Alka Jain And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others
!" #$%$!&' (
)' *+) , ,,- *+) , -+
!""#$ %&" ' ""( ")$*$ "+""
' ,$-" . "/"( "0"#$ %&" ' 1 ,,- . /0 ,
) "0 $" & "##)3"
4 51. 4 51. " ( "
(+ " & +$ ' 6 ' 3"$ $ "& /#" 3"$ $*)"3$ " ''&5$ $*)"3"
" &7 ''&$8(" "$*)"33"/)" "
9 &"7" %"# +'3"/)' " $ 3 ' 4"& "% "' " 4 "% "' " 451.$(&34"& "'
!"
# $#
%&''& (
)
#'(&&*(&'
'+&$'& (
,-
-
!./ 0,,1 !
-
&(&2'& ( (&('& 2
, 3,
'+ ''& #
&4&$'& $
, !5,
'+ ''& # 1 *
- !./ 0! 5
6
)2#&+* ((&
3, 3, - "
-1
,1 7,5
0 !
0,,1
,
!6 ) '%$&*'&''
*
5,7
!
8
- 9
7, :
1
) $ " '& 4 51.$ "( "'
, 3, " "0" " 1.,11:,-" ' " :;:<1:,<$()"#" '&" "' "##" 0%$ &#' ") ( "%# ' 4 5,. " (7 & &$ " "
(" &"#&#"'#' && ""$"3& "$ ""&" " 3'1,=:7 +" $" #%"3" #'""'1,=:7+" "#)0
" ""$ " (&3) &&#+ 3 "'' "%> #+ ' 11,:,??:$ " (&"3 ' ( "#' ' && $6@A-:.',??: '$& (&"3"##3"#+&&# 45,. "$&3'
*%3 #&+$ 7" && "" ' ,<<A 7 +" "#)0 "%"&"""' 1" -<17 +" "#)0 "%"&"""' -$0"#' '"&7$" " ""0(&# "0" $"0"3"
1.,11:,- $ &#'
")$ " 3)451.$"( ()")3'%"# + "0" " 1.,11:,-$( 3)451.$"( "
""$"&& "&3 ##+&&$" $ (+ 6(&# ") "
7"0) ")45,. !0 3 0 %!&% !4 %%$5& 63 0 $& " 0. 3$%!70 6! %&! 6 8$ "$ &6 990!90$ !:7 %3&& ;70 <
- "##+$ 6( %"# +' 3"/) '45,.$%5"5% %"# +'45?" 45 1.$ ( 3 "#+ "# %"# + ' "&7
& )" ' "0" " 1.,11:,-B45;C$"0" 3"
"& &' 6$"$ &%#+&" 45=$" 45< .
3"+"'3"/) "(%&&#$ 3)'3 '"&3$ ""# ' "0
$"0(&3 $ ) *"#0'
+' && $ #" "
"#)0 &5
6@A-:.',??:B45=C$(' 6 0 B "C$ 6"'3"/)&"#%" (%"BC "")"
,-' % &$"(&"33"
$ (%"BC0 '"4"& "'$ "
#3"#+ &
3 0 0 &' 1=$:::>5
#;
1
- , , "
,1 ,
,
6
-
!;
,
, <,1 8 ! 0,1
7
,
, -5*
8 .
- '&&2 1
1
=, ,
>, "
1
, - -
-
1 =-
>,
-
!. ,
, -
, ,
>, "
3, 7
,
!8, 1
, 1,
-, 8
1 %% %40,1
, -
,
3,
3,
1 1,
-
1 1-?8 7 1 / 1 @
- , !6
,
;
3,
,
,
,
-
1
,
3,
, A
,
-,
1 1
1
,
3, ;
, @, , -
0 1- ?8!"
,
)'B#
-
3,
)
, -
, -;
)
1- , -, 1 -
-
, C
-
, !
, '&&
,C
, +
,
, && 2
, 4
=
"
&& 2
,*
+
.
3,
,*
4
.
