High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18554/2008dismissed

Ut Of Chandigarh v. Kesar Singh And ORS.

2015-09-16Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial10 pages

" # !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,

! $ %&' %%

#3%(

"# .#)3. %#0%#,#+$3$14#, -5 $"# (#6#3,#( 7$" %#,0-+(#+$ *%18 1+)" 3%# 1*0.#3(#( 3, +#6#,,3%9 03%$9 $- $"# :%1$ 0#$1$1-+

*#+(#(*#*--503%$1#,51.#(/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$1,$38#+-+%#6-%(

00.163$1-+1,-%(#%#(366-%(1+).9

;

))%1#4#( /9 $"# -%(#%, 03,,#( /9 $"# .#3%+#( #+$%3.

(*1+1,$%3$14#%1/'+3. "3+(1)3%"#+6"<5-%,"-%$=%1/'+3.=> +1-+ #%%1$-%9 "3+(1)3%""3,0%#5#%%#($"#0%#,#+$:%1$0#$1$1-+

"# 0%143$# %#,0-+(#+$, 3%# ,#%41+) 3, #+1-% ?3/-%3$-%9 $$#+(3+$,1+$"#6"--. 3(%#-5

+ ;

@AA$"# -4#%+*#+$-5+(13,:1$6"#(-4#%$-$"# #+$%3.3963.#1+%#,0#6$-5

"3+(1)3%"#*0.-9##, #,0-+(#+$,- $- :#%#-%(#%#($-/# 51B#(1+$"#039,63.#-5 @ ;3,0#% #+$%3.039,$%'6$'%#3,$"#9 #B#%61,#($"#1%-0$1-+$-"34#$"# #+$%3.3963.#

"#0%143$#%#,0-+(#+$,3))%1#4#(/9$"#.-:039,63.#51B#( :1$"-'$$381+)1+$-366-'+$$"# #+$%3.3963.#)%3+$#($-$"#,1*1.3%.9 ,1$'3$#(?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,1+-$"#% +1-+#%%1$-%1#,'+(#%$"#6-+$%-.

-5 $"# #+$%3. -4#%+*#+$ 51.#(

C -5 @A@ /#5-%# $"# %1/'+3.

"#9*3(#36.31*$"3$$"#9:#%##+$1$.#($-$"#039,63.#-5 ;3+(7 :

# @A +5-%$'+3$#.9+-%#0.9:3, 51.#(1+$"#3/-4#

#1$"#%/9$"# +1-+-5+(13-%/9

?#3%+#(%1/'+3.:"1.#(#61(1+)$"#6.31*-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$,"#%#1+-+ *#%1$366#0$#($"#1%6.31*41(#-%(#%(3$#(; @@ 3+(6-+,#D'#+$.9 (1%#6$#($"# +1-+-5+(133+( "3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+$-6-+,1(#%$"# 6.31*-5$"#0%143$#%#,0-+(#+$,"#%#1+3+(51B$"#1%039,63.#3$ ;3+(7 :

# @A:1$"3..6-+,#D'#+$13./#+#51$,

"#0#$1$1-+#%,0%#5#%%#(?< 141.>- 7-5@@/#5-%# $"# -+=/.# '0%#*# -'%$ 3)31+,$ $"# 35-%#,31( -%(#% 03,,#( /9 $"# %1/'+3.-+;

'%1+)$"#0#+(#+69-5$"#?/#5-%#$"#-+=/.# '0%#*# -'%$ $"#%# :3, -+# (#4#.-0*#+$ :"16" %#D'1%#( ,0#613. %#5#%#+6#"#%# "#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%,1+536$1*0.#*#+$#($"#-%(#%03,,#(/9 .#3%+#(%1/'+3.3+(3,36-+,#D'#+6#$"#%#,0-+(#+$,:#%#0.36#(1+$"#

#+$%3.3963.#-5;:

# @A-56-'%,#,'/&#6$$-$"# -'$6-*#-5$"#0#613.?#34##$1$1-+0%#5#%%#(/9$"#* "#%#35$#%$"# 0#613. ?#34# #$1$1-+ :3, $38#+ '0 -+ @@C 3+( $"# -+=/.#

7 '0%#*# -'%$03,,#($"#5-..-:1+)-%(#%

$ %

$ "&

' "#

" () * +

)

, &

' '

$ -

)

1-2

' - ,

)

"#%#1,9#$3+-$"#%536$:"16"3.,-:1.."34#$-/#%#5#%%#($-

; "#%#1+ + 7 @@ $"# -4#%+*#+$ -5 +(13 :"- 1, $"# 6-*0#$#+$ '$"-%1$91+#B#%61,#-51$,0-:#%,'+(#%%$16.#7@-5$"# -+,$1$'$1-+-5 +(13 5-%*'.3$#( #%416# '.#, 5-% $"# #*0.-9##, -5 $"# (*1+1,$%3$1-+300.163/.#:

# ;

@@ "#,#%416#6-+(1$1-+,-5$"# #*0.-9##,-5 "3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+:#%#*3(##D'143.#+$$-$"#1% 6-'+$#%03%$,1+$"#$3$#-5'+&3/ "# -+(1$1-+,-5#%416#-5 +1-+ #%%1$-%9-5 "3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+*0.-9##, '.#,@3+(-%(#%, 5-%:"16"0%-41,1-+"3(/##+*3(#1+ '.#:#%#%#0#3.#( %-41,-$-$"# 3/-4#E #0#3.3+(341+)F,$3$#,$"3$E,'6"%#0#3.,"3..+-$355#6$$"# 0%#41-',-0#%3$1-+-5$"#,31( '.#,-%-%(#%,-%3+9$"1+)(-+#-%3+9 36$1-+$38#+$"#%#1+F

"# +1-+ #%%1$-%9 -5 "3+(1)3%" (*1+1,$%3$1-+ *3(# %#41,1-+-5039,63.#,41(#1$,6-**'+163$1-+(3$#(

@@@0'%,'3+$$-$"# %#6-**#+(3$1-+ -5 $"# ;$" '+&3/ 39 -**1,,1-+ + $"# 3/-4# 6-**'+163$1-+1$:3,#B0.31+#($"3$1+63,#-53 -4#%+*#+$,#%43+$ (%3:1+) #+$%3.3963.#-+$"#,$ -53+'3%9@@$"#039-5$"# -4#%+*#+$,#%43+$,"3../#51B#(-+$"#/3,1,-5$"##*-.'*#+$,3,-+ 7 @A +-$1-+3..91+$#%*,-5"# "3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+ 141.

#%416#,< #41,#(39> '.#,@@3+($"#%#35$#%-+$"#/3,1,-5$"# #*-.'*#+$,3,-+7 @@

"#35-%#,31(%#41,1-+-5039,63.#,:3, 6"3..#+)#(/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$,/951.1+)

- @C; @@@6-+$#+(1+) $"3$$"#963++-$/#6-*0#..#($--0$5-%'+&3/039,63.#:"#+$"#9:#%# 3.%#3(9)%3+$#( #+$%3.3963.#-5;

'%1+)$"#0#+(#+69-5$"#35-%#,31(

$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%,

"#%#1+0%-('6#($"#-%(#%(3$#(A 03,,#(/9$"# -4#%+*#+$-5 +(13%#41,1+)$"#039,63.#,-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$,3,:#..-+ #+$%3.039 03$$#%+ ,$"#)%1#43+6#-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$,$"3$$"#9"3(/##+6-*0#..#( $--0$5-%'+&3/039,63.#"3(/##+3(#D'3$#.93((%#,,#(1+$"#3/-4# -%(#%/9)%3+$1+) #+$%3.3963.#$"#3/-4#

