Arun Nanda And ANR v. State Of Punjab & ANR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH *** CRM-M-628-2015
Reserved on: 04.12.2023
Pronounced on: 22.12.2023 ARUN NANDA AND ANR.
-Petitioners
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANR.
-Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KULDEEP TIWARI Argued by: Mr. S.S. Swaich, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. P.S. Grewal, D.A.G., Punjab.
Mr. B.S. Baath, Advocate for the respondent No.2.
*** KULDEEP TIWARI, J.
!
"
#
$$ %
&! ' ()
*
+$$, (!
"
+$$ %
! ' ()
-
##
$ +. + / $ 0 1, !
"
#
2/34&4.+$ &4.+4&! %
!
56
74 % 2 8 '
(
#
%
! # () #
2 '
(
(
:;
<# =>
%
!
5
2 ';
2
( 2 & ';
## %
<# # #
-4 :;
<# # ## %
2?6@ 33 2 & ( 2
' ) 2& &
2 &
( ( 0( !
2
(
)
# ) (
' (
)
# ( :
; ( 2
)
( (
)4(
2&
'
'
2
2
2 &
2 &
'
'
# ;
)
(
&4 # .
#
: $ @ '
(
(
# : @ 2
#
# 2 & ' '
#
# :& @ 2
# # -4
# ) '
#
:&.$$$$4
+
#
A) )
'
B
#
#
# :$ @;A
A) ; #
)A
; # /
'
'
(
'
# (
# ( '
)
(
'
'
(
(;
# : .$$$$4
'
) ;
(; #
'
; # '
)
#
(
'
( '
)
# #
2
2+ 3 $$/
(
3 $/ $$.
'
(
' (
#
1 ' ( (
)
( #
) #
)
%
$
(
#
?
' #;
CD <# (
<# )
)
)
%
- 2- &./ $$ (
C A(
B( C)
$+ $$
'
' # #
) (
)
C A(
)
%
&
?
)
) )
'
(
C A(
C
#
&
'
##
(
##
E4 $+4$4+.4+/4+4/4$ 0 1
<# <# ?
( '
B
C A(
C A(
B
)
) )
C A(
#) ;
) ##
#
##
# # : .$$$$4
#) ;
) (
#
B
8 &
!
2
#
#
#
#
= 2
= C :
=& % # #
G G /
)
2
#
+$$ () ##
.
+$$
) '
(
*
C'
*
'
$$ )
+ #
!
() (
(
'
()
/
#
)
(
#
) (
;
'
2
#
#
B#
&$+$ (
)
3$/$$. )
2
#
-
H
#;
) '
(
(
B#
#
2
(#
B#
&$+$
! '
2
)
3$/$$. '
(
'
B#
$3$
#
) '
(
#
B#
B#
(
3$/$$.
(
) '
3$/$$. ' #
;
9
)
)
(
( ' '
)
B#
(
' 3 ? # (#
#
2
) (
(
2
) ) ' '
B
$
#
(#
$$ '
()
'
+$$ (
' (
#
#
'
#
2
# 9 B#
(
' 9
(
(
# 9 (
'
3$/$$. '
( (
#
(
'
(#
9
:.$$$$4 ()
'
(
( B
2 (#
'
(
# :.$$$$4 '
()
) ##
2 ( )
(
(
(
'
)
) (
() (
(
&
#)
#
()
#
$$ '
()
(
% (
$$ '
()
+$$ (
'
) #
B
)
$$ #;
#
#
2
#
) (
#
#
4
()
)
'
#
. !
"#$%& '
(# #% )*+,# @ ! 2+.4$+!
C A(
#
(
8
()
#
#
'
B
B
)
3 B#
'
53 G
#
@ F
-:
0
%# #
G
E
3/ ! %
G: ! ( I
#
#
I 1 %
-
) F
)! @ (
3/ @: $!
' ( I?
#
B
:
;
)
I :
(
(B
) () (B
)
#
I
(
I
()
#
#
'
B
B
) :
(
B )
#
#
%
) ;
'
')
# D
)
B
#
'
I
(
I
'
B 9 B
# + ? C A(
- .(#/,&
01&#,2
,!
,%!3
/(!
!
'!# 00%
'42% .'#/ 0,'2( 8 @' ?
F 1 J/33.!
)
# ' ##
#( B#
'
'
. ##
(
B
') (
#
)
B
) ( % 9 B
) #
#
B
B
#
) (
# (
'
:
)
(
)
B 9 B
#
'
:
(
#;
()
:
) ( #
(
#
#;
(
B
() B 9 B
() #
(
:
B
' ()
B
##
'
(
B #;
B
)
B
*
9 B
)
B
'
# %
## ' #
()
(B
) #
A
B
) )
# B
( B
(
)
) ; 1 * 9 B
( 4 #;
#
;
' '
#
:
#
%
A(( # A
9
'
#;
#
(
)
( B '
)
#;
) #;
B #;
( #;
# (B
(
)
F
* 3/! $$ C' @' :
' /& /&/!
#
(
#;
'
) #
# ' ( *
33! 3 GC:: ..& .+ 3 /5# !
/& 2( &,5 760(%8 9
& '
%
+ G
C# :
' I 9
#
B I
##
' B
B#
)
#
:
'
) IF I /
(
'
()
C A(
#
) ()
)
F INAL ORDER ?
! !
$$
() 2, # &%2 (
'
#
#
'
(
4 #
(
19.
The petition is disposed of accordingly.
(KULDEEP TIWARI) JUDGE 22.12.2023 devinder Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No Whether reportable : Yes/No