Bhagwan Dass Gupta v. Special Fraud Investigation Office
!"#$" %" & '("
)(*(*
+
-*
."
/(*#"(*
00*
)'
(
(
12 1!34 1
"(4
("
-(!*4 -* "5
5
'
(
4 $"7
'( 4 8
# 5"
3'5"*(
"( : 4
;
:;
:
<"
5
!3(57
"# !" %* = "(
(*34 !" ! * !"#
"7
"7 "00"*
3'"7-- -"5=
3'5"*( 0*5
-./ '""
3'5"*(4
5"57
3(*
(
"55 3""#3(
--
&
""*#
3'5"*(=
7
3'5"*( *(504
"55#
33*((
;
(= ($*
(*#(
(*'
5"(
:
"''57
*(!
!"#
57
"55# "#"*(
;
4 (*(5
#"(
*
6"*5
(! 63*((
!"*# *# .*" -("(3( 7" =
= "33(
"3
7" 4 (!0 4
" 3" 5*"65 "55# *#*#
.*" -("(3( 7"
(! "#
0" 6"5" !(
4
0"55
:;
:
"3 6"*5"65 #" *#*#
.*" -("(3( 7" 4
;
"(("
(
<"
5 (!
( "55#
*(
'5"
7" 4 $!" '(
3'5"*( #*(
: * "0( 5"7
"6
7" *# '* 4
*(!
"55
*(*#"(*
*
4 *(*#"(*# "# 7
-(*55 (!4 "#
60* *"7
(""
"55 %* 4
"3574 >"*5"!
!" !("= "7"8 & 7"5= >!3 !"=
"2 > 3" & '("= " -!"3"= <"5*( >!
5"4 %*!
> 3"= 16!*!8 & 7"54 %'"8 &"# !"#$"( %"7"5
*(*3 6"*5
(! #
4
5
8 #"(
("4 5" -* "5
5
'
(4 $!*5 !3(57
''
*# 4
( '(
"4 ("5 *#!(7 *#!(
$ * 5
*(*#
-- &
-- &
'4
6"*
0"5 0"6* "( ("(3(4
6("*
" 0 *00( 6"8 * '"7 "3
:
-! (!
( (!
00* *( 3"(*"5
-- <*3*( *(
"*
$
( 55 1*5 ?*"54 *!"
""54 9""8 !" ,"7"54 - !*5 -*#5"
"2!
-*#5"4
?> &"# >&"#= $"@*
%* @1*(* %* 0*
"
*"( --
&
"3
(
:;:
!" *(
0 -- &
$"7
'""(@*(*
(""
(!
( *(*#"(*
'
"5 %*
--
$ (57 3'5 74 8 $
5"(*
( 55
-- &
'
("
-(!*4 (!
( "5*
!" *3*
- !*5 -*#5"
"2!
-*#5"4 ("*5
*(*# *!"65 0
"
1 #"
63** 3" 5"
5
4
(!0 4 ($*
5"* $ :
"''5* "654 5"
-* "5
54 "$ "(((*
;
6
$!
;
("*5 *!3(
(
-! (! "# (!
(3 5*8 %
%* !"*# *#
.*" -("(3(4
" $*##5
!*
*3*"5 5*"6*5*(7
/ !" 5"
5 '"(*
5"*3 !*350
%
%* $4 (! (!*#
(!(* "(
'5" 1 ' %* B *
* !"# !* (* *5*# *# (!
*'!
*#
"@ *(*#
-(*55 (! !"*#
(*57 '"(* *'"( "00"*
3'"7 !"*#
*# .*" -("(3(4
" ("8
'5"
!*3 3"( %* 4
5*"6*5*(7
0"(
!*3
/ '
((*
5"
5
! 4
($*
:
"''5* "65
!*34
( 5"(
'
;
C; *!3( 0"5 ("(3( -"
(!$*
* *0 ( 4 '
(4
(*0* "(4
0*" ("(3(4 ' ("(3(
(!
3( B *
4 '
5 3" (! 4
3"8 ("(3(4
" D!* 0"5 3"(*"5 '"(*
5"4
8 $*#
0"5=
6 D!*
3*( 3"(*"5 0"
8 $*#
3"(*"54 ! !"55 5*"65
E
' "5
6 "0 "*
!
;
("*5 *!3(
3*
4 "#"*( -
*(7 "(
5"#4 (* (57 "5( ( '"( +7
(574 F65 1'G
+*2"7 ""5"5 !