- @C; @@@:3, (1,0-,#( -5 /9 $"# .#3%+#( %1/'+3. -+ @

:1$" .1/#%$9 $- $"# %#,0-+(#+$, $- 6"3..#+)# $"# -%(#% (3$#( A 15 $"#9 :#%# +-$ ,3$1,51#(

"# 039 ,63.# -5 $"# %#,0-+(#+$, :"- :#%# ,#%41+) 3, ?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,"3(/##+,"-:+3, @ ;<3$%1603,,>3+( C @;<A$" 03,,>:

# @A3+( 7 ;

# @@ "# %#,0-+(#+$,$"-')",3$1,51#(:1$"$"#(#61,1-+$38#+/9$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%$- 6-+$1+'# #+$%3.3963.#5-%$"#%#,0-+(#+$,51.#(

- @@ /#5-%#$"#%1/'+3.6"3..#+)1+)$"#-%(#%(3$#(A 3,1$(1(+-$ %#5.#6$$"#039,63.#)%3+$#($-$"#?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,1+-$"#% +1-+ #%%1$-%1#,

- @@ -5:3,'.$1*3$#.93..-:#(/9.#3%+#( %1/'+3. -+ C C 3+( $"#1*0')+#( -%(#%, (3$#( A 3+( @ :#%#D'3,"#(3+(6-+,#D'#+$.9$"#0#$1$1-+#%,:#%#(1%#6$#($- 0.36#$"#%#,0-+(#+$,1+$"#039,63.#-5;: # @A3+( ;:

# @@ :1$"3..6-+,#D'#+$13./#+#51$,-53%%#3%,-5 "#

(*1+1,$%3$1-+"3,3,,31.#(1+$"#0%#,#+$:%1$0#$1$1-+$"# 3/-4#-%(#%03,,#(/9.#3%+#(%1/'+3.-+C C

?#3%+#( 6-'+,#. 300#3%1+) 5-% $"# :%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%

(*1+1,$%3$1-+(%#:$"#3$$#+$1-+-5$"1, -'%$$-$"#&'()#*#+$03,,#(/9

$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$-+ @@C1+?- 7-5@@3+( ,'/*1$$#($"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$,"34#6-*0.#$#.9)14#+'0$"#1%5'%$"#%6.31* 0'%,'3+$$-$"#-%(#%03,,#(/9$"#.#3%+#(%1/'+3.1+

C @A@3+($"3$$"#%#5-%#$"#93%#+-$#+$1$.#($-6.31* #+$%3.039 ?#3%+#( 6-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-%$"#%#,0-+(#+$,4#"#*#+$.9,'/*1$$#($"3$$"#-%(#% 03,,#(/9$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$1+?- 7-5@@"3,/##+ 6-*0.#$#.9*1,%#3(/9$"# +1-+#%%1$-%9 $1,"1,,'/*1,,1-+ $"3$$"#-%(#%03,,#(/9$"#%1/'+3.1+

C @A@3+($"#-%(#% 03,,#(/9$"#

"3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+5-..-:1+)$"#(1%#6$1-+,1+ $"3$-%(#%"34#,#$3$%#,$$"#6-+$%-4#%,93,$-:"#$"#%$"#%#,0-+(#+$, :#%##+$1$.#($- #+$%3.039

+3$"-%-')" 0#%',3.-5$"#-%(#%03,,#(/9$"#-+=/.# '0%#*# -'%$1+?- 7-5@@-+ @@C:#51+($"3$-+.93 .1*1$#(1,,'#:3,$38#+'05-%6-+,1(#%3$1-+/#5-%#$"#-+=/.#'0%#*#

-'%$ "#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$$--8'0$"#-+.91,,'#3,$-5%-*:"16"

(3$#$"#)%3+$-5 #+$%3.3963.#3,-%(#%#(/9$"#%1/'+3.:-'.(/# #55#6$14# "#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$:3,6-+6#%+#(:1$"$"#6.31*5-% %#6-4#%9-5$"#3%%#3%,-5 #+$%3.03951B#(/9$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%3,0#%$"# (#61,1-+-5$"#%1/'+3.

