High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47936/2018disposed of

Narotham Puri v. State Of Haryana

2018-12-18Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()

+" ,-.+& ***! & &"(!+ /!+'.'

!"#+0( *** !'1"($!( ) 23 *

/ 4

!" ##

! " #$$ %$&&'$(# ) %* / 45* +# $$ * " ( " $!$ * ,$- $ ./ 0

($ '!$

'!$

23 42 2 3 "#0-)$( $!+!#$5 2(-$ $$ "$3 ! -$!'$ 1- 0( )$$! &,- 6 ! -" #$$ ,&$##--($ ($#$$ ###$ ! ! & %7 #$$ 8 # 6 ! -" #$$ #-$ #

,*#$ $

$ 8#$!#

! !! %7$'$(#(#,( $$&$!$ *,$-,* #$ +# $ "#$ 63!+(!$%".('!7#"+ ,!1! & &"(!+'.8-& ' , '1!+ ,!77!9 &"('-$!&( ,! 5 ,!&:&7 .+9!"(5 -87,$+!%!&:!$(&(#"+- &"(8". ,!&77!97 % &:& &!'"#1+!( 7'!;$! !+-&( &"( !' "#1+!9((

7$&!' ($ ,! &(#"+-!+ +-<!! =.+ &(#"+-!$ 8". 7$05(-!705+<!! =.+5>,">'&(:"7:!$ &('.%, 01!"#1+% &%!* &'#.+ ,!+' !$&( ,! >,!( ,!&(#"+-!++-<!! =.+%"( % !$+<!! =.+5',!$!-($!$ '*

?#"+%"($.% &(9'.%, !' ($"(+!%!&:&(9'.%,&(#"+- &"(5 !->' %"(' & . !$($# !+>& ,$+>&(9 ,!-".( #+"- 8(@5 ,!%"(' & . !$ !-'@!$+-<!! =.+ " 8+&(91+!9(( $!%"07$0#"+ ,&'1.+1"'!5>,">&77 ,!71 ,!$!1+ -!( :"7.( +&70* (

5 ,!

!- %77!$ +-<!! =.+5 >," 7"(9 >& , 1+!9(( $!%"07$0>!( "&:&7 .+9!"(-87 * *-*,! !-9:! ,!-".( "# '*

? "

+-<!! =.+ ",($":!+ "+<!! =.+#"+ ,! '!;$! !+-&( &"( !' *# !+ , 5 ,!$!%"01+!9(( 7$0($+-<!! =.+' &(1+&: !%+,&+!$80 ,!$!1+ -!( ($>!( ">+$'=7@,">@ *

*-*,! !-' + !$#"77">&(9 ,!-*''""(' ,!0+!%,!$ ,!+!5+<!! =.+' &( ,!%+($ '@!$#"+ '*

?#+"-+-<!! =.+($# !+ ,($&(9":!+"# '*

? ",!+5 ,!0+!%,!$ /&779! ,"91.+5 &' +&% 7($,+ :& 3.$,&(5 ,9>+($ ,!0' "11!$ (!','>!! '',"1 -&( ,(@" +"$5 ,"91.+5 >,!+! ,+!! 7$&!' >!+! >& &(9 #"+ ,!-* # !+ , 5 +<!! =.+ ,($!$":!+'"-!-"(!0 ""(!"# ,!7$0($'@!$ ,!+ "9">& ,$!%"01+!9(( 7$0&( ,!%+($9! ,!+ '!; $! !+-&( &"( !; $"(!* ,!+!# !+5 ,! +&$&(9 !- &(#"+-!$ ,! &:&7 .+9!"(5 -87 +!9+$&(9 ,&'1+"%!!$&(9>,"&( .+(&(#"+-!$&:&7

.+9!"(57($,+($+!A.!' !$ "'!($ ,!7"%7 !- "<"&( ,!-*,!+!# !+5 ,! !-(88!$ ,! 7$&!'1+!'!( ,!+!* (&(A.&+05& >'#".($ , ,! .7 +'".($"# ,!$!%"01+!9(( 7$0>'$"(! 9,"'1& 7($ !+(& 0!( +! $&' (%! #+"- ,!'1" *,!$!%"01+!9(( 7$0&$!( &#&!$ ,! 17%!($,"'1& 7>,!+!,!+.7 +'".($>'$"(!58. , +""->'#".($7"%@!$($("$"% "+>'1+!'!( ,!,"'1& 7 , &-!*,!$!%"01+!9(( 7$0 >'&(#"+-!$ , ',!&'%++0&(9#!-7!%,&7$&(,!+ >"-8 ($ ',! &' +!A.&+!$ " 9" #"+ 8"+ &"(* ,!+!# !+5+<!! =.+>'++!' !$($-".( "#

? +!%":!+!$ #+"- ,!+* ".('!7 #"+ ,! 1! & &"(!+'.8-& ' , ,!1! & &"(!+&'$"% "+($,! >'(" #".($1+!'!( ,!'1" >,!( ,! !-:&'& !$ ($ ,! &:&7 .+9!"(%.-&' +&% 11+"1+& !

. ,"+& 05 7($,+ ,' 7+!$0 #&7!$ %"-17&( 9&(' ,!1! & &"(!+.($!+ !% &"('5B55

($ "# ,! +!"(%!1 &"( ($ +! 7 &9("' &% !%,(&A.!'C+",&8& &"( "# !; !7!% &"(D % 5 5 8!#"+! ,!,&!#.$&%&79&' + !57($,+($

,! - !+ &' '.8<.$&%! ($ "( ,! '-! '! "# 77!9 &"(5 ,! 1+!'!( ,' 8!!( +!9&' !+!$ -87* ".('!7 #"+ ,! 1! & &"(!+ #.+ ,!+ '.8-& ' , & >&778! ,!$!8 87!&''.!>,! ,!+ ,!-87 1"7&%! ,$ <.+&'$&% &"( " +!9&' !+ ,! 5 ' ,!

77!9 &"( 9&(' ,! 1! & &"(!+ 1!+ &(' " ,! "'1& 7 '& . !$ &( 7($,+ ($ %"-17&( &' 7+!$0 #&7!$ 80 ,! 11+"1+& ! . ,"+& 0 ,:&(9 <.+&'$&% &"("#+!*".('!77'"'.8-& ' , !:!( $.+&(9 ,! 1!($!(%0 "# ,! ( &%&1 "+0 8&7 117&% &"(8!#"+! ,! !''&"('.$9!5 ,!1! & &"(!+ ,$<"&(!$ ,!&(:!' &9 &"(5,">!:!+57 !+"( ,!'&$ 117&% &"(>'$&'-&''!$*3!+(!$ !%".('!7,'

(" $&'1. !$ ,!#% .71"'& &"(5'!;17&(!$8":! ($ '.8-& ' , %%.'!$ +<!! =.+ ' ($' ++!' !$*3&' "(

*E 6 ! -" #$$ "#,&$#$ "# #$$&$!$ *,$-( ! !!

%7$'$(#(#,! "$& ,*#$ 6 ! -" #' $!$ " & '/'7* & # $ # "!- $$ ,&$ # # $$ , $! 7 $$$($ /$8 "#, #$$$ $-- 8 +#$$ $ $! ," #/$($( 9""$! 7 $$$($ 9 $( #$$ #--,-

$!$ * ,$- ,7! #$ "$#$( ,$-:* , # $"!$ "#/$($(9""$! % 8 #$$ #--,$ ,*#! $$ $(

'!$ 3 !%!-8!+

C / 4D