High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6989/2015dismissed

Ram Niwas v. Jagdish Parshad And ANR

2017-11-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

"# $

%" &'(")(*($ +"$',$$ "

%" -."()& /'*($ +"$'"#, $#

"(0" $'#,$$ #+"#$$ /(#+$'),1/ 21/) $($

41" 56,(##70$'"*# (81"$ *9''""($ :,(##70$'$"(81"$ ") (8 $ ; +

5 : +" #1)) / $' "#, (1#9(##$(# "++($#+$'(#("$'($$'(1# 9(#

71# ##$/*) 0 $"#$( (#.$'),8( $$,1"'(# '#8( )(#1" /.( (8 )("8(#$9''$'),8( $'( #'9 '# (78$0 '"+"(1# (#.$'),8( $$/$ #(841$ '#+(*1"( $,(0$'()1 $ $"#$<

5=,") $',"'1 " " /80$'),8( $(/"$ ,1"'(#$'8( +"$$(8 # :!>5=( +4$' ($+"41$ +$'#(8

7$'$' $ ( (1# 9" ,"# $ $' ++ + &17

/#$"(" &17 '#8 ?( ( ( $' ),8( $ ,1"'(# #$(),

,(,"#( /$$'#(8"(+$9$'1$,(0) $+ # :!>5= $9(##'9 $'($$'#()1 $'(#(8"(07 ,(($$''1#+ (1# 1# /$$'#/ ($1"#+$'),8( $

$( ",$( $'),8( $,1$'##/ ($1"# $'," $ ",$9$'$'',$'($(1# 918,",("$'"," $# ",$#+ >5=(' '"(+$"(1# "+1#$ 41$$'#(8( $"$1"

$'(+"#(," $#( ",$# $#+1"$'"(88/$'($9' $'),8( $$8(1# $'($'#/ /$8/(),8( $9$'$',8(1#

"$1"

$' (+"#( ," $# ( ",$# ( $'"(+$" $' $()$.

9$'($(1# 70,8(0 /(+"(141$ $'," $( ",$#+ # 8(#($ >

+ # @(#($ >

( $'" + # >5= ($

#$( +

>5=('+":," $# 881# 9$''#7"$'"(1# A$'$'#(88/($ $',"# $),8( $9(#+8 $',"8) ("0* $'),8( $4() () ?1)("(#A (0( $<.18(#A "$'*'( &'(")( A"$"(#A:( $'),8( $')#8+'(#(,,(" $'9$ ## 74(#A '"(+$"'$ "#)1) $#( 8#$' ,"8) ("0* ' $"(8 1"$ $'"(+$" * "" ($ :

#1)) "#, $# /( #$$'#""$'0+8 ( "*# ,$$ 7+"$'1"$+### # -),1/ ""($

$'"*# ,$$ 9(#(889( $'"(+$"$',"#

,$$ '(#7 +8 '"*# (81"$9'8,(## /$'),1/ ""'(# )($'+889 /7#"*($

+$"7#$9 /$'1/'$+18 $$'("/1) $# $'#1"$+ #+" $' $ $ +8("

1 #8+"

$',$$ "#

$918 $71$+,8($) $ '"$'($ $'#(# C1"01 9(#/$ 1$70 $'1"$( C1"0 1$70& & ?( (#

""( 1" / C1"0#$($) $#+"#,$(78#9" "" #$($) $+(0( $<.(8# +$"()9' '(# 7 4() 70 $' ),8( $ ,"8) ("0 * (#A D ;

''(#()$$$'($(/#'

$',$$ ",1"'(#$'8( +") ()9(#( () 9(#'( $" $( (/") $$,1"'(#$'($8( +")(/#'( ," $#9"+881,+$'()1 $+ #(8 $'#," $#9"+881,+"( #1)+ >5=9'"(#(/"#(8 9(#

# :!>5=( $'1#+"/"09(#))$$9'"(# '# #$($) $)($$',870$'#9$ ##1" / C1"0 : :''(#) $ $'($' $.

9(#$ 9'0'9(#$(#(9$ ##( '##$($) $$'(# (,,("$'($ ()9(#'((#.')$7)(9$ ## $'#(8+ .( (8>)("8(+8( 9'''9(# ,1"'(# /( ()9(#(88(/#' $8,' ( "/#$"09(# $++$ $'($($ " $#9" $ +881,7+"')( ''( .

98/++88 /1,+ $#( ''( .

