High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14143/2009dismissed

Yadwinder Singh And ORS. v. F.C.Appeals Punjab And ORS.

2017-05-05Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

!"#$ #% & %#'#'(") *+*,-./0/, %%% , 1,2

344,566378! 29:!/*.,/0/, %%% 6* "% & %#$###") *+*,-./0/, %%% , 1,2

344,566378! 29:!/*.,/0/, %%% 6*

!"#$ %&'()$ )(

#*%&+,$

,%;+39-./!-,*<+/

,%,4 */!*<! ,/6,://6,%

,%*,-/,4!**3%%% 29:!

,/-%

,%,2!-,*<+/

,%1,2 ,=/!*<!

,,6*% $://6% >>>>>

)(

#*% /,*,!/33*6+<3&, :,.

%#'#'(*#$###")/44?23+*, <3<*% & %#'#'( ")! / 33+. ,3 / : 2./

#$ !

% " & " '(())* +, -. /!

(0$ (00())0 +, 1.

($ (00(0**+, -2. /!

(2 # (0)(0**1 +, -0. /!

('$ 3!/""$

$/#$ !

4 5 #

/ "

(1 &7"

& $ " !

# 5 6 ! #$ # 9/

&! & &

* +, 6! %%! & %#$### ")! / 6,/<2.//33+.,3 @

#$ !

% " & " '(())* +, -. /!

(0$ (00())0 +, 1.

($ 0('(0***+, -2. /!

(2 # (0)(0**1 +, -0. /!

('$ 3!/""$

$/#$ !

4 5 #

/ "

(1 &7"

& $ " !

# 5 6 ! #$ # 9/

&! & &

6,23/,3!<*/://6 *3,3/:2./<*,*,2*,/33.!+2 3* :

/ ,6*73*3,* 2*, - $$ 5(8 / 29:

!#AA$5,/,@#AA$B8,*+/-$*A

62 *.,232,3C*!#) 5,/,@#) B8! /<:*,*%

,%;+39 -./! 3,* -, 23 * :

,%,4 */!3,*23,6,./6,:// 6/2:4*/6,%# ,/3.3/,-2,9 ;2,%/,6*,/:.3*+,*/,3*+*3,* 2,632% 6*% $,+,3*!+//23<. 6/6,3.%/ 3*+2#"%D%#)A 2*, / ,4* 6,< / , 94 / 6,/.,2*76 4,,/ ,#)$)7A #)A#7A"!#)A#7A"#)A(7A'*#)A 7AD#)A$7AA%**6 ,,*/"%D%#))!/6,/*6*24 %(D!E7 ,,,,,/ ,#)A#7A"#)A(7A'F %#"!E7/ 2,%%,*%!/6,</+,463* +/%/,++,:/3/,6*33.26 /6,G2/;:234*2%"+*** <2,/6,%+<,!/33,: 4,*.!

42/34*,./<*!6*/92*.4**,** "D%#%#)) !G2, 7#*,*,*94/6,/ .,2*76 4,,/ ,#)A#7A"#)A(7A'%..,<* ./,4*,*,!6,6,,,*663:,/ 33,46*:

663=.**3 /,4/*+633 63**//.,*- A#)) /<:6,<*/,6*+,*2 :2* 6,<// +,4333*+,% /2,/,2:4*/24,3+<3:3 ,,* :, ,6* %(! :2 +/2 *92* / ,4*!<*,*,**"D%##%#))$!G2, 7(!

*4* / 663 :. :,,* : 3+ 34% / / ,4*,*,!%%!/33,*/33, +,/33.*:,/44,:

3.,<6%+ 633 <,,*//6,+,<,33+**6/ ,,/ ,#)A 7AD#)A$7AA!/2./+,,* *+33. *6/4%/:=*,6/4,!663** "D%'%#))D+4<*:,/33,,*6./,,,, */33,!<*,*,**)%)%#))D!G2, 7)!/3*// 42:*6*//33,*!/,,!/ 663+33+**,*,*:3*%!/6, /**6*/42:

3.//33!:2/4!<*,*, /33,!+*3+/*!/,,!/,*, 2:3 / 3+% / 3 44, / 3 44* / 4 3 % / 3*3,* + ,?2,* 6,< / 33+./,.,*<.*2*,/#) 7

8 / + 23<. / 3* , 22 6,*/, ,H :8 /3*3,*4333*3,*H* 8 /26 ./.,232,33*,#) D% 266, / ! / / ,,,* / , *** 233* 2 :

/ I:3 -26,4 2, + . / 010 2 .

