High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/46219/2017allowed

Harish Gulati And ANR. v. State Of Punjab Thru Insecticide Inspector

2023-08-08Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary10 pages

!" #$!%&'( &")&& & &* &"

,-./01/23435 6 6 -73489:;-.3-51-5.8/7 /.3.35/74 </74:4 =.-./0:5>-?@87:A8B54/2.3231/B54C/2.7 /4C51/5. "&DE

F'G D"H%!I &D& &!* &") 7/4/5. 7-J/48</7K--517-5348</7K-LM1N2-./4 07.8/C/.3.35/74 7-53C-;=35A8M.O-;L,M9:5>-? PPPP &D& &!* &")Q%H 7-R/7 35 .8/ C7/4/5. C/.3.35 03;/1 :51/7 =/2.35 6 0 .8/ 1/ 0 73K35-; 72/1:7/ 34 07 S:-4835A 0 2KC;-35. 4 1-./1 7/4C/2.3N/;R :51/7 =/2.354 J 3L L 6L -51 0 .8/ B54/2.3231/ M2.L 6

07 487. T.8/ M2.U .3.;/1 -4 T=.-./ N4 +4 V-35 W8-1 KC-5R -51 .8/74U -51 4:KK535A 71/7 1-./1 L M55/X:7/ L C-44/1 ?R ;/-75/1 =:? ,3N3435-;V:1323-;-A34.7-./L,8:73L,34.732.=-5A7:7 @8/ 0-2.:-; K-.73X 0 .8/ 2-4/ 34 .8-. .8/ 2KC;-35-5.B54/2.3231/ B54C/2.7 17/O - 4-KC;/ 07K -5 73A35-;;R 4/-;/1 C-2J/. 5

L 0 5/ 354/2.3231/ 3/ -7.-C R1728;731/ Y 9L Z-.28

L 07K .8/ C7/K34/4 0 +4 V-35 W8-1 KC-5RL ,8:73 K-5:0-2.:7/1 35 .8/ K5.8 0 -728L ?R +4 MA732

7A-5324 [.1L ,/;83L O3.8 -5 /XC37R 0 .O R/-74 B. O-4 4/5. 07 ./4.35A -51 .8/ 7/C7. 0 .8/ 0374. 4-KC;/ O-4 7/2/3N/1L 1/2;-735A 3. . ?/ K34?7-51/1 @8/ 4-KC;/ -07/4-31 O-4 0:51 K34?7-51/1 5 8-N35A ?//5

! "# $"" &'"

(&"

) * +"+!, *-# .#+

)+ "& .+ 0- " 12

&" 0 2, / +3+" " "#+0"+, "# +0++4 3+" 0 "# & 34 .& & " " "+4 &'"

* +"+!, 5+ , -3 .# '# '"

)+ "& .+ 0- " 2 6 &#. '-&

' .&

&&- " "# 3"

+& 4

) "

) 0 "# ' 34

" " ,

-+ .& 4 &-

) ++ .& 3&& / ++0/ ",6

-+, !"#4+ (+ 4-+" *+ '- &4 0+ "# 3"

+& &-

"& "#" "# ' 34

& ++ !

& 3+ $'"

7 +,

" .& 4 0"+ 1 !+& 44!, "# 3"

+& + 4! "# +'"+ 9.

'#+) "#-&, +

+ "# +&3 4 3+& & 0+ &-+

) "# :-4 "! 0 "# 3+-'"& (#+0+, "#! +

" 4 " 3+&'-" & 3+ $'"

0 "# 6'" 0+ "# 3+-'" 0- "

& + 5-+"#+, # &-

"& "#" "#+ +

&3'

' /+ "&

"# ' 34

" .

"# +)+ " "#

) +&3 4 0+ "# !"! ' -'" 0 "# -&

&&, "#+0+,

"! ' 0&" "# 4 '

& 34' ;<=<> ?@AB CD E>FGHI JKL M=NHJ OGPQ=R=S

$ , ;G>Q ;HRTG =RU =RC<G>Q JKL ;<=<> CD VPRN=WS

1 7 '

1 AG>XHRCJ= YRUH= Z<UL JKL ;<=<> CD VPRN=WS

7 $ 77 *+ $"" '- &4 "# "#+ # ' " & "#" "# 4!

