Makhan Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana Etc


 
   
  

 !"#$"%!"&'(!)*+

)($($'")*+ ,+

#(()'-*.""&"'(!)*

)+/'"&)"(+

01 2

)3$&)&'"41 5 "$6!($"&'(!)*+

)($($'")*+ ,+

#(()'-*.""&'(!)*+

)+/'"&)"(+ 

       *)+)"(4

*

# (76$8#* &,'3() 7$(! * $ *9:$(#$"%!(76$8&,'3()8 -'*(!)/)($($'")*+$"
 

*  # 68#* &,'3() 7$(! * #)7#$"%!"& + ":;#!*98&,'3()+ -'*(!)/)($($'")*+$"
01 2

* $()+!"&$(8&&6 8*."

<<    

 .(!$+'*&)*87$66&$+/'+)'-=',)+$&(7'7*$(/)($($'"+=)*$"%
'+  "&01 2+(!).$",'6,)3'99'"6$(.'-67 "&-3(+

66  (!)  /)($($'")*+  !)*)$"  7)*)  7'* $"%  +  "+(*;3('*+  $"  (!) >'3($'"6&;3($'""+($(;()+ !)*)$"-()*-'*+!'*(?>+?!,$"%(!)

 @;6$-$3($'"'-'+(*&;()+$ )

'97$(!5A9* +7!$3!7)*)(!) /*)+3*$=)&*)@;$+$() !)*)+/'"&)"(+*)&)+$%"()&(!)/'+('-"+(*;3('*+ +B)3(;*)*+=.,$*(;)'-(!)'*&)*&()&C  0('(*)((!)9$"(!) +9)/.+36)  "  28 "'($-$3($'"7+$++;)&( $"%',)*(!) &9$"$+(*($,)3'"(*'6"&++)(+'-1>+"&(*"+-)**$"%(!)9('(!) &;3($'" #;=+)@;)"(('(!$+8,$&)'*&)*+&()&C   "& 5 C  8(!)+)*,$3)+'-(!)/)($($'")*+7)*)+)"(('(!)#3!''6&;3($'"

)/*(9)"(('-'*9+)/*()3&*)"&+)/*()+)"$'*$(.6$+( '*(!) /;*/'+)+'-*)-)*)"3)+8*)6),"(/'*($'"'-(!)'*&)*(*"+-)**$"%(!)+)*,$3)+ '-(!)/)($($'")*+('(!)&;3($'" )/*(9)"(('*)($"+)/*()3&*)"& (*)($"%(!)9'"/*'=($'"-'*/)*$'&'-(7'.)*+$+)D(*3()&!)*)=)6'74 E5 
    

           

                    

   





 

        

    

   !" 

      "    



          

   

 

# 

   

      $    $ 

     $  

          "

1  

  

 

 " % !)&$+/;()3)"(*)+*';"&(!)&$+/*$(.'-/.&9$++$=6)('(!)B)3(;*)*+ '-(!)&;3($'" )/*(9)"("&(!)'")+&9$++$=6)('(!)/)($($'")*+7!' 7)*)  (*"+-)*))+  $"('  (!)  &;3($'"  )/*(9)"(  -*'9  (!)  >'3($'"6 &;3($'""+($(;()+ !$+3($'"$+/)*3)$,)&=.(!)9('=)&$+3*$9$"('*. '"(!)%*';"&(!((!)./'++)++(!)+9)@;6$-$3($'"+B)3(;*)*+'-(!) &;3($'" )/*(9)"("&/)*-'*9+$9$6*&;($)+*(!)*9'*)'")*';+'")+ (!"(!)'")+=)$"%/)*-'*9)&=.(!)B)3(;*)*+'-(!)#3!''6&;3($'"

33'*&$"%('(!)/)($($'")*+8(!)-;"&9)"(6*;6)+'-/*$(.'- /.!,)('=)&)()*9$")&7$(!*)%*&('(!)@;6$-$3($'""&(!)"(;*)'- &;($)+7!$3!=)$"%+$9$6*3""'(*)+;6($"&$--)*)"(/.+(*;3(;*)-'*(7' +)(+'-)9/6'.))+7$(!$"(!)+9)$"+($(;($'"

"
01 2$(!+=))"+/)3$-$366.,)**)&(!(,$*(;66. 3'99'"+)"$'*$(.6$+($+=)$"%*)($")&-'*)--)3($"%/*'9'($'"(!)/'+('- >$3)*$"3$/67!$3!-3(!+*)9$")&;"3'"(*',)*()&$"(!)*)/6. !)*)+/'"&)"(+&'"'(&)".(!)-3(;6+/)3(+'-(!)/)($($'")*+ 7'* $"%  +  B)3(;*)*+  $"  (!)  >'3($'"6  &;3($'"  "+($(;()+F  (!)$* 3'"+)@;)"3)9)*%)* 7!$3!(!)./*)-)*('()*9+(*"+-)*"&(!)-3('- (!)$*  =)$"%  $"    +)/*()  3&*)  =;(  /6)&  &$--)*)"3)  $"  )&;3($'"6 @;6$-$3($'"+ ,)"(!';%!(!)*)/6.7';6&"'(+;+($"(!)$**%;9)"($"
';*(

