Jaswant Singh Etc. v. Pb.State
! "
!! #$%
"
&$'
&
&
& ()% * "
!! #$%+"
&
$ ,
-! $-
!.
, %
/
, ! &
()% 0 , &
$
$$
-! $- ,$ -$
!.
, %
/
, ! &
- &%
! "
!! #$%
"
&
$ ,
-! $-
!.
, %+
/ &
, ! &
/ ()%
% 3 4( 51% ) /
! & 6 - - 6.
3 $ 7
- 6 !$ &
6$8
!
" # # $ % & %
" ' (
) * & )
* &
#
) ( & *
# ( " +
"
*
,)
*
& # # (
# ) # & #
* + "(
* ) # #
# "& - " .//01//2)
#
" ") # "
/!//3 ( " /!./ )" # 4
4 # (
# 34
)
* # %#
) #
# # ( #
* #
5
(6 ( # # # " & ## " #
" # # #
* #"
#
&# #
# "
7 ) ) # # # 4
4 8 & 9 # " : "
*
&
# ( 5 6#
&
) +
* # #
) & # &( " ; ( )&
;
)
3 < # )9:
.2<0<1//2
% ,
4("
'
9 !
6.
0 -,
!!
: !$% 3
6$ .
,$ !$-$- 1-
& -
'
& ,$- !& $&& & &$& % 5' 6$$
9
$ !$ 6.
!$ &
! !& !! % ++%;%
+"
* "
% ! "
!!"
6.
!$ &%
$ $"
*
$ &$'
! ,$-
&$
!&"
& 9
$ !$
--$
!! % 3 ! 4$ & & & <6$$."
"
,$
6 6$$
% 3 &
! !& $&& & $ !! % , &$-!
&.
'
$"
!
6,$
% % , &$-- & $ "
$ !
&&$-!.
$& -
,-
& &
() * "
!! #$% +"
% ! "
!! #$%
&
,$ &$-- $,,& ! 6 & $
/ ()% ! & &
- & $ ,-
* "
!! #$%+"
,$ 9!
!$ !% !! !
$
.
&
& -
% 2% ( $ !$' & "
!$& 1-
! &% 3 !$& 1-
)=+ % '
"
$
,$- 51% ) 0"
)$ & $"
! "
'
% 3 !$& , 1-
% # 7 -"
& ,, &"
'
0$!
"
$ "
)= $
&$ &
!$-$- 1-
6$ .
+% >%
+% 0 $6'
8 2 "#='!> " ?
# # ( "#
#
44# "
4#&
)4 )
# .= 72= !
@ & A" : 4 "# # " 4
"
#
& "# ( 9 #"" #" < #" 2;
) # (
4 " #
#
" # )# " # B 0 , $!
!$66 - !
6
? .
$
6
!$-$-
$ % 0 !$'
&$!.
!$-$- !$ 51% )5
!
&$
- 51% )5/+% 3 !$& , 1-
0 7 !
)="
$ '
& ,$-
% )= 3
' - $
&$-! 51% )
!!$
& !$& $% ( -$."
$
6$ "
& $
?$ "
&- $ $ ?$ 9 % = .
&
,$ $ ( "
& ?$ $ $ "
* "
-
"
-
"
% ! "
-
"
( "
-!.
%
-"
,$ &&
( .
$
$ ! ,$ & .
,-
-% * "
!! #$% +"
' 6$
!"
&
,
&"
6&9%
? ."
,
$% 3 &&
.
,$- !$ !& ' !$% 3,"
,
$!
6.
-"
&& -6
? %
( &$1- $"
$ -
$ !$ &-
- 6.
-% 0
- 6,$ !$ & .
,$ &&
,$ $ (
-
( 0$'"
&$,$
- 51% )
( 6.
-
&&
- $ % 3 (
6
,-
- & .
$.
6.
* "
!! #$% +%
% 3 !$& , 1-
)=2 $ "
$ !!$
-$.
)= 3 % 5'
&$1- $"
.
( .
