High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7248/2021dismissed

Charan Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2021-12-13Mr. Justice B.S. Walia11 pages

!"#

$%# !"# $ %" &'%( &% )*# %

) +++++ $ %"& ,- . % # *( / 0#) 1)##)%((. 2 3% # % 3 # 4*5 + 6 ##

) # #3 %%( 4*5 +76 /

/ 1(( ##3 4*5 +6## /

, - 8# ( # %) 1 95+ 3)!# !" ( "( 7::

# 1 % 3 # .1 .3%(" 1(# ( ;0$ 7##

# +00) 7) /)) )

0#:+< 95%(* #()+ ) *3 (( # # *3= # 3 = #

(= (( =#5%(3() ( # *3= #$8(1& # <=3

#" ! )(# %

#! # 34*5 + 6%#".(#*##(' # ) *3## :

) 3 3%3 %# 7.#%. $

+# ( #

3%3 %# 3 # +000) 3%3 %# .#%. $

+# ( # 3%3 %# 3 #:+< 95%(*# # 3%3 %# 3 # %. $7

+# ( # 3%3 7#. #

0 1 (( 3%3 (. "#) %# # (#. # ". %# #(" 3%31## ,- 8# (#% # % 3 %) %# ) ((. " )#3#% 3##4*5 + 6 ## /

1 :

# # %%( # #3(1#3#".*%%((* . %###4*5 +76##/

/> ) % (#

/) #$ (/ !" ($ (( 1%%( # #(.1#3# 3 "# ". %# # # 4*5 +6 ## /

, - 8# ( ## 3% # # #3( 4*5 + 6 ## /

"# ((. %1 = # %)(# ) 3.

(1(##1".?@"( %3 (#A

) )%1 3( #( 3#3()3(# =###1 ((1#".< A @) )A ! "

## @) )A

$ %"&'( )*+, ! @) )A - @) )"# ## #1%1("(3% .%(. #3(8# ( ##% # ( ! $ -. @) :

: ### :)#A ! @) )(3 % %1 " ## 3 $ ( / !" ( $ (): " % # #3(1(%$ (//+* !"($ (B( 3)# .@) 3%(. 1 (# %# # %"# 3% ((.# #3()3. %." ) %$ (: !"($ ()%1(# % ## 3 .@ )*%%((1(($(* .##= 1 # # 1 3) %( # ".

%11. %) )3% ##1 .3# $ (/ !"($ (1(( (1(##1A ! / .

3% ##1("("##%# 1((2 (" ,7- 8#**C) !")#3(. %%# %( # 3% # # # 31((2 (" 8#**C# %1%(# # %##4*5 $+6##

;0$ 7##

0#:+< 95%(*) ) *3 # ! #( #.

((

1 1 # "( 1 1 %((. # ". % . 0% C( () <# $ ) *3 # # 4*5 $+ 6 ##

1 %! #3( #%3(%# %# 3 > ) % 1 %(# # % 1

#4*5 $+6##

(3 ;0$ ## :

# / )95*)#)*3?1)%1 # ". % . 0% C( () <# $ )*3#

###

# #".

# 9# 7 < 4*5 $+ 6) ##

8 % 1 # ". (# *##( ' # ) *3 # ! # 3 4*5 + 6 1 % % 1 #3# 3##4*5 $+763 !" ($ (/ 46 "2 (.)#%#".?@"(? ##

73(*%%(

+<+

% 1(#"( 3('()*3?1)%%( (# ".% #4*5 + 61!#".% .

0%C( ()<#$ )*3##4*5 $+/6##

/8=1)% (#".% 1!#".0%C( ()<#$ )*3) # 3 " 3 "# # # ## /

> ) % (# + 3+3. % " C( () !")# )11(!#". 3% . > 3( %%( (#". % 1 #3#".?@"(? #### /# ! # 3 ##".(#( 1 %(## . "# ((# > %) % 1 ! #( #. # 1 (# 3 ( '() *3 : 3%( 3%3".= %# ((.

# %)" # ##% ('()*3 ,/- 8# **C # % 1 #3# 3 3( (( (" 3 = # 1 1 (" 3%(.# ". 3 3 = ( () 11(# (.".(#( ) 1 % "( % ) (( %(#33 3) #% " 33" #%(# ) ! # 3 ##".(#( 1 %(#".?@"( ? #8 (#".

%1#3#".?@"( %3 "#%1 (."(# ,- D2 .

%# ". %# )

*5 +7 ## /

/ %# ". *%%(( * . %#)1((*5 +## /

%#". $(* .)#3 %%(## %(# # #3(".1. %. 3 .)(# (#%#( (( #3% ##? # 1 % ( 1 (# " 2 # 3( # 3% ## "%#(." )% $ (/ !"($ (): )31"1#". .1 #% $ (4 6 $ (/ !"($ (" 1 %#" %(# %?@"( %3 #%# # 3%3 % % 3 1##) % 1

(#8# ((% % # ?@"( %3 / - % # "& # #(.>3%# # #+ E !"#$%&'!% !&(& &#& $) % $!$)'$#&'%&$#*!+"% ,-&%%%& % %$! &%&!+"*&$)$(% ** #% +#!$% ** #% '$ ! #$% .%&$#! % ( %& '.&%%! +" % &$# $% /# & $) % *' & '&'(%#'&#$& % 0&- $% #$%1%&)&!&# 1'%&#-% *"$)% ** #%*&(& "$#% -$#!$) ! "#! '