98/(71$$'($ $ ' #$($) $+(0( $""1" /,8 C1"0#,(.# *81)#$'($ '($ /'(#7 70$',$$ "

: * $'#(#2 $#$($) $+"#,$(78#,"# #8. &(",( '+*88(/'8(9(# ()80 ()*$(" (/'7"

& /' &1)" & /' 4=&(",( ' %('(7" # +

"(7'($ @(8 (* "# + ()"& /'( %( 2 ?1)("# +()"& /'1" / C1"0 9(#"" 9'" $'((,,("$'($((#+870 ()9(#9(# 9" / ' $ $ ()9(#9(# $/(

.( (8>)("8(+8( +(/#'9(#(2 /$$'8( +

() 9(# ( "/(" / $' $'" 8( (71$$ / "( $#9"+881,( $'#," $#9""$1"

70 (/#'$ ()9(#( )($$""/(" /$'($8( '( )7+"$' '(0($( $9(#(/"$'($$'#1$ +870 ()9(# $'1"$($%' "/("'9187 9$'"(9 (/#'91841$$'#(8+

.( (8>)("8(8( 9''9(#(2 /$'8( + () 9(#( $'#1$9''9(#+870 ()9(# $'0("

9(#9$'"(9 70') $'0(" $'7(##+ ),")# & +") $' * ,8( "" +"(118 $ $ $ +$'"*# #$## $)(1$ ( 0+"(17 ))$$$' ()9(#918 $'(* $" $$'),")#9$'(/#'$',$$ "( 918 $'(*9$'"(9 '#*8#1$, / *8 1"$($%' "/("'( * #(8+ .( (8>)("8( +8( (71$$ /+8#+),8( $'(#(8"(07 /$ 41$9''+1"$'"#'9#$'($ '($ / '(#7

70(/#'9$' ()9(# $'"9# ()9(# 918 $'(*/$#(8+ .( (8>)("8(+8( (2 / $ '# 8( "/#$" (+$" #$$1$ + $'#

1"$'")"$'),8( $'(#()$$'##/ ($1"#

$'"," $#( (#,"&$

;++$'/$(78 #$"1) $#$ ;;

$'"#,"#1),$ +(*1"+ '8" $'($ ,")##"0 $ 9(# )( " "(9 +"

+")$'* ,8( ""$#

$)(1$$'($$9(#7$( 70(/#'+") () 9(#70( 0$+18)"70+"(1 $#$'*"# + "*# #$$'($',1"'(#.( (8 )("8(+8( +")

()9(#( $',("$$ ," /#'"*#

.( (8>)("8(+8( (2 /$$'8( +'#8( (

.( (8>)("8(+8( (2 /$"(( 8( (2 /$ $'"(( ("$(7(9(#*"0#$80( ##(8 +$'($8( 9(#+4($ >5=( #(8 +$'($8( )(#"1 / .( (8>)("8( (2 / $ $' 8( + () 9(# 9(# +4 ($

# :!>5= 71$ $' 9"$" ))$$ )#$(.

#"7 /$'#(8( $'($#9'0#(818 $7 41$( +$9(# $#$' ),8( $918 $ '(*,1"'(# $'8( )(#1" / .( (8>)("8(+") (/#'(+$"+8 /+$'#),8( $ 8#+( 0/18$0 $ $ +(/#''(7 $'"$' '918 $'(* "$1"

$'," $#

> 9"$$ (/") $'(#7 7"1/'$ ""$#'9 $'($(/#'(/"$#88.( (8 )("8(+8( +"( # :!>5= * * '(#7

7"1/'$ ""70$'),8( $$#'9$'($88$"

"($+#)8("80#$1($8( #)(#1" /.( (8 )("8( 9(# # :!>5= * 9$ ##+),8( $ (0( '(# $#1,,"$$'(#+),8( $9' ')( #$($) $7+"$' C1"0++"1" / C1"01 "

&$ "

* $' C1"0 ","$ $ '(# (,,("$'($$'#,1$9(#"/(" /$'"$1"

+()1 +#$(),#9''9",1"'(#($$'$)+41$ + #(8 9'# ,'$,0 (" (8"(0 "" ' $9' (,,("(#A'(#()$$$'($#$(), ,(,"#9" $"$1"

$') '"# / $(

,#$** $'""$#'9$'($(/#''( (/"$+881,( ()1 $+ >5=(' $'$'" $##/ 70$'),8( $ * $' C1"0","$ # (/( #$ $' ),8( $ @("

89" 1"$ '(# $ #"$' C1"0","$ "/'$,"#,$*( '(# $ /* $' $(8 "(# # '# 1"$ '(# +(8 $ "#$( (#$'98("

89"1"$#1)) (1# 1 D 9' $# $((#+'($ / 70),"# ($ (8#$'"# * +1#+ (88/+"/1) $# ," $#(#/ 1 ($'"

$'#," $#'(*7 "$1"

$$'),8( $ & * &$ !