3,
10
,
, 1 '' + =!# ## =! 2(2
=!
1 4'+%
1 #$$#
1 "
,*
+
,*
.
3,
1 ,B6 @ ,
,
1
,
3,
"
, 1
)'B#
,
3,
- ,
)#
:
=
'$ 3 "&' "(%4"& (%"BC$
"&& % & "0(+ 6B45=C$"( " BC $ "#") #" "(# "3#+ >"3" "#3" %# % " +"1::A$" ""'&%) "#& "$ +0 "+%)') $#" ) &5
$" $ " $" + #) & )&#"3#''7" )' "&7
& )
'$ ( (%#+ "&7
& )>'&"BC$"(&"3#"& +",?A?" ,??:" &7 "0" " 1.,11:,-B45;C$ " (&"3 3"
+" 1:,-$ (&"3 # &%#+ ) &45=$" 45<$"(&"33"
"#(+ 6 " &03"
30 ' &5 "& "$ 0" "#
#"#+$0 "&7 & )$"(&"3#"& 3'&." ;' " &7&$,A?.B "' ' &"## " D&',A?.DC$" "0" " 1.,11:,-$ ( (&"3 # $ &%#+ ) &45="
45<$ (+ 0 $" & ")" %"# +' " "&7 & )"0##"")" "
"0" $(&3 ##+
(+ & #'
C,
;
0 (&3)
(+
& # '
C,
"
"BC &&3% " & #$ 3#+ )"(') "0 $ ) *"# 0'"+ 0%$ " &&3%) #+ '" & #'
C,
$"3 #+ (+ &5 6@
A-:.',??:$" 6@-=,1'1:,.$0 $ &%#+ &&#%" ( )% &B45=" 45<C$ (&"33"
(+ 6" )") & "##)3" "&7 & ) " "0" 3"
1.,11:,- B45;C$(" "&3 ##+35& "% " 35& "% 7 ( &" )3$( 7 "43 #"+&$(3 $""3"$ "&3 ##+'%#
$"& (' 6 < "
" "3 "+""3)
" && $ " 0 & # ' 6@ -=,1 ' 1:,. (' 6 ) "
&3"
" 0 B45<C$ 6 "
) &%+ 7" "+ "##) )" ) 3"3BC' #" #" $ 3"
"&&#$ " "
353"3BC ' #" #" $ " () "
"(# (+ && $ ) 3%) " "
""
#&"(' " &76##&&& %$ ) " #""#(&"3" 0 B "C$#") ")3 3$' ('' #" )
% " &" & 1. B1C ' ) " 63 "" " "&+" &7$ "(#""
#3 &$ 1:,-$ " 7" "# #"& "&7
& ) D&',A?.D( " #""#(&"39&
(+ 6 %$" #""#(&"3" " 0
"
") 5&3 #"& ' 3" "+ "+
%")"' D&',A?.D$(+ " #"0" &&# ( %"%" %")$ '$ " #"0""# 9& #"#+$& "##)"##& &' "0" $" 3"
1.,11:,-$(+ " &76##&&& $"&) "& D&',A?.D (&"39& A
#+ #' " & 0 & (&"3 )"
" 0 #" #+"+ 35 3"3BC &' #" #" $" ' "&
353"3BC &' ""' #" #" $ () &"%""(# " #+ (' " &7 6##& && '$ "( & '3 & $0 " %+ #' $ (&"3&"%" "& (+ $ ) ""
""
#&"() (' " &7 6##& && " )" $ " "
+ '& ' " &7 6##& &&
B45?C$"3"
3' % &45<$"3"
(+ 6$ %"#$ " " &76##&&& $ 0 ( #"#+ )" "+ " + 3"/ &&BC "0" $ "'4"& 3"$ 9& &#"3' 7"#"' #" $"(&"3 "&7 "##"& "&7 & ) /
,
,
3,
3,
, "
, 1 /> #> +>!
-
-
,
- 1 , 1
3,
5;,
-
.
