High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6998/2015dismissed

Shingara Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-03-26Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

"#$$%&'&() *

+,&(-"."+&(-, $#&#&($.

/$.'0'

+#"#$ 0(1"2#,$.'

$'3(4$(#'

.$'$(#) .50',"64$$3++"(4,0748%"#$.#,$3$#&#&($. ,$&('#"(#3$#&#&(&6$40(4$.+$%#&(: . &'4&.$%#$4 "-"&('# #,$ .4$. 4"#$4

:7 3"''$4 2; #,$ 6$".($4 44&#&("6 +$''&('04-$7<04,&"("8&4$=,&%,#,$.4$.4"#$4 >

:73"''$42;

7<04,&"("'0??(&(-.$'3(4$(#'( #:"'"44&#&("6"%%0'$4 &(%"'$ 4"#$4 >

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

%064(#,"8$2$$(.$1$%#$4(6;(#,$2"'&'#,"#,$,"4(#"##.&20#$4 '3$%&&%&(10.&$'##,$3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#' "8&(-,$".46$".($4%0('$6.#,$3$#&#&($."#6$(-#,"(4 ,"8&(-3$.0'$4#,$36$"4&(-'(.$%.47"?#,$%('&4$.$48&$=#,"#( -.0(4.&(#$.$.$(%$&'?"4$0# ( #,$ &.'# &('#"(%$7 &# ?"; 2$ (#&%$4 #,"# #,$ 7 <04,&"("=,&6$3"''&(-#,$.4$.4"#$4 >

:"#(($B0.$ =,&6$ '0??(&(-#,$3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#',$.$&("'"44&#&("6"%%0'$4,"42$$( "6&8$##,$'$##6$43.&(%&36$'-8$.(&(-$B$.%&'$3=$.0(4$.'$%#&(* . "(4 ,"42'$.8$4 &(#,$.4$.&#'$6#,"#'0%,3=$.=,&%, &' %($..$4(#,$%0.#',0642$0'$48$.;'3".&(-6;"(4(6;&%?3$66&(- .$"'('$B&'#.#"C&(-%-(&A"(%$(6;#,$("3$.'(%"(2$"44$4"' "44&#&("6"%%0'$420##,$.$"#$.,"'3.%$$4$4#"66=#,$"336&%"#&( 0(4$.'$%#&(* &(#,$6&-,##,$66=&(-2'$.8"#&(')

! "

%&' #

(

)* + ,$$(#&.$4&'%0''&(=,&6$'0??(&(-#,$"44&#&("6"%%0'$4 &'2$.$#"(;.$"'(&(-#,$("#0.$$8&4$(%$2.0-,#(.$%.4=,&%,

* %0642$%('#.0$4"'?0%,'#.(-$.$8&4$(%$#',=?.$#,"("3.&?" "%&$%"'$"(4?$.$3.2"2&6&#;#,$%?36&%&#;#,$3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#' ,$.$&(&(#,$"66$-$4%%0..$(%$,$.4$.,"'2$$(3"''$4&(".0#&($"(4 ?$%,"(&%"6"',&( ,$'%3$"(4"?2&##,$3=$.#,$0.#0(4$.+$%#&( * #,$4$.&?&("6 .%$40.$%"?$03.%('&4$."#&(2$.$#,$ (D26$+03.$?$0.#(4&"&(

!"!

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

,#. .

( )* #

$ ,

'!0!/**1234567!8 /9/ & #

# #

+ 48$.#&(-2"%C##,$"%#'#,$3.$'$(#%"'$7&#="'-($ 0(%(#.8$.#$4#,"#&(.$6"#&(##,$"66$-$4%%0..$(%$4"#$4*

7&( #,$ '#"#$?$(# %?36"&("(#@3$#&#&($. +,&(-"." +&(-, .$%.4$4 0(4$. +$%#&( . #,$3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#',$.$&(=$.$($8$.("?$4,$&. ("?$'7"''0%,74&4(#$8$(&-0.$&(#,$ ,$3$#&#&($.,"4"6'(# ?8$4"(;"336&%"#&(##,$,&-,$.36&%$&%&"6''"'#&?36&%"#$#,$ 3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#',$.$&(&(#,$"66$-$4%%0..$(%$"''"06#"(4%"0'&(- &(10.&$' #&'(6;"#$."3$.&4"33.B&?"#$6;*;$".'"(4=,&6$ .$%.4&(-'#"#$?$(#"' E*#,"##,$3$#&#&($.( *

:,"'("?$4 #,$3.&8"#$.$'3(4$(#',$.$&("(4?"4$"("##$?3##&?36&%"#$#,$?8$( &('0%,'#"#$?$(#('3$%&&%&(10.;@.6$,"'2$$("##.&20#$4##,$3.&8"#$ .$'3(4$(#' ,$&?30-($4.4$.&'0(4#2$2"'$4(%-$(#"(48"6&4 .$"'(&(- +0%,.$"'(&(-&'&(6&($=&#,#,$4&%#0?6"&44=(2;#,$ (D26$+03.$?$0.#&(

& '03."!"'

.$-".4'$B$.%&'$3=$.0(4$.'$%#&(*

-.0(4.&(#$.$.$(%$&'?"4$0#,$&('#"(#3$#&#&(&'7 "%%.4&(-6;74&'?&''$4

$#&#&(4&'?&''$4

60%C;

E,$#,$.#2$.$$..$4# $3.#$.F$'