 #,$05"(&$'%#7 *@4$ 1$#,$05"(=>"9 "167 1&(%&5"-$(%,7$9$-,&"(6&(9,&%,#,$51$'$(#5$#&#&($19"' "11"=$6"'5"1#=?1$'5(6$(#( "--$:&(:551$''&("(60&'0"(":$0$(#
#,$%05"(=&(C/$'#&(8$(&('/%,5$#&#&(#,$"--$:"#&(&'(#9&#, 1$:"16##1"('
$1 ',"1$'4"'$6(" $16$$6 /('$-"55$"1&(: 1#,$5$#&#&($1,"'$8$(1$ $11$66/1&(:
#,$ %/1'$ ,$"1&(: # #,$ 5-&%$ &(8$'#&:"#&( %(6/%#$6 /5( #,$ %05-"&(#"(69,&%, 10'5"1# #,$ "(6&(9,&%,&#,"'4$$( (#&%$6#,"##,$05"(=>"9"16,"'#"<$("8&$9"(61$'#1$6',"1$ ,-6&(:&( "8/1 #,$%05-"&("(# "0,"(6$1,/3""(6,&'9& $ "(3$$#,/3"##,$$B#$(# *D $1%(#1"78$1'&( #,$%05-"&("(# &(#,$51$'$(# &' " 1"/6/-$(##1"('
$1 ',"1$,-6&(:##,$$B#$(# *D
$#&#&($1&'&(%/'#6='&(%$ >$"1($62#"#$%/('$-/5(&('#1/%#&(' 102"15"-2&(:, 9/-6 "551&'$ #,$ /1# #,"# $8$( #,/:, #,$ %,"--"( ,"' (# 4$$( 51$'$(#$67=$#7&(8$'#&:"#&(&(#,$%"'$&'%05-$#$"(6(-="1$51# 10 #,$ 2>&'"9"&#$6 ,$4"'&%&''/$9&#,1$:"16##1"('
$1 ',"1$',"8&(:4$$( $
$%#$6& "#"--(#,$4"'&' $16$$679/-64$"
0"##$1 $8&6$(%$#4$-$64$ 1$#,$1&"-/1#
(#,$-&:,# #,$%&1%/0'#"(%$'(#&%$6,$1$&("48$7#,$ 5$#&#&($1 &' ,$-6 $(#&#-$6 # #,$ 4$($ &# 4"&- 1$'$(# 5$#&#&( &'7 "%%16&(:-=7"--9$6 $#&#&($14$$(-"1:$6(4"&-'/43$%##'"#&' "%#&( ?/#=":&'#1"#$7,"-& #&'7,9$8$170"6$%-$"1#,"##,$4'$18"#&('%(#"&($6&( #,&'16$1"1$%( &($6(-=9&#,1$:"16#%('&6$1"#&( #,$51"=$1 #,$ 5$#&#&($1 1:1"(# 4"&-"(69/-6,"8$(4$"1&(:(#,$0$1&#' #,$ %"'$
$#&#&(6&'5'$6
-/%<=