) "# ' 34

" .& '-& & &

.& ' &-

) 33+/4 ! "# & '"

) -"#+ "!, & &-'# "# & 3+ '4- 334 '"

0+ ' "

0 "# & .& 4& 4 "# & +)+, /+ -& +

+& .+ 4& & " ! "# 83+"

" &-

"& "#" 44 "# 3"

! "##$

!# $ %#

" # "# '#()#* "# $

#'&$'

" # + #!!($)(+#")'

$#'' , -$

#") * # $# ()$'# + # &#

$# ' ''# ' #

) &''# # ')..$ $ # '* ) # "# $ $! && ( $ '##/ $ ($$ $ + # ! 0# ()'# + ( $ + # (.& $ '# $ #

#(# & + # +

#& + # &)"

( $ !'* % ( %'

* %# #' # (.& $'"##$+ #$ 1 # # # $#()$'# + #&

#'$&# )'##+ #'

- "# &&'

#+# #

# #2$ 2 $' + % + 3) ( $+#.# *% ( #)' 4567189:;<;9=>?@A<@?>B9?AC9D;C:E9FGC<D;HCFC:><I<D E>J>;9;><?1

KL(#&'# '#& 2 ## '#%# # $ '#* $) ' /#( $ M$(#+$++#$(#+# (# !'&#( + # $')"'#( $ *+# ##L&

!+ #&#

+ .

0#&#

+ .

$' "#

L.$'* +#++#$(# '&)$ '" #% + $#$ !

" $# !# *

+ # ++#$(#

' &)$ '" #

'$.#$+ # .$#L(## $ $#!# N

( ## !# '*

+ # ++#$(#

' &)$ '" #

'$.#$ + # . #L(## $ $# !# ") $ #L(## $ ##!# '

O # &) &'#' + ' '#( $* # &#

# $ ++#$(#' % ( .! "#

# ## * ' "# ## .

#+# #$(# # ++#$(# % (

' &)$ '" # # . '#2# &)$ '.#$ * ' # ('# .! "#* # .''#2# #&)$ '.#$P 56Q1R<JJC?ACJC?;<D;HCFC:><I<DE>J>;9;><?1

0# &#

# $ $ ++#$# * ' (..#$(#*

$##+#++#$(#N

" %# # (..

$ + # ++#$(# %' $ /$%$ # &# '$

#2# "! # ++#$(# $! & (# ++ (# * # +

' ! $ % ( ')( ++#$(# (.#' # /$% # + ')( &# '$ $! & (# ++ (# *

$ %$ &%% '( ) $ **

))$$ +, $ * $ +!( % $ + %$$( * $ ** %+ &%% $ $ - % !..

+ '( $ **

$ $ -"

)!&%. %

$.!$%%$$ **

)-0$%. $ !+ - +, $ +!( *) - + $'

)-0$ + !""'

"0+ + 23456789:;<=>=?@<AB<>8BC@D<>8D;B;5

)-0$%. $ - + * ")$!$%, $ $) +0%. !%( - % !

% -

0$%. $ +0 +".

!%$ -

0$%, $ % ! 0$ * * $ % $!%

% ! 0$ * !-- !"

%, !.!% $ $ ** %+ , !""

"0+ + + + $!$ %

"0 % !"" )!+ 0%"

$ -

0$%

"!$ $ $ !) *!

$ E !%+ -

0$ + % .+ *!$ % ! 0$ *) + *

$ * F0 + $% $

!0 *!"& %!$0 , 0%!'"

$ %$ $!%$

$ % $$0$% * $ -

0$% %

$ * !% **

% $!( + '( !% %F0% $% + , $ %, %

)-0$%. $ - + * ")$!$%, $ - + * $

%$%0!%

* $ %F0% $% + , $ +!( % $ ! 0 + )!+ , !%+ $ +!( % $ ! $+!%, !"" "0+ +

* -

0$% * !% **

% .

, 0%+ !%( "! * $ $) %. % *

, $ -

% %$ !% $% * $ H

%) %$ !%( $ !0$$(

I0 + * $ % $$0$% * !%( -

0$% * !% **

, $ %, %

)-0$%. $ - + * ")$!$%, $ - + * %$

, ! $

)!( , $ $)

I0 + *'$!%%. 0 % %$ !% $% !""'

