High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12088/2020dismissed

Jasvir Singh v. Ld. Financial Commissioner Punjab And Others

2020-08-25Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal8 pages

#$ %& ''( $)*( & ( $)* "

$- .

!&( / " ,

1- &! " 2 , $ /& 3 " $ 4( " , "&&! " , 5( *- " & %& ''( $)*

6" ,$ " , & 2" , ,,' /& 7' 8'* ' '! " 7) ''* "$& &$! " 8 %& '' " ,, , 9 :

6" #&&! 7' ,, $ " $)* 8 + $ +$& ; +$& 51 " +$&( , 2 ' ,,' & 7' ' '! " 7) ''* "$& &$! " 2"" < $

!"#

" $

% !"

& !"

$ & !"

$ '

% !" % !"

% !

" $ '

% !" '

($ $ $ ($

= !" & !$" ) *+ !"!$"

& !$"

&, ' >$ *

" " & "

$) !"( /& 7) 7'( - "( ,,& 2 < ,,& 2

72 ( " ,( "( 2"2 " ' 6"( 9* 6"& $*' , ''! " , ,,' /& 7' 7)? "$& !-

, 5 :

=( 2"" 2 ?,, *- " $* & ! 3 :

72 ( " &&( " ,,! $"-( ' " " 9* 6"& :

6" 9* 6"& ! '' " , , = :( 2"" 2 ! *- " $* & ! >$&-( " '( " && ,, " , /& 7' "$& / ,,& & *- , 9 :( * " '' 2 ' = @ 72 ( " %& '' " " ,, , 9 :( /& 7'

$& ! " , *- " %& ''( ,, " " & " ,

: /& 7' " * " !$ " " , " * ' ' " , /& 7' *- " && ( " "! " " $& " A< ,'( $)*

6" ,( * ( " 2 "&&! " , *- " & %& ''

6" $ " " & $& " , 2" " *& ! "$!" " ,, *B

8 $& " , " " , 9 :( &&!& , " & *&!! & C ' ( "( * & /& 7'

7 $" $*' " " %& ''( 2"& <! " ,2 ( $& " " && " 2 $& " " " &&

%$"( $' " " , $& $ " , 8'*( " %& ''( $!" " " $ " ' ! ,,& 7 & " " ,,& & *- " , ! " " ' & *- " && ( ,! "( " ' ! " , " *' &

, &- " !$' " & $& " ,( " $ " 2 " " ' " , / " $( '$ * " " $ <! " ,2 )$& 2 2"" B " /,,&&

)$ 6" , " B " <- )$ " $ $ 2 2"" - &

6" , " < " ' ! "' '

" , #&&! 7'

/&"$!"( " 2 ,( " , " " & " '$ $&( "2 ( $! " $ !$'( & $& " , ' " " '$ $& ' " (((?

$& ! " !$ & * " %& '' *- , 9 :( , " " , ,, " '(

& 4 " * " , ''$ $ *- " A< 6<

( " $& ' ' " , =(5(:(? 4 '- * " " " , " 2 , &' " ! " '( - ,! ,!

6" , &' " & ,,& ! " , *- " && ' ! "' ' " , 7'

$& ! +$& 51 *( *' ,, " 2"& ,,! " 7'( " ,,! $"- " B, ' " " /& 7' "$& * ' *

&& $"( " 7' * ' ?' $ +$& 51

*( " #&&! 7' $&- '* *- " * 9 $*( & $& " $*' " " '$ $ "

@ /' D @3 3 "( " $& * >$& " - ( 2" " , 2 ,,( "2 ( " $ $* " $*' 6" $& " , $*>$ " " ,,'

4 2 " $,$ ,( ' ,- " ,,& ! " ' & " , 2$& "&- * - & && $"( & $& " , " & 2 " " $ - ' , ! " , " ,! ,,& 4 2 " ( " '&?' & " , ' " , /& #&&! 7' $ * 2 &- & 2"& "! , ! " ,,' /& 7'

/ ! " !$' " & $& " " , 2 '' *- " 9* 6"&( *- " $* & ! ,, *- " && "( $& * ' *- " %& ''( $ 2" " $ *$ " ( " %& '' " " E &$ ', ' ' " 6" %& ''( * ( " " ,,' , 9 :( ! "' * &!*& ' $*& ,$&&- 2 " " " ,

3 ' ?' ' " 7'

4 ,, ' " , 9* 6"& < 2" " , /<$ ( " " &&! >$( , & " $ * 2 *- " & C ' 2""

&&! " $ " "$ 8 "

$) !"( " & $ "$ 2"" , 9 :( $ $,- " "

6" %& '' * ,! " ( $!" , ' " 1&B &,' "- $'A<$ ( ."( 2" , " 1&) !" , :( &&!& , " & *&!! " & C ' +"( " ! "

&&!

9< !$' & $& " " %& '' "$& " $ " ' ! " ,,& " ,,' 8'*( &"$!" &B " ',( "2 ( , $-( $ * 2"$ ' 6" , ,,'?& #&&! 7' ,! 2 $*)$ 6" , & *- " && $*>$&- ' 4 $"

$'( " ,! 2 ,! " ,,' /& 7'( " %& '' " &- & , 9 :

4 '- * " " " + $ /$"- " &- B - &E " &?,,' $) !" @ 2" " %& '' ,

" ',$! 5 && $"( " 2 , " &$ *$ " " &- * "( " ,,& ,,' " & *

8 !$' " & $& 2" ! ,- " ,,& ! " ' &?'& " , '

" , #&&! 7'( ' " $ " , 2 " !! $

.,! 2 " ( " $ - ' " , 2 , 7( " 2 , * ' &'

/&& " ,! '&&$ ,,&( -( , ( 2 " * )$!'

!"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.

!"#$"#%%#'.%$(12#0 #&-.