Swaran Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#$%%& "#"'#( !"#$%%&
" )*$ "#+,- %'
./( %0%01 21)3).
"#+,- %'
./( %0% 3)-
! "
#
$
%%% %0%01 21)3).% &
'
&& () *(*+ , # "
,
+(*-!
*
'
.- /0 !"
,' 1 2
3
! !
"
" #$ !% & ' " ( ) * +" ,+
" " " "" % &% " " , - . & "
"
/ ( * "
" % &
" ! $ % &
" % & 0$ . & " +
$ 1
$$ "% & !+"
$ 2 " "
$ "
"
$$ " % & "
% & /3 3
4
$ %
% &
2 "" "
$ " "$ " " " $ ( *
'5 "
2 +" ' % &
! $ $
% '
$ " 6/7
"
4
$$ "% &
% &
" " $ "
" . &
% & "
+ +" '
/ !' " $
"
! 1 + ! !89:
;< => ><<< ?
+
.- , 3 0 2 -145
6
/0 7"
'
5(8 &* *(((
-
,
2 "
, 4 2
2
"
2
,
,
,
+(*-!
! !
,*:
() *((&
$
+(*-!
; ,
3
+(*-!
, , ! <
=
0 >3& =
$ ?
=
.
$
!
3 0 ,7 &*9(
(< &* *((( - , = $ >3& 3 " @#3 !" / "
"
" " "
" " " $ - " $
8 / " $ $
% "
$ & " A "
!
"& 9/ = ! " > >B< 6" $
# "$$ $ " $ C
9 "
$ $
" & + $ " =><<
$ " #<<
5 % $ " $
" ><
" !& D =" / "
& D = ""
8 $ "& " "
" "$ / " => >E
! $ 9/ = / $ / B " > : $ 8 - $$
= =E$ AF 8;
$ / $ AB 8;= $ " &
"! : ?
'
0 >3* 4! 2 @ >3+! A @ >39! >< ! # '
0 >38'
5
.- /0 !"
'
0 >3B?2
& ,>38 ' '
0 >3:
0 /0 @ 4 3 0 ,
'
0 2 >3)
,>38' >3B?2 4 ,
' 4 ' $
6
/0 7"
4
.? 0
+&+! !
, -
,
, ! :
?
, , , >38' >3B?2 , 7
" ,
2
B
,
, , .- ?
6
'
2
, ,
! 6 ,
,
,
+(9 --!
+(*-!
)
5 >38' >3B?2
, ,
-
,
,
, , 4
,
,
, - ' >38"
?2 >3B" ,
.
, ,
,
+(*-!
, . ,
>38' >3B?2 , !
&(
>
,
7 &&
'
, 3'
>38"
B
?2 >3B"
7
" 7
> ,
4 2
7
2 '
7
" 4 0 , 7 / 4 2 7 : 2 "
4 , :
7 C ,
?2 >3B" , 7 2 4 2, , ,
# 4
- 3 0 2
4
'
, >38 '
, ,>3B?2
,
7 4
7
&*
'
>38 ' >3B ?2
,
'
0 >3) 2 -145
4
'
.- /0 !"
4
6
/0 7" .?
/0 ?"
/ 2
, 5 (8 &* *(((
4 3
@
-
(:
&* *(((
:
@ " '
2 2 ,
/0 D"
,
/0 4
2 0
&+
>38 ' >3B ?2 ,
, 7
:
(2 "
= $ >3&"
,3
E= ! " > >B< 6" $
# "$$ $ " $ C
9 "
$ $
" & + $ " =><<
$ " #<< % $ " $
" >< - " ?
>3& = $ ,A &3 2 ,A & , 4
3
/0 = &9
?
, ,
, !
4
>38 ' >3B
?2
>
,
, , ! >
! ,
! 7
7
,
2
7
' ,>38 '
,>3B ?2
2 , 2
/ 2 , , 3
,
&<
>38' >3B
?2
,= $
>3&
B
/
, ,
' ,
2 ,
>38' >3B?2 ,
&8
=
+(*-! ,
+(9 --!
- ,
2
,
2 ! 6 ,
,
+(9-- &"-!
&B
'
4F
!
/0
A 9
+((-!
3 37 $ $
" <>!8: 1 "
<>!8: <E!8: >G!8: 4 "
& " / $ "$ "& "&
" 4
"
! "
"
$$
"
" $
$$
! "
/ " "
$
& 3
4 &:
, 4F
!
