High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13203/2022disposed of

Kala Singh v. Union Of India And ORS

2024-09-30Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma19 pages

!"#$%

! &!' !"$%

(" )*( ++

+ ,

)*( + ++ + (

!"

# $

% &&&& +

+ ,

- '

(

)

*+ *, -*--. / 0'1

# 2"

(""

)

3"#

.'/&.0.'12 &!

-

( " )

# *5 *6 -**' "# ! # ', '- -**'

*,# *+

( "" # '7.71

#.!1 # ""

(9

/ # #:

(

" "#

!

#

!

) -* ; .*50'*;1 "

"#

# ) -*;.''0'<;1

""

"#

" ) "

$= .

1 4" ) )

#

>

!

# ) !"

"

$= .

'6 *?

-**7 (

"

""

-**7

( # )

""

'7-*-'

# 2"

(""

"

( "# !

*+ *, -*-- ( !

*+ *, -*--

"

!

! "

! #

$

%

#

"

"

!

" & " '

( )& (* "

"

"

"

!+ <

#

0# !

.1

# 2"

( ""

)

$ ,

"

#@ !

4"

)

)

A

""

.-**-1.# 1-**?

( !

@

/

"

""

0

!

#

"

)

# "

( !

"# "

$ " "

&

, !

&

"

& !-

& &

.

"

&" &

&

&

"

"

!/ "

"

! &

"

"

"

" & "

" !

!

@ & "

" && &

& & " "

" " "

"

!

2

#

@

"

) "# $

% 9 # A " 0!

121 " "

""

& " "

!

! !

" # $

"

"

!

% & ' (

!

!

)

" !!

"

*

% $ " $ $

!!

(!

!

$

"

$

$

! "

!!

" $

*

%

3! 4!

$

" $

$

$

$ $

$ $

$

!

$ $

$

"

!

$

+!

$ !

"

$

$ $

$

,

-

$.

$ !

$

! "

# & "

" ,

"*

0

" "

$.

$

$

"

!

!!

& '

1

! !$

!

$ $

" !! $

2

!!

$

$

" "

$ $

?

B) #

"

! A

""

.-**-1.# 1-**?

# )

" #

" #"

8

( '

+

" >

# "#""

+

#

!

>

# / 0' ) " "#

#

"# # ) " @"" #

"

C "

C

#

'*

( ! )

"

# ) "

"

, #

" > '- '* -**'. / 0 -1 )

) " "

) # "

"

#

) "

"

)

# >

.1 "#

!

#

''

#

#

"

# # # #

"# "

# !

> #

"

!

#

"

# " /#

# #

# !

) " # "#

>

!

> # !

)

"

# # "# " # # C

# "# " "# !

#

'-

)

>

# ) " #

# #

)

#"

"

#

# @"

)

# !

# "!

/

# # " /# "##

"

" > "

@ "

#

"

""

) " # >

# " "

" >

"!

" "# #

# "

1

!

1

D "1

# '7

)

"

# !

"!

# #

# "

" >

# #

"

#

# @"

>

#

) " " !0E0!

) " "

# "

#

"#

! ) " "

"

"# !

#

>

) )

""

'<

!

"

#

""

#"

#

# >

"

""

# > "

3 " $ # "" "

" 2 "

# #

)

"

""

! #

#) # "

!

# # ) "#

"#

"

',

"

!

"

)

#

)

"# !

"# !

#

'5

# "

# )

# !0E0! # #

"

#

"#

# #

"# "

#

# #

# "

"

" " "#

!

# "> #

"

4#

F3

/$ " 4 * 5

6

78 , * 0 ( !

"

"

35!

,

) 6 $ "

"

&

" &

"

"

" 1"

378

! # & "

"

"

"

" ' & 0593: 1// 0;4! "

"

!/ "# "

"

!< =%& 0>"?! @

1 & !

" "

" " !

5! /

" " "

"

&

!

