High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4790/2016allowed

Neha v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2019-05-10Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma17 pages

! "#" $

"& "

'''''

" $#($)*+,

" (-"

&.++/% 0/#&+,

"& (&.

" #( "" .*

"& (&. " . "& # $ 1

2#"

)

34 5# $ " 1+5 * $ 4 " *.. " $

$ #. ""$ #.6 7"8 ,

+ "9+ 8

$:$6 +9 )" ;

(

. $ 0 * .. "#7"2#& )" ")

(

" 34 *" )" 7 "

"& &*

*"( * +7 , . 5 6

#"(.+7 , ." #"7!#"(

+"& 34

(&."&"#

( #

. ( ) ( " $ ., * #"7 % #") (&.< (= ) % *, ( )7 , #

#"7(

.*"" .*8& " & 9*" )

* " 6 "(

( * " "") $ *""#7= #.

* %

),"

": ) " "

",.+) ),"

( #

":"

() " .*" "

",.6 (&.7.

)" $ #. "8 ( 9 ((#* " .*7.

)" 0?* 8@(7 =9 ((# 6 ."

.. * 7 (" #" ) * " )" $ "

*" "". 7)

"""

( , (&. $#&

.0 * 5.) )"

& "34 > #".

& " )# ( )7* "& (&.* +7 , .*".

, ( )6 (&."*..2#. .

.))A& "$

& )( * 7 *

"7 #1 " #) $ (&. 7.

)" $ #. " * " & 7.

)" 0?* ."" & ,"

# $

$:$6+ "7("#"+ (

( ) (&.*" & " " +"""

/ , ( ..) ?#. ( )"

= "+"""

/ , ( ..)0* @ B#.56 (&.) ".

( ?#.

0*@ 5 ) #

(&.) " , # . " #.

/ , (& . % " # )# " & " ( ) #. &#..*.., & *" .7+7 , .)" "& (&. " # ) 55 % *, "& ( ,&&. 7

" # "?) "

" & 0 * # $ *" .

, ( ) 7* & " * ."* < )"*"( )

.?)

& " *

"#( . ""

+7 , . *" ) ) 77 * * ." % " # " "& ..) )" &

(

* ""( #" "& 6 ...) )" " "

*" & * #"7(

.* "") (&. +" & (&. (

$&(7 * & ".*

(&. ) , &. -(# ) ( )"

" . " #

(&. , "( (

.*6 ..) " * , (&.#" (

( ..) ? "

( & (

(&. #" #"

(

( #" " (&. " 7.

) . (.

(&.

.* ?";

#?) " (&. #" #.

. 7.) ""& *"

.*"

> #".

& " # )# & " 7) ,(A

& ,. " (

&) , ((7

(."# &

( ( . (..) "6 " .). , . . ( ". # 7 (&. "#7" ..) "6 ..) " 34 ? ,.# "#

..) 2# & " "

" #( ""

#"7

(&.4" "(

.* #.& ,")( . 6 .*"

#.7,).

& "

"( "#

( )( .

.+.. ..) "

#. * (* ) (= * " (&. "" & (. ((7 " . (&. 0 * * , , "

) "

0*@ " 0 *"

(&. # ." ,* "

" , ""(

#)" # $ " 1+5 * $ 4 "*.."$

$:$6+4" (&. *" #

( , & * #. , 7 "# #<&. . .

)) & " 34 4 " (&. *

" (( #. #& & 7 (&.)

.""6 (&."

#. 7& ( ?7

** )6 ( )7*+7 , . (&.*" .

,( ) . * *"< )7# ". " (&. " ( ." 7"."" ..) " )" & *

. (. 6 & " * ?) #. 7"" /% $ ) "

& & # 7

(&." * "( #(. "" *

*" "7 ( , ., *

. (. & )".? & " > $ #". * . (?) &. "#7( 7 *

!= "*. % $ $ 0 * " )# 34 *" )" (&. "#7( 7 (&. # ) ,") #" +7 , . 8 #"79 *" " 6 .. *" & " )" ( 7

. # 56 "#&&.( .. "7& "& & )" > #".

"& (&. " )#

( )7*+7 , . (&.*""

.(" 5 ( ) #"7(

.*"" .* 8& 9 " "") (&.

(

* $ (&. 7.

)" $ #. " "

*" ( # " 6 & (. #" " " (&.7.

)" $ #."

$ ((" (&. .

(

&."+ "(( (

(&. #" "&

# "* "

(

C"?) 7 #"#

) (

(&.#" &#..

(&.* " #" ( , 6 #"#" &

(DE (&.* 7:, "

(&.

% " # )# ..)" "7 & "7

. # 6

34 72#"

2# & % " ! ""

#$ % #"

&'()*+, *- ., //& ,") & .

#).

"& * , ., "*..C

& . "

#( .)" #" & " .. )" 34 72#"

% "."

&. . #& -" 0 ! !

". !

! * , &'(1 *&, *- .,)2(* " # " . # 2#"

& )"* ( "7,") )"

"7 "#7( 6 #(" , 7 <( " # ) & )"&)7

. # C " )

=#)(

% F7.0 (7%) # " 3 -!"

# #"

#$ " #"

&'(2*(, #-*,22/. #".

" )# * ..) ".,.. 34(? #& (

(.& ". #."*.."#.* #.(

( & )" 7 2#"

# $ 1 . "."

7&.#& !.

40 ! ""

* ,#$ .

&'()*5, *- ., 61) * % F7. .

