Gurtar Singh v. Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - ./$#/ 0*,12 ------ %$*$*&,%/
3%/+.+
66%#4+7 .,8#9 &$2%/+ ------
%+6&,(%,$+
: ; -
0 0
/%+%,$ /- 5#,(%%6 0*,12 *447
(<&)#$% 6%$*$*&,%/-
+- 3*=#+ 0.5#, 2#.(2#/>7 ! .,8#9-
/- 02%//> ?- 0*,14#7 (<&)#$%
-
- - 0
-
;
- %$*$*&,%/
./$#/ 0*,12 /$*)4%+ &,+$*$.$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%/ #4*#7 +%%=*,1 ,#$./% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,1 #+*(%
6#++%(
66%#4+7 .,8#9
+2&/$ :
&55*++*&,%/:- - /*%'4>7 &, (%5*+% 02/*
,=#/ 0*,127 6/%<*&.+
#$%1&/> %2+*4 !*+$/*)$
6/&)%%(*,1+ @%/% *,*$*#$%( '*44*,1 .6 <#)#,)>- 6./+.#,)% 6/&)4#5#$*&, 5#(% <*44#1%7
*,)4.(*,1 6%$*$*&,%/./$#/ 0*,12 #,9*/ 0*,12 #664*%( <#)#,)>-
- #*9 %2+*4(#/7
#4#,(2#/ @%44 0.9 #1*+$/#$%7
#4#,(2#/7 /%)&55%,(%( )#,(*(#$./% 6/%+%,$
./$#/ 0*,12 <#)#,)> '&/@#/(%(
#4#,(2#/
+2&/$ :&44%)$&/:-
- ;%#/,%( .6&, )&,+*(%/*,1 /%4#$*<% 5%/*$+ (%5%/*$+ '*,(*,1
./$#/ 0*,12 )#,(*(#$%7 2*5
#$%&1/> <*(% - -
- -
%%4*,1 #11/*%<%(7 )2#44%,1%( - -
'*4*,1 #, #66%#4 9%'&/% &55*++*&,%/7
#4#,(2#/ !*<*+*&,7
@2*)2 (*+5*++%(7 <*(% - -
-
- 0$*44 #11/*%<%(7 6/%'%//%( /%<*+*&,
9%'&/%
&55*++*&,%/7 @2*)2 )#5% #44&@%(7 <*(%
/%%<#4.#$% )&56#/#$*<% 5%/*$+ 9&$2 *-%- 2%/%*,-
- #'&/%5%,$*&,%( )*/).5+$#,)%+7 /%4*%'
+7 ,&$*)%( #9&<%-
- %#/(-
- %/%7 *$ #66&+*$% /%'%/ )&56#/#$*<% 5%/*$+ (%5%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+7 ,&$*)%( @2*)2
#/$*).4#/+ %$*$*&,%/
./$#/ 0*,12
%+6&,(%,$
#,9*/ 0*,12 1% (.)#$*&,#4 C.#4*'*)#$*&, #$/*).4#$%
$2 ;#,( 2&4(*,1+ %$)- )/%+ ?#,#4D 2#<*,1 4#,( $2/%% 5&/% <*44#1%+D
2#<*,1 (#*/> '#/5D
%59%/ &&6%/#$*<% 0&)*%$> ?#,#4 #/4#
%)&55%,(%( 9> #*9 %2+*4(#/7 %2+*4(#/ 0.9 #1*+$/#$%7
#4#,(2#/
$2%/ /%5#/=+ %/%(*$#/> )4#*5
- 6&, ,&$*)*,1 #9&<% %A$/#)$%( 5%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+7 '&.,( 5&+$ )#,(*(#$%7 &9+%/<*,1
! "
! !
#$ "
$$ %
& &
!
