Harinder Singh Dhaliwal & ORS. v. UOI & ORS.
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 1
! "#
$%
&' ()*+,&-.
/0,**'-'/(&0
!
" # $% &
' ( $
) '*
' "
')*++**),-
.'/0" ) '*
1 &
" + 2 3 " "
4
"
67 "
8
+/*/'999
6 ++*/+**+
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 2 / + 2 & & "
':'+'99+8
"
5 5 '*'+'99;+/*/+**+
: / 2 % % & & "
5 /'*/'999
++*/+**+ (
) '* '(*++**) "
6 + "
'9;<
&
" ,0=- > ,0
> ,08
> 4 "
" ) '*
&
?
6
) '*
& "
6 @
> " ) '*"
6
&
" & =
& +/*/+**+ '<*'+**) "
6 "
"
" +**'+**) ) 4 &
&
7 "
8
,5
60
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 3 3
5 7 "
8
3
.
7
&7
'99:,
A'99:
B0=- '99:7
6
!
"# !
" !
$ #! $ $ 0 1112) 11
% " ! "$ & + $ '$ $ * # #! " ! $(# $ ( "$ $ #( !
" "! $) 0 1112) 11 "! * $ * %(( $+ ,-.+ 0 .312 ,11 /" ((( ! / $0 "$ !
" < C'*'*'99<
5 " D '*'*'99<
" 7+***6/+**
"7'):*6+9**7
'*'*'99<
5 7)(**6+**6'*(**
6 & 7+**.6 " ; C'<*'+**)
''9
78.78 . ,!
0 $
7 " ; " &
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 4 9 4 & 7
7
&
7 "
8
,5
E10 3
5 ,7 "
8
0 3
07
&7
+**),
A+**) 7
B0 4
" ')*'+**) " @ +**'+**)
&
6 4( 40 % $ $ !
$ $ # ! "$ ( #
) 3 - .
0 $! %((
- 6 11.
6 #7$ " 8
* % "$ * *94 ( 0 12 :-2
)+-11 ;2 $ 4 $ # # " $ % 5 #! $$(#!(; $$(#!(#! ;# ( $ ;#$ (;;## #
#!"( (
31<( -1<$$( " ! $ 0
1<#! .-112 1+-11;2 " ! 2( !(($ "$ 00 $ #!(0 &
7
" $( / ! ; # ! "$ # $ (+ #
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 5 $" ! // ! ; # !" #! ( $ / ! ; # !"$!+ $ " + " $$
! $( # ( =
7 " !$( $ / ! # !"$0 '* 4
) '*
"
'<*'+**) ,-
.''0 " +**) 7
@ +**'+**)F ')*'+*'),-
.'+0G 4
) '*
')*++**),-
.'/0 "
'' H
&
) '* +**)7
5@ +**'+**) " &
"
'<*'+**) " & ; $
7 "4
'<*'+**)
"
- ; "
'99:7
"
6 " 5 6
"
6 4
7
'99: &
&
6 "
"
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 6
'<*'+**) 7
+**)" &
+**'+**)
& $ + 7
+**)" A> !
$($ # $ $ 90? "
&&
) '*
1 &
'<*'+**) " ;
" " &
$
7 " " & & '+
& & '*'*'99<
6 "
6" 5 6 " & '*'*'99<
6 5 6 " D " (
D &
" '*'*'99< "
&
'<*'+**) & " "
.
D +**'+**)
')*++**) 4
1
7
'99:
"
7
+**)
&
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 7
"
6 6 &
')*++**)
) '* '/
': I
A"
,!
0 '<*'+**) & &" '99:7
7
&
+**)7
7
&JB '(
'99: 7
&
6 " &
+**) 7
&
4 "
6 ++*/+**+.+/*/+**+
&
6K ) '*"
6
&
6 '<*'+**) '99: 7
"
"
'<*'+**) 7
& +**) 7
" @ +**'+**)
D &
&
&
"
+**'+**) 4
'99: 7
7
&
" -
6 '<*'+**) " "
4
"
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 8 '<*'+**)
"
D
& ;
$
7 "& ''9
&'<*'+**)
4
'<*'+**)
1 - ;$
7 ""
K &
"
& ,'99: 7
0 4 1 " &
6 5 '*'*'99<
"'*'*'99< "
5 '*'*'99<
'*'*'99<
D "5 5
7)(**6+**6'*(**&&
- 7+**.6 I
& "
"
"
& &K
& & " " & & D 4
5 " & '*'*'99< & " &
& +**)"+**'+**) " 1 & '<*'+**)4
&
"
'<*'+**) ; "
-
'99:
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 9
"
&
'%( " ) )%"
*+,- - ., 9 &
6 @,0 " $ + $ $0 # "! ! (#0 $$
!+ "# !
,:.( #2 * "#( 0 " 8
40) -
" # "
# $ (0 > "$$ $ $$ ( # "#! #! ( 0(#!$ # $ ( #2 *
#$$ 9 # 2#+ + /$
0A /
"$$ $$ ( 0 5 "
# $
"$ ( #
"#! #! 0?
&
( % " ) & )"
"
.//0**1/2 6 B.0> #" # ! #! $ 40. C:0 5 "$$ $ $$ $( ,, #
,
$
05
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 10 7 (
D #0 5$$
!0 :0> $ ( $ # 8$0 ##
$ $ " A$ =$ ( ,,
# $
-
=( #$ $$ # 3 # $ 4"(# 11- + (4!E
40)#+ #8 " $ ! /! (0 " # ( 4!E ##7$$ 2 1,0
0 11- #$( . D 11-+ ( #( ,
+$ # " # 7 ( ($$
#7$ $( $
(0 5 (
0 #
( ,
#(!#$8 (# 11100 # $( #( (4!E05 # " # 7 ( #7$ $( $ !$ 00? ') "
&
')*++**) ,-
.'/0 4 1 &
'<*'+**)" '99:
" &
& - D
&
CWP No. 4353 of 2006 (O&M) 11 '< ?
" ';
&
*'*<+**:
" &
&
5 5 " +**)7
" " +**'+**) 4
D
*'*<+**: +**/+**)&&
'<*'+**)
" "
'99: 7
'99:
&
64
&
"
+**'+**) *'*<+**: &
''9
'<*'+**)
! "#
$% 1**23!4
-567 ? . L ?
L