Kulwant Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"!
#$%&%'
$ ()*% + *+ ** ) ****
!"
#
$ % & ! +#,
- .,/!01 % (1).
()* ## $
+ ,
-.-.*.-/0 1-(2 $
3
!
-4.)*.-*0 1-*2 $ 6
" 6 "+ "
6 " '
+,
-4--*.-( 0 1 -72 !
-// ## $
6!
""
6 " + &8) ' 6
6 9 $ 6 -4.)*.-*
" &- 7 66 -4.)*.-* 6+7 +6
" * $ : ""
6 $ &; -- 0*2 < " "
&-
6 " 6" 5 $ V VISHAL 2023.07.12 17:47
- 2 - #66 .4.7*.-.
" 7+6 , " $*
" ! $" 6 ="$" '
" ' 6-..7*.-- 9 -4.7*.-. "$"
9 ' +
6
66 9 /-.7*.-.>
"
"6 6"
$ 9 '
6+ " 6" " " " 0/2 '
6! " ?6
#66
" @"6 $
#66 ' 6-(.8*.--'
6" $ ' 6 6 9
6 A -.--*.-- " " 6" " " !
$ "
!
$ $ 6" -.--*.--0 1=*26 $9 (+-(6
+ &8) ! ""
+ $ ! -*6
> 6 6" " $ &4 -- ""
$ 6 "
,
&4 --
"
- 3 - 0(2 &; --<
5 "6 " -7.7*.-- 6"" 6" -.--*.-- " " & " "
"" 6"
!
0 1 (2 " & ' 6 6" " " '
& ' 6 9 A " "
6" " " 6" "
"
6" " " " " $ " " 6"
6"
6$ " " 66 + 072 B &4 --
!" ""
$ 6 ! " "
=3
6 " 5 $#66 !" --.7*.-*0 1=;2 0;2 &4 -- 6
"
$ !
-;.7*.-* 0 1 =42 '
! 6 $
6
!
.8-.*.-/ 0 1 =)2 '
&4 -- 6 " */.7*.-*0 182 5 $#66 6" 6!
!
5 "6 8);; $
" $ "" " 0 1 =(2 '
5 $ #66 !
*/.7*.-* " 6
- 4 -
6" " "
!
" " 6 6 6" "
" " $9 6 " " 0 1=82!
042
""
+ !" ""
6 6 $ ! 5 $ #66 " 0 1 =;2 -7.7*.-*
"
6 $
-// ## *-.7*.-* 0 1 -.2
6 6" $ A.*.;*.-* "
6 6" .*.;*.-* 0 1 --2 '
-// ## $ !
-4.)*.-*0 1-*2
" !" ""
6 6 $ 6
8)0/7= -.2 0)2
-4.)*.-*"
$ &; --$ # !
&4;@*.-*
3
?!
!
$ &; -- !
-.-.*.-/0 1-(2 "6 "+ 6 " 082 " -.-.*.-/ 0 1 -(2 '
6 " " 6"
!
"
" 6" !
*4--*.-(>
0 1 -( -72
! "
#
- 5 - 0-.2
! " 0# =-*;.;= *.*/2"
" 1-;
+ " 0--2 A "
" " 0 1=-2 6"
!.4.7*.-.> $ 5 $#66 ' 6 + "
-..7*.-.' 6 +"
" 6 !
6 6$
6 +
"
?6
#66 6" =* 6 -.--*.--> " <
"$ ! "
> " &; -- " =( $ "
$ 6 $ " @ $ $"
!$ !" $""
"
" !
6
!
"," 0-*2 9 "
! "$ 9 $ 6 6" 0 1=*2 !
6
!6 /( " 0 1=(2 6" 0 1=*2 " > " ! "
!
6" !
6
"
!
"," $6
! ( $ 8 6 ! " " 0 1=-2 6" 6 $
6 ! " 6" 0 1=*2" "
- 6 -
$$ $
$ !" $ &- 7 ""66 <
5 !" $
>6 0 1 =-( =-72 ! 6 > ! 6 6" 0 1 =*2 6 $ "6 "
" $ &4 -- $61" " 0-/2 & "6 .8./*.-7
6 *4--*.-( $ 0-(2 ! $ &- ( &7 A 9 6 6 ! "
!!
0-72 &4 -- ! $ ! 0 1-*2 $ 6" "
-//## " " , " $ " " " &4 -- $" !