"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$:3,1+5-%*#($"3$$"# %#,0-+(#+$,"3(%#6#14#(039*#+$,0'%,'3+$$-$"#-%(#%,-5$"#%1/'+3.

+(#%,'6"6-+$#B$1$:3,-/,#%4#(/9$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$$"3$$"# 3%%#3%,-50393,(#$#%*1+#(/9$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%0'%,'3+$$-$"#(1%#6$1-+, 1,,'#(/9$"#%1/'+3."341+)/##+3.%#3(9031($-$"#%#,0-+(#+$,+-6.31* ,"3../#*3(#:1$"%#,0#6$$"#%#$-/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$,0'%,'3+$$-$"#-%(#%

C '+(#%300#3.

;

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

+-'%6-+,1(#%#(41#:$"#1,,'#3,%#)3%(,039,63.#300.163/.# $-$"#%#,0-+(#+$,1,+-.-+)#% 1+41#:-5$"#3/-4#,0#613.536$, 3+(61%6'*,$3+6#,

$:3,6-+$#+(#(/9.#3%+#(6-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-%$"#:%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%,$"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$,/#1+)#*0.-9##,-5$"#

"3+(1)3%"3%# /-'+(/9$"# -+,$1$'$1-+-5#%416#-5 +1-+#%%1$-%9-5 "3+(1)3%" *0.-9##, '.#,@@+-$151#(/9$"# #+$%3. -4#%+*#+$-+7 @@

+-$"#%:-%(,1$1,,'/*1$$#($"3$$"# -+(1$1-+,-5#%416#-5 +1-+ #%%1$-%9 "3+(1)3%"(*1+1,$%3$1-+*0.-9##, '.#,@3+($"#-%(#%, 5-%:"16"0%-41,1-+"3,/##+*3(#:1$"%#,0#6$$"#%#$-,$3+(%#0#3.#(3+( 3,36-+,#D'#+6#$"#%#,0-+(#+$,3%##+$1$.#($-039,63.#-+.91+$#%*,-5 $"# -+(1$1-+, -5 #%416# 1+ '+&3/

141. #%416#, ?#3%+#( 6-'+,#.

300#3%1+) 5-% $"# %#,0-+(#+$, 6-+$#+(#( $"3$ $"# 3/-4# '.# :3, +-$

A /%-')"$$-$"#+-$16#-5$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$3$$"3$0-1+$-5$1*# $ 1,"1,,'/*1,,1-+$"3$$"#,31( '.#:3,)14#+3)-/9:"1.#)%3+$1+)

#+$%3. 39 63.# $- $"# %#,0-+(#+$, '+(#% $"# 6-**'+163$1-+ (3$#( A

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

-4#%+*#+$ -+ A 4#+ -$"#%:1,# %-41,- $- '.# 7 -5 $"#

-+,$1$'$1-+-5#%416#-5 +1-+#%%1$-%9 "3+(1)3%"*0.-9##, '.#, @@*38#,1$6.#3%$"3$$"#-%(#%03,,#(-%3+9$"1+)(-+#-%36$1-+$38#+1+ 6-++#6$1-+:1$"$"#6-+(1$1-+,-5,#%416#3,6-+$#*0.3$#('+(#% '.# $"#%#-5:3,+-$3$3..%#0#3.#(

$1,$-$3..9'+531%-+$"#03%$-5

(*1+1,$%3$1-+$-%#-0#+ $"#1,,'#3,$-:"#$"#% #+$3.039-%$"#'+&3/039,$%'6$'%#1,$-/# 300.1#($-$"#%#,0-+(#+$, 341+))14#+'0$"#1%0.#3/#5-%#$"#-+=/.# '0%#*# -'%$1+$"#?0%#5#%%#(/9$"#*3+(3.,-"341+)1,,'#($"# 6-**'+163$1-+(3$#(A 6-+5#%%1+) #+$%3.039$-$"#%#,0-+(#+$,

