Mohinder Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "
$ %# &
' $ &( ) *
& + ) $ %#!,
#*
) -(*!$,-!&( )
# % #
# ". *
/#,
$
0(%!$##1#%$ %#2%!
3# /#*
# #% #
( $
4 5&
!# %!#654. $
4 715&3 % %
#*
8 $ %# # # / ! /!9( !(
$ %# :9!9 ;# !
#%
#(
# 3 ; !3# 3 (%#7 73 #*
<# 65 % # # 9(* $ %# 3 # # %
##
(
# 3 #/ 3 # $#
#$ %#:-
$ %#( # 3
;#
# 3 , (3 / % * #%
#65
!##( # # / ; .;# ##( # !3# #
( (
<#
3 % ## #( #
##( # 3 !# / !
( %##7 73#* *
# #
* /3 ## )
( #
/!
#
% #
* =
> #
* /!
4? ( 4 *#
3 #- #
/
# (
+ 3!
!#
* % *#
##
(
7./ <##7 73 $ %#!
#7 3 9( #/! #7 73 9!
7 73 9 ;# (%# 9! 1 #(
/ # *#
% !3# % #
<# 3/!% (@4 * # *#
$ %###
#
;#
#
#
*
%#
;#
#, ( # / #
3 / %
#
1
#
* 653 % 4 , %
# 65! # *
**
$
+ ! & $
1 #( %
%
9(3 $ %#:1 (:
( 0 9(:$# %# (%#7 73 (
#*
/#*
!#
3 7 % # 3
$
4 5& $
45&%
9(3 $ %#:1 (:
(!# 3 0 9( : $# # * *
# # 3
%/* , /
!( %# #% 3 %
# *
( $
4 5& /
". !3# # ( # % #*
? A
** %
# #*
##*
# / * #* <# # # #*
3# #
# (%##
#
#* # !
#
!;
# ( !
3#
( %
# *
! # %
( % #
= =
(/
% #
5 ! # 3
=
%
= = = /#*
#
5
# #
%3 ### #
3 % */
#* /
#*
#
3 5 ##*
#/ / # *( #
3 ( / ####*
3
/#* %# =
# % 5
##*
#3/
# ;# (%# #
#
3# ##
#*
=&*) =
( 5 #
!
%3 #
(%
#*
3# #3 ( #
(
##
?
*
/3/#
%
&
!
** %
# # *
8$ ##* %
#%
#%
#*
# #( #
(# %#/ # #%%
#*
( $
45& 5##
#* # (/ %
# (%##
!
( %#
. <#
/ #* #
<# ! (3###
( $
45&% #
/#*
(
! 3 (
/ 7* ( #
/!3# # ( B
!
!
!
" ! " # #
$ % &
'
"
(
)
*
+ " ! #
,
- ./
0
( "
1
2
$ / & + " ! "
"
**
3 0
#
1
# ! 45 2
$ / & !
" # #
(
.
3 #
/
"
-
2
8 2
"
0
,
#
2
$ / &
," "
- 9
##
,
#
"
,
#
"
,
"
2* "
3
8 "
"
3#
2*
3
* "
2*
8 "
3:
3
#
- " 2
5 1% /7;
.
3
3# 3
#
3# 3
#
8
3
#
3
" "
-
3
3
#
8
# # 3
3
" 3
8
3
3
- "
3
-
"
** 4<
)6
8
3
- "
#
3
( #
"
** 4<
)6 3
,
" ! #
(
$ .
3 # " # #
"
** # # 40 + !
4"+ 66
2
/ & #
/ & # 4<
)6 "
<
) "
3 3 #
=# # 3 # "
#
82 #
3
,"
"
** 4<
)6
+ " !
!
#
"
2 #
3
5 " 3
( !
>+ 3
"
0
3
##
8
3#
? ##@ 8 3
"
! "
>?
"
# %;
# (
+
<
:
- "
#
- /; B
2
!
<
:
" 2
,
" !
3
# / & "
<
:
"
59
/ B /
! 2
( #
3
" # #
#
"
3
" # #
.
# "
2
# #
# C
"
3
#
"
,
"
## ""
D2
# #
<
:
"
"
#
<
:
3
#
2 <
)
<
: "
# ""
#
-
"
3 #
" ! # "
#
"
!*
$ 4 86 5E *
" !
9
$ // "
(
2
( 3
3
! 2
0
3
2
"
"
" #
!*
$ 4 86A " <# ( #
#
9(3 9( :1 (: (#%
+ 3 #;
3 ###( # #/ " %# # 7@ ;# #*(*
!3# #3 % 0(/!