", -/) ## "
!
6 0-;2 > 6" 0 1 *2 -.--*.--" 66
" C?
+ D6 ?$?
# > # => = 2
" " " "
- 7 -
6"
" 6 ""
!
" $
" "
6" ! " 0-42 9 " &4 --
"6 " 0 1-(2 $ =
6" $!
!
0 1-72 -4--*.-( 6" " $ !
" "
" 6" " $' "
E?
+ F "
6" " ?
# 0-)2 > ! "
" 0-82 > "
" 6 $ " "$ ! !
-//0-2 -/4 -/)##
! "
#
$
%
& $ $$ $ # #
$
$& #
"$
#
# $
$ " &
"
"$ #
' $( #
- 8 -
# # )
& # &
#
# & "
&
# &
& &
&
&"
& "
&"
兟 $ # #
' ( # &$ * #&
$ $ !
# #
$ # # & #" &
$ # #&" # #
#
# #
#
++$ $
&
#
$ " & &
& &
$ $ " # " # &)
" #
$
$ " & &
& # $ # & &
$
#
#
+,& ) - .$ ) $ #
#
$ #
&
#
$
$
# # #
/ ' #&$ $ #
#
&
# ##"
+, + 0 " &
)
#
#
& $ # #
$
$ $ #&"& # #
&$ ###
#
$&
- 9 -
)
#
#
#
.$ " #
#
++ # #" # &
#
- .$ $ # # & #
* #$ #
&
# & #
# " #$ &
&" #$ +.$ $ #& $
#
0*.2 !
" # G # "6
! 6 # >
!
"
#$%&&'()!*+ 6 #
# G # # " +
<"
$ 3 -. -- ! = 1 $ / 2 $ /# #
"
#
0
# " #
& #&
$ " $
#$
*
$ &
# $ $ # # 1 $ & "$ #
#
$ # "
#
* $$
3
#
#
++
# # #
"
#$$
$
1 $
# #
"
- 10 -
0
"
$
++ #44$ /# " " $ $&
1 $ &
# # $ $
$
$ 1
#
#
++ $
# $
5 1 & &
# $$
" # # #6
# $ $
# $ # # $ * $$
& #
#
++
# 0*-2 H! 6# , "
- .
.
- #))'!$/(!'/+ = 1 * #
#
++
$ $
#
++
# " #
#
1 $ "
#
$ * # # * # # $
$ # $
#
# 1
#
#
++
# # #
#
#
#
++
$
# 7
# "
$ # #
#
# " ." #
++ # $
# # # $$
0# $
- 11 - & " # " # #
$ $ $$
# . # "
++ #
$
# # #
#
# #
# $
++$ /# 8 0**2 >!
" 0
10 2 0 #$%&&(! )+ 6#
" -//##>
-//
6 " " , $>
E " "F'
6E "F 6 " 1"
?$FAH C! $ 6 " " 6 " " $
!
'
6# " -//
# 6 $ ", " " '
" ""6 "
$ +$ " " '
"
-// # $ ! " " !! "$
+" 66
$ 6 "> "
" 6 $ +
6$ 6 6
- 12 - 0*/2 > 6
6 ?
# " "
!3
"
1#
4 -/ * '&/%&&+
*).(*..) $
-//## $! ?
#
6# "
= 02 '
-//## 6 6 " I 02'
6 $ 1" ! " 6
6
6 I 0"2 "
-//## !
66 " 2J $ ""6
"66 $ -//## " 02 & "
" + "
1 " -//## " $ "6 "$ 02'
"
-//## "
!
"
2 9 !+ -//## 6
$ ", " "
- 13 - 2 '
1"
" "
!$ 1"
6 " "
!" "
"6 "6!
"" 0*(2 >
$ "
"6$ "" 6
" !
"
6+"
, " "
"
" 6! 6 " " " $ 6 B
" 0*72 > " 6 !
$ -// ## $ " ! " !
$ -/)## 6+ 6 !
0*;2 "
$! 6
, "
+
" $ "
6 " "
"
$
" $ -//## 0*42 >6$ 6 =5 !
$
)
"
-// ##
" !
-/)## 6 $ = !
-4.)*.-* !
'
$"
" ="6 "
- 14 -
6 $, 6 $ "
-//##'
"
-.-.*.-/ $ !
# 6
6 " 0*)2
6 *7.(*.*/ 99 2+#,
- .,/!03
.,/
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No