"0+ + J1-"!%!$% /%

)-0$%. $ $)

I0 + * '$!%%. $

% %$ !% $% * $ H

%) %$ !%( $ !0$$(, $ +!$ % $ !--" !$% ! )!+ * '$!%%. $

% %$ !% $% !%+ $ +!$ *

-$ * $ + * $ H

%) %$$ !0$$( !""'$'

"0+ +

)-0$%. $ - + * ")$!$%, $ $) +0%. $ ** %+

! !

% !'

%$ *) /%+! *) !%( $ $( 0$ + /%+! 0%+ $ !+)% $!$% * $ %$!"H

%) %$,

' ! !

+ + !

$ '( !'

%+%.

!"%. ) "*, !""'

"0+ + KB8@<=>LMNOPN<P=?@QBR>;B8@<8<SB;T8@CBDS; @Q:;U V * $ * $ **

, $ )- %) %$ * ! $ ) )!(

1$ %+ $ $ ( ! , $ *% !"" %$ $!% $ % $0 !%+ 0-

'0$ )!(

1$ %+ $ **$(

"## $ ! %& '( )*

& +! # +&!

++#)#$ %& &,"!& ,# +!

#!, %&) , - #.# % -# !

$ ! %& +&# %&)

// '# /#

"## %&), -#.# +&+-

"## $!%&'(0 1 2 , &+#

&)# # ,# "!# )!&'# +! # ++#)#

#! 3#)& + # #)&)& # 4) % -# !

$ # "#!& +! 5&6 )6&7 )#

#8&

6# #!3#)&1!& !##-# !

2 % / '# "#!&# ,#& #!# %& !#6 !

""/&) & +! ) & + #/ -$

'8#$ %#!# & #

,,&6 ! #!

# $ 4#.

!# + # !& / !$ &

'## )

)

""/&) &

+&/# ! #/ -

) # !#8#!$

"#! # ! #!

# 1 1 1 + & !$ /# !# 3 #

',&# !

)& +!, !

%& #! 3&6$ #)&)& # "#)!$

""/&) &

#! 3#)& + # :&,& & 4)$

##5&6 ) & + #/ - '## +&/# #

'##"/ )# !#)! ;#

& ! #!!#

:# !# 3 #

#/ !

)& +!, !

%& #! 3&6$ #)&)& # "#)!$

# & $ %&/# +&/&6 # ),"/ &

#! #)&)& # 4)

#)&)& # /# $ # ),"/ &

+&/#

""/&) &

#! 3#)& + # :&,& & 4)$

##5&6 ) & + #/ - %#8#!$ /# !# )

#/ +! # "#&&#!

# & &+!, &$ #!#

)

""/&) & 2% / '# "!#+#!#!#/#8 # $%&) !#

<=>?@ABC=>DEFGHGI?D J=?G "#)&+"!#,& #

K&!

,"/# #

#"!+;# &6

!" # $ !%#&' #( )

* +, #&% #( ---- .% #& #(

#(#,#( & !"( # /# 0,"

1 )( &," # %&% # #2 3, ) ( #2 & 456789:;< =9>8< ?878@6>

,!% 02%( 1" '2 ,!% ,%# 2"

#2#B CD2 (# ( "% &% #2 ),) & #( B % #2# #2 !%( & "( (##(

2"" #2

# & && B #2% (

% #

E !,##( & "( (##( "F &% #2

# & %(!# & %!%# & #2 #%" /

#(( ' #( ) G1%#%FB H%( I !% #2 !% ,% !% %(1 ,

% #2 ##,#B (B /

#(( I#B $

#2 %,"

#2%,

%B #2 /

#(( ' #( ) G1%#%FB G, 2( #2 !# ,#2%(#F # 02(2 #2

# B &#%

%0( ) B

#2 %!%# &

"F ( %(J B

,2 #2

( %"IKG %" &

# (

( # 1 #2 %,("

# &% & !%( & "( (##( LF J(%#, & #2

( %!%# %(J 02(2

## #2# #2 #(J ( )% ( & #2

!" "F # #2 M#

)(

#2 "1""

"%#( & NB (# ( "% #2# (# ( #2

# & && "") "F (## 1F #2 , %"F 1, &,%#2% %+, (

( ) #2

!" # #2 #%" /

#(( ' #( ) G1%#%FB

# !"# ,

% #( & #2 I#B 02(2 %!%# %(J

B %(!# &

"F ( %!%#

# 1 #2 ( &% & "( (##( '2 %!%# &

" # $% &' ( !& !

