High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5685/2016allowed

Amandeep Singh v. State Of Punjab

2017-01-09Mr. Justice Krishna Murari6 pages

!"#"$% '()*

+ , $- ./"$01 2 ""$ ' 3# / 5 2 #.$- $ % 67 //

' # $% '3".&8"$- 8*-9!

'1 . ""$ ' ':/ 8;

*--8* 5

""$ ' 1 # 5 $ "$ !&#-( #"$! &$ *

< "$ !

# ;1"!1;

#' 0"# ' -$1 5 # !' "$', "$1 !1 3"!=( :&, '* 04 /"$01* "'9 "8 /"$01* ## $* ' /"$01* &'4 $ /"$01* &'4 /"$01 $- 1 '# 1 - ', - 5"0 0 $0 ' #&..8("$0 "$>"!

"$0#&5# $! # $-"88 0 8 ',#5(&#"$0,5"8 # $-#",!

'-#

="# $- , ,5 '# 1 0 $0 ; ' ,9"$0 "$ ; 9 1"!8 # "## ' $ $-$- 9&' 8$0;"11 9(?& $"(1 '"$ &'#& $1 "- "$', "$* $ &'4 /"$01 ;

'' # - @ =0 1 '"$* ;

."#8#*;' 989 '#*!

''"-0 # $-"## $ ' $!

' !; ' ' !9 ' - ',1","#. '"$ $5# '9 1 $ "1 '1 . ""$ '"#$ , -"$ 1 $'1 ;

'' # - 8$0;"1 $("$>"!

"$0#&5# $! 1 !

# 1 .'# !&"$"#1 &'4 /"$01, - -"#!8#&' # , $1 !1 1 1 -5'&011' -" ' $!$#"0$, $#+ =0*=0 $- < =01 '"$*' #. !"9 8($-" ' $- #',

="# $-1 1 - $- -9 ' .

!= #1 '"$ !!&# -&'4 /"$01A:&=*#$ :

#1,"'/"$011 $ , 1 . ""$ ';

#-"#!8# -5(&'4 /"$01 #$$- '4"/"$01-&'"$01 !&'# 1"#"$ ''0 "$1 . ""$ ' 1 '

'' # -$&$ +*

< $-' !9 '( =01 '"$;

! -',1 . ""$ '$&$ *

<1 . ""$ ' 88 0 -8(, -

-"#!8#&' # , $"$.8"! !&#-($&$ )*

<$1 5 ;1"!1 $1 '

=01 '"$;

88 0 -8(' !9 ' -',1"#.## ##"$ 1 . ""$ ' 1 # 1&# 5 $ "$989 - "$ 1 !

# $ 1 5 #"# 1 , $ $ &'4 /"$01 #$ $- '4" /"$01 ; 88 0 -8( &$-"$.## ##"$ =01 '"$1 ' , "$"$0' !9 '(;

# ! - .&'#& $ 1"# -"#!8#&' # , $ ;1"!1 "# !8 ", - 5( 1 .'# !&"$

0 $!(*5 # , $&$- '/ !"$+1 9"- $! ! 1 #1'?& #"$;1"!1 '"# #'- ',"$ "$"$1 .' # $ !

# "#;1 1 '1 . ""$ '!

$5 # "-1 9 5 $&$-"$.## ##"$

=01 '"$' !9 ' -$1 5 - 5(1"#!

!!&# - &'4 /"$01 $- $ 1 5 #"# $1 ' # , $ , - 5( . ""$ '"$!&#-("## 8 -.'"$!".8 #8 ;1 $(# -

5( $( !!&# -"$.8"! !&#-("#$ -,"##"58 "$ 9"- $! / !"$+ 1 9"- $! !"#*1; 9 '* $ >! ."$1 .'1"5""$",.# -5( / !"$#<* $-1 9"- $! !(/ !"$+1 9"- $! !* "$', "$* 9 $ " ,&$ - !$ ##"$* 1 9"$0 5 $ , - .8"! "! '&$- ' $(!"'!&,# $! #, (5 .'9 -*''

1 '#,&!1 ", (5 .'9 -* #' 8 #-"#"$!8(1 !1 ' 5(-"#!9 ' -1 "$', "$;1"!1' 8 #1 -"#!9 '( !#"# -,"##"58 9 $1&01 1 !$ ##"$"# 8"!" -5(",.'. '"$-&! , $"# 8## 8 -.'"$!".8 8 ;1 , ' -"#!9 '( ! ' #&8"$', "$', - # $ , = " -,"##"58 &$8 ## "# ' 8 9 $! "# # 58"#1 - 5( 1 ' 9"- $! #1;"$0 1 !$$ !"$ 5 ; $ 1 ! -"#!9 ' - $- 1 $! !1 '0 - "$#1 !!&# - '"$- 8*8 '$ -!&$# 8'1 . ""$ '1 #!$ $- -1

#1 . ""$ ' #$ "1 '$ , -"$1 $' $(' !9 '(1 9"$05 $ ! -',1", $-1 1 9"$0$5 $ '' # -',1 #.*!