< 0> ?! /

" &

*

&

* &"

!<0>"?! /

"

&

"

#

!<0>"?.

/

& &' 1// :A

3773 B : 6 A :

;

9 5

"

! 47!

C

& "

#

!

'6

"!

.1

!

"

"

" )

"# # #

"# "

# ) "

-* ; !

" # # > ! #

#

>

'?

B

#

# #

"# "

# ) "# )

> #-*;# # !

> " #

"

"

"

"#!

#

( " "#

4

' &

0593: 1// 0;4! '+ 2

#

# !0E0!

"# # #

"

# ""

" )

"#

" "#

)

!

# )

"" >

.1

# > # #

"

#

# !

!

)# > .1!0E0!

""

#

"

#0"

"# "# !

!

"

""# "

""

" " G ")

!0E0!

""

> > # C

# !

#

-*

#

"#

" .1

"

""

1

# ""

"

""

#

# "# "

" !00!

) ) "

) "# ""

# "#

1

# > "# ""

"

# #

#

# "

-'

2

# "

" !

# " /#

""

# "#

# )

# !

.1

" >

"" --

!

" #

" )

)$

0

HA

".

1 -**-%H9 #

" H

-7 ( )

# )

#

!

" )

# #

#

# # " /# # !00!

"# " #

#C)

#

"#

)#

!

>

# #

"

)

" /

0

C

#

@"

!00!

"

!

##

) $ # ""

) >

# "

)

"# !

#

-< >

#

" )

" "

#@

"!

"

"@ "

!

# #

# "

" > !

"@ "

" " ) #

"# "

!

# #

# "# "" >

>

# @ "

) " ) #

"#!

#"

#

$

#

" >

# @"

"""

""

# " "

#

#

# !

"

> "

!

C

" # )

) ""

" "

!

"# "

# !

"

" " )

)

-,

F) )

! $ >

"

"

"# !

) #

# "

# "

#

( !

"

!!3& 4

0565!.

765'.03.65!./5 !8 5!

D

6( - 69 :

00! $ E &

A F%03 G F%03 3;! -

- '

! !!3& 4

/!

006!/65'.03.65!./5 !8 / &

, B * @(/(/ADH*I$*/J$(/A/(* 0!

$ " % " 6H 3!

/

" " & &

& 6

"

"

( !

"

" .

& !

" & " !

4$ % '

@(/(/ADH I I H /J$(/A/( I I H

0 /

" &

"

" **

&

" !

9%

$ $ !

/

" &

* *

!!!!

9%

$ $ !

/ " *'*

&

!

;<-=<->+<?

-<<+< * 9- @ :4@++4A -5

/ 0' "

#

# @"

"# #

#

" .1 "

F3 /$ " 4 * 5

6

7!8

" # ) " )

"#

# #@ #

" )4# .1

#

"

) > > !

) !00!

(

#

! "

# "# "

F)

" ! "

" " !00!

"

# "

"

! # #

, "@"

"""

" > .1 ) #

"# !

#

"# "

#

"#

!

) >

# "

) #

) " "#

!

"#

#

-6

F) / 0- "

"

# !

"

.1

"

! "

# .1

$ " !

)

# " " / 0- $" " "

"

#

" >

"

#

$ > " # #

> "

"#!

#

5!.0 9/:5 & / -?

# $ #

)

) ! !

# )

-+

( # . / 0'1>

)

""

"

/

"

#

!

"

F3 /$ " *1 * 5

6

+

7 8 * 0 ) B '' ) "

/

& "

" " &

" "

& ! 00!C "

"

"

"#

"

# !"

" - .

&

"

& !

(

- # "

,

&

&

" !

"

& " " & &

" ! = "

$

% =

!

$

$ "

$ $

" !

- % "

&

" !

3 7*

( !

" # )

# #

"

#"

"

" .1 .1 4+

+ ,

4+ + (8 $% @!

:/: ;.15!2< .

! < :/: ;

/.=0 <