# ) * +,& - +.#'

# !&

,# *-

&& #

&' !%/ &- &'.

- &' / # $ && &'

&' % * $ 1 !& - !%% !

$% 2 )'

34546787 9:;<4 7=6 7=><:;8 ?@A B<7<; >C DE=F7G -

HH- 0'

% 0'&

$!& & &'& $ &' ! & '#- &' 0 . I/ #

# & #

&' $ * $ &' !%/ &- ' # &'&- J"

* ' # &' # !. $ &' /&

- &'

.& $ # # K.&

., &!

&' *.% &

, # !. $ &' / & L , / .

$ &' $!& $ &' ! !#

'0 &'& &' /& $ &' M" % & L

& '# , !

" # , &' !%/ &

N" &'

!& $ / !.& - &'.*' // & , & # - 0 !

" #

$ ! / &' %#& $ 1 !& H $ O # P.#*% & $ 1./ % .&

&' ! $ 1&& $ P &' 1./ !%/ &

&' / & ! !.# '" , $ #- & &' , &- &'

/ # $

$% &' #& $ !

/& $ /& $ &' M" % & L

& 0 " - &' !%/ & ' , $ # $&

$% &'

#& ! - &' !%/ &

&' / &!

& % , #2 )'

Q:7?;@: B:7: ?@A B<7<; >C DE=F7G - H # !

# #

K. ' # &' !%/ & , * % , #

& '# , $ # H $% &' #& $ &' /& $ &'

%/ 0 $

& ,& # , " I!.# * &' / # $%

R H & H-! .% #&* & !&

$%&%

% ( )*&

) *

%+%( )

)%*!

! &,$ * ,* %

" -.$"

+ $ ,!

/# -

* !#

&,$ % - ! %!

, *%"

% ! % %( + %$ '$ %

&,$ % *

* ,$2

3$."

.!#

&,$ % %!$% '$ ) $$'

%((*!!$2 %& ' ** " / %! .* %

! ) 456758 9:;<5 56= ><?@AB CBD 4<5<@ >E F:675G / %"

" # HIBD JA>; J?@KLM5NB O6=L5 P<=D CD 4<5<@ >E F:675GQ /// %"

" # HIB R6LS:@ T5AK UL= FC<D P<= CD 4<5<@ VE F:675G %"

" " 456=@@; 9>85N 56= ><?@AB CBD 4<5<@ >E F:675G % / %"

/ # W. !

&,$ % ! %(

%& ' ** "# )%$ " 2"

, *%" ) $%&%

% )

* $ + , * ! ) 4567589:;<556=><?@AB

!.,* #* "

.! X Y+ %

,* !

"%(!#

.( ))%" +%

)%$ " '2

%%"

- + *#

3,$ %# -

! + *#

(%+ )*

.( $ 2 ) '.

*!#

& 1 $ &

3.!

& 1

,,* % , * )

$ 2

) Z(*%.$ .*

))% *# [ (*.*# - %!

W. $$2 $% '$ )*

%! % % "

$ 2 % )%$%(

&,$ % %! .* " ! )%"

3,$ % ).*%!

+ -# '2

%%"

*# 2-

* *

%( !

%!) *2

&,$ % )%$ " ( %!

% *!%!

$" '

%& ' ** " 33 33 33 +% - )

'+ ) ! " %*.&!

%! .* )%"!

%% % " %.

% ) &,$ % "

"%(! ( %!

% *!# * $ ( $$2 \.!

%)% " " !.!

% '$ ] .!

)

$ 2 .!

" '2

&,$ %

,* !

"%(!

+ * !.$

" % &%!.!

)

,* !! ) $ - " % )

"! ) \.!

% *! &* , !.'\

"%(! )

&,$ % Z*"%($2

&,$ % " !

"%(! *%!%(

* )*&#"

*+ '

W. !

! "# $%" '()*+ (*

, , !(# - ,.

