Raj Pal Singh v. Sukhdev Singh

  




!"#"

$"

%"

""   




!"#"

$"

%"

""   




!"#"

$"

%"

""   




!"#"

$"

%"

""
"

$ "


"

$ "


"

$ "


"

$ "



$&'( $(  )* $&'( $(  )* $&'( $(  )* $&'( $(  )*  +   +   +   +

&,-&.)/0&)1 '0(    2(3 .3401(5.)/0  .  $ 

6

6

6

6

&,-&.)/0&)1 '0(    2(3 !&/.)/0  .  $  
 







 .7)1(.)/0&)1 '0(    2(3 .'&'(  3),&8&)1&) '0(  .  $ 
 "* 9#: .!

.
:." ::

 "* 9#: .!

.
:." ::

 "* 9#: .!

.
:." ::

 "* 9#: .!

.
:." ::

(()'*0&

;&<"15 &'(< '0(-('' )()


< &)1


6  

&5=&'03&<"15 &'(< '0(-('' )( )


 

 ..
0&310&;<$"

< 3),&8)




 2=.&)10<"15 &'(< '0((- )1()')


&)1


6  :." ::<! :." ::<! :." ::<! :." ::<!&


6  +


6  +


6  +


6  +
>)&   (&)( 3  "-- &' )    & 7(1 38,( ''

,3'(? (-' )$ 3>()'"))(?3( +&)1  @&('&4() )( 1











 0 1(0&1- ( 
 



    &,-&  .)/0  &)1  '0(  2(3  .3401(5  .)/0<
 



6  &,-&.)/0&)1 '0(2(3 !&/.)/0&)1
 



 .7)1(.)/0 &)1 '0(2.'&'(  3),&8&)1 '0(
 



0&8(()(1 A3&0)/B('')/  &1(  >-&)' 

CB6  1&'(1  ''(1 D:&407)1(.)/02(3&-&.)/0 &)1 '0(E-()1)/)'0( !31 &&/'&'('

&<  ",)&&  "))(?3(    &  7(  &  &  )(A3()'& - ((1)/  &)/  '0(( >  ) 31)/  '0(   3>> ))/

1(1&'(1  "))(?3(  )'0(8&  & (''(>()'&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'( 
 



6 0&8(()(1 A3&0)/B('')/&1( >-&)'

B "))(?3( 

  ''(1  D!&/  .)/0  2  &,-& .)/0  &)1  '0(E  3)1( .( ' )6<6@C<6@<6C &)1 #<
-()1)/)'0(

!31 &&/'&'('
&<",)&&<&7(&&

)(A3()'&- ((1)/&)/'0(( >) 31)/'0( 3>> ))/ 1(1&'(1  "))(?3(  )'0( 8&  >- >(&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'(F&)1 
 



 0&8(()(1 A3&0)/B('')/&1('0(

1&'(1

C< (/'((13)1(.( ' )C<@6<+<< @< <6<

6< <<
<  (.'&' ):

- 4(<$' '">'& "))(3?(  <   0&/(0(('  1&'(1    "))(?3( <&7(&- ((1)/&)/'0(( > '0(8&  >- >(&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'(  0&18(()(/'((1 )'0(8& '&'(>()'

 &, &.)/0
>-&)'0&5(8(()(18;!&/.)/0 &)1  :&407)1(  .)/0  &/&)'  '0(  '0(  -&'(  '   38>''(18;(&)(1 3)( '0(-('' )()&'0( &('0&''0( () (-3)0&8(3)1(.( ' )C<
 '  &''& '(1   0  >- >(  0&  8(()  &5(1  &'

8('7(()'0(-&'() 1('

>&)'&)-(& (<0&> );

&)1 1&(&' )8('7(()(& 0 '0(0(;1 ) '70 '

-(-('3&'(&);8&18

18('7(()'0(>0(;&70'

/5(&A3('3'

'0(1-3'(0() 1()')A3(' )0&1 '&4()-& (&''0('>(  &> &) 0&;&'(( ' ))'0

'3&' )<'7 318()'0()'((' ,3' ('

