High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5880/2016disposed of

Payal Bindal And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2016-02-18Mr. Justice Krishna Murari6 pages

!"#"$% &'( ') *

) +"$, + $, $- ' . ""$ '# /# ($1 & $, $- ' . #2$, $# % 34 00

' # $% '0 ,"*0',5!

6"- '45 7"'

0- +*,5!

'- 2 ""$ '#

""$ '#

) + "$, + $, - ' -(#& $, 0 $1 5 8(9 +-'(:-"$# $2 ""$($, '0 !"$;' # 7<( #-"$:

' :"# ' , +"! 0 "$="'

72('($, '0 !"$#;> $,

++- #(&# <( $2'! ,"$:# ++ :"$:- - - #& $' :"# ' , - "$# $! $ 00 - $, !+ "9"$: -"9# + & - ' #", $ /"#-'

$"")*="'

72('- !- 2 '$ '#>#0 "2 '9 $#

$, $'

#'(!(' - 5 #+, 2+# "$ /"#-'

$" ") $ 6-"!- $(9& ' 2 '#$# - , !$#'(! , -(# # $, & "$ , + !'"!") !$$ !"$ $ 2'"+* ;*

'$ 8 (' $ ' , - !+$) $ 2'"+ * ; $,

"$'9 ,- 2+#- 5 & $6'$:+)#+,- !92+ "$ $ $,- ' 2 '#$#0- '

"# , $! $($ ?* ; $!"'!+"$:- 2'2 ') ' 0 ,"* + '$ , # $"' !($# + ' - 2 ""$ '# - !$ $, , - - 9 ' - , & $ "$5 #":

, &) '9 0"$:-* 0 *

+"! 0 "$ ") ="'

72(' $, ' 2' , - "' !'# - 92 $) 5 #+,- + $,

'$ 8 ('6-"!-- ,& $# ) ,*&):"5"$:7- #'

$(9& '#," ' $' ,#4 '$ * 0- , ,&)$#2 !'-(2"$, ' 0"$:- ($, - 2 ""$ '# # "$$! $ $, - #(&9" , -"# ' 2' 5",

$$ @(' A- !- 2 ""$ '#

) +"$, + $,0 $1 58(9 + ' ($, "$$! $ 4 '$ , !($# + ' - 2 ""$ '# - #(&9" ,- # !$,!- $6 "$#(&9" , "$#0(#-"+"$, + - 2 ""$ '# - 5 + '$ - 2'# !("$ : $!) - # 2'!(' , '' # $# "$# - 2 ""$ '# &) 0 - $ 0"$:- &) 95"$:

22+"!

"$$6-"!-- (,"!"

##* '

##"5", ', ' , ,5 9& ' * - #"##( , $#&-- 2 ""$ '#

+$:6"-6 $# 9

1 $,0(9" #- ' 6 #$# )&) $)('

"$#- '' #- 2 ""$ '#' ,"*0 $"',5! '"$: '- 2 ""$ '#- ##(&9" ,- - 2 '(# +- "$,"!

#- - 2 ""$ '# - 5 & $ "$5+5 , "$ - !

# & "$: - 2 '$ '# "$ -

"'#>#0 "2 '9 $# $,$'

#'(!(' &(- 5 '"(#2 '$ '#-"2 , ,# '9 A "$,"!

- - 2 ""$ '# ' $- 2 '$ '# 5 $ -(:- - &'- ' 2 ""$ ' * $ 9 +)* 0(#-"+ "$, + "# '$ '6 +# ':( ,- - 2 ""$ '#- 9# +5 #- ,2('!- # ,

2+# "$ /"#-'

$" ") $ ($ A* A +)"$: (2$ - !- ': #- ($, ' 0 !"$ ?A BC ' #(&9" , <( - ! !!(# , - 2 ""$ '#* " 6 ':( , &) ' ," - - ++ :

"$# # ++"$: $, $,"$: 5 ' - 2## ##"$ - 2+# 6 ' "$# 0(#-"+ "$, +* /"#- +) +* 9

9* - 0- '9 *1 )8(9 ' !0 9 $#($, ' 0 !"$

' 6"$ ## #6 ' ' +" ,(2$&)' ,"#(&9" 2 ""$ '# - 5 $ & $ $ 9 , &) $) 6"$ ## - 5"$: !! 2 , 9$ )$& - +- 2 '$ '#-"2'- 5"$:, +6"-- "'#- '$ '#-"2 - , +# ' +" ,(2$ - !$ $# D ;E? "$ #(22' -"# !$ $"$ - - 2 ""$ '# ' * ,"' !+) ' "$,"' !+)*$!$! '$ ,6"-- "'# $)2 '$ '#-"2"'9 ##(!- 2 '- 1(,:9 $

! " #" !$ %&*

EE 0 ;* $ !:$"F &+ $! - 5"$: & $ 9 , ( "$# - 2 ""$ '#*- , # '5 #& <( #- , - 5 - ', + '$ , !($# + ' - 2 ""$ '# $, !