$$5 "-5 "$.## ##"$1 !$'

$- 1 #' '' -1 88;"$0 4&-0, $# ;1 ' "$ $ !!&$ - 5

58 "##& "$989 - . '

"$"$0 ' !9 '" # ! -$1 5 - &$- '/ !"$+ 1 9"- $! ! "$ .8"! !&#-(* 1"# &' 1 # 0'

$ - !$! ##"$ "8% "B + )

<"8 - C /"$01 A 4 3#/ 5*- !"- -$ (@*

""B < <

< "8 -

9" A $"8 1 &1 $3#/ 5*- !"- -$ '( *

"""B <<@

"8 - ';

$ /"$01 A '5 $# /"$01 3# / 5* - !"- - $ '()*

"9B +)

<*"8 - '9"$- '/"$01A

",.8 3#/ 5*- !"- -$&0&#<*

9B +

< "8 - / 8 , 1- 3# / 5* - !"- - $ 9 ,5 ' <*

D B 1 8#' 8" -&.$1 88;"$04&-0, $#% "B '4 $/"$013#/ 5*'8..

8 @

$ 1 # "- !

# 1 .. 88 $

!!&# - 1 - 5 $ !?&" - # 1 ' !9 '( 1 - 5 $ ! -$1 5 #"#-"#!8#&' # , $ , - 5( 1 !!&# - &$- ' / !"$ + 1 9"- $! ! ""B $ 5'

/"$013#/ 5*

DB D'8B*!$9"!"$'- '"$ !

# ' !9 '( =0 ."$"$ ;

# # #"- # 1 ' !9 '( - 5 $ ! - $ 1 5 #"# 1 -"#!8#&'

, $ , - 5( 1 !!&# - 1 .8"!

''"$0 1 .'9"#"$# / !"$ + 1 9"- $! !* ' !9 '( ."&,* "$ .&'#& $ 1 # , $ 1 !!&# - !

$ $8( 5 .'9 - 5& " !

$$ 5 &# - #1; 1 1 1",# 8!$!

8 - $-= .1 ."&, 1 .8 ! ;1 ' ";

#&$- $1 1 '1 $-*' 8;

1 #!$ $- -1 1 ' !9 '( ;1"!1 "# ! - ', !!&# - $ 1 5 #"# 1"# # , $ , - 98&$ '"8( "$ .8"! !&#-( ;"88 5 #&"!" $ $&01 ''"9 !$!8&#"$1 1 !!&# -1 -5 $"$!$#!"&#.## ##"$ 9 $"""#$ 58"#1 -5 "$1"# !& 8.1(#"!

8!$'8 ' '' - 4&-0, $"$ !!" # ! *D

B/$1 # "-!

# *

!!&# -1 -5 $ '' # -"$ 5&;1"8 "$!&#-(1 , - -"#!8#&' , $ 1 1 1 - #8 $ !$'

$- '"!8 # ', , 8=1 $ "# , $8 -' !9 '(1 !$9"!"$;

#&.1 8- 1 !$'9 '#("$989 -"$1 !

# ;

#;1 1 '.'9"#"$# / !"$+1 9"- $! !;&8-5 ' #'"! -"$ !

# ;1 ' 1 '

' ; $-# , $1 #5 $, - "$$ ;1"!18 -' !9 '( "$ 1 # !$- $#"- '"$0 1 ' !9 '( 1 9"$0 5 $ .'9 -* 1 !$9"!"$&$- '/ !"$ 1 /!;

#&.1 8-;

#1 8-1

!!&# -;

#$' ?&"' -5 '' # -"$' #. !1 # , $! '

-,"##"5"8"( ' !9 '(&$- '/ !"$+1 9"- $! !1 # "- 4&-0, $- #$- 8-"' !8(;"11 !$'9 '#("$989 -"$1 ! # ="$0 "$ !$#"- '

"$ 1 59 # "- !"'!&,# $! #* ;"1& >.' ##"$ $(."$"$$, '"#1 !

# *""##&"!" $ 5# '9 1 1 ! '' #1 . ""$ '$1 5 , $ 1"#! $-' !9 '(1 9"$05 $ ! - 1 ", 1"# '' #

$-&'1 '' !9 '(1 9"$05 $ ! -

=01 '"$$1 5 1"# $1 '# - "$.8"! !&#-(*";"885 - 5

58 ;1 1 ' 1 . ""$ ' !&8- 5 - , - 5 "$ .## ##"$ 1 !$' $-* ;

$"$0!$9"!"$&$- '1 #'"$0 $.'9"#"$#1 /! ="$0"$!$#"- '

"$1 !1 1 . ""$ '1 #5 $"$ !&#-(; &$ *

<*1"#. ""$"# 88; - ""$ '"#'- ' - 5 ' 8 # - $ 5 "8 $ 1"# &'$"#1"$0 5 "8 5$-#E #&' ( 5$-# 1 "# !"$1 '"

8&' '()*

+ D/B # $4 ( F1 1 '#.

="$0E'

#$ -% #E F1 1 ' .'

58 % #E