Gulshan Dewan And Others v. Karan Avtar Singh, Ias Chief Secretary To Government Of Punjab

  
 
 



  

     

    ! "#


   
!  "#$#%& 

"
'(%)#*+),-(&# "

" (%)'#"+),-(&# "&'#.#&/&/%#"$

$%0
'(&"(&'+ #%/"),-(&#1/&'

"/$'(%& (/%/+),-(&# "&'#"#$.%)#%&  $%% &'&()'* + '#1"/&.#&/&/% /*#)23&'#&#%(%&$4--0./#"$ &'#$/&#$/% (%&(#'"/ ("5#&+'($#6+  (7(" '(*/2#/%7(77"/#,#)&'(& &'#/"-*(/8 ""#'(2/*/&(&/%1($%&-%$/)#"#)%&'#7"0%)&'(&&'#3 1#"#0%(0&'"/$#)&#%(%&$4--0./#"$+1($)/$.$#) %9 

9'# "#*#,(%&."&/%/$"#.")0-#)2#*1

 



             

    

   

  

    





           

        

    

 

   

      

   

           

    

     

! 

  "

#

    



#$%&%  



     

  



 "

' 

(       

   

"                     

      )

(            



   " #

 



     

 

 

 #$%&%          

   

    * +  + +

     

 

     " ,' !  

 

"

        

       

    + 

      

      

(

   - "

  "  #

      

           

     

(       

 ( 

   



    #$%&%     

  

 .



    

'       

      

  /  

    

 

      

 

            

 

 .



        0 &



 1 %(

/)(,/&)(&#)

 

 1($ /*#)1'#"#/%/&1($.*#()#) &'(&

#"'($2##%8()#&&'#.#&/&/%#"$ "(**&8#%& 2&'$/&#$ (*"#()3(,(/*(2*#1/&' /%)/

#"#%&$#-&"$ &'#"2(%$&(&# #("%#)-0%$#* "&'#"#$.%)#%&$07'&&/8#&'(,#/%$&"0-&/%$($& 1/&'/%1'(&&/8#&'#)"(1 *&$-(%2#'#*) #("%#)  -0%$#*  "  &'#  "#$.%)#%&+  %  /%$&"0-&/%$  "8

":(8(*;/& /%7'+(1

/-#"+ $&(&#$&'(&#%&/"#."-#$$ "

/$$0(%-# *#&&#" /%&#%&10*)2#-8.*#&#)1/&'/%68%&'$ "8&)(3+ /%-($#&'#"#("#%*#7(*/8.#)/8#%&$

6 %  ,/#1    &'#  $&(&#8#%&  8()#+  *#("%#)  -0%$#*  "  &'# .#&/&/%#"$$&(&#$&'(&%-(0$# (-&/%$0",/,#$ ".0"$0/%7&'#."#$#%& -%&#8.&.#&/&/% /$.$#)  *$%% &'&(+ ', %  

 <'#&'#"$.#(5/%74"#($%#)

#$4 <'#&'#""#."&(2*#

#$4