$#% *%$)% ** #%&#.%&$#&#-% $!$)%(&#%&$#*!$# &#*%&%&$#)& !&# % " F

, - * % ( %%( # #(. (# ( 1%4*5 +/6(% # (# (1. ( % ?@"( !" # ?. ? " 1 ## # ( % # % !" ( $ () 1 % % ( 1 %%( # #. #(. 1

(#; )% ( % % %( %=3 #%3(.) 3 3( ## ( 3#3( 3 $ ( / 46 !" ( $ () : 1 # A / ' * ) #(.) # % 1 = # 1( % # #3()113#.2 33 $ (/ 46 !" ( $ () : ) (=1) #3( # # " %# ((. " 1 = # %1(#&#!$-%&$# (1 (# #1 ". A0 # (# 1 . . 2 @)*0$:G? #?@"(*%5 0#

@' * #<! # 3 ?@"(? A / '

* ) % ## 3( % #) ) (#"3#" #3(1 #A ! - @)

%' ,:- 0 ## "3 (# ( %

, - *#3#(.) % 1 # # # # 3%3 7.%#( ! # 3 4*5 + 6 ## :

# ( #(( (" 3 =)(# = # 5%( # 5%(# # 1 (" #3 =)#. )"#1(" ! ># #%#". (#*##(' # )*31 %(#".?@"(? )1((?@"( %3 #% #1 3%3 3%# % 3 1 # 3 *5 + #".!( ,- D# #3(4*5 + 61%#".%# /

>31 %(#".*%%((* .# # 4*5 +76 ## /

/ ". %# $ % ! %%(4*5 +761#3# ".( .##4*5 +6## /

> %1(#"(

73(*%%(

+ <+

(( #3( 3( %%( / ". ? # 1 = #. # # ## # (# 3('()*3 : # 3%3 1## ?1) #% =( (## (#%.

/# 3 "#3#.

)#" "((( . /) % ## #3 %%% (( 3% ###3(#%%# 3 ." (35 # (( # 3% # #3( # % 1 (# "

2 # 33( > #(. . (( 3% ##>% (# . 1 %# ".

3 = ! # *( (( 2 ( 1 (#

)" 35%1(=(." 2 # " 1 2 # #

*( #% 1 #%% (1% ! # 3(# %".%" 1 5#. #(. . (( 3% # # # ! "( 5%( " #(.)%" # 3 % (# ". 3 4*5 +/6##

/1###( # # %)0 # # . # 1 1 3% # # # #(. . ' # 3 ?@"( %3 A / # * ) %%("(" #) %%((1 ##%12 #". " )%12 #".. #1 %(# %?@"( %3 , - 0 ' ( ) $!!

* + , !'

-../ 0/1

$ 23-& 1 % (# ". % (( 3 #(. .1#3#".<)". (. % # < ?@"( %3 $!!

* ,'+ , ' , !'

) '" '" , !'

4 562/ $7 ! 5..2 $( 5 3 %# # #+

2 *'& (!" *$&!! &# %&' & #$% &#%#!! %$ *! '$(* % " % ($! $) $+%&#&#- &) +" # '%&$# &# '&& '$%$%$!#"!)#' -&%&(% "$*#&#' '%&$#/% +# (! ' ($ % # $#' % % % *$ %$ -& &) #!

%&' &!&'%&$#"*$ &&*'& "%&#% '$) *$ %$ & &% &# % #% $) (#!( ($#- % (%%

% 0&- $% &- % " %3 &#%$ '$#&!%&$# &# % 4'&$)% %!&'%&$#&% ! "(!+"% --&!*%"&# 3&#-% &*'& (!"#!

%4'% &)$&% 555555 2/% & #$% " #$ & &% !&+ %$ " !$ # #" )$ #& ** &'%&$#/%(" $ +%%!-# % %&)% +##$#+ ! "% '$%$- %#$%$!&#& "%$ #!&%&!%$ *%"+"% &4%$!&#"(!"$)(#!(5 555555 2 *$&&$# $) % &(&%%&$# '% !$ #$% '

** " %$ % -#%&#-$) &)#! %&' 0$ % (4&((*&$!)&4! +"% -& %% %&( &% &#

% &)+"&%&#'&& '$% (% + +$- % (" $!&#& " + %3# %$ + $#+ %#!! +"

! " &# 3&#- (!" #! %&' '# + (! $%("'$#&!% ! "#$#+ #&)&%& % # % *&$! $) &(&%%&$# *'&+! )$ '&& '%&$# )$ % (!" +%

% ! " & ($ % # % & *&$! &% & ($%

"+*$*)$% '$%%$ $ !% %&%&#$#+ 5 ,- > # <(( <@ 4 %6 1 ((1# ". ?@"( %3 8 "9#', !"#', , !'

) '" , !'

4 56:.& $7 ! 6;6 ( ". 9(+' # < ?@"( %3 *! , !"

<!, !# = "*," !# 5662051$-;>&11(# ? (# "(# % 8=1 < ( (# % # ?@"( %3 (""( ','+) $!!

*% ! ? ,!'

& 9 '() $!!

*+@!'

56:-$ -.2.&(#% 2 # 3 (% 1.##"#3# # #(. , - . 5%( " = ! # . % 3% # #>1%# (.

# #(.# ( 0 $ %"1 ,?

5> 5- -.-5 61# %=

# H %"( H