!"7
+ H*
/*"
-
<* - 4
$!*5
**#
(*( "5**(7 "''5* "6*5*(7
(* (*
*
(*
7 <"
*# 4 !" !5 7
5"
*#
"#"*( *#(7 *(#*(7
(7
5*"
!* 8*# '"*(7
"
4 "5* #"(
*
6"*54
!5'
"4
* #"( 60
#3(
F65 - '3
+*2"7 ""5"5
: !
!"7F
'" F65 - '3
(4
#3(4 !" !5
C
GGGGGG ,!* (*
#3(
(*(
!" 9*8!
,""
!" -!"!
.
(!4 $
"#
6"(* ##(*
75"
*# 5 !*
(!"
( *3
#!(
("
85
,1%1
(!
3'55*# -("( *(( ("
85*#
75"
*# *("(* *
*
*# 3"
75"
*#
# 5"
6"* *( 3 (*3= ( #57
33
"
(3(
(*#( 5#*5"(* '(*
7 5"
*#
36"(*# 3"
(! *#
(
00 "(("
!3(
0* "(*
*3 !"*# * *3'"
0*"
7(3 *#(7 *(#*(7
(* ,!"(
!" (
'*# '"(
*(
-("(3(
62 ( " 4
"3
6*# ,!* 5""(*
"5*"3( *(50 ((*3 7
3'55*# *(7
(*#( #*3
"
(3( '(*
(
3"
75"
*# (
1(* 5 ;
(*(
/*"4 (7
-("(
*"54
3*
5*(* "5 (* 3**3*I
3 *B "5*(* 1(* 5
(*( 3""(
-("(
'(
("(*
$"5(!4 (!
"5*I *(
*"5*( # "54
3 *3'"(* -("(
3"8
5"$4
57
"
( 7
*0 6"
3*
7(3
(74 "5
'( (**(7 "3"#
3*
0"6*
"(*
" #"*"*
3*
("
#"
(*# (!7
57 * 5 *** "5
* * (*34 !"3
*(7 $!
5 (!
<"$
33** '
( ,!
<"$ 33** "5
*(
(!
'
33 " *!3( (
* (!* .
(!4 "(
*!3( 75"
*#
4
57
7"4
" 6"*
3* *
#"*(7
"(
( 3"((
5#*5"(* 5* 7 *!3( *
("*57
'* *'5 **# #"*(7
4 $4
" 5 0"
**# *(7
(
75"
*#
!*
*34
57
"00 (
3*
0"6*
"(* 4 "5
(
(
(! !*
4
( *34
5"(
9%- ( 0"
*("(*
*3*"5 ($ 8 ''
3 # $
G(3*( #
' 5*
("0
"
( 7
"(* -("( "3 ?(!3"5"*
H*
/*"
44 (!
((
*3"#*"(* 4
" (!
3'55*# -("( *((
**# (*#(
7 5"
*# / "3 ?(!3"5"*
H*
/*"
44
G'
7
J 0(
("(J
*6 "(*
"'"65
'(*#
75"
*#
GG
GGG
GG
,!0 4 ( "6 4 *(*#"(*
3*
4
75"
*#4 B *
7(3"(*
"'' ! .
(!4
*((*
"5*"3(
G
'"(*
"(* *'"( 7 6"*54
(!$*4 $*55
"(
"7 * 6($ "(* *'"( 7
57 $*55 *"(* "5
* *3*"( 7
"6*("7 ,!
("557 3*
* *#
$*55 "''57
"(* *'"( 7 6"*5
- 00*
6
''
(
*55 #* "5
*0 "''5* "0( "(4
!@!
#"( 5*0
57 *0 ($*
50*55 "*(*
(! (*'
5"(* '* "(
= (! 4 $!
7(
"(
"3
75"
*#4 $*55
B *
50*5
($*
$!*5(
**#
"''5* "(* #"(
;
5*0
6"*54 "(
# 5"
"(* *'"( 7
6"*54
*
3 *6
(*'
5"(*
'* "(
(
57*#
'* *'5
#( (*##
*(!
60 5*0
75"
*# ("8 $" 17
(! *$
('
(* 0"( '
62 ( 6!* (*#( "
(
; "5*"3( '(*
75"
*#
36"(
3"
(
(**(7 * (57 *3'"
(
0*" 7(34 *# *#(7 *(#*(7
(7
1 5(4 $
!*("(* 4
6*#
$!"( 3 5*0
! *# "(
*#4
;
3"((4 * 8*# **
(*(
(4
57*# '* *'5 *#
(
3
'5"7
G '(*
#!(
'!
62 (*
' 5#*5"(* **# (*#( # 5"( 7 3"
36"(*# 3"
75"
*#
,! *4 $4 G '(*
"
(*
3'5*"
($*
3
:1
4 !"