$
$ $
$
6 & .
,-
-% 5'
> &&
.
,$- !$ !& ' !$ ,
? .
&
6.
* "
!! #$%+% ( &$1- $"
-
- 6,$ !$ &"
,$ &&
(
6 & .
,-
-% 3 !$& , 1-
)="
9 "
,-"
$
!!
&
! 51% )*% )=> ( * !$
(
)$ & ! +% >%
+% ++%;%
+"
"
(!&$"
$
* "
!! #$% +
! &
&$ -"
$ &$'
! ,$- ,$
$
6.
-
, % 5' ! 6$$
9
$ !$ '
--$ 51% )< &
6.
-
)= 3 % 5' $ 9& ! $ !! % )=;"
* ?
"
6 "
)5 "
! &$ 6$
>%
!%-% % >%
+"
& & .
!!.
-
'
$$ ! &$ % 3 - )=@"
<%% 7 "
)=+
0 -
)=++ <%% !
,$-
% "
(!&$"
1-
)=+ $
!$'
'
! &% 0
'
$,, &
! &"
$ !!
: !$ 51% )% : 51%)"
6$ .
6?&
!$-$- 1- $% 0 !!
$ ! 51% ) &$& -
$
6$$
-! 9
$ !$ '
51% )0
! !& !! % 0
&&
! & ++% ;%
+
$ $"
* "
$ &$'
! ,$- $$-
;
- ,$ $
&,,
- 9
$ !$ 6.
-% 0 $ !!
! !& &$'.
51% )#/+
!$
& !$!.
0% >% , &$& !$& '
&"
- !! &$
!.
& + %)%%
.
3
&$&$&
, '
.
,.
'$'
& - % (
,&"
!!
$
.
'
&% ;%
! &.
! !!"
* "
- &&
1!
'
$
;%+ %
2"
!! : - $$
6 % @% <
&$ !!
6, !! #$%
'-.
& 6
-
!! ,.
'$'
! &% ( 6 $ !! #$%
' $ -
"
"
.
-!.
$ 6 ! !& $&& &
$ 6 6
.
$ $'% ( ,&"
!! #$%
$ ' !
.
6 ,.
'$' % <
&$ , &$
' & 6
-$ )= 3
)=2 $
6$ '
&$ $&
& % )= 3 "
6$
& % 5' .
6 ,.
'$'
! &
!'
$ - .
6 ! % ( '"
&$ ,$ !! #$%
6-
$&& &
9 !& ! -$-
$.
6$
&
&
6.
*
@ "
!! #$% +"
$
.
1!
% # 6$ !
$ &&
9 ' $
&
& $ -
6"
.
&$
6 &$'
&
,$ &$-- $,,& ! 6 & ) (( ()% + % $
&$ '-.
$!!$
6- $ - 6.
&$ ,$ !! #$%
$ !! ' 6
!& , & $ 6.
)= 3
)=2 $ % 5' $& &&$
.
&$$6$
6.
-$.
)=
% # 7 -"
$
&$ &
!$-$- 1-
6$ .
& % 0 ,$
&
! &
$
,
& & &
6.
* "
!! #$% + 6.
!% , &
? "
!!
,
,$- !$% 3 "
!!
' 6
-
6.
$ % ++% = '
&$ ,$ !
!
&$
'.
&, .% + % <$$9
$ "
!! &6 !$'
$ (
) $ "
$ !
$,,& ,,&
- 6$ .
&$
! AB( (
) $ "
+; % &
@@
$,,& & !6 $- &
% ( !$'
$' &
6.
$
&
&
"
$
&
& 6$
.
? .
9.
&
"
$ 9$
9.
6.
& & &
"
&$-- $,,& & !6 $- &
% +% &
, C- C% &&$
& $"
& !6 $- &
- &
$ 6.
&
+
&
& &
$
&
% &$ ."
,
$
&
& 6$
.
? .
$,, 9$ 6 9.
&
!$ $- -
&
$ - % 3 ."
& $"
C- C
&$--
, &
$
&
6$
.
