High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1370/2023disposed of

Khushal Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another

2026-02-24Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

$ (" $# (" $# (" $# (" $# 0:5 0:5 0:5 0:5$# $# $# $#5 5 5 501 A 1 A 1 A 1 A 3 .''$!

.''$!

55 5 5 5> DD DD DD DD// 22(!"

// 22(!"

/$!, !"

(;'2(+/"(),-$.(" "% (// 22(!" &%'!(%('!))(*(!

!( +&%' (!(),-$.(" #$ ('!'),-$.(" /$!, !"$0 BBBB )1 (23 )1 (23 )1 (23 )1 (23 $ $ $ $0456 04567 $#50 $#50 $#50 $#50 * 8(*$#/ !"(//2'.("'$!)/( (* %(& !;(, #$.$!,$!

!'!= "% , 2(*$#99 9:,(*'!#'2'!="% / !"(// (2 $"

"'. $#"% (//2'.("'$!8('+ , ,"$"% /$!, !"$!545 50) %$8 - !$ /2 2*%(& !#'2 , $!

!. , ,2*)"% $"% ';'2(2*'"

"+(" ,2(!,$8! / "('!'!="$ (; (.<+''"'$ ! /$. ,'!= %(- (2 (,* & ! % 2, !"'"2 , #$ "% !%(!

(;$+!" $# .$;

;/ !("'$! / "('!'!= "$ "% 2( (!, '"+(" , '! - !+ "(" ' -'22(= (28(2) (,&("$>) %'2(!,' "'." (',(&(,1!$8 (28(23(2$ $!= 8'"%$2("'+;(!

!,$"% "("+"$*& ! #'")'!- -' 8$#C+,=; !",(" ,545 5: /( , &* "% $!?&2 / @ $+" '! '-'2 '-'2 '-'2 '-'2 // (2 $64> // (2 $64> // (2 $64> // (2 $64>7646 $# 5 646 $# 5 646 $# 5 646 $# 5 5: 5: 5: 5: 1(''!=$+"$# 1(''!=$+"$# 1(''!=$+"$# 1(''!=$+"$# 1'-'23$50:

1'-'23$50:

1'-'23$50:755$# 55$# 55$# 55$# #5>3 #5>3 #5>3 #5>3"'"2 ,E (!-'F(2+(( (!-'F(2+(( (!-'F(2+(( (!-'F(2+(( (!, (!, (!, (!, "."( "."( "."( "."( (" $#(*(!(A (" $#(*(!(A (" $#(*(!(A (" $#(*(!(A

( ,"% +/$!(!,(//2*'!="% / /'!.'/2 $#/('"*)& ', =(!"

"$# C+"(!,#('.$;

;/ !("'$!)"% 2(!,$8! K(// /2'.(!"& '!=';'2(2*'"+(" , ( !"'"2 , #$ =( (!" $# ';'2( (;$+!" $# .$;

;/ !("'$!) %$8 - ) 8'"%$+" ( (!* /(*; !" $# '!"

" #$ "% / '$, $# , 2(* '!

! #2'!= "% / !" (// (2 ! "

"%' =(, 2'(!. .

.(!& /2(. ,+/$!"% , .''$!

!$#$!?&2 +/ ; $+"'!.

.( $#G'!=(//(% G'!=(//(% G'!=(//(% G'!=(//(% %$"(//( %$"(//( %$"(//( %$"(//(!=(,'1 (,3"%$+=% !=(,'1 (,3"%$+=% !=(,'1 (,3"%$+=% !=(,'1 (,3"%$+=% % % % % / .'(2(!,.<+''"

/ .'(2(!,.<+''"

'"'$! '"'$! '"'$! '"'$! ##'

##'

##'. (!,!$ . (!,!$ . (!,!$ . (!,!$ $"% H $"% H $"% H $"% H /$" ,(G55163 55163 55163 55163 966 966 966 966H(!,"% 2(" " @/$'"'$!

!$# 2(8 2(', ,$8! '! $%( '!=% 1 (,3 %$+=

$%( '!=% 1 (,3 %$+=

$%( '!=% 1 (,3 %$+= +=% A +=% A +=% A +=% A "(" $#

"(" $#

""(

(, % $22 ."

"$ A "$ A "$ A "$ A /$" , ( G50 50 50 50 56H 56H 56H 56H 8% &*) , 2(* $# # * ( (!, 090 ,(* 8( .$!,$! , "$ (..$, , /('"* & "8 ! ';'2(2* /2( 2(!,$8! (2& '"!$'!" "8((8(, ,#$, , 2(* ,/ '$,% 2 -(!"/$"

"'$! "% $#' @"(.

." ,% +!, 7 G (-'!=% (,2 (! , !'$ $+! 2#$"% /("' (!,$!/ + +(2 $# "

"% ;(" '(2 /2(. , $! .$,) 8 ( ("'#' , "%(" "% (// 22(!" ( !"'

"'"2 ,"$ I/('"*8'"%"% '.$7- -'22(= '!"% =(!"$#.$;/ !("

("'$! #$ "% ' (.<+' , 2(!, %' $+" %( .$!'" !"2* % 2, '! ( .(" !( ( $# , .

.''$!"%(""% '!$,'!(" , 2(*'!# #'2'!=(// (2'!.$;/ !("$*;(""

" ) / );(*!$"& #("(2("% '=%"( (!, <+'"' & "8 !"% /("' .(!

