← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10601/2010allowed

Balbir Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Darshan Singh9 pages

  

   ! "#

 $ %  &'() 

            %*   &'()   

            (# +,(-.       !"

#!   $ %& !'!  ( )     * + ,   

 

   - * ./&0 1) )     .       .

 .     

& (/012 (/2/( +/(/#

%  . #  "

"  .

# # "  3#3#

 ) #  

4,& (/2/( +/(/ # "  #  .

3     ) # .   4  $       4

            56#  )6

-  !        "        

      6#  -   # 4

. #  .

#  # 

.

     #

                       

7# 7. 4

7# 78"    "# 9# !+//+.

   : 3+/!

+//; ,  3." !'

       # #        #  .

    #  #  .     #    #          #  .   #(< (2 4  $ 

"3 # # !  #    

4,& <;;= +//0!.

.#3    : : 3+>!+//> # # .   "   

      

         

  

       

 

                        

    





   

 !        ""     #$  %& !     

'         (

  )*+         )         $             % ,  

     

-  ! 

 

       % ,    

  !.         %   

 , 

  ,

#   !    )                                ,%  

     !        #$  %&

         

            

!         , 

  !   

 

   ! $      ( +          !          

/(

+     

!



          /

  (

+              $ 

!  

   !

  

 % , 

      ) #  #  .  # .   



## 3 . #"3   $  ".        3     4 !      '

          "      3  +1!  +//>    : ;!+//>3  56# )6

 !! #

 

3!.

  #   # ;;  4$#

3 .

 .  !.

. #   3+//2 ,  '

   #    ## 3(/?(;!+//+3 4 #3! "

   ;; .3#   56# )6

  .

    #   3.

   .   )       

3                  . 3    #  .#     .   $ #!   !  3! 3  ! 

   

  #        ;; !.

  

  "   '

  .

 # 3 6  #3 '

 $ #       3+1!+//>  .3#;;

 . 

  3 "  #

3#   

   6#  3 3 

 #3 '

            #  ,   " 

 !    .

#

  3

 .

  #   # 3 '

  

"  3     #      56# 

)6 4

 !! "  # '

  .  # 3. # 3 4     $        #!             7.  3     #  .

" # .

 #  .# ) #6 #   3  4

  +//>                '  56# )6 9#.

%  .   1 )   



(  +      $

               

#

   ! ,

#$  ))3 #$  ))& 



  ,  3 

3%) 3%) 3%) 3 34. 33#

5 5 5 # 

& & *6 899:

*6 899:

*6 899:0 $  7.    #!   6   . ". **   3  ;

, !<  <

  3

    3   <    

! 



   !             

 



#$  %& !

      

     .               *9%*"

8998   # 3 !4 , 5

!                       

  

  

!  

      

           !    

   !

     

*8

    )

                  4 ,  

!

  #   

          ,



 !                  

  ** 

*"

  !  *"            





   

 #         



 

    !3  .     

  **  ) #   ((   #     #       .  3     @         3 ##   #  .   $  .          3  .          #     @ "#.

  #.    #3  #   @ "# #$  3 "   9     ##  !              

   ## 

  # '

  "

 #  #  ) 3   & " 1!+//> # .   .

 #   !  %  

 $   #!+//0 3   $   )$ %!.#3 $9  .#  A#

 .  #"B)  # "3 .   A B  3# $   #!

* .3  #     #

     6 #    +//2  )         '

     " (;0+//+ #  .      

 "#   $   # #  .3  .   (;0+//+.

3 "    3  #  .



 .

 8  #-  #;;  +//2         )  # #   .  .

#   .#   # #  ..  @ "#   6 '

" (;0+/(+.

!##   !# 

" .# 4 #3! $        

  "  3     (;0+//+    #"3     .3  #   @ "# )     .           # #  #   

  . .

#   $  

     3  3#   3 '

  +//2

.

 # 3  "# )  "3   #   #   #+2++/(/.    $ ". )$ !  # 

   #!.



  #3 '

 ?    " #     

 

 ! 3& 3 

#  '

 .

  # #  .

        "    # # 3 ".          # "  # #      " # 

    "  )     #  3 #.  3 .

 .  #    #  #  +//2 3  .   +//+.

  #   #"#4

 ! 

 .   #  6# 3  '

 $    . 

  #  

 #      ;;

.3  #  $                         # 4  4,& <;;= +//0#

+>(+//>   .3 -"  # 4 3  4,& <;;= +//0 4, & ;=(; +//0!# +0++//> .

 # #   : ." +//2!  

 #

  -

05/-

 6 0"

'0!8! 9  8 '0! !+//2C<D44(!

    6#

#"  0;    @ %(/3 "#     #  #     #       @     

$  '

   #3# % #) #  6  3 '

     .  #         $  ".     3  #    ##  # #  #    #   #  .      ## "    # #     #    #

 

3 " 6   

   

   3 # CD  "        

  ! 3  .)  "3##  #  #

 

3

             ".    

# 3   :  4,& <;;= +//0     E #   #.  <



 # ## 3   9