3
: :
*
,!*4 6B ( 5"$ "
(
"5*"3(4 ( '"*5 :1
"
:1 "G*3 '*
(*"5 '*
("* D! !"4 *# '*
*(*#"(* 4 *B *7
(*"5
5"$
*!3(
"(!
!" ' *0*
*!3(
5"$
# ((* '* G(*#
!"50
3"G*3 '*
*3'* 3( ' *0*
5"$4 ! !"55 5"
!*
(*
*
3"74 "0( !"*# 65*
"
$*(*#4
(* ((*
'*
# (!"
!"50
'*
5" !*3
*("
(*
* (!
!"55
("* *# '*
*(*#"(* 4 *B *7
(*"5
(!" 3"G*3 '*
*3'* 3( *
5"$
KG'5""(* /
3'
(*# '*
((*
#"(*# 6"*54 '*
((* '"
5"7
*#
!"55 G J
/ -("(3(
62 ( " 4 ("( (!
GGG
GGG
GGG
/ A 3 ("74 -("(
*!"4 "("
("(
*#!(
'7 (*"5
0"
(
1(* 5
#*I *#!(
'7 (*"5 "3("5 *#!(
,!* * !"
*((57 $
"5
" "5*"3( *( $* *(
:1
#*I*#
(* "(*# ("(
(*"5 '*
* (!3
37
2 (*0* ((* / - '3
<#"5 1* 33*(( '(*# H(*"5 * + ! " :
- 4
(4 57*#
"*""
>!"(
4 * ( 5"
'*
!"#
9"
% # 7 ( '*
"0(
3'5(*
!"50
3"G*3 (3 ' *6
(
*
* "0( ("8*#
(
6("(
9%-
*3'
*#
($*
5"
6"*5
6
J D
*
("( 7
0**# '5"
' *6*#
"(*0* 60
5"
/ $ "(
"5*
'"(
#3( D "5
8'( 3*
*('("(* '5"
*3*5"
,1%1 (*( >"("
-*#!
+ -("(
2"6 %'*( 4 $
* ( "6 3"*57 "(
"55
1(* 5
*#!(
'7 (*"5 3"7 B * 3
"
"!*#
*3*"5
*# "5( #(!4 !5
(*(
1 1( 5"7
- 9"7"84
- 4 5"
6"*54
("8
36 *#!(
'7 (*"54
3"74 3
" 3"
1(* 5 1 $
05( 5*
'( G(3 63**
"!*#
*# ((*# 0
$!
(*"5 5"7 67
" "65 (*3 " "5"7 "55 $
05( '*"(*
5*6(7
*# '7 (*"5
"5
"
*#!( # ""( 1(* 5
4 3
"3
(
'*"(*
5*6(7
"
" *
"= *0 '*
'*"(*
'*# (*"5
3
#4 0"* "
1(* 5
* 5(
$ 05( "0(
00 *3'* 3( !"50
3"G*3
*!3( *
4 (!
'*"(*
5*6(7
* 5"(*
"3("5 *#!( * "5* 1(* 5 4 !"
(5
' *#!( # ""( 1(* 5
"5
3*
(4
0"*
" "65
"5 3"(( J
H*
/*"
"5
#*I *#!(
'7
(*"5
(* "3("5 *#!( (!* $*((
63** "4 (!
63*(( 5*3*( *( "(*
*#!(
#"(
* 5"(*
1(* 5
(*( .
(!4
(
:1
*( "0(
"
(3(
( ,!
"'' '*"(
7 5*0
:1
$!
5 3 60*
( $4 :1
4
* "6 ( *#!(
0"
5(
:
.
4 0"
*( "(*
"4
3"7 (*55 7 5*0
$*#
#
4
$! (*"5 5"7 "( *("
!*350E
#3( 5* $!*5 "2 * "(*#
(*( +"5**(7
<14
"''5* "65
'(
"4
"55#
'(
"8*
"55#"(* "#"*( *
"(
3'5"*( 0*5
57 "0( ("*5 *(*#"(*
'
( *(*#"(* "5 F * 53(
;;
-- &
' %*
3'"*4 *# 4 !" 63*(( 0"5
("(3(
6( 4 *05"( !" "5 0*#
5*6"(57
"5 3"(*"5 0"
(
*'!
*#
:;
*(*#
:;:
0
--
&
$"7
'""(@*(*
(""
,!
8'*# *$ *
"55#"(* "#"*( #3(
F65 1'G
+*2"7 ""5"5 !
!"7F
'"4
*
6"*5
A 4 '( *3*
D!(! '"8*#@"
L@9
D!(! '
("65
L@9