← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1389/2009dismissed

H.B. Garg And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-12-24Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh10 pages





          

 !

"#  $%  &' ()   **+,+ ! $% -**** $.$.

-    / % 0$+$  1+2+ ++ ! $% -***** -3

$- 4"  564 * 0 /66  5640* 0 746

 - $"

4*

3+& 3$+(0 .

!8 +$ (9.$% 4*0.!!%+$%0%+&+(!8 +$ (1 $% 3 $.$.

-* 4-*+ .-%+ -%+9+.+((+2+ +* 4* **+9+(!8 +$ (1  -3

$- *$ #* 

/66(*  

    !  "

# $

 

 

% % 

 &   &



 '& (#'"

 



) *+,

, - , .

, .,.

.,

# ,. ,,



#& &#

 /

 '& (#'"



+

# $

 

   

/#   



 # $   

   !  "

#+

 

#

&# ##



+

#  &##$ ##

$ 

 

  %"

 &

##$

  #

$

(

0



  /

$    !

##$

#    /

%$

+

/  *+



#



+ +

.

  *+ & (&

% &(& # (#&& /##&

1& /##& &2 "

%$

! # 

#

 3& 4 % ! 

- "& % & & 

" $ 5 

/#

%  

/#%

 +



  

 4 % %% /

#$ /

 "



 /

  &

#$

 

6 7893:

  /& (1 

&# (#  5 

#+



 %"

 +

 



 (%

&   %

 



&# #$

%"

 '"



/

%  #

  

 "

#+

##$

0  

& 

% ## # +



   !  "

#  #

%$



/#&

4    #

$

/& 



#$ &   /#(# % ($ /&      &#+

 (% (# "

#$& &#

 $

( 

 

/%+

#&# &  &

# 5    

/

%

&/ (#  

# %&

  & 

/ & &

  

 "

#

(% /&  #

"     / &+

! #/  

#$   

/

 

"  

/  / +

4

 (%

(#  %& 0&    " 

 & 

&+



 #

   

<

/&

+

 (%  

(  % % /&  "

( %% % # 

$     ($  & 

% % 

 &  



/&

## %

&+

  %$   

/& & 

+

4 

 (%

#



&%

);(#

%  8&# =  #   >+ 8++=



 7:

<  -<+

$ /

%$    

(  

 $ /#/ +



)$ (%

&  (

  ##% # #

 #$ 

+

  &##$ # /   

%$  &  

/  /   

  /



#&



%& &(& &2&

#

/ &  (

+

 #

& 

 %

#&

 /#   &(&

% # &2&  #

$

 /# & 

% ## # 

-

/ /# #  &

##$

 $

%+

 " /&

  $



%#  (1 

& 

  %#+



 (% #   



   (

/

% )?6! / %% *+'<



-+ + ##&

6 7893:

& %#0+

 %#

#& &



%

 +

    # 



# *+.,.

., # 

#



# +., .,<+

@

%& <   ##

  #$ +.

  ## +

%#0

  

 "

# /   ##

"

/ 

&

 0 

 +

1   (

 

 (#  

/#(#+

 # $  #& %

%$

#/

/#(#+

    $ ( %(

" 0 

 (% 0& 

 % %+  

  

/%  #$

#

 /

.

% ## # 

  # 

#  %   "# &  %# 

 %&  0  (#$ & #

  ##  

  +  #

&% 8&# =  #   >+ 8++=



 7 : /# (# #$  $ &#

( +

  & 

&% /

  #$ #

%% *+'<

 ( "

-+ + ##&

6 7893: 7

  

:

& %#0 #% 

   

#&

  ##  # "

( "

  ( % #$ #% 

   &+

 

 $

 &

  %

/    #&

% #$

%    

%

  %%(

/ ( #  + # $  +



%

##

 +

/&  

6 7893:

 

/

$    



# # +

,

  # $   ## 



&

%#0

 +

%#0 

% #$

# &

/#

& 7'A  6/:

# 6  

& 

 "

#+

 '  ##

# 



/

 +

% #$

%    / "

##

 

  &+

 1  %$ %#

+

 %$ "     $



"

/

  # 

 &  

 +

 #

/% &# 

#

$

 /# $

/#%



  ##$

& ##$ /

& 



##B 

C+

  +  #



++

.

  0

!0    3  + ($ &



/$

# 



"

##

# 

 % % ##$ #

% "



$

 

##

& &

2

&

&(& 

& ($ /##& #/  #

&2&

% 5  

 #

 #   #

" 

#   % 

( %



+D (/ 0  /#

 



/ 

  /  (&

&(& &

&2&

# 

1& /##&

/& 

+



   

  

% $  

 &

%$

/



 

 

/# " &#$ & 

# 

#

=+)+8+E& 7:

/# ## #

#  & & #"&  " # #   +

 

& !0  ! 7 ##$:+

&   & 7!0  <: 

&# +

& 7!0  <:

 /   

 !0  ! 7##$:

/# ##

  " /&

  $





((#$   0

 (1 

& 

  %#

# &

 +

   #

&

5  

/  # $

% #$ #& 0 / $

;

%

%(#  #

&# (# +



)$ % /#

   

$



/ ##$  

(# # 

%$ #

% / 2# $ # %

$

%

& $&  +

  /

(# #  

  

/& &# (#   #

&

  

%

(# 0  &

$ + (# "'    /

 # &$

 / & %&$+

 /

$  

0 0 #

&# (#

&

! 0%# #& %(

"

  (

& % 

  & /  

 &  "'   #

(# #&+

 ##

(

& ##

 & # "

#$ %# 



$

/#&

+



)$ %   /

%

 

 ## &# (#

   #



 /+

5 #$ "&      

(/ 

%



##&

 B

7:

(# #& ## #

 

   ##

7(:

& ## 



$ # 

  &  ##   /

&

7 :   ##

## (# #&

  ## #  # "

 &    + : !$    !  "

#

##  (#

(# #&      &

$ + *  +

: /66;

   < 6 %(

-

: 746;

%