!& 8 2 22 &(2(!. , &* , !*'!= "% "("+"$ "$* & ! #'") +.% ( '!" " #$ , 2( 2(* , / '$, J ( "%+ $# "% .$!', , $/'!'$! "%(" "% , 2(* * '! #'2'!

'!="% #'"(// (213.$+2,& .$!, ,$! ,+&C .""$"% .$!,'"'$!"%(" " "% (// / 22(!" 8$+2, !$" & !"'"2 , "$ !+ +!,+ & ! #'" #$ "% , 2(* (* , / '

'$, J =(!" +.% '!,+2= !. '!

'! "% (// 22(!"

#(-$+ (2$ #$ ( ($!"%("(&(".%$##'"(// (2(" "% '!"(!. $#$"% 2(!,$8! 8 8( "'22 22/ !,'!=.$!', ("'$!& #$ "% '=%$+"22"%(""% '=%$ $+" $+= =%" "$ %(- ;/%("'.(22* , !' , "

"$ "% 2(" 7.$; 8( "% & ! #'"

'" $# '!"

" '!.2+,'!= $! "% $2("'+;) + +!, ."'$! 0 $# "% ." #$ / '

'$,#$;"% ,(" $#/('!=$#"% (8(,&*"% # !. $+""'22 2 "% #'2'!

'!=$#"% #'"(// (2H

!- -' 8$#"% ,'.+'$!;(, % '!(&$- (8 22(.$!" !"$# (//2'.("'$!)"% (; '(22$8 ,(!,, 2(*$#9 99:,(*'!#'2'!="% / !"(// / (2 '% &*.$!,$!

! ,

$0:5 0:5 0:5 0:5$ $## $##5 5 5 501 A 1 A 1 A 1 A 3 LM * 8(*$#/ !"(// (2).%(22 != = %(& !2(',"$"% 8(,,( (" , >5050 /( , &* "% 2 (! , ,,2 '"

"'." +,= ) (28(27.+;7 # !

!. $+"8% &*

# !. "'"'$!+!, ."'$ $!4$#"% (!,.<+''"'$! .") 46/ # , (""% '!"(!. $#(// 22(!"K2(!

!,$8! 8(/("2*(22$8 ,8% %'2 (8(,'!="% ;.

.$;/ !("'$!F )4)06>K7 / (. (2$!=8'"%$"% "("+"

"$* & ! #'"K'!" " '!"% '#(-$+ LM ( (! , .$+! 2 #$ "% /("' ( (, ', ; "%(" +!, ';

;'2( .'.+;"(!. ( (!, / "('!'!= "$ "% 2(!, #$;

;'!= /(" $# "% (; (.<+''"

"'$! 8'"%'!"% - !

!+ "(" $#-'22(= (28(2)( (,&("$>) %'2(!,'"

"'."

(',(&(,1!$8

(28(23)"% ;(I "-(2+ "(!, ,'!. ( ,"$ >5K7/ <+ +( *(,&*"%'$!

!?&2 / @$+"-', C+,=; !" ,(" ,545: !, ,'! '-'2 '-'2 '-'2 '-'2 // (2$64 // (2$64 // (2$64 // (2$64 4> 4> 4> 4>7646$#5:1(''!=$+"

646$#5:1(''!=$+"

646$#5:1(''!=$+"$ $# 1'-'23$50:

$# 1'-'23$50:

$# 1'-'23$50:755 55 55 55 5$# 5$# 5$# 5$# 5>3 5>3 5>3 5>3"'"2 ,E ( ( ( ( (!-'F(2+((!, ". (!-'F(2+((!, ". (!-'F(2+((!, ". (!-'F(2+((!, ". "(" $#(*(!(A "(" $#(*(!(A "(" $#(*(!(A "(" $#(*(!(A (!,"% %+) "% (// 22(!"K2( (!,$8! ( !"'"2 ,#$"% ';

;'2(& ! #'" L0M ..

.$,'!=2*) "% / !" (// (2 ' ,'/$ , $# '! " ; $# (#$ ; !"'$! , , .''$!' (!-'F(2+((

(!-'F(2+((

(!-'F(2+(( (!, ". (!, ". (!, ". (!, ".????.( 1+/(3(!, (// 22(!" ( % % 2, !"'"2 , #$ ';'2( (;$+ +!" $# .$;/ !("'$! ( %( & ! (8(, ,"$$"% ';'2(2* '"+(" ,2(!,$8! ) (2$!= 8'"%(22"("+"$* & !

#'" (!,'!" "(-('

'2(&2 +!, "% (; !, ,/$-''

'$!$#(!,.<+''"'$!.")4 46 ( (//2'.(&2 "

"$ "% / !" (.<+''"'$! '!.

.2+,'!= "% '!" " $! $2("'+ +;

$8 - ) "% (// 22(!" %(22 !$" & !"'"2 2 , "$ '!" " $! "% !%(!

.$;/ !("'$!#$ $"% / '$,$#, 2(*'!#'2'!="% (// (2' 99:,(* LM

!,'!=(//2'.("'$!13)'#(!*%(22 (2$"(!,,'/$ ,$#

&+(*

&+(* )5 )5 )5 )5 "'I 1 1 1 1 > 3 3 3 3 J% J% % "% / (I'!=K ($! , % "% /$"(&2 K$ K$