Surinder Pal Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#$%&$&$
' (((
)(
(((
*"(( (+,-.,%/0"+ "( *"("!" /+-%(((%- 1!"+ (
!
+ , " 2-,", (34/ &#($5(&$6- /" 7&$%745%743%748%73%&$%7339%7$6 / #:;+"0 ""- %688 "2"/, <. ++"%" 2"( &( ",<% + ,,2 2 + " " + + " ."2"/ +!+ , /!< * 1=- "% " 2 ,* 2" ", > /% .+" +/++ "%.+.."> 2/ +" ", > /. ++"" +%.,> "+ < /" /</<" +" + / . ."/ -+"? 0"- " ( "-/-, ,<.+/". <" + >- /" " /+ + + > 8(6(&$8( +/ , .+/".
(($5 "" " + - + - " / + "2"/ (4 // &($6(&$8 .
& "2"/2 + ( "" %+ "+/, /-,2/ "-/-, " !< " " 2"2//- "/" "-/ (63%56%655@9.++,/"2" + ( -/ " "0- +- "!<- +A-> + +- "+ > /-/ .+/".+ - " +"- "-/-, ,<( #( '/( - ," "+"2-/++ "+ ! ,,< ,/ + " "-/,,2/. / !< + ( + -"+" // + + "
!+,/" !,"+,,2/"-/+/- ."! 2/,!<+",+ >,(0 "+ ,,2 + % /-2 + " +- +,/"." " 2+"- / > 2+
"< .+/"., / / ( + " . + -/ +/- "++ / < "< +""/ +. 2 <" "+.+/".,,,2/ + ('/( - , -"+"-! / + /" ,< / + >."/, 2 .+ +- / +" / "</"2" 2"2-,"!,+ "( 7( // %+! // !+, "+ + " 1- B /+ "" + "2 .+ ," 0"< ,,2 + </ +" + ", > /% . ++" " +% . ,/2/ ! 2 (4 / &($6(&$8% .++%+."/"/!",/ !,!< "/ ++ -" *9*938&$&$6:
C*;
# 0/+ "/" / &7($5(&$6:
B-"9&;%"++/ ,"/<" / / +/", 3 +( +""%+ ".""/ / ,/ +" !< + ", -"- 02 % .++ + ,,2 2 + ."++ " , "<.++/ =( ("- -+/.+/".
+ +,"+ - " 0-+"+ //0"+-/ " +,"+ + "+""0/2"% /+/+"!</"-//+B+A-"
+ < +" + ", > /. ++"
" +(.+""2" /!, +/"2"/!< + !<+/,/ "/" /!<+2+ -" +, "/+ "(*:*;(7$6&$&$/(4(&$&$:
B-" 97;"+0 2" / / +/" "+
0 +,,. 2+"" #((&$&$(-+%+
"++! 2 0/,<" / + "
/".
- 2 + 0"-,,< + ,,2 %.++ ."+-!1 "+ "0- (4/&(6(&$8% ,<.+0./ + -/<" / "/( - "+ %'/( - ," "+",/- + / - " -" + "# $%&#
#'(%& ) & %&% * %
&'
+
&+ ,- *
#.& #, /
01234 15% .++.+,/+.+"" @ " / /" /!-+"." "+ " % ,< " !,( 5( +!, "<"+ 0"+,+.0"%! /
!+,+ " .+/%+! // +
7 " + </ +"+ >%+/,,2,,< /." 2,<.+/".
+ </" " !< /-,2 "-/-, " /!< " " 2"2//- "/"
"-/ "" - (-! + % + + ,/ ""/+0,- - ""-
2 , 75$2%.++" " +,, ,"/<-! / 2 + "(+ -"+ "-/+/- @ ", ,,/2 + /-" 2 02 .++" "+ +,, "(
"-,+ % !/++" - ", 0,!, "- + " " + -/+ %,+-2+'/( - ," "+ -! / + + ", ,,/ /-" 2 02 - / ,( 4( + "2"/% '/( - , " " + /".
+ -"+++ +,, 2 + "
.-! / &&(5(&$&$%" 0, " 02 +/
! ,/ -+0 + ,2 -"+ "+/ ! ,,//-" 2-+ 02 " < -! 0 .> 2 +,,2/ , + " 0,0/%.++-! / "-,27$ + +,, "%.++"/- /"9
!
"
# $
%
5 !
!
!
!
! !
#
!!
& !
#'
! #( 3( '/( - ," "+-"+"/".
+ -" + + , 2 " -! + +,,
&&(5(&$&$+ ,2 -"+ "."! / , 3(6(&$&$ /."+"" " " + /." 2B "( +!>/" %+-! ++ +,, .,/2 + " +-""<1-> +
/ ",,<"++/! ""/ + " ,< +" 2+"/- D"" (#(&$&$1-.+
+."/"/!",/ !,!<+ +,"/+2+ -"0/ "/"+//%,"/<"""/ "7 +"/"( 8( + "2"/% + "E - , + / 0", / - " + + .+" + 02 + ,"/<! ,/%
/ "" + -/ 1-/ / + ", 2// +
"
!+ /".< ."/ 2+ < - + %.++,2,,<+-,/,,."
, +", "(+" +"2"/ +/ B -" & 6&7 %& ) & 00
4 2 #"# &'4 / '/( - , " " + ,,<",/- +,,. 2!"0 +-/2 9 #
! ! % !
) *
+% ,
!
#
#*
+ # ! ! !
! !
! # *
! !
!
# * !
#*
+ !
#
! !
!
#*
!
!
!
!
"
!
%
# *
3
!
!
! !
"
#
#* ! &
# #-
"
./
# 0
% ) !
#* # !
# *
!
"
"
!
#
" !
"
# !
+%
!
!
!
#-
#*
!
" # !
$ %&
'
# ( ) $%& *+ ,' %,& ) %$&
- )
8 /1#
!
!
!
#$
! ! %
2 ./
!
2$
!
! # 33
4
5 .
6 !
! #
7 #8
**
#( 9 : ;
+
!
"
+
#
-
#-
" < #
! = 7 # *
!
6
#-
!
+ ! # 6( +"// +,! A-/ / /!< + - " -" E#9&:
%+$& %(%& ) & % & & )
0204 2 #"# &'4 ; /!<+ -" <# # &6 &
,-
& 7& & 0204 2 #"# &'4 =1 /E #'
>+"&
&
,- + 6&$ 01214 2 #"# &'4 =5,!<+,+2+ -" +
% >&'"&)# 02=4 2 #"# &'4 ==3! .++.!"0/9 (
* %
!!
!
! 5 !
!
"
! #
>3? 5
!
# *
5
# &
!
#
" 4 6
!
!!
@ ! !
" #( $(
,",<% +&%
% >+"&
&'
+
&+ ,- *
#.& #, 0524 2 #"# &'4 03=%+,+2+ -"" /" 2+"+ B -"E/
& 6&7 %& ) & & ) #9&:
%+$%& %(%& ) & % &
$ 2+9 &4 2" /!,+-/ " %.+." ,",< -/ - /"0"- ( ( +0 2- /++".2/ ",2 + !< !"0 2 "9,9 -$# &
! A
! /.B#5## ?
C /.5# ! !
#*
"
"
!! !
D@).
/ 0
'1 # %$$&
(( '
0 3* 4 4
0
%$$& (
" #4
5 0 6
. ** 8 0 $$- % &
9:
( +- + ",",< "!0"/!< +""// / /,<+ +,, +!
-! /2 + "+ -" +2 /+" "A-" "+-"+"/ ,,< 0.+ ++.> -/< + " !"+-,/! ",/ !,2" /+ !<+ +,"/+2+ -"( '/( - ,+ 0"+,, //+ /" + -" 0,0/+"0"<,>,+/++ ".,,! / /," 1- - .+++ +-,/ !",/ !,(+-! %+.0"%/ "!-! / /" 2+ "0-!>2"- /+ "E"" / , (4//&(6(&$8(
"""/+++/ "0-,<! 2" /!,
&7(5(&$6!< "/ ++ -" +/
"2"/2 + (+""+" / !, /., /,2 ,< / 2+", -" ! " +F
"/"+ -" +/ / 8(&(&$6% < .+++! ,/ !+, " + &7(6(&$&$( "-,+/ "/" /!<+'/( ,-/2@( (%
(( (2",",<2"0,++ ".+, !, . +<,,< " +/.++- ,.+ ", B D* 1=- ":.+ / ,,<+ ! 2 + , + " ;.""// /+
/""/+ + "- /,(+ ". +""/1-"
/&$(&(&$&$"+ -" (.0"%+ ". + ""/!<+ #((&$&$
.++"/2 + + +, "/+% .+++.-, ,<2" /!, (#(&$&$%
.++/%+.""/ + " +" 2+ "/- D"" .+,,, -/<(+""%,"+ +0 2! 2" /!, &7(5(&$6 (4 &$8+ , %+ "+/ 0" -/+ ,!"< /./,2 / 2+ -",,8(&(&$6%"
.+++.""/% /+" ", /+++/ "/,.<( &( 0 + B-! "/ !+, + +",/ !,+-,/ ".++0/ , " !- - // + "/ /,<- //" +
& / +" + "
/ >% /+""%- !, +0 <+ >""/ //- %.++.-,/ ,,< -+0/ /-+ "- % / +0..,> !<+ +,"/+2+ -"
2" 2+ !, "6:/;",0 "/":
B-"97;( #(
"+"/" %+ -" /+ "! ,/ "2-," !, + " /" 2 + , / B/ 24G +% /++ +,, 2 + +! ,/, 22(%+""%"/"/!",/
!,-!1 " "" / / -"+ / %.++",+/" +'/(", -"@-<*2" "
/( 2
<
!"#$%&$&$ @
( D++" > 2@" /H @ &(D++"" "!,H @