High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47205/2018allowed

Kapil Dev Aggarwal v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2018-11-02Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh6 pages

!""#$

%&# '#( ) * +,"#+ %

&# # &(-./#!, $+ # '0+ 1.!, 2 # 3+4.!, , # 3 / /+".!, #+ #

# !5 (5#67.!,, & & .) * .+,"#+

# 8 / /+4+$.!, $+ # '/+".!, #+5 99999

-7$7"+ .+ #4"# # #"#,"+5 ,:;8 <

,,= =

(,#/ >.

-;,&,.> & /#./# .+,"#+

*+:;$,",+ /+51.$+#+0 ",++$##5 75,?&#5(5!# ;#+ & "

, + + , 5 7 +, +#, # +##,!(57!41, !""#$?? -

!""#$ /, !""#$+,0#,(,+5

07&#5,#/"+/+".+##,!( ;",+0 +#+7#

$(,,07!41, # #

75@#5( < .

?$5,(

# + 5 *+0+ #+7#

$ (,, 07 !""#$ , $ ", 07 !4 1. $+#

# #@#5(

.=.

=?+,05, ;", +&#5,#/"+/+",+5 7+++,+4,+ 04(.@(,++5 7$0#A(#,

7 + @ # + # 5, + 0+ , A(7+5 7###,+#A(5(+(

!""#$ 7+@07+5 &#5,# /"+/+"",+ +$5 ,4$,"5# , "+ 75?, +@$++;5*@ #5 ,+,# #,++5# +57# A(+,0 ,5 07+;5*@ #5 ; ",++5 7+,, ,5(.

. ?#5 55+( !""#$ 7+5@ 0++5 ;",+(0A(7$+++(0, 5( (,"+##, #,#5;5 *@ #5.$# ,++#,5@+,0

,,++4$,"5# A(.$+++,0 +$+5 707&#5,#/"+/+"$##", ;+( ",+&#5,#/"+/+" $+!41, !""#$+, 7,#(,$++5 7$$++;5 *@ #5

8+ $(,/ *+#,/(, 07#,(#+5

*+#,(#+ #+(05,+++70 5 ,+ #,++ #:;+0",", 07 #.$+$5 ,"+55(++, 5 /+51$"###+5 $++:;$,",++,#,7#",#5##+ 7

;+(#+#0(05,++ #0"

#+,, ,+5 7 +5, 07+;5*@ #5,+$+ "+,+5+ #@07+#,70 , *+#,(.+ @.+###,#/+5(.

>!@(#& , & . (,# $++ + # @ 07 +, 0 , 5

;+0(05,++#,5 $, $++ +.$++$,(7A(#,,$(,0 *+#,(+@+,#$++ (#;A(#7# #+&!@(#&.0,(,#

# "+;#5!.$+#+,0# #,+ ( #+##,.+#@+ 0(,0 , ,+,0#55,,++5 0,, ;+ +(0(05,++#5(",7((# ,07+

#,+#(,,, ,$+;5*@ #5.

0,05,(,++#(5.+

#,# +

++#+,.+#,/(,07#,(# +(05,++55", ,5 ,+7#

.$+, +5 7+ "

,+("5(+ #$#, 755@.+5 $ , , , $ ((# , 07 + # , #", 4$,"5# $#+$+5 707+ #, +(, *+#,(+(#+#(05,+ . #".75($, ,$++;5*@ #507 + #.+5$, ,07+ #7#+ #,A(#"+5#,++,(0A(, @ $(,$+(+(,#/ >,

;,& ,. > 55, 07 + #. 5# #(#7. $+ +

#+, # ##,#",4$,"5# *+#, (+(#+# ,(++##+#+#" + #.$+++$+++0(,#,5,. (+.,,# +0 *+#,/( +(05,++4$,"5# #70 # #,.+##.#"#0+ #5,(

;+ ,#,# (05,,#,0#+(# !#"#, ++#,/(++##+# ,"

"+ #.+0 ,(07+#,(#+

#+$+# :;8 <,,<

(? >.

> . >. . =.

-;&.& / /# .+,"#+, :;8 > ,,<

>(?

. > . >. .

-;&.& / /# .+,"#+$#"#"#,+/B71.+(0,

+5 + #.$+#+ #+#,7 0"#,0 ;+0(05,++, (0$+ $#,+#+,#+5 7$+#+ #0"

,5#7(+++ ## +##,!(+,0+#,07+5 7.,(#"+(# $++++,+"+"+,"###"(#(+5 7, +"+(,+5 7$++ ,#+## /B71, /+51 *++#,,+ 0 ,",+$+#+ #0

;, (,++#5(.

. ?,, , $++;5*@ #5+("++5$, ,+ 7#

>. 5(+#+5$,(0, ,,(#"+ # 57#

, +++ 5 7+, ,+,5( #5(+##

-#"5,+(, (,++5(A(#,7 ,, ,$++;5*@ #5,+,,+ (5

# #+5#$(,0+,#(5 +5(+ #,+,, $++;5 *@ #5.$++5#00+,#5,(5#7 ##,,#$++.57 .(,##"$##, +,$(,00#(#5+##,+04,##, 5,;5*@ #5 *+/(+ #",4$,"5# 70# #,+#("+(, ##"0 , $7#(5 ,7 *+ .(+. ,,

+ #.+ +##.+0#,0(0B + (#+" # 0, , (#7 0, + !##"?; "" # 3$ #. + # + B ",$+,( ,,+ #$++ ; ""#,+0,07+, # ,, (,#/ < # &

;+$ #5,#++0# 5,0 +0 40@ #5#+5

*+ , ,#,"7

!"#$%&!#$'(#))*

4B %'& C++# 4"?#, D?8 C++# #0 D?8