High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6350/2014disposed of

Rajinder Kohli v. Nirmal Singh

2017-02-15Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri3 pages

!"#$%"&'('#)*"+,- ,. / 01 2')%",3#45'

111

',7 5')84 111 *

,"(")!* 4,'7 ,%""9')84'55/%6#& !"$#,!4"9"!'!'#)",1 4,'""9 :,#, /%6#& !"$#,!4","(9#)%")!1

!1 , 5* -5"1 " ,%$#,!4;'!41 .#,%",% !"% 11 /!4'(#-,!

4 %9#(!"%!4"9"!'!'#)$#,$') 54" ,')8(')&"!4'(#-,!; ()#!'79,"(("% ;'!4!4"#+2"&!'#)($'5"%+.!4"&#-)("5$#,!4","(9#)%")!&#795 ') )!1 ) !4 !6'";#$!4"7 !!",/!4"7 !!",'(9#(!"%$#,$') 54" ,')81 " ,%5" ,)"%&#-)("5$#,!4"9 ,!'"( !5")8!41 ) 9,'6 !"

&#795 ')!& ("$'5"%+.!4"&#795 ') )!,"(9#)%")!/!4" 55"8 !'#) 8 ')(! !4"9"!'!'#)",'(!4 !4"('8)"% ( ) !!"(!')8;'!)"((#)!4" 8,""7")!/ ;4'&4 &&#,%')8 !#!4"&#795 ') )!/; ($#,8"%+. &&-("% )!

,: (414"&#795 ') )!(-&&""%"%')!4"&'6'5&#-,!-9!#!4'(#-,!')!4" &'6'59,#&""%')8(')8"!!')8!4"(-'!9,#9",!.1 )%""%!4"$, -%; (9, &!'("% -9#)!4","(9#)%")!&#795 ') )!+-!!4")/!4 !; (%#)"+.!4"&5#(" ,"5 !'6" #$ 52')%", ')841 4" ( '% &5#(" ,"5 !'6" 52')%", ')84 ',,"(9#)('+5.4 )%"%#6",!4"9 9",(!#!4" &&-("% ;4#-5!'7 !"5.'(

(! !"%!#4 6"&#77'!!"%!4"$, -%14"&#795 ') )!+#) $'%"5.4 )%"% #6",!4"#,'8') 59 9",(!#4'(&5#(","5 !'6"+"5'"6')8!4 !!4")""%$-5;'55 +"%#)"+.4'(&5#(","5 !'6"'),"5 !'#)!#4'(9,#9",!.1-!!4")/ 52')%", ')847 %" 7'(! :" )%4 )%"%#6",!4"9 9",(!# &&-("% /;4#'( 55"8"%!#4 6"&#77'!!"%!4"$, -%1 "!4 ! ('!7 ./!4","(9#)%")! &#795 ') )!4 (5-&:'5.#+! ')"%4'(9,#9",!.+ &:')&'6'55'!'8 !'#)1 4","(9#)%")!&#795 ') )!!4"," $!",$'5"% &#795 ')!+"$#," !4"&,'7') 5&#-,! 8 ')(! &&-("% )%!4" !!"(!')8;'!)"((/'1"1/!4"

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

4"6",'$'& !'#)(! !"7")!+"$#,"!4"&#-,!#$!4"&#795 ') )! )%!4","5"6 )!9#,!'#),"5 !')8!#!4"9"!'!'#)",," %(!4-(* >

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

'( 55#;"%A

'' (-77#)')8 #,%", )% !4" ,"6'('#) 5 #,%", )% !4" &#795 ')!<- !4"9"!'!'#)",#)5. ," 55<- (4"%1 B

C "+,- ,. / 01 "

D4"!4",(9" :')8E," (#)"%

"(E # D4"!4",,"9#,! +5"

"(E #