'
'
( ) *+
' " + ! '
' +
' ! ) *+ (
) , - &44%)$&/:+ './$2%/ .62%4(
-
&55*++*&,%/7 .,8#97 <*(%
#44&@%( /%<*+*&,
7 #'/%+2 (%)*+*&,7 &9+%/<*,1 - +
%
+ (
) ./01$0.-
! .# 3 4
+
" 5" 26
%
" $0.7879:;#82<"9
=
, +
(
.# 3 :
& 5 &
&
(
1 &
+
> .#0$$0.1
) (
) ./01$0.-
(
) (
) * >&
) *+ (
) , -
6%/.+#4 #9&<% %A$/#)$%( '*,(*,1 /%$./,%(
5#,*'%+$ &9+%/<*,1 &,4> &, #))&.,$
2*+ 5&/% 4#,(2&4(*,17 @2%/%#+ &$2%/ /%4%<#,$ '#)$&/+ @%/% ,&$ 6/&6%/4> #++%++%(7 2&@%<%/7 #5 ,&$ #1/%%5%,$ @*$2 /%#+&,*,1 6.$'&/$2
-
6%/.+#4 &44%)$&/:+ +2&@ 2% $#=%, ,&$% #1%7 %(.)#$*&,7 4#,(2&4(*,1 %$)- /%+6%)$*<% #4+& $#=%, *,$& #))&.,$ /%)&55%,(#$*&, 4&@%/ /%<%,.% &''*)%/+ %$)-
$ /%4%<#,$ $*5%7 @2%, 6.$ .6 9%'&/% ,&<*)% #9&.$ >%#/+ #1% @2%/%#+ '&.,( 5#$./% *,$%44*1%,$ 6%/+&,- ;%#/,%( '&.,( )#,(*(#$% )#//> &.$ (.$*%+ &''*)% ;#59#/(#/-
&/%&<%/7 4&@%/ /%<%,.% &''*)%/+ 2#( #4+& /%)&55%,(%( )#,(*(#$./% <#)#,)>-
- + '#/ /%)&55%,(#$*&,+ 4&@%/ /%<%,.% &''*)%/ )&,)%/,%(7 #4$2&.127 ,&$ 9&.,( /%)&55%,(#$*&, 5#(% /%<%,.% #.$2&/*$*%+ '#<&./ )#,(*(#$%D 2&@%<%/7 (.% )&,+*(%/#$*&, #))&/(%( +.)2 /%)&55%,(#$*&,+ $2%> #/% 6&+*$*&, #++%++ +.*$#9*4*$> )#,(*(#$% +.)2 /%)&55%,(#$*&, 2#<% +&5% 6%/+.#+*<% <#4.%- $2*+ /%1#/(7 /%'%/%,)% )#, 5#(% &9+%/<#$*&,+ 5#(% )#+%
*<*4
;
E-
- + /%1#/(+ 2%/%(*$#/> )4#*5 )&,)%/,%(7 +#5% 2%4( .4$/# <*/%+ &,+$*$.$*&,7 !*<*+*&, %,)2 $2*+ &./$
! "
#$%&'()*&*-
- $ @%44 +%$$4%( 4#@ ;#59#/(#/7 )2&*)% ,&$ 4*12$4> *,$%/'%/%( @*$2 %<%, *'
$@& <*%@+ #/% 6&++*94%-
$2*+ /%1#/(7
/%4*#,)% )#, 64#)%( .6&, !*<*+*&, %,)2 8.(15%,$ $2*+ &./$ +,
,, -.. /0$*$/&'- - &,+*(%/*,1 $&$#4*$> )*/).5+$#,)%+7 #5 )&,+*(%/%( <*%@ 2#( /*12$4>
#$%1&/> %2+*4 !*+$/*)$
@2*)2 './$2%/ .62%4( /%#+&,*,1 6.$'&/$2
/%5#,(*,1 ,&$*)%( 2%/%*,#9&<%7 .,+.+$#*,#94% =%%6*,1 <*%@ @%44 +%$$4%( 4#@ ;#59#/(#/7 )2&*)% ,&$ 4*12$4> *,$%/'%/%( @*$2-
))&/(*,14>7 *56.1,%(
6#++%(
+%$ #+*(% - -
7 6#++%( #66&*,$*,1
#$%1&/> %2+*4 !*+$/*)$
5#*,$#*,%(-
- <*%@ #9&<%7 #44&@%( (*+6&+%( #'&/%+$#$%( $%/5+-
E-
%,(*,1 #664*)#$*&,
+7 *'
#,>7 +2#44 #4+& +$#,( )4&+%(-
0
!
- -
+8=+ 2%$2%/ +6%#=*,1/%#+&,%(
"%+
& 2%$2%/ /%6&/$#94% "%+
&