Raman Goyal v. State Of Punjab

  


    







!

"#$%$ &'

()()  

     

 
'

*+ ),
 ,  ,



  !"#$%&'"

 (&

   ) $## +",

----- ,  ,- )
(. ..&/$"*"0$(&

 $& # % 

) *

(&," .  )(   *

#( .$,0

$'

123&(4 ))""

0""5" 6"6)""

"#
7
38 ) 

( .$/ &"'""  5& &(& 7

2$"

$ 7
7
9(& )'&  & &(&(( '* )",. $'

32:1;# 332#  33<:3;#  317:
;  &( )""

0"  0"0"  "

"#  &. '    "$"

$) "

 (.0

5 5(&'&$" )&(

) '"'"

&, 5"

'&(4 !")""8#) "( , 5($ &"4'&*."

8& .0  /" $,0 )",&%= "$ '&*."

)/")"% 5, $".

5/

",&%=

$, $".

5#

$ &$"/.&"

(&) $& "

0&''" & )  )"#, *&

# /" (& "&( <#<9#777>=/"$ &/"$

''&$ &'&*."

#& ' )",&%=

$"''&

/

.$ &$ &$ ')"5) . ", .

0#

)"

$$&%)  "  ?6  ?"  '"  ," 5  5  "

 & 7@A=
3
1  &  ) ".& 5/ )& 5 ".B"

)"(( $"% /& $,0 )& 5 ".&/ # ".0 $0" .),)" 8  /"( )"..5$,0 )'&*."

) +&0$

)",&%=

$'"(&",& 
9=
<$"0#"

3 7

7
9"

",&

7
37

&,&$0)"$ &. ) ",&%=

$'"  /"".& $,0

)'&*."

)BB'"" ' $

)( /"'&$$ /"&,%$ "((.$("'$*& /) . 5'& $& 60 &( )'")"$ "/"0

"$$ &",&%# )'&*."

)"$".&

1 7

7
9#)' %$"'".."

",& 2 1
"

)'".."6$)  *"0 #97#777>=(& )  &('"

  )'"&( )*&' *"

&",&%=

$ 

#(&".&( ) '"/".&$5$"

*

  *  *&'  $ 5  )  '&  &(  )  *

 /" " $ <

 '"$%"

' ')""."$0, %$*& ) #

 ) $## +",#"''* '& ,)".(&(*& $

= @ '#

% '&( '*& )  ),0$ * $/ )." $ B& .)"( .$' &$0' ( '"

&(

)",

'&$ &(&".*.0)", ( .$,0 ) @&/% )." $ '& .)"&"..0&**&$

*

@"$

)'&$)", *$'"(..0

*".&('&$)&/

'"#(&..&/ 5"

).%"

("'

&/) ')"E $ &,

&'& (& "

$'  &

= ;

)&(( '   ",.,0 &($ ' "."5  "

F ;

)  "G   * )

 *' ,$  (&  )  &(( '   * &

* &70"F ;

)""."$0(($ (&"* &$ &(& (&&

)F %;

)  )   '"    "."$0  '&*. #  "

)(&#  5  )"  ,  .( &  ,  '&%$  (&  *& & &(*

F %;

)  &% $ '#& '&$ &)&/ 06 $&( (&50)", '&

$,0

F % ;

".

)&5) )""..5"

/ )( %) '.#, 0'

5"$ )( )" , %&6$,0

)

5 (( ' ) 5"$"

"%0 "

5

  / )&  "

0  "& ",.  ,"   )  '

  5"$ (&50)"%, %&6$F % ;

 ".  . 6.0 &,'& '.$$ "( F % ;

)$

&(*

 +$ ' "..&'6=*  . 6.0 %"

0(.**&F G;

)  '&$ &)&/  (."$& ," .#

  "0  "*  / )  )  % $ '  &  (. ' 

/

F G;

)  '&$ &)&/  (."$& ," .#

/ .. '&=&*"

>*" ' *"

  ".

7

'"# )* ' *.&(."/." $$&/ ,0 )@& 8,. *B& &( $ " )'"&(4"

""% &(

" "$) $"

)8#:
72;3BB

#".%"

#/) &,%$

H" ( $"

". *& ."

 &(' ". + *$ '  ) **  &(

&' '#"

),0 "*&  ,. %$ &,

&'



.(& 5 .

@&/%# )" ' &' ".."//)"%&  )", *."'$& "''$/ &&*' ( '&(( ',   )"

$$& $ "'

(& )( $"

".*& ."