(*1+1,$%3$1-+1,+-$,'00-,#($-%38#'03+1,,'#:"16"3.%#3(9,$--(

@ (#61(#(3+(,#$$.#(

$:3,,'/*1$$#(/9.#3%+#(6-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-%$"#:%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%$"3$1503903683)#3,(1%#6$#(/9$"#%1/'+3.1,)%3+$#($-$"# #+1-%?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,1$:-'.(6%#3$#3+1*/3.3+6#1+$"#039,63.# -5-$"#%#*0.-9##,-5

(*1+1,$%3$1-+:"-0-,,#,,/#$$#%D'3.15163$1-+ 3+(,$3$',

"#%#,0-+(#+$,"34#1+536$#B#%61,#($"#1%-0$1-+$-3431.

#+$%3.3963.#%1)"$5%-*$"#9#3%@AA "#3/-4##B#%61,#*3(#/9 $"#* :3, $"# ,-'%6# 5-% 51B1+) $"#1% 039 -+ #+$%3. 03$$#%+ 5 ,-*# #*0.-9##,-5

(*1+1,$%3$1-+"3(+-$#B#%61,#($"#1%-0$1-+-53431.1+)

#+$%3.039,$%'6$'%#:"16"%#,'.$#(1+51B3$1-+-5.-:,63.#-50395-%$"#* 1$63++-$/#.3:5'..9"#.0#(3+(-+$"3$)%-'+( #+$%3.3963.#51B#(5-% $"#%#,0-+(#+$,63++-$/#(-:+)%3(#(G.-:#%#(

$:3,5'%$"#%,'/*1$$#(/9$"#.#3%+#(6-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-% $"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%,$"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$,3%#6.31*1+)303903%1$9:1$" ?3/-%3$-%9 $$#+(3+$, ,#%41+) 1+ (155#%#+$ +1-+ #%%1$-%1#, :"-,# D'3.15163$1-+"3,/##+51B#(3$3"1)"#%.#4#.

"#%# 1, +- *3$#%13. $- ,"-: $"3$ ?3/-%3$-%9 $$#+(3+$, 300-1+$#(:1$""1)"#%D'3.15163$1-+1+-$"#% +1-+#%%1$-%1#,(1,6"3%)#3 (155#%#+$+3$'%#-5:-%85%-*$"3$-5$"#?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,,#%41+)1+

+(#%,'6"61%6'*,$3+6#,"1)"#%D'3.15163$1-+0%#,6%1/#( 5-%?3/-%3$-%9$$#+(3+$,1+-$"#% +1-+#%%1$-%1#,*38#,+-(155#%#+6#

"#%#5-%# $"# %#,0-+(#+$, 3%# #+$1$.#( $- #D'3. 039 3, $"3$ -5 $"#1% 6-'+$#%03%$,1+-$"#% +1-+#%%1$-%1#,(%3:1+)$"# #+$%3.039

+41#:-5$"#3/-4#:#3%#-5$"#6-+,1(#%#(41#:$"3$$"# %1/'+3."3,%1)"$.9(#6.3%#(3,1..#)3.3+(D'3,"#($"#-%(#%++#B'%# (3$#(A 3+(++#B'%#(3$#(;

3+(03,,#(,'1$3/.# (1%#6$1-+$-$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+#%,$-0.36#$"#%#,0-+(#+$,1+$"#039,63.#-5 ; :

# @A 3+( ; :

# @@ :1$" 3..

6-+,#D'#+$13./#+#51$, 7

!#(-+-$51+(3+9*#%1$1+$"#:%1$0#$1$1-+3+($"#,3*# ,$3+(,(1,*1,,#( !

"# #0$#*/#%

" # '.3$1