A3&0'0( &8 5(>()' )(1 >-&)'&)1  :(&)(1 3)( '0(-('' )(&7(&'0(-5&'((- )1()')&'0( &(&>'0(& '3> (''(>()'8('7(()'0(-&'( &)1  '&'(  '0&'  ) )(    '0(>  0&5(  &);  8,( ' )  '

 '0( A3&0)/ '0(&8 5(&1 >-&)'&)1'0(  0( &8 5(&1(''(>()'7&&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'(

  )'0()'(5()' (-( '&8(<(1(&)1 ()1 ) 
>)&   (&)( 3 

      -&'(7((1( '(1'

&--(&8( ('0('&
8( (

 +<)
>)& (&)( 3

6  '0(;7((1( '(1'

&--(&8( ('0('&

  8( (  6  6  &)1  ) 
>)&   (&)( 3

 -&'(7((1( '(1'

&--(&8( ( '&
  6)&'0( &((&)(1'&
3'

7&   1( '(1'

 ( 1'0( '&'(>()' '0( -&'() (-( ''

'0((''(>()'&)138>'&(- '(/&1)/'0( /()3)()(    '0(  >- >(<  70('0(  '  0&  8(() ()'((1  )'

3'    ((  7  &)1  5 ' )    '0(  -&'(< 7'0 3'&);(&<&--(0() )<3)13()3() (  (  ) ) >&' )7&&  3/0'70('0(&); '0(-('' )( 7&&- &>(1 ()1( )5 5(1)&); '0( &( .(-&&'((- ')-33&) ('

'0(&8 5(&1

+

1(0&5(8(()( (5(1)&'0( &(  (- '1&'(1 6  6  0&  8(()  ( (5(1  ) 
>)&   (&)( 3

6  >!31 &&/'&'('
&<",)&& '

 '0(  (( '  '0&'  '0(  (''(>()'  0&  8(()  &5(1  &' 8('7(()  '0(  -&'(  7'0 3'  &);  (&<  -(3(  &3(>()'.'&'(>()' !&/.)/0)'0(&1 &(0& 8(()( 1(1'

'0((( ''0&''0(>&''('&)1(''(1

3' 0 7)((7&)17'0 3'&);'0(&'  (  ) (1 () '70'

)')3( '0(- ((1)/&/&)''0( -('' )(   .'&'(>()'    &  '0(  -&'(  0&5(  8(() &--()1(1& )/7'0'0((- '

(- '  1&'(1   +  0&  8(()  ( (5(1  )
>)&   (&)( 3 

        >  !31 & &/'&'('
&<",)&&<70(()' 8(5(1'0&''0( (''(>()'0&8(()&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'( 3' '0( 

7)  ((  7  &)1  7'0 3'  &);  (&<  &--(0() )< 3)13()3() (  (  ).'&'(>()' '0( >-&)&)'

.3401(5.)/0 '0( /)& >-&)&)'<:&407)1( .)/00&8(()( 1(1&>)/'0((''(>()'8('7(() '0(-&'( (0&'&'(1'0&'0(7&38''3'(1&'0(

>-&)&)' )6

 & /)& >-&)&)'(<0 &'0(:&407)1(.)/00&1-&(1&7&;

 .'&'(>()'  &, &.)/00&& 8(()( 1(1 0( (- '>()' )(1 )( '0(& 3(1 & 0-&.)/0'

8(&

@ - &>(1 ()1(<'0 3/00)&>() '>()' )(1) '0(&&; '0((5()& 3(1 .'&'(>()' '0(-&'( 0&5(8(()&--()1(1& )/7'0'0((- '

(- '  1&'(1   +  0&  8(()  ( (5(1  )
>)& (&)( 3

  >"11' )& $' '&)1.( )!31/(<">'&70(()' 8(5(1 '0&''0((''(>()'0&8(()&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'(

3'    '0( 

7)  ((  7  &)1  7'0 3'  &);  (&< &--(0() )<3)13()3() (  (  ).'&'(>()' '0(

>-&)&)' &, &.)/0&7(&& ) ()(1-( ) 7&  ( 1(1  '    ) >(1  '0&'  )(    '0(  & 3(1 .&7)1(.)/0 "0&.)/00&18(()-&(1&7&; " 3(1  &(  ) '  '&'(1  '

 8(  - &>(1  ()1( .'&'(>()' &'0(&( '(1-&'(0&5(8(()( 1(1 &)1&--()1(1& )/7'0'0((- '

)1 38'(1;<  () (  -3)0&8(  3)1(  .( ' C<  
 &)) '  8(  >- 3)1(1      &  >-&)'

(/'((1  3)1(  .( ' )  C<  
 &> )/  '0(  ( ' ) &)) '8(('&1(>((; )'0(8& &(''(>()'

8('7(()'0(-&'( 7(5(<'0
3' &)) ' (/0'

'0(& ''0&''0( )')3&) ( '0(- ((1)/)'0 &(7 318(&3'((?( ()5(7 '0((''(>()'

70 00&)1((18(()&5(1&'8('7(()'0(-&'(

3(3  -3- (  7 31  8(  (5(1  8;  )')3)/   '0(  &1

- ((1)/   "  '0(( - ((1)/  '(>  > &  1-3'( 70 0& (&''0('>(  &> &) 0&;&'(( ' ) &'( 0&5(1( 1(1'

83;'0(0&' 0('")( '0&8(()>&1( '

 >&)'&)  1&  (&' )  &)1  >&)'&)  &  -(& (3 &'> -0(()'0'3&' )<'7 311()'(;(5('0( )'((' ,3' ('0(&8 5(>()' )(1- ((1)/&( A3&0(13'0(> (< 0&) (  )5 ' '0(& 3(1 -( )&(&8 3'(;8(&40(( (<' )1((1,3'

&)1(?-(1()''

A3&0'0(& (>()' )(1- ((1)/ ) =37)1(  .)/0 &)1  '0(  5(3   .'&'(  =37)1(  .)/0 &)1  '0(  5(3   .'&'(  =37)1(  .)/0 &)1  '0(  5(3   .'&'(  =37)1(  .)/0 &)1  '0(  5(3   .'&'(  3),&8 &)1&) '0( 3),&8 &)1&) '0( 3),&8 &)1&) '0( 3),&8 &)1&) '0(<C 
 +<&5(>(>8( #() 0 '0 3'0& 8(5(1< D0( >- >(<)&> 1() (';<'0( )(A3&) 0&> );&)1 1(;8(0&5 3 ''0( 3 ,3' (&)1'0(- 7(3)1( .( ' )6 '0(
1( 
>)&  (13( 3(1'

()0&) (3 0& >- >(70 0<) '3)<()0&) ( '0(  &&>';&)1(13 (  ' )<'0()''3;<D)('0 3 ,3' (E
)(A3()';<  &  '0(  &8 5(  &1   -('' )  &( & 7(1&)1 >-&)'

CB6<1&'(1 ''(1 D:&407)1(.)/02&-&.)/0&)1 '0(E-()1)/) '0(  3'    !31 &  &/'&'(<  ' 
&<  ",)&& "))(?3(  1( 1&'(1  "))(?3( &

7(  &  &  )(A3()'&  - ((1)/  &)/  '0(( >F

>-&)') B "))(?3( ''(1D!&/.)/02

&,-&.)/0&)1 '0(E3)1(.( ' )6<6@C<6@<6C &)1 #<
<-()1)/)'0( !31 &&/'&'(<'

&<",)&&<3>> ))/ 1(1&'(1  "))(?3( &7(& )(A3()'&- ((1)/&)/'0(( >F &)1

1&'(1

C(/'((13)1(.( ' ) C<@6<+<< @< < 6< <<
&'  ( .'&' )  :

- 4(< $' '  ">'&  "))(?3(     0&/( &>(1&/&)''0(& 3(18;'0((&)(1'&
 &7(&& )(A3()'&- ((1)/&)/ '0(( >&(0((8;A3&0(1)'0()'((' ,3' (   + :." :: ")

- !

$