' (++) !$#", ' ,- !$ $"$#"$!$ @- # (#- "$5 #":

"$ $, ' 2' ($, ' 0 !"$ ?A BC ' - 2 ""$ '# - 5 $ & $ !- $ , "++ , $ - & #"# - 9 '"

+ '9"$: 2 ' - "$5 #":

"$ '$ ,0 $"',5!

- #' '' ,- 2+"! 2'! ,"$:# ' !', , ' - "$5 #":

"$ !$ $, - !- $ ($, ' 0 !"$# ;> - #& $"+ , "$# - 0- '9 $,/"9 +8(9 '"$- ('(,"!"

## ('- '#(&9"#- 0(#-"+8(9

' + 6 +# '' # , $ 2'"+ E* &) 0 - $ 0"$:- ' "$5 #":

"$<( - ' 9 "$"$: !!(# ,$ 06 #!$#"( ,- , ,&) $,"6 #&# '5 ,- '!92+ "$:- "$5 #":

"$- ' 9 "$"$:

!!(# ,#-(+,& 22' - $, , $,- '

' ## 2 !- $6(+,& 2' # $ , & ' - (' $ - & #"# # ", &# '5 "$#"$- ' 2' ($, '0 !"$ ?ABC' D- $<( #"$ , #6- "#- $ ,'<( #-"$:- 6- $ - 2'# !("$ : $!) "++ , - # $ 2 , 2' # $ !-

"$# - 2 ""$ '#* + '$ , !($# + ' - 2 ""$ '# - # 5 - 9 $+) (': ,- $- & #"#- ++ :

"$#"$- *-(:-- !- $- $ & $ 2' # $ , "$# - 2 ""$ '# &( $ - & #"# #9 &# '5 "$#9 , ,('"$:2+"! 2'! ,"$:#"$- 2+"! ," ')* 92 "#& "$:9 , '' #- 2 ""$ '#' ' $! - #& $9 , - "$ '"9 ', ' , , 5 9& ' * 2 ## , &) (,"!"

+ # + ##* '

##"* "##("$: '' # 6 $# "$# - 2 ""$ '# $ -

22+"!

"$0- $0"$:- 0"$! - 2'# !("$ : $!)- #$2' # $ ,!- "$# - 2 ""$ '# $, - ) ' $ & "$: '" , $ - & #"# - * - 2 ""$'<( #-"$:- '#& 2' 9 (' - 5 !$#", ' , - !$ $"$ + '$ , !($# + ' - 2 ""$ '#' :

',"$:- "++ :

+")- 22+"!

"$# 7"$: $#

"$#- 2 ""$ '# $,- ', '#(,"!"

##* '

##" ++6"$:- 22+"!

"$- 22'2'"

' 9 ,)6"-- 2 ""$ '#

6(+, & # 72' !"$- "' +"& ') &) "+"$: - ' 9 ,) ($, ' 0 !"$;A' &) 22' !-"$:- ('!92 $1('"#,"!"$ 2 '+ 6 0"$! #2 '!$ $"$#+ '$ ,!($# +'- 2 ""$ '#* - 2 ""$ '#- 5 $& $ ":$ , !!(# ,&)2' # $ "$!- &( 92"#& "$:9 , '' #- 9&)# 7"$: $#* #(!-- ' "# 22' - $#"$ '' #"$- *- 2 ""$ '#9 ) "+ - ' 9 ,)# 72' !"$- "'+" $,+"& ')&) "+"$:- ' 9 ,) ($, '0 !"$ ;A ' $- 2' # $ 2 ""$* - ', ' , ,5 9& ' * - #$& $!- ++ $: ,$- :'($,- $! - <( - 2 ""$ '#"#<( #- ,$- & #"#- !- $2' # $ ,

"$# - - ' !!(# ,* - 2 ""$ '# 6(+, & $"+ , ++ - !$# <( $"

+& $ "# , $ "$, - ':(9 $# !$5"$!"$: 2 '#$ "$# 6-9 - 2'# !("$ : $!) - # 2 , $ 2' # $ !- $ !

$$ & , !!(# ,($"+- "##(99$ , !!(# ,&)- (''$ - & #"# $)('- '"$5 #":

"$- 5", $! !++ ! , "$#- !

!!(# ,- 2 ""$ '#!

$$& !$#", ' ,<( #-- 2'! ,"$:#<(

2 '#$ 6- - #$ & $ !- $ , "#$ ('

+!$# <( $! $$ @"# $! $) 5", $! "$# 2 '#$- - )- 5 $& $!- $ , - 2 ""$'<( #-"$:- "#2' 9 (' $,$9 "$ "$ &+

""$ '# ' ' + :

,- + '$ "5 ' 9 ,)2' !"$: - "' +"& ') &) !- ++ $:"$: - ', ' "##( $! 6 $# 6"-( -

2 ""$ '# - 5"$: & $ !- $ , $, - - 5"$: $ 7 $ !:$"F $! #2 '2'5"#"$#0 !"$ E' "#2# ,6"-- &5 ,"' !"$# -"## :

&'( ') *

B0C # $1 )