← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1182/2024dismissed

The Bhakra Beas Management Board And ANR v. Jai Bhagwan

2024-07-02Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl7 pages

 



  

        

           

             

          

             !  

            !         " #$%&$'&%$%(  "  #

$ %$%$%&'   %   #

$ %()% )  #

&  *+",  & ----- $%$%*+,-*.*/0*'120+3-045672014 8*/ .

/0012/3)/%$%( 3)/112%/%$%( .

/0004/3)/%$%( 3)/1%('/%$%( .

/004(/3)/%$%( 3)/1%40/%$%( 1& "  , 

  

 ,      ,  $5&$2&%$%(      +  ,  +    

2- " &6

,     , $5&$2&%$%(  & %& .

    ,& .

/%2((/3)/%$%( 3)/112%/%$%( .

/%77'/3)/%$%( 3)/1%('/%$%( .

/0$11/3)/%$%( 3)/1%40/%$%( 0& " ," 

 ,74  ,

           +  ,  +     "   8 ,,+,,,"& ,74  ,

    8 "  & (& .

    ,& 3)/112%*1%('1%40/%$%(9  4& .          , 0   8

 3)/ 112%*1%('1%40/%$%( :

$(&$1&%$%( 8  3

 8     "

1(&1$&%$$2 8 ) 

9,,"* . ;+

<  8 /" /38./<*.  

, ,+, & +, :

*  3

         "  , &%  "8  ,0  , ,"=    ,"," ,&9 ,, ,    "8*8 ,,    > 5?

 8   & 5&    "     3

   , 172'177$  +" 

  + ,+  %4@@@, <    "*17(', *A"B&    *,"

3-      177( 

 + ,"

" ,                " ,  " ," *    & , "  8    :

 ,  C .   +99: %-*8;* (7$ <41620=4 +30+448' 6>/01 4*/2- 0=0709+ 9$ *+0:*2'    % ?,  , 8 ,  

,"

  

      " %($    "+ B    , "  " ""  

8 3

  "  , " ,            

" 

,* +  %4@@@ ,  "*  ,, , "   8   

" 8 +&D

 + +  %4/@,"*   " +

8

 *3

   8 ,,"  +  ,     "  "" 8   

  +" , & '&

&    +   8    

     "       8 +    ""  B       , " "      "  ,   " " 9*  &

, "   "%'&$%&177$

C)/2    ,"    "&    *      :

 ,   .  *@;4+2 95 &*347 +7:41298' AA*0+ (7$ *8+*3*8/412801%6::/@ +,67280*/9$2,$ *+92-48'?? % !?  8          3



4-    

      ,"       8,  8 * ! &5'*   "8 +  8  , ""   ,, 8  , 8 ,  ""  &<   8 3



: ," "            

  "   "  ,  

" 



&<  "    "+ 8  ""  8   + &  6     , 

%""," " , 

   " 

 

 ,  " ,      ,  8  "  ""

    %4/@@@, "& 2& E       8 "  ,  & , "%'&$%&177$

C)/ 2            "  ,     "  ,    

    * +"     &&,&  C   && %2&$%&177$&  !" ,,

 +  + ""   &  "   # FG .9!

 H.<9!9 )9E E<!; @ GC"+G

* ;

+ &* ):"*  &   

   , ;  *    , 

 *  D* " *6  &

5-

8# !", "   %4@@@,<&&"* 17('& I8  , " *   "   ,        

 , *  +"  

J &&,&%2&%&7$&!&& )  ",  & I+ ""   ,

 "  , " ,  9;=E= =<<)* &

=/ GC"+G

* ;;

+ * ):"*    &!&%$'7/2%1  #%'&%&7$ 7&  3

     ,  8"  +  %4%48,"" "     + B  "&8:"  

B  +" 8        ,&   8

                  

8,"   +  " 8   &" 8 ,"",     "    , & 1$& <  *8A0+,48 %0+3- (7$ 6+A*> %2*24 &*84-9670+3 98:98*209+'    % ?  :  " ,   17'$   177$    

K  "

 "  ,  K ,&  < ""

 "   " ,      J8J8 

 +      ) 8,.  &+  "   ) <,  " 02*07*(0(0 , 

  ": "  "+   

6- ,,

,&" ",E,G   , ,".  . +   "" 8  ,  

     "    

   8 ,"    ,     + ,   +* J    &  <,       8   *  3

   + " "   "" , %4@@@,"   + ,+   + 8  " & 11&        ,  ," &

, " "  8    :

    *3>08 %0+3- (7 *8@*+* %2*2438016/268*/ *8B420+39*8,?!% *4=0+,48%0+3- (7 6+010:*/96+10/'%*+*68'%! 77072*+2+30+448'

*A*72-*+ 4=4/9:;4+2 98:98*209+ *+, *+92-48 (7 02*; %0+3-   ! %  &      -*8*2 %*+1-*8 03*; 2,$ (7 *+ %0+3-%!!* ,  ,   *  , "   & 1%&  :

 ,  8  "  ,     ) ,E  < "*H::     ," " ,   8 ,"

 ) ,E  "*1705 ,"+  "" , ,,  

8   8 +      %4@@@, ",

& 10& E          3

 

    ,  "   "  "  %'&$%&177$* "8+*          "" , "" ,   J  * 8   , "  

8

" 

"

7-     ,* " 8    

8  "  & 1(& <  """  " * ,"     + "   8    8   3

    ,,,  ,   "    , "   , &    *  8   & 

"      ,& $%$%&   % $$   ()%     E 

=  # I   E 8#  !