2#&+
((&
, 1 $$2 3-
, 1 $$2 3 -
* ,-
1
C , %
,
,
, 1#2D='%DB &D= 'D 7
#+
#&D= 'D %D= 'D2D=4D &D= 'D E
) #% 2D= +D 7
'&+ 'D= &D 7
'&%"
=
,
' %& 3 +2+ 3- +#%4 3 !
1 ,
1
1
C , %
,
,
' %&D='D +#&& 3 5
-
3,
,
- ,
3,
-
7-
?8
!""#"$ !#" !$ !
! !%!$ "%&"'$:
?
" B4 5?C ' " &7 6##&&& $"3"
3' % &B45<C$ 0 & (&"3 " (+ 6$ 0%3"& "##) $" $ ' "&7 &&#% " ( ) ''& #"#+ ''&"#>''&$"+ " +$0 045,.$
"0)45,.$" #+("& 3" "' 6 %$&45?0" "03' % &B "C$ 3"
(+ 6$ '$0 ""(%" $"&7( ) " &&#% ''& 7#$ #+ 3 + "%"#"(#
0"3 )45?$ "3% " 45,-"/)'%0'45?"#0 4 5? "&7) ( ) " &&#% ''&$ ' 3")
& "##) $" 6##&&& $ &# 3 3(#+ %0 4 5? ''+) " ' 3"/) "(% &'3 '"&3$ " 9 &&' " &76##&&& $' #%" $ (+ 6 ) 3"/)" $"&3 45<$ 0 (&"34& "& (+ 6##&&& $ $ #(&"3& "##) (' 6$0"(%0"(#$ ""(#+ (+ " &76##& ) "0) 45,. ,, ! ""3"+$+"
" "45,." & & +"(#+)"& 6 " ") "+#)"#'&45,.$ '"+"&"/) #"/ 45,.$" (+"+''&>''&"#' && $"#"&7""'& "&"/) ()( &#"(#$""#(&3)"&" (+3"#"' " () "& "&"/)0(+ 3" "'45?$ 0 & (&"3 "0&#+3' % &B45<C$" (&"33"
(+ 66@-=,1'1:,. ,1 &$ 3 ) "451.$ "") & & 45?$0 & 3" 5& "##) $" "(&"33"
(+ " &7 6##& && $ &%#+ 3 '
4 5=$ " 4 5<$ " 0 " "(% " (&"3 #"#+(0 $0 "+9 &$3"/&& #") ""( #") 3' #" #"
'$ "(% 3 3(# %0 '$ " ) 45,.$&"(&3&"& (+ 6
,- "'3" $ (%#+ 0 6 4&' 3"BC'5%"# +'45?"
451.$ "03'45=" 45<$ %5"5% 4 5,. " (7 )"
& &$ " 3"
(+ 9 &"##+ &3 ''&$ $((%#+ 60# ")& &45 ?" "#451.$ "45,. ,. !' ")$ 3 "
""#5"## (%"B "C$"3"
(+ 6"% &B45 =C$"(&"3 "0 "
0 $0 & ( ) #) $ &3 ##"&/') $#" ' &#"3"+) "& '#") #" '3"&7"
0 & 3'& #" #" ()&&#+ & $ "0" ' " &76##&&& ,= "'3 "(%$""(%" $ 0 & & "##) "&7 & )( "& "##) %"# +' "0" 3"
1.,11:,-B45;C$ ""#"
+ (&"3&#& )#+ (+ 6$ ) &%#+3"/)
&45=" 45<$ 0 B "C %$0 ""(%" $ 0""&5 $ (+ )&&3% & # '
C,
3#+ ) ) "0 ) )"#0'+ ,; 67#+$"' 3) 0 $+& "0 &3 ##+'%#" "#"35&
"% '$ "# ' '%# " 35
& 0 (' 6$ 6 3'"
"
""'"''3)451.$3 43 #"+&'
=:$:::>5 " & "## ( ' 0
0 "' 9"(" "+"" ) 6!" &" /,,-2 /-+ (
/"%) @ "/)>"
> @ "(# >