Satnam Singh v. State Of Punjab And ANR
%)% IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH 207-2 %%&'(')%&*&+ ,- -.
1 '* *3 & &*&+
/ 00 0
04 0
!"# # " 3 4
!
'+
# 3 .
5
!
' /
3 6
.
'+
#
# "$
- # , #
! " #$% &#'( '
)&)! ## "
*#$% +, !
! + #
, # 0$.
, "& " " ")#$% %
-.
/
- #
(
,#(
#( 0$. ,
# ( 1 /2
!##
,, ( !
%&%
,!
# !8 , ! 4 , 2 1 / 2
! ! # 4 ! , ( ! 5 9 ,
,
# ! ,+,# ! 5 5 ( 7
( 8 , !
,, !
9
,
, #
(
, # #( , # #
#( ( , ! + ! '
# ! 8 , , ((
( - (+ !
#
!
# !8
2 : 4 , 8 , ( (
(( ! 4
, # ##
/ ( '# , # 0$. +,
, ,!
'# ,
# # !
,
# ( -5
: / , , ,,
)'3 , # 1 / 2
!# # 4
, # 4 8 ,! ;
,!
( ,! 9, , ! 4
, 6
( $ ( !
( , ,
, #( ( ( ( !
( 0,#, #
%'% ( ! # !
(! 5 ( - #
5
/ 2 , '
, , # 5,
( "
$
( + #( ( , #+, # ,
#% #, #
,!##
" *# $%! < * #!,!
# =$ # # ( ((
! > >
6
! , ! # - /
# ( 6 #
, # (( !
!
! ) ?'9 @ !, / +, ! ( , ## + #(
< 5, # % 3 6
' '
/
##
3 ,'+
#! # ' ## A % # A ( #
( # ( ( !
! ) ?'9 @
%+% $,# (( # # /+, 6
# $+, , <## * '3 1
/ +, $
#
#',<##
/
" ?@#% % #%( -
(
# #
"
B & - "
! #(, * #!,!
# =8 #
( ! % * /+, , + ,!
! -#
(
#
#( '
$ 1 /
,
% #
!+ +( (
# 2,+! #
# /
(
! + ! < * * #( !+
(
+ , " ?@ ?@?+@% % B
%(% * ' #( , #+, + #8 , # #
,# (/ -5 2
# (/ !
!
#,!
, #+ (( (# ' ### " *#$%!
, , # 0$.
', ( +
# , #
# % # ' 4 ,
( !
( + * & &*&+
$
(
# * , , # # # (
"
! , , (
(
! %.3 3 "& 5, +!#
(( + !
$
(
;
##
" *#$% +
+ ! $#
! 9 ,, ## # #(
, ,, # !
# # 8 , 6 5# (+ ! +
(#5,!# .
!
+(#( $#
-5 ,# #
%5%
# 2 (( # ,,
1 # ( ( / -
(
,( # ,! 6
# !
##
5 # ( ( 6 6 9 # #
(+
( # ( 6
, ;
6 / +, -# , + !
+ 9 ##
# :
+( ( ,
, ' ! (
, ( #
$/ 2 +
!
5#
(
! # (! -5 +
!
!
5#
(
'( #+ ( (8 ,!
#
( /
# ! - (
(5
2
, - ,
( C
, ##
+ ( #
## # # ,#
( #( # -
!
! # #
%6%
!
##
, $#
( , # 2 , D 2
,5 5,
#
, + * "
1 # %
! ! #
#
! ! - ,
6 ( ( 5 -5 / 2 + + #,!
5!# #
#(% !
, #
2, +!
+ ( + # ( +#
+ #( ! ,
, # / , !
, #
,
( ) $ + # #
,
+
, ,(
'
#(
#0$. ,
# ( (# 1 / 2
!# # # ( 5, , (( #
)'3
# 8 , ,
/ ( ! + + (8 , < ( -5 ( # + ;
%7% 5
!8 4 ,! - # 8 ,
9 ,4 , 6 #
#4
,
, #( # ! !
( ! (#
2 , '
'
+## " *# $%!
;
!!
+ + (8 ,#( (/ # ( !#+
( -
#
5 ( # !,
## + # '( , #/
2 ,
+
!
5#
(
! # (! :/ -5 +
!
5 #
(
9 # #
1 # %
!+ # * "
# ( 5 9
#
# (
# ( .
!
! #
/
!
( ! + $ # * "
( ##
#
%3%
!
+ # # ( - , (
+ +# ! , # # # (#
! ,
-5 2
#!# - ! #, ! , !
+, ;
! 5!,
/
!
5
!
#
(( ( # (( ##
" # $% '
'
# (( # ##
* # $% !
(( (
,# ( / -5 2 , - ,
( 6E
(% ! ( # , #
(
!
"
! #!, + !( = - #!, #
(
5
! ,!
- , +#
9
# # ( # ( F
( ( - #
, #
!
+ , (( ( + % # ,G
##
F - #
##(/ F
%)*% + - #
>5 ( ( ##
+ C
+ ( !
/ #/ , ( , ,
,(
+ $(
#, #
# ,( , ## , , + , #
+ - ( +
+
(
+
# - (
(9
#
-
!
(
! # " ")# $ %
! + ,
+ (
( # ((5!,
F + C , #, #
5 ! ! #
( /
# # # +, + # ( ( ( / # #
F 9 -
# ( , #! # F 0+
!
( # , +
( # , #
+ # , (
, #
( # +
#
- 9
! ,
( + + #
( # #
B
2,+!, + #
+
( # ,+ # (+# + !#
%))% ,#/ / ,!
, #
#
( #
#
+ , ( +
# # ## " * # $% ! ! #+ #+ %.3 3 3 " $ ( + , #
'
'
, (
$( + (
+ #
# , (
9# (#
'* *3 &*&+ + (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE
Whet Whet ther speaking/reasoned ther reportable Yes/No Yes/No