! "# !$ 3 3== B$ <<!8:
AB$
"
$
( $
*
B$ " $ " $$ $ AB$ $ $ $
$ %" AB$ = $
/
AB$ E $
" ) "" " $
AB$ E AB$ =& 4 $
! AB$ E
" " " " $
$
" " 4
4 $ $ $ $ 4 1 3 3 $
$
"
$
" $ H "
AB$ $$ $ $$ " AB$ = $
1 $
" $
! " " $
$$ " $ AB$ E (*" $ (*
(* "
(* "$
" AB$ E
! 3 3
AB$ E << !8: !8: ! " .
$
4
$
" $ "
1 "" $
" " " "$ ! $
"
4
! 4 " 4
$$ $
H $$ AB$ E
" " 4
" $ ! "
B$
3 3 $
3 3 ?
&)
- 2 $ % "& $' ()*+++
+(*
+(9-+(9---! 4F
! G >7
$ $ 4 " "
"
<> <E8 !
<E8 !! $
/$
4
"
& $ 0 & $
5
$ ! 1 $ " $ $
$ $
" !
$ <>
$ <E8 !!!
$ $ <>
"
" 9(* "$ I(*" "$ "
" $$
$ I(*" "
$ I( *
$ & I( *" "
4
I( *"
" " $ I( *"
" $ " "
I ( * " " $
$
I(B*"
" $
I(B*" $
& I(B*" "
"
B $ " " " 4 % ?
*(
-
, - .- #/ 0 *
4F
! 3 # !1 -&J1 -& 0 !(><=<*G::
E#9(><=<*::(:
*=K :
& B " "
<>" !
:
"$
$ " " " $
!
: $
" "
" $ "
# E !1 L J1 L '& (><==*=<::G<E9(><=>*=::
(:
*7#K" " "" $ !" $ "
" $ : " "
<> AB$ E <<!8: ! : & B
"
!
:
!
$
"
&
$ " "$ " # 1 " : + -( $ * :
""
<> <E8 ! <E 8 !! :
&
<> !8: ! :
AB$ E << !8:
$ >= 9(::$ >=*
6 3>= 0 AB$ E $
$ $
9(* " " $ I(* " I(* $
$ 4
I( *
3 *&
, '
. 1 , ()2030 4F
! 3 = ! "
& "
" <E 8 !!!8:
" & &
" $$ " " $ $
(*" " $ I(* "$ I(*
B
$$ 1 " " $
& "
" "
" =E ! LJ(=77*=::>G9 =77::(:
*>=K :
&
<>!8: ! & "
7 $$
$
& "
.:
<E8 !!!8: & . "
& $
<<!8: L
8&J1!-=76$ : EGK: 4 <> !8:
: ( L J(=77*=::>G9=77::(:
*>=K ::$ <$ E*
% 5 L
J1!-=76$ : EGK 9(L
J1!-=76$ : EGK1!-$ EG6$ =G* 3=G 2 $ 5 $ 4 "
& " " " 4 "
4 $
$ 3
" 9(L
J1!-=76$ : EGK1!-$ EG6$ =GM=#* 3=G 4 " $
& "
& $
$ !
" &
4 $
% & $$
$
2 "
4 4 "
& $
"
& 4 I B
& $
"
$
"
$$ %" " 2 " " "
$ 4 "4 " $
& 4 =# ! 4 $ "
& H B$ $
& $ $
"
$ "
% $ &
& 4
. "
&
"
I 3 ($ $$ *?
**
A
0
-
,>38' >3B?2
, (9 &* *((( , 7
- 2
,
4 /
7
> 7
,
, 2
/ , ,
,
,
2
/ ,
! 6 ,
+((-!
+(9--!
-
2 ,
6 ,
,2 , '
,
+(*-!
,
+(9--!
*+
6
+(9--!
0
A
*:
() *((& !
B(, ! 6 , , ,
)9,
.- /0 !" (< &* *((( ,
,
*<
,
,
,
, , 8, 9
4 ,
,
, &&, 9
! 6 , 2
,
, ,
*9
&& () *((+ , ! #
"
0
+(9--!
, , '
*<
>
,
,
*8
!
, , , ,
*B
'
'!
%0%089 %0%9: %%&
>
21 1A >
1A