 *'

&(& )&(( ' ) *&

("' &(&' ".+ *$ ' 

)5"

&(," .  )5 ".."

$*

5"*& +" .& * & & "'&'

)&:/) ')%G* & "0/ ) &;  G'*

 (& .0#&&( )," '* ' *."**" &)"% , .&  5) &(/ ).

&"

$&*& ",

$"

$(&.& 5* &$ ) $& $&"

05&&$ &&' ".

+ *$ '& &&&'  )  &$&, )5"

&$ ".&( ," . 

.0 )$ ' )+$5'&  $ 5"'", % &# G' &(+$ ' ".$ ' ' '' ,$,0"."5 ,&( $'  &  $$,0 ) B& $,0%0@ 5)B& )'&

0 # &''" & "..0 ) " ' 0

&*'

/) )$ 5," . &"

"''$*&   ) 5) &$&& "

)' ' '&( "'"I



)* ' *.." $$&/ ,0 )@& 8,. )*B& &( $ " )'"&(4"

$!"

. B

"."&(

$   )8  :
7

;  7  BB  9#  "  ".&  .%"

)   '"   ",&%

$'"# &,%$ H )"

&('& % '

' ".'"  $ " ",0"..0.&/  "**" & ) ("'

&/ 5) $&( /) .$' $ )," ."**. '"

" 5"

%   B& 6 )*& , .

0&("'& % '

, " " 0#," ."**. '"

/ ..)"% &,$' $$  '

.0#'&

"0 &.5".

* ' *. J'"

 G*'& &("," ."**. '"

#/) ') 

*

% / &("*& ,."$+$ '"

,0/"0&(  ".

'&

"0#"

.

"'E

"./ )'&

$' &$0/&.$,"'"&(5"%

+ 'I



'

.0#  )  '"  &(  4"*"  !"  ".

      &( B))"

5")8#
7
9BB .

B3

# )@& 8,.*B& &( $ "

)"&,%$ H ("

"''$  &5 "( ".%$ '

"(  &(  G &% 0" +" .""

 $  ".* & # #$(

.0# '&.$, " $ )  5) &)"%"*$0  ". $ '.
&( )B&

)", ( 5$I  )"".&, &,%$,0 )@& 8,.*B&

&( $ " )",&%

$'" H$."0","$(& )"''$"

G .0,"$(& )% '

#(& $ "

&'  0"

$(& )'$ , .

0&(& + '0 #/) ') %".$ $5" )" &( ) B& &&"

)B ". &'$B&$*&% $"

0 &&.(& )$5 &

&$ &  '"*&'$(( ' 

.0I

3

&.' $"

( )# ) B&  '& ' &&( )," '"

( $"

".* ' *.&(."/  5) &*$0  ". "*" &("& ",.# (" "

$+ *&'$ ) $ $ '.
&( )B&

&( $ "

) '&

". 5) '"

,$ )"''$""

$"

$,0

@& 8,.*G'& H"./ $ 5)% &( +","

$ )I#
7
1BB .

B1391

1

(  )  '."

%  (('

 &(  "..  )  ",&%

$  ("'

&#

%&.%$

'"# 

&'& # ."$ &"'& '. &

 

.$(& ), ( &(," .#"

*

$% &,"..&/$ 9

''&$ 5.0#/ )& '&

5"

) &( '"#

*

 ),0 // 0"

)*

 ),0&$$ ,."$& ," .& ( ) 5*& ".,& $"

$ 0,& $:; "

("'

&(."  ".B&

@&/% )",&%" $'& ' & )".., ,+'

&(&..&/ 5'& = : ;

)  *

  )"..   $ '

.0  &  $ '

.0  "6  "

$'

# )"

&*&  &"

0*& "'E"

$/ ("'

&( )'"#&" &$ "$)  &$ '.&')("'

B& & &"

0& )" )& : ;

)".."

&(G' &(,& $#( )

)"$$ '& ' $"

$)".. (0 )')"

5

"$$  ".B& # .. )( ".$'  &  ".F"

: ; 

)".. ."% $ "/ )& * &*  &

&(  ".B&

<

% /&(

'""**"

.0 ))"

, .&$5$ $*&*'

# )B&  & &( &. '# $) "

),0$ '

&.&&6

)"

"6"**&* "

$ ' *.

"0 "'

"5"

) 5&(( ' ".

,  ,

 ()()

J) )*"6 5>"& $ >& % *

J) )*& ",.

>&