# $($$"($

## (#$'," $9(##/ 70$'),8( $( 9(#'( *"$(/#'$' (#,"&$ +$' /$(78 #$"1) $#$ ;;

(/#'7()$''8"

+ $' ," $ ( $' #$"1) $ # #( $ '(* 7

/$($ ' "#) $##($'(*7 )(

78( ./* /(1$'"$0$$''8"$+88$1,9$'( ()1 $( $'1#$'," $(+$"#/ /9(#'( *"

70$'),8( $$(/#'9$''##9$988( +" # $ '"# $' / ""$#'9$'($$'," $ 9(#7$( 70+"(1

! & $'9(.+(7*#1## 9'($$#,(.+,")( +((#* (##)(1$(/( #$(1# @("

89" 1"$ '(# ))$$ /"(* """

#1)) /(1# '""# $8/(8( ""$ & $' ),1/ "" ($ : # #$ (# " /80$'"*# #(,$ E $##17)$$ 7'(8++$',$$ "$'($$'"9(#(

"(8(/") $7$9 $',$$ "( (1# 9$'"/("$ 41$ +$'#(8( $'#()9(# $('"$70') $# (8##17)$$$'($ $'7(##+$',"8) ("0* 870$' ,$$ "$'$"(81"$'(##1)) "#, $#+ /,")(+( (#( $'(#) $'* +$',"#1$ 9$ ##$'($ "#, $ #$(+/$$ /#(841$+"(118 $80/$ $'," $#41$ $#(8##17)$$$'($$' C1"0 1$70 $',81 9(# $,","80(,,"($

$'$'"'( 8("

1 #8+"$'"#, $#'(#

("/1$'($"*# (81"$ "=(,,"($ +* ""'(# +1 $'($,")(+( (##)(1$$#1)) $',$$ "$ +($"(8 +$"'(" /8("

1 #8+"$',("$#+ )"$ $' ,"# $ "*# ,$$ # ," $' (# #$ 1, 70 $' $ ' '( ()$$ '# #/ ($1"# $'" ," $# ( $'"+"$'#(" /$(78 #$"1) $9$' $',1"*9+&$

"( 9$' &$

; +$' /$(78 #$"1) $#$ ;;

$'"+"$',$$ "=),8( $(

$ 0#17#C1 $80$'($$'# $#9" +($/$41$70,8(0 /+"(1 '(##$1,70 $'),8( $$'($$'(1# '(#(/"$#88'#.( (8 )("8(+8( 70+4 /#(8 # :!>5=# $,"* ""(# $'"( 0(/") $ "( 0#(8"( 0",$+ ,(0) $+()1 $9(#,"1 "" '$"(81"$/$(

C1"0 1$70$',81 ( (#,"

$'# C1"0","$$#+1 $'($$'"#(#,1$"/(" /"$1"

+ ()1 $+#$(),,(,"9''9(#,1"'(#+",1",#+41$ + $'#(8( $'()1 $9(# $"$1"

70$'(1#,"#

'# C1"0","$#'9#$'($$'($$'),8( $'(#')#8+(/"$ +881,$'()1 $ $'#$'"," $# ,"#1(8+$'#1)) / "",(##70$'$"(81"$#'9#$'($$'$"(81"$'(# $$(. $ $'#","$1 @("

1 #8 +" $' "#, $ '(# "8 1, $' 21/) $+ F78&1,")1"$ (# 36 3") (86 ;D9'" $'(#7 '8$'($ $'1"$ $'1"#+$"(8'(#

"$$',8$ 1$ C1"0 $')($$"( #17)$$#","$ 8($"+$'$"(81"$ $"801, $'#( ","$$'(#$""(+ /+"#(/" /9$'#1'","$( (

$/ "$'","$ '#,"1"9(# $+88970$'$"(8 1"$ '+ //* $' C1"0","$1 #$'($$#(*8#,1$"/(" /"+1 +) 0+#$(),,(,"(8# + ##1,,"$+")$'+($$'($ +$'9$ ##+$',$$ "

()80(0( $'(# $#1,,"$'#*"#

"$'"(# ##$($(7*+ )"$ $',"# ,$$ $'#()##)## # $%&'(&')*+'),+'- .()/

# A'$'"#,(. /5"(# #5 A'$'" ,"$(78 #5