3. 4400

* 1 5.6* 7 ) '8 */ /2./-A.<,.///G 2,4424 /, ,!+23*:2:9/*24,*-$% 44 ,4,33/,<24,* -$!*6//-A.2,4424,4/,

,!/3:3:9*%/2!G6, /, ,! 2433 3:3 : 9*% / +23* : 3:3 943 6,,4,33/*4* -$,-$%/6,/.,2*663* ,</<.,33 4*/,6*% $,:. 3*+, * /, 2,632 3* + 3 *3,* <* ,*, ** (%#%#))!:2/2/,***,/4*6*/ 462.*,*,%/2!<+/,***233*2: / I:3-26,42,!/462.*,*,,3:3:7* ,6*% $,*2 :2*6,<+//,/ ,433 3*+,,%<6,6,2+,,4*% 3,3*26/92*.4,*,*:

/2, '94,.+ / 0102 .

3. 4400

* .:.

; 0* 8< #%7- */,*6,: *6,*G 4/!/2,//92,*G*466,6,%

/2!,33*62,6!//: ,.

/,,/6,*,4*!%%!#)A 7AD#)A$7AA<*2,. / 6* / 6,*. :, / 6633 2, * / ,<3 2, /23* /< : 3=* *! /,,! / +, 6,3:3:33+*%

,,! ,%,2!3,*-,23*:

,%1,2 ,=/! ,6,. ,6* % $ :/ / 6,/2:4*//6,*G4/!<.*2*, -$/#) !:G**% ,/=:,< !

-$,*/2 @( &

!;- +0.

! / &, # 3

#""

$&!;- <+.=>>>>= +/.

,& ;

3 /4

! !

,& &

" 4& ! " 5=:

266, / ! / / ,3* 26 / , ***233*2:

/2, +9..' =9.

9 / 010 2 .

3. 4400

1 5.6.

; 9 0*- # 8 */2*,/6,<6,,:*2*,-$5#85:8#) !/-2*6,4 G4: */6,* G4/,4/**,*32,/ *6/42!/ ,3:3:<*% /2,/,2:4*//*94!*,*

/33,,*! 3!"D%#%#)) */G 4/G6,*" %'%#))D%+<,!/663,*6. /42!,<3*,4G2, 7)!**"D%'%#))D!%%! * ,/*!/,,!6,*G4//*3,* 36*% /.,</6,!,*. ,%!6*!

/.6,<*/4 *,,,,: + *,E/?2 /,2./,.,*6,/,6*,/,2./4 ,*,, */,../,:3.%<.3**!6,<*//

,*23,*/6,*:G**% /2,/,2:4*//2,:3*3+/<3 :/3*:<, ,.276 4,<+ /3+3**+:

/I:3-26,42, .> 09.;9.?.

; 9 0 / 010 %.=;.46. ) ;10. @ .

; 9 0* / AAABB # <**/,,!27,6 6 4,,/6,*#)A 7A #)A$7AA!/6,,3:3 :9**!/2!2,./2,,*43/+,6 +/% /</,*/3,*23,/6,!66,*/ 66, := * / <+ / /, , * 4, / 2:4 ,%;+39-./!,!6,23G2, 7)!* 3./663*</*/663/+ /2,*2,./2,/,."D%'%#))D!+/,/6,* G4/G6,*" %'%#))D%/.6,<*/6,,4 *6./,+//6,*G4/**/ 94,*,**"D%#%#)) !G2, 7#% /,+,*,/33,,/+./

/6,*6/42: + /33%/.

6,<* /4 * / , : + 33+. 4 , / ,4*6,*44*3 ,6./94,*, .

& ! 5 .

/!#!

% 5 .

!9 % ( <.3*6 /,!/6,*G4/6, /6,<3+!/!:G**%/,4*<+ 4266,*,4/,***233*26,.,6/#( +9..' =9!03.0 01@. 43,3!/2,6* ,*,"'%#%"#$

< 9.' =9 .

; 9 0/ 0102 .

3. 4400

; 9 0* :

=. *,/,<3/3,*23,/6,! 42/3/6,<3+*:,**,/ 4,!%%!/2, 6,<3+!/3*/+,3* *,/,+//6,*G4/!/4:G**% / + .!03.0 01@.* +,*,.!

+/, + /3*/ /+23*:3:324 942*,-A/ 62 *.,232,3C* !6,<.///44*,4/ ,< 24,* - $! +/2 =. ,2,6,<-A/%+<,!6,/ ,<3*/,77:<!+/,/+,.,*4 G 4/ *6 / , * /<. *<,* / 24,*:<!/6,/<3*6,<,,*//

/**/,.*/,:3.4=./6 4,+/ 6,*G4/%

4 <+!/,*,94,6,3 3.3* 92**!/,,!*33, ,,!42/3: *<*4,*<*3+%

233 !/4,26/3**/+,6, *4*% .:-*< )(

# .4 %&+,$ 9 9 0@ .> =C .0

;

9 9

@ .6