%) # " . 2#" " * , ("(7

(&.* ) "&. # .7 & " .) .6 # "") ) & " ( ""( #

2#"

) (&.

34 )" 7 "

(&.# $ " 1+ * $ 4 > #".

"& " # . #& 77 !- ! .. - 8 - #"

&'() ..*.,655 * )"

" . " ( . )" #" & "

" & )" )" ( 7 2#"

#),) ) "

". "."

7&.#& ""

#$ #"

! - #"

(//( !9 - #!" (&6'*(, * (&.

,") 34 & " 7 "#7( 7 & . )" & ( ""( #)" #" %) # "

#. "")* .< ")" & * " # $ 1 6 2#"

)

)A" ?7 (. # ( #" ?..)"..7 .6 %) # 2#"

& )"7?) "

, #(""#7(7 #" %) # , ".

. # < "

" =# " 4 , . #".

& " "#( "" .*

(&. " * ?) /% $ ) 6 & ,." ( )7* (&. #"7*".

,#( ) ( )"7

( ) & "* ? *:.

)

7* (&. #"7 +7 , .

# "#7"" * ? *

(# 7

( )+ .,(* 342#" *" )"

(&. *" ") ) "

*" & " " +"""

0*@ " 0 ** " , "

0*@ *".,)(= )

. " ..)

#"(

* . & 6 (&. "( *

" #( "" .* & 77. 7#" "

*" # .#

( "#& " "*"),)"

#& (&.6 " . *..&." ,*"

. .&

# ." ..) , "" (&.

(

* )#(

. #".

"& (&. & "7"#7( )" & ( " " ( #

( 34 )"

" ""# %) # "

#. "")2#"

34< "

" & * " "7 " 7 +&< # "

! ""

#$ #$3 .

&'(+*&,*- .,))+ * +&< # " . %) # " & * " 2#"

"# & )" 6 ., & ) & 5

" =#)( ""#

% !

& "

% %

% & "

% !

(

% "!

E $(. . +&< # :

#" #"

! ""

#$ #"

&'(&*5,*- .,)(& " . (. "" ") #

( ( . "&# 7 #

<& 7 , .

? " , .,

(.((7 "

. ("2# .?)&. ( ( ."&#

. 7#" )"

" 7 ( )" & " ) # . . 6 7. ..) ")" * "#))" <

(

&"(" .,"

#"7"& ""7.6 34"7" * ".

(& " ( ," *" .

) )" & *

*" #"&#. .,) * (&. 0* @ ( * 34*" )"

#. 7(

. " #( "" .*

(&. . )" " ..

* & ( "

..7 # ,, "

( )& "& () "

"* "

34 & #""&& " "& ..) )"

(

* "

*" "

"7(:.# 34 7#

" #( ""

#"7

(&. 4 :

#" #"

; * !9, % F7. $#& ( # * .2#"

) 34)" (. ((7 "

#"7 "(

*) 7" , "& ) & "

=#)( )

" &''+(+)6

# < 0 ""

#$% <

**# + ,-.# /

% + ,-.# %

% "

" 0

+ ,-.# %

+ 1)2

& '

& &

))

& %!

% &

% (

% &

' # !

0 ""

#$-. !* !9,

% " "!

(

+ ,-.# + 14, 5"

/ #

3 %%

% % "

% !

(

% "

' %

+"!

& '

%% "

(

E .7(?)) ...) " *"."

, ., & ". (. #

"& (&. *

#( ),").)" "."

* "

#.7 ( , ( * * "

" . ."""

(&.F" #"7 " # " (. & )")" .7. 7""7)

.7#"

& ""

.* $(. ,* *" ? 7 % F7. $#& ( #

" :!9" #"

! ""

#$ = #"

&'('*5, *- ., 51 * " 7 . * ""( "" . )#(7

(&." (=

(&."

. ,* <)) , " "6 .,& ) & " 1

"=#)( & #"# ).

(

" # "

,-.# /

7,-.# %

"8%!

% !

9& !

% "

; "< =

;

% "

,-.# /

% % 8

' % #

0 %

& %

,-.#

(

% %

E =#)(

; * !9, 7 . #".

"& (&. " &&.7. " #(""

& """ "=#)( ."

# $ " 0 4 " *.. " $ 1

) 7. 4" #(" + 11 $(. .

=#)( 7 . #".

"& (&. -" 0 !

; * !9, ."

# ,

#& + 11

" # " "

? =#)(7. #".

"& (&. " 3 -! "

# #"

; * !9, " ""*" 7?) #

.=# " " # #7 " " #"

" ". & &.

< "

& * "# $ 1 " "". & . 7""

..) " ( (&. #(" (& * 7# # " =# " <( ""

..) " 6 +&< # (

#$% !

> .. #"

(//&6'5 ". )#."& ) &

=#)(* ""#

8 %

(

E 0# "(( " " # " ( ,""7."

( * "

7" , . &

" =#)( (&. " & 77. .#* "#& " , 342#" *" )" 0*@ " 0 ** " *

"#( "" .*

(&." ") ) "* ?)

/%$ ) + &

(& , " 0*@

,) # " & ," "

$ 1 " # " )"

34)" "

.("#"

& ""

.* &

(&. + ). & "& "..

* 34 5# $ " 1+5 * $ 4 "*.."$

$:$6+ )" ;

(

. $ 0 *.. "2#.& )" ")

(2# & 2#"

-)# ;

"&?): "

-" ;

& 7.