? .
6$
.
? .
6
, &
,, &
$
.
&$ &
% 4$ ."
, !$ &$--
& 9$
$
-- .
$
- "
!$66 ."
&
$ & 6$
.
? .
9.
&
"
&$-- - & &
&$--
$ .
1& ,$
&
9 &
% +% 51&! $ &
- $ & !6 $- &
$ - % 3 - -.
6 1&
6 '
&$1 ,& $6
! &"
$7 2<%
C<8
#
& # < " & & # & & " " (
&7 4 # & C< +
< & &
"
& ( "
7
( " "< & & "" # "
& # 7
#
&
++
"< & & "" # 7
& $7 <% & # & &
A $7 1<8
7
&
"7 # & "#
# 7
# # "
"
$7 .<8
&
&
&
4
7 # & "# " #
& # "
"
&# <# # # $7 <8
#
A
#
'& ( &
$7 <)
#
"
&
+
$7 =<8
# # & "
(
( # # +2% = &
! - - "
&
6$ ! - ,$ & !6 $- &
$ -$
- % 3 $,,& & ()
! 6
) (
) ((% = !$& !$'
!$
:
, &
&
6.
& &&
&&
9 & &
9.
&
"
$,,& $
6 ! 6 & ) ((% +%
& "
() $ ! -.D & ) (
& ) ((% 3
& 6 $ ) & "
()
:
6 &$
'
!$'
$ & $
@@
()% = $,,
&
$
$ &
6 $ '
& $% +>% 3 0$E6 !- $
- D 9 " 51//!6 2= 88 0=.
$6'
, 6 &
()
&
@@ ()
,$
! !$% !6 $- &
"
-
!& % 5' &$&! & !6 $- &
$ -$
- 1!
6.
0$E6 !- $ 6.
-9
,$$
$6' $8 >) 4 "
# ( #
(" #
# #
./ ) #& 4 "
+ ( # 4 "
# #
./ ))
) 4 " ("
# ) # "
( # 4 " (" # ))> +;% ( E?( & ")
- !! #$%
"
&
% @%
(
(# ;+
<* 2@ 0$F6 !- $
,$$8 2F 8 4 3 , & ")
8
3E 1/ . 1/1. 1//01/1.
7
( #
>@/ +#
#
" C 526%
# A #
&
( #
) ( ##
8526 5 6 .// )8 # & " 4 " #
CG3' G'
& & G3' G3' ( "9 #
" G' G3'# ( " 4 "# #
# 8526 .// )8
( G'( "G3'# (
+ G3'G'
"#
G3' #"G3' " 4 " G3'
#
" "
" G'
"
4 " 4 " # 4 &"
" #
G'# 85.6 .// )8
"
"
4 "# 516$&# ( #
"
# 8526 5 6 .// )8
#
# # # ( & #
' "
&7 ) & # " 7
#
# 2 ./ )8
# 8526 5.6 .// )8)#
)) ./
# 85 6 .//
)83 ( #
"
"1 .
1FF )8"
" .// )8 )
#
./ )8)#
)
# 1 1FF# #
)) ./ # .
1FF )8 5.6 #
#
#
1FF )8
./ ) #& #
+2
./ )
# "# G " '# # "
# G "( #' 5 6$& 4 "
4 "#
4 &" 4 " #
" A
8.
" .// )8
# 5=6 ./ )8# " #
C5 6#
.// & " 7 5
6# 4 "
( #
& " 7 G
" '
# ( #
" ( 4 "G (" '
8516 .// )85
6# # ( # (" #
4 " ("
"
##
./ )8
&
7 .// )8#
&
"
./
)8
# 7 .// )8 5@6 # G ("' "
G "'% &
#"" # G "')
4
+ #
( # " # (" 506 #
5 1FF
)86 5 .// )86#"
" # #
./1 )8 H " #
# 8
# #
& 7 .// )8&
&7
&
A
#
"
.// )8 ) "
.// )8"2" " # "
1FF )8 5!6 A )
8
" .//
4 "
" & "
& )& "
#
&
"&
# "
4 7 4 "
4 " (
( 5F6) ( " (
4 "
4
" (
"
4 " 4
+>
4 "
4
52/6% 4 "
"
&
#
&
4 "#
&
%
A
"
A #
5226% &
" " 4 4 "
&
4 "#
&
A " 8
" .// )8 7 5216) A #
"
"( # # "
4 "
" 4 "
" #
A
4 " 4 " #
" 4 "# "( #
# ./ )) )8> 1/
#" < &
& ./1 ./ )) &
# & ) #
"
# 4
"# ./ <)))8)
+;
# &# ( # (
(
# $&
" %<2#
#
# 7 # # #
&
:
" #"
( #"# &
# ( # & " '
##
, #"
" #
&
1<. #
( 9 " #"# & "# & # & # < - #
& "
#"# ( "# &
"#
( 5 6
7 # &( " "
#
" #
" (#"
"## &# B
+@% #$ $
!$&
1- ,& ! &
6$'
! & ! % 3 4(
! &
+@
6 - 51% ) - 6.
)= 3 % ( -"
&$-! &.
$
)=2 $
&
&
$ ( "
&&
.
% 3 !! #$% + -
! !! #$%
-
&9% 5' &&
(
"
& .
$
'$ & !$"
$ ,.
,-
-
- .
6.$
$ $ $
6.
!!% 5' !!
)= 3
-!$'
-
,$ &&
! &
( .
$
$ ! ,$ & .
,-
-% 3,"
* !! #$% +
&
? .
&
!
$.
6$
' &
& % 3,"
&&
.
,$- !$ !& ' !$% ( &$1- $"
$ -
&&
?$ .
(
(
$.
,,&
6 & .
,-
-% 4$- - - 6.
)= 3
)=2 "
$ - .
. "
$
'.
& &&
$
( & $ % ,$- - - 6.
)= 3
)=2 $ "
!! &&
$
&
!!
!&
&& % ! "
!! #$% "
.
& - $ ,$
,-
% !
'
%
% , "
$ -
,& * "
!! #$% +"
-
!"
!! #$%
-
&9% 4 "
$.
$
? .
&
6.
!! #$% + ! &
, &
? "
&&
,
,$- !$% "
' $ !! #$%
-
&9"
6 .
$ & .
? .
!$
& % , "
' !! #$% + &
? .
&
&
'
$ ! 6$% 3 "
&
,& & 6
!!
$
& -
.
-!.
& - $ ,$
,-
-
'
% 5' !!
$ &
& -"
$
6 !!$! $
!!
.
,$ &$-- $,,& ! 6 & ) (( ()%
+% #$ '
$ : - &"
!! -
? .
! & 6
* "
!! #$% +"
$ .
1!
!! : - $$
6
'
$
;%+ %
2% !! #$%
-!.
$ 6 ! -
!&
$&& &
$ $ $
-% 5' - &$'
& $"
!! #$%
6$
."
%%"
6$ ; . !% - ."
!! #$%
6$
. - &$'
&
- 6
6$
. -$-% $: ."
$
6
'
6
6$ !! #$%
6
6 % 3 $ $ &$
$
+ ,& !! #$%
, - $,, % $$'"
&
-!$
- !
.
+ ."
.
-
$$
&$ &% $: ."
9!
'
,$
-
& & -&"
&
-!$
6$ !!
$
6 &
! $
.
$ 6.
-% 0$'"
& , - -%
% 3 $ &$
!!& ,$ % 7%)%% 9"
- & "
$
6 & $ 6, !! #$%% ,
%
/"
& 6 !
6.
&."
$ < '
& $-- %
% 3 & !$!."
, ."
-.
6
! %
% 3 $ &$
6 6&9 $ %
2% !
!! & $"
, ."
!$
$,"
&&$
.%
#%%0570=3
*G 5
0%% 5=<
*G 5 +% %
- = !9 /$ 8 H5 / # = !$68 H5 / #