C "(!)*)/6.8(!)&;3($'"6@;6$-$3($'"-'*/'+(+'-B)3(;*)*$" #3!''6&;3($'" )/*(9)"(!+=))"%$,)"';(+-'66'7+4 E  $

G

#3

'9  7$(!  (  6)+(  5A  9* +  -*'9  *)3'%"$H)&"$,)*+$(.F $$
)*($-$3()  '-  !,$"%  @;6$-$)&  #3!''6  )3!)*+ 6$%$=$6$(.)+( #

$$$$"&$;/(' (*$3I !)-'*)+$&$+(!),)*.+9)@;6$-$3($'"(!((!)/)($($'")*+/'++)++ )D3)/((!)3)*($-$3()'-#3!''6)3!)*+6$%$=$6$(.)+(@;7!$3!$($+ +(()&(!((!)+9)7';6&=)$"//6$3=6)('(!)9+(!$+/*)+3*$/($'"39) +;=+)@;)"(6.$"(!).)*2

)6$"3)!+=))"/63)&'":;&%9)"(*)"&)*)&=.(!$+
';*($"  !"!! "# $ % &
& $ 


  '

(  $ +6+'(!)&)3$+$'"*)"&)*)&=.(!)'"?=6)#;/*)9)
';*($"
  '

(  $ 

 %

 $ $  )*% #++,
 "-!.7!)*)$(7+'=+)*,)&+;"&)*4 &  ' '

   



(



 " 

    $)
*+ , +



" -.//0**// 0     

  1        

" -2,20*/2/ 0'"   

 



"

5 -*.3/0,4// 0

    (



 "  '   

  

"       51    "   (  51  + 1   6   ,  "7

 + 1   51 



 $

" -*.3/0 ,4// 0

 " 

    51 

, *)
   

5+51 

  "

   

 $

"     1    "5"-



+   '  "    '      "



         "   "    "           

             " 

         

       6       -

  5" -  

 

    

        5" -

  +      "         " *+, +5 1 (



 " 5+51 (



 " "" $

  

 ** *,  $





     "'

 8" -  " $

 

 

   "       +  **     *, 





    " (" 

   

  ** *,



 "9 ' '

    

  

  "              

  -

5"- $

  

"

    "%

"  /)*;+6  '-  (!)  -'*)+$&8    9  '-  (!)  ,$)7  (!(  (!)  +("&  '-  (!) *)+/'"&)"(+3""'(=)+;+($")&$"(!)).)+'-67-'*(!)+$9/6)*)+'"(!( (!)/)($($'")*+7)*)&)+$%"()&+B)3(;*)*+"&!&+$9$6*@;6$-$3($'"+ (!)'")+/'++)++)&=.(!)B)3(;*)*+$"(!)#3!''6&;3($'"

!)/)($($'")*+!,$"%=))"=+'*=)&$"(!)&;3($'" )/*(9)"(7';6&=) )"($(6)&('+$9$6*(*)(9)"($"9(()*+'-/./*($3;6*6.7!)"(!)*)$+"' &$+($"3($'"=)(7))"(!)-;"3($'"+=)$"%&$+3!*%)&=.='(!(!)+)(+'- )9/6'.))+ (!+=))"+(()&(!((!)/)($($'")*+*)()3!$"%!$%!)*36++)+ '- (!"& (!7!)*)+B)3(;*)*+$"&;3($'" )/*(9)"(7)*)()3!$"% 36++)+ (!('(!

!)  -;"3($'"6$(.  +/)3(8  (!)*)-'*)8  =)$"%  +$9$6*  6'"%  7$(!  (!) &;3($'"6  @;6$-$3($'"8  (!)*)  7';6&  =)  "'  :;+($-$3($'"  7$(!  (!) *)+/'"&)"(+('&)"./*$(.$"/.+36)+/*($3;6*6.7!)"(!$++/)3(!+

0 =))"+/)3$-$366.&)6(7$(!=.(!)'"?=6)#;/*)9)
';*(('")%() +$9$6*+("&

"(!)3+)*)6$)&;/'"=.(!)/)($($'")*+$"
8(!$+
';*(!&%*"()&/*$(.'-/.+36)+'-(!)B)3(;*)*+'-(!)>'3($'"6 "+($(;()+7$(!(!'+)'-(!)&;3($'"6 )/*(9)"(+),)"(!';%!(!)*)7+ &$--)*)"3)$"@;6$-$3($'"+ "(!(3+)(!)/)($($'")*+(!)*)$"!&=))" )@;()&$"()*9+'-/.+36)7$(!B)3(;*)*+'-#3!''63&*)=;(&)"$)& (!)9-;*(!)**),$+$'"'"(!)%*';"&'-!$%!)*@;6$-$3($'"

!)  3+)+  $"  !"&  7';6&  =)  '"  =)(()*  -''($"%+  +  (!)*)  $+  "' &$+($"3($'"=)(7))"(!)(7'+)(+'-)9/6'.))+)$(!)*$"()*9+'-)&;3($'"'* $"()*9+'--;"3($'"6$(.


'"+)@;)"(6.8(!)+)(7'7*$(/)($($'"+*)66'7)&"&(!)3($'"'- (!)*)+/'"&)"(+$"3*)($"%&$+($"3(/.+36)+-'*(!)/)($($'")*+('(!('- (!)  *)+/'"&)"(+  $+  !)6&  ('  =)  &$+3*$9$"('*.  +    *)+;6(  (!)*)'-8  (!) /)($($'")*+7';6&=)!)6&)"($(6)&('(!)+9)/.+36)++&9$++$=6)('(!) B)3(;*)*+ '-(!)&;3($'" !)*)+/'"&)"(+*)&$*)3()&('

%*"(663'"+)@;)"($6=)")-$(+('(!)/)($($'")*+*)+;6($"%-*'9+;3!/*$(.

!)**)*+=)*)+(*$3()&('/)*$'&'-129'"(!+/*$'*('(!)-$6$"%'-(!) 7*$(/)($($'"+

"+"#/ 0) 1

%231%4

 561