(* / ,$

$! 1*#

, .* ! , )*1$ +, **, . - 2( ,03' 456789:;5; <= >?@5 A6= BC5CD ?E F=G= H '

$I,$' J ( ! " )*-, " + /

*-*$0 2(!.+$ - K5@L5CL:5M N5:M@ A6= BC5CD ?E O8P5@5CQ

' H *,$ $%" '()*+ (*H , R)($!,$. ,!

$! ) $,(! )* - ,.

(* "

*1!

S'0,$ T * )* *1 ,$ *$ )* )*1$

"( - )*0

$# 0(* *

0(* $!

- 2( ,0 )*1, ,$ ! $ 0$-* $ )* $ # *0.$,

$! )* *1 )* ,0 ,$ * ,$ ,.

(* U V(* *H ,$ W57D6: X:5YZ@5 A6= BC5CD ?E [=K= H '

$I,$'H$%" & '()*+(* ! ( \ ] , (*

$ 00

,$ 0$ ,!*

+",

0) - )* - ,.

(* ($!* '0,$ T * -* ^(

,$. - 0*,+,$ )*0!,$.

,$ >MYDDC _875@ A= BC5CD ?E [CC5@ K@5ZD6: !0,!! $ *0 H + # " ( -( *-* ) *

$! -

"1 2(!.+$ * - ,$.

! S ` aab` c-* $* ,$ - 0 - )* $

, , $0

*# 0$ ,!*

+",

0) - 2(*, !,0,$ ($!* '0,$ T * ! ,$ ,.

(* '0,$ T *

,$ *$ )* - ,.

(* + /

(0 *!*

+ " $0

*# .,1 --0

$# *!* ($!* , !H * )*1$

"( - )*0

$# 0(* * *, 0(* $!

-2( ,0 ` b` , (* ,+

R +,$!

0) - 2(*, !,0,$ - ,.

(* ($!* '0,$ T *

,! !$

1* )*,$0,) ,0 .1*$ R*0, - 2(*, !,0,$ - ,.

(* ($!* '0,$ T * d *e(!. c$0 - , (* ,$ BC5CD ?E _5@Y5C595 A6= f= g8YM6h57i H

(* , $, ! ^(

)*0!,$. ,- , 0+ 0$0 ( ,$

,$. )*0!,$. 0$,$( ( ! "

"( - )*0

- (* *

- 2( ,0 *^(,*

! "# # $ %!&'"

( &&

) #"

+ #, #"

)--.

"&'$

'#&#

/ 120 3 ( #"

) #"

' ."- '+ .

, #"

" !#

# #-

# %!&'" &

)

+ ' # #"

-!'

#"&# &--.

# # !

.!- $ & &$!'

) #"

'' ) #"

!# #"&# #"

' ) *!'# %!

#"&# #"

! "# # $ %!&'"

'&6 ) #"

" !#7 '

', $#"

- + &- +&## ',

# &"

& '&-!#&8 !$- !'

' #"&# & !#

! "# # # $ + ##

# & .

& ) "&&''+ '

!# ( & + &- &'

, #"

$* # $

& -&+ '

!# , #"

8 &#! ) #"

+&# &- ."

" #"

'#!#! ) #"

!# '#' #"

- .!- *!'# )8 #"

" !#

%!&'"

# '# ) *!'# 5"

' ) *!'# & #"& #"

' ) + -&. #"! " *!'# "&' # # $ +

# -&.' +&

$8 #"

'-&#! 5"

+ --

#8 ) +&9 #"

6&# '

' #"&# .

#"!# & &- '&# ) #"

$* # !'

) #"

6 ."

9' # '&6 #"

# .

' ) #"

" !# #

*!'# , $ #.

:#&#

#' '!$* #',

.!- $

+''

$- # & &# #"

#" #!')#"&#'&-

#*!

# ; < (

. ) #"

)

'!''

, #"

' !#

' ) #"

#"&# #"

# !&# ) #"

+-&

'# '"&-- '!-#

&$!'

) #"

'' ) #"

!# #"!', #"

# # '

6 # $ & $8 &--.

+-&

, # #-

&' = :#&# 6' >' ?& @"& +&8 #"

4! &' .

-- &' #"

'!++

4! & %!&'"

%!&#"

# # ' A"#8)#"

$ -&

) - )#"

BCDCEFGCHIGCJKL MHINO PQRPQRSPST U2UVWXYWZ[\X]0 ^"

' &9 > &'

_ '> ^"

#&$- _ '>