" /#
%3 ###( $# 3 9(3
"
9( ! %# 4" "!##( # 3 5 #
# #! !# % # 7@ ;# # (%# # #7 73 &* ) $# ( % *
/ ##( 5 ! ! # # 9(*$ %##% 7@ ;# $# ## #*(*
%
% #3
#4;# 5
!9(3 9( :1 (: ( 1 #(
# #!## ## # # 3 #
!3# #3 /##(
,# # 3
#
$#%
7@ ;# (
## #
(
% # C/!
(% ** ## 3# #3
#
* # /+
# # # #
#
/
!#3 (%##( ; +
(# #;* # !#3 (;# #
#
/%
(#3 ;@) # # 3 (
;##( * # # /!
#%#
2 .
""4 # ;# ;* ;
% #
*#
+3 ( ;#
;! (
#/( #
/! ( ;#
# ;
# !
##
(*# #
(
#3/!##7 73&*0 #+ ;#
3# #3 %
%( ! #* # (# #
#
( %# # <#(*
!#
#7 73&*0
;# ##
(,## ! # 3 $# 3* #/ # 4;# #*(*
%# = # ! 3# ## #7 73* #9( *- = $3 = ##/ %
7@ # ( %7@ 3 ( * / +&*0 #7 73(# ; ( ;9( *
%! 3# # (* ##3 ( 9( *3 #
, # # #7 73 &* 0 ( <#!# (= 3 # (#
/ #! (
*# / D( /( ;# #
% # $# #B+ 3
"
0
3
##
8
3#
? ##@ 8 3
"
! "
>?
"
# %;
# <## (= # , % #
3 ( / ## #
%
D(#*
% # /
3# #3 (#
*#
,
/3 %/# $# 3 ( /# 3# 3 # #
#
(
% 5 3 9(3 9( :1 (: (3# #
*(*
# #
#
#
** ##
*
3
/#* %# = # % <#
/
3 #% #* *
# #
( %* #
!3# # #
# B- /; B
2
!
<
:
" 2
,
" !
3
# / & "
<
:
"
59
/ B /
! 2
( #
3
" # #
#
"
3
" # #
# "
2
# #
# C
"
3
#
"
,
"
## ""
D2
# #
<
:
"
"
#
<
:
3
#
2 <
)
<
: "
# ""
#
-
"
3 #
" ! # "
#
" A
,# %! 3 ( C* $
45&
3### ( #*
(
$
4 5& ( B. 7
, "
#
2
# # # "
9
" $
. #5& # !3# #/ #
/ ;
,
F, #
F 4' 68
# G
4!6 8D
# #
# " "
3 # # #
G
4( 68
<# ! % 3 # # *( 3 $
4 5 & # #
#
!#*
3# # #
# */ /
%
/
% #
! "
#$ % & & '()! *++,#-.).+/!#$(* (##
3 #$
4 5& 3 * B E
* ( $
.5&5 ###*
#
/
%
# (=
/* *
#
( ) C*
* !
7 * ( # (
# /
#*
(
3#
3# #
*# ; C *
% # F#
# %#*
#
% # %! # /*
## % 4 6(#!# ( # (0!12"
& 3 1 *+-4#5)# 1 (/65 3# %3 #$
45&# ( B(
> A "
<
82
# 3H I > A
E 4 6 3
'
# -9" D > A
E
4 6
( " > A
2 # 9#
( ,#9
# > A
> A
E* B/
, # !
# 2
"
"
# G
# #
# " "
3 # # #
G
D9# ! / ;
"
# "
"
> A
"
22 # #
4
"" "" ! . 7
< @
/B
, # " !
# 2
> A
#
( > A "
<
(
J
!# 3 " *) $
I )
8 I # 6 " # 23 >
A
( " C > A
"" > A
#" 2 C
K
C
#
!
"
#
,
"
C
"
/%
( > A
#
# 23
> A > " A
(
> A >
E # 23
A 4!E -9" D 6G > 3#
A 4!E -9" ,2 I + L ; D6
! > A
2 #
3
#
2
C3
?
# # " #
( "
#
> A > " A # 23
, 2
$ 4# 6
" " # 9#
> A
"
# 2
# E 46
3#
"
2
" # " "
3
2 "
C3
" G
46
# 23
2
= #
6
% #
!* ( ! ( /
##*
# !
/ !
%#
G
%%3 # /
*
/
* /
%## % ( /!#
(#
#
% # *
D( % #% %
# *
$ %# ?
D( /!#*
3<# *(%
". *
/#,
$
0(%!$## 1#% $ %# 2%!
% #% ( $
4 5& D( # *
+ 3! * % 3 # # )(% #
(
;
#B%
E #* * %# *
# !3# ##7 73 # <#
/# !3# # ## 3 % # * !
* # /
2
/
( # #
(# * # <#$#
*
( / #
$
45& #
;<#5 %
3 ( 3 % ( '7 